For decades, filing an FIR under Section 154 of the old Code of
Criminal Procedure was the easy part. What followed was often silence —
sometimes for years — until a final report finally surfaced under Section
173(2) CrPC. The complainant had no enforceable right to interim information.
That era of "administrative silence" has now been legislatively
dismantled.
Saturday, 26 September 2026
The 90-Day Rule: How BNSS Ended Police Silence Over Your FIR
Saturday, 8 August 2026
'Perfect Victim' In Rape Cases Is A Myth; Women Deal With Trauma In Different Ways : Bombay High Court In Tarun Tejpal Case
I. Regarding the ‘Perfect Victim’ construct:
45. The Trial Court proceeded on a notion that a victim of sexual assault must behave in a stereotypical manner. The PW-1 was to be a perfect victim and only then could the Courts believe her story of woe. The ‘perfect victim’ concept, more formally known as an ‘ideal victim’, describes an unspoken cultural archetype where a person is fully believed, sympathised with and granted legitimacy only if they exhibit absolute vulnerability, complete innocence and total passivity. When a survivor does not fit in this mould – such as delaying a report, knowing the attacker or being under the influence of alcohol- their trauma is normally devalued. Expecting a survivor to be constantly miserable, meek or visibly broken, the Trial Court has ignored the reality of human coping mechanisms. However, these concepts of a perfect victim are a myth. Credibility must be evaluated on facts, not on whether a survivor fits a narrow cultural mould.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY AT GOA
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 16 OF 2022
The State of Goa Vs Tarunjit Tejpal, s/o Inderjit Tejpal,
CORAM : DR. NEELA GOKHALE &
AMIT S. JAMSANDEKAR, JJ.
PRONOUNCED ON : 6th AUGUST 2026
JUDGMENT (Per Dr Neela Gokhale, J.)
Citation: 2026:BHC-GOA:1562-DB
Print PageSaturday, 18 April 2026
Supreme Court: Whether the court can rely on recovery of articles of Victim as per statement of accused U/S 27 of Evidence Act if relatives of victim have not testified that those articles were belonging to Victim?
In the preceding paragraph, we have considered the law laid down by this Court on that issue. Let us now consider the circumstances in which the recovery was made from the locations as disclosed. It cannot be questioned that such recovery would be relevant since the Appellant-convict could have affected the recovery only if he had specific knowledge of the location. This, however, in our view, is not sufficient to take the recovery of the objects as a circumstance against the Appellant convict. This we say for the reason that the objects recovered also have to be verified and tested. Now, this was not done. His statement is said to have led to the recovery of - (i) a sickle, (ii) a jute bag, (iii) a green coloured lungi, (iv) a blue colour checked shirt, and (v) a red and yellow colour striped towel from his house. {Para 26}
27. How any and/or all of these articles related to the alleged murder of two victims and rape of one of them is undemonstrated from the record. None of the relatives of either D1 or D2 have testified to any of these belongings being that of the victims.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Criminal Appeal No. 1672 of 2019
Decided On: 15.07.2025
Kattavellai Vs. State of Tamilnadu
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Vikram Nath, Sanjay Karol and Sandeep Mehta, JJ.
Author: Sanjay Karol, J.
Citation: 2025 INSC 845, MANU/SC/0917/2025.
Read full judgment here: Click here.
Print PageMonday, 26 January 2026
Bombay HC: How the magistrate or Session judge should protect interest of victim if arrest of accused is declared illegal ?
There is another important aspect in this matter. The offence is quite serious and therefore, it would not be proper if the victim suffers because of the lapse on the part of the investigating agency. A Division Bench of this Court in the case of Kavita Manikikar Vs. Central Bureau of Investigation & Anr. in Writ Petition No.1142 of 2018 vide the Order dated 10th May, 2018 had held the arrest of the Petitioner in that Petition as illegal but had further observed that the investigating agency was not precluded to arrest the Petitioner if the investigation so warranted, by following the due procedure of law. The relevant portion in paragraph 17 of the said Judgment is as follows:-
"17. In result, of the aforesaid discussion, the writ petition is
allowed in terms of prayer clause (a) and it is held that the
arrest of the Petitioner is illegal and contrary to the provisions
of Section 46(4) of the Code of Criminal Procedure. However,
the CBI is not precluded to arrest the petitioner if investigation
warrants so, by following the due procedure of law."
11) Therefore, to strike a balance, liberty needs to be given to the
investigating agency to re-arrest the detenu if they deem fit.
{Para 10}
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO.4539 OF 2025
Dhanshala Prakash Vishwakarma Vs. The State of Maharashtra & Ors.
CORAM : SARANG V. KOTWAL &
SHYAM C. CHANDAK, JJ.
DATED : 7th OCTOBER, 2025.
Citation: 2025:BHC-AS:43397-DB
Print PageSaturday, 27 December 2025
Supreme Court: Criminal Revision Filed By Informant Doesn't Abate On His Death; Other Victims Can Continue It
Since strict rule of locus does not apply to a revision proceeding, on death of a revisionist, the law of abatement that applies to an appeal does not apply to a revision proceeding, more particularly when revision is not at the instance of an Accused. However, where the revision is at the instance of an Accused/convict, the revisional court may refuse to continue the proceedings on his death, inter alia, where (a) the revisional proceeding emanates from an order passed during trial; or (b) the revisional proceeding is against an order of conviction, or affirmance of conviction. In situation (a) (supra), on death of Accused the trial would abate and so would ancillary proceedings emanating therefrom. In situation (b) (supra), the sentence or fine cannot be executed against a dead person, therefore, in absence of any application from a person seeking leave to pursue the revision, the court may terminate the proceedings as having abated. However, where the revision is at the instance of an informant or a complainant, on his death, the proceedings will not abate and, therefore, revisional court may exercise its discretion and proceed to test the correctness, legality or propriety of an order passed by the court subordinate to it. {Para 17}
18. In so far as substitution in place of the deceased revisionist is concerned, there is no specific provision in the Code for substitution. Therefore, no one can claim substitution as of right. However, what is important is that there is no provision for abatement as well, as is there for an appeal (see Section 394). Hence, once a revision is entertained, in our view, the Court exercising revisional power has discretion to proceed with the revision and test the correctness, legality or propriety of the order under challenge before it, regardless of the death of the person who had invoked the revisional jurisdiction. However, while doing so, the Court may, in its discretion, allow a person to assist it in discharge of its statutory functions provided that person has no conflict of interest. In that context, a victim of the crime would ordinarily be the most suitable person to provide assistance because of his interest in overturning a decision that went against him. Therefore, when revisional powers are invoked by a victim of the crime, and he dies during pendency of the revision, other victims of that crime, who fall within the scope of its definition, as provided in Section 2 (wa) of Code of Criminal Procedure, may be allowed to assist the Court in effectively discharging its statutory function. In that regard, the Court would be well within its jurisdiction in granting leave to such a person to pursue the revision. However, in absence of a provision for substitution, though a person may not have a legal right to claim substitution as a revisionist, there is no legal restriction on revisional court's power in allowing a person to assist the Court in furthering the cause of justice, more particularly, when strict rule of locus does not apply to a criminal revision.
19. In light of the discussion above, the impugned order of the High Court dismissing the revision as having abated on death of the revisionist is held unsustainable in law. More so, because the trial against the Accused-Respondents is pending.
20. As far as rejection of the application of the Appellant to assist the Court as a substitute for the deceased revisionist is concerned, suffice it to say that the original revisionist (i.e., the informant) had alleged that the Accused had set up a fabricated sale deed to stake a false claim to his property. Challenge in the revision was to an order of discharge of the Accused from offences other than cheating. Since on revisionist's death, his son (i.e., the Appellant herein) would inherit an interest in the property, in our view, the Appellant is a victim of the crime and, therefore, has vital interest in the outcome of the proceeding. Hence, in our view, the revisional court could have allowed him to assist the court in the capacity of a victim of the crime.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Criminal Appeal Nos. 5589-5590 of 2025
Decided On: 19.12.2025
Syed Shahnawaz Ali Vs. The State of Madhya Pradesh and Ors.
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Sanjay Karol and Manoj Misra, JJ.
Author: Manoj Misra, J.
Citation: 2025 INSC 1484, MANU/SC/1719/2025.
Print PageMonday, 1 September 2025
Supreme Court: Appellate court can not enhance sentence in appeal filed by accused against conviction in absence of counter appeal by complainant or state
In this regard, it must be noted that for exercise of powers of the appellate court for enhancement of sentence in an appeal filed either by the State or the complainant or the victim, the Code of Criminal Procedure provides that the appellate court can reverse the finding and sentence and acquit or discharge the Accused, or order him to be re-tried by a court competent to try the offence, or alter the finding by maintaining the sentence, or with or without altering the finding, alter the nature or the extent, of the sentence so as to enhance or reduce the same. Thus, the power to enhance the sentence can be exercised by the appellate court only in an appeal filed by the State, victim or complainant, provided the Accused has had an opportunity of showing cause against such enhancement. It is further provided that the appellate court shall not inflict greater punishment for the offence which in its opinion the Accused has committed, than might have been inflicted for that offence by the court passing the order of sentence under appeal. Therefore, in an appeal for enhancement of sentence filed by the State etc., unless the conditions prescribed in the form of provisos to Section 386 of Code of Criminal Procedure are complied with by the appellate court, there cannot be an enhancement of sentence. Obviously in such an appeal for enhancement of sentence, the convict or the Accused is the Respondent and therefore there cannot be enhancement of sentence unless the Accused or convict has been heard. However, under the scheme of Section 386 of Code of Criminal Procedure vis-a-vis in an appeal for enhancement of sentence, there can also be an acquittal of the Accused as per Sub-clause (i) of Clause (c) of Section 386 of Code of Criminal Procedure. But, on the other hand, in an appeal from a conviction, it has been expressly stated that there cannot be enhancement of the sentence. Therefore, while in an appeal for enhancement of sentence filed by the State, the Accused can make out a case for acquittal or discharge or retrial, in the case of an appeal from conviction, the Respondent in such an appeal, namely the State or the victim or the complainant, cannot seek enhancement of the sentence than what has been awarded by the Trial Court in the absence of filing any appeal or revision. The above distinction can be explained by way of a latin maxim which has been discussed by Ujjal Bhuyan, J., while in Bombay High Court, in Jyoti Plastic Works Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India and Ors., MANU/MH/1857/2020, in the following words:
40. In this connection we may refer to the maxim reformatio in peius. It is a latin phrase meaning a change towards the worse i.e., a change for the worse. As a legal expression it means that a lower court judgment is amended by a higher court into a worse one for those appealing it. In many jurisdictions, this practice is forbidden ensuring that an Appellant cannot be placed in a worse position as a result of filing an appeal. When the above phrase is prefixed by the words 'no' or 'prohibition', which would render the maxim as no reformatio in peius or prohibition of reformatio in peius, it would denote a principle of procedure as per which using a remedy available in law should not aggravate the situation of the person who avails the remedy. In other words, a person should not be placed in a worse position as a result of filing an appeal. No reformatio in peius or prohibition of reformatio in peius is a part of fair procedure and thus by extension can also be construed as part of natural justice. It is not only a procedural guarantee but is also a principle of equity.
14. The rationale of the above can be explained in simple language by stating that no Appellant by filing an appeal can be worse-off than what he was. That is exactly what we are seeking to reiterate in our judgment having regard to the facts of the present case.{Para 13}
Ratio Decidendi:
In an appeal filed by the Accused/convict and in the absence of any appeal filed by the victim, complainant or the State, the High Court cannot exercise suo motu revision either to enhance the sentence or to convict the Appellant on any other charge.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Criminal Appeal Nos. 2892-2893 of 2025.
Decided On: 04.06.2025
Nagarajan Vs. State of Tamil Nadu
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
B.V. Nagarathna and S.C. Sharma, JJ.
Author: B.V. Nagarathna, J.
Citation: 2025 INSC 802,MANU/SC/0808/2025.
Print PageSaturday, 23 August 2025
Bombay HC: Non-Examination Of Sexual Assault Victim Or Officer Who Recorded Her Statement Amounts To Denial Of Fair Trial To Accused
In the above context, it would be pertinent to note herein that the prosecution has placed heavy reliance on the version of the victim as brought on record through her mother (PW 1) so as to bring home the charge brought against the Accused/Appellant under Sections 376(2)(f) and 377 of the IPC. Notwithstanding the same, as has been noted above, the victim/prosecutrix has not been examined as a witness. Sections 25 and 26 of the POCSO Act, 2012 lays down specific provisions for recording the statement of a child. As per Section 26(2) the Magistrate/police can even take the assistance of a Translator or an Interpreter while recording the statement of the child. Notwithstanding the same, neither the child has been examined as a witness nor has the PSI Ghodke, who had recorded the victim's statement called as a witness by the prosecution. The failure on the part of the prosecution to examine the victim or the PSI, without any just explanation, in our considered opinion would amount to denial of an opportunity to the accused to prove his innocence and therefore, in the facts of the case, would constitute denial of fair trial to the accused. {Para 41}
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Criminal Appeal No. 188 of 2023
Decided On: 14.08.2025
Deepak Babasaheb Gaikwad Vs. The State of Maharashtra and Ors.
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Suman Shyam and Shyam C. Chandak, JJ.
Author: Suman Shyam, J.
Citation: 2025:BHC-AS:35291-DB,MANU/MH/5049/2025
Print PageFriday, 22 August 2025
Supreme Court:Victim can not challenge order of acquittal of accused passed before enactment of proviso to S 372 of CRPC as said proviso has not retrospective effect
20. She submitted that no right of appeal was available to the victim in law at the time the revision was filed and therefore, there was no scope for the court to even treat the revision as an appeal that 'lay under the Code of Criminal Procedure (for short, "the Code of Criminal Procedure" or "Code")' at the time as provided for Under Section 401(5) above.
37. The Proviso to the above had not yet come into effect as on 19.01.2006 when the revision petition was filed, for it was added only w.e.f. 31.12.2009. The Proviso says - [Provided that the victim shall have a right to prefer an appeal against any order passed by the Court acquitting the Accused or convicting for a lesser offence or imposing inadequate compensation, and such appeal shall lie to the Court to which an appeal ordinarily lies against the order of conviction of such Court.]
i. Thus, the statutory right of appeal by a victim against such acquittal arose only from the date of the amendment w.e.f. 31.12.2009. As the said revision was filed by the father of the deceased on 19.01.2006 well before the above amendment, such right was not available at the relevant point of time.
ii. Therefore, the very first condition Under Section 401(5) itself would not have been possible to be fulfilled, i.e. the right of the victim to appeal did not lie under the Code at the time of filing the revision petition.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Criminal Appeal Nos. 5560-5561 of 2024
Decided On: 29.01.2025
Mahabir and Ors. Vs. State of Haryana
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
J.B. Pardiwala, and R. Mahadevan, , JJ.
Author: J.B. Pardiwala, J.
Citation MANU/SC/0122/2025.
Read full judgment here: Click here.
Print PageWednesday, 2 July 2025
Can police refuse to lodge FIR on email complaint from abroad? Kerala High Court answers
The Kerala High Court, in the case YYYY v State of Kerala & Ors, delivered a significant judgment clarifying the obligations of the police under Section 173 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS) regarding the registration of FIRs, especially in the context of complaints sent via email from abroad and unsigned complaints.
Case Details:
-
Case Number: Criminal Miscellaneous Case No. 4778 of 2020
-
Date of Judgment: 1 July 2025
-
Bench: Justice Kauser Edappagath
Kerala HC: U/S 173 of BNSS, Zero FIR's can be registered even if a complaint is sent via email from abroad and police cannot reject it for lack of signature or territorial jurisdiction
The implementation of Section 173 of Bharatiya
Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (for short, 'the BNSS'), marks
a significant shift in how the police handles information relating
to the commission of a cognizable offence. Now, Zero FIR has
been given statutory recognition by incorporating it in Section
173 of BNSS, which deals with the registration of FIR in
cognizable cases. Zero FIR has been introduced with the
primary purpose of ensuring that victims can file complaints
regardless of jurisdiction. Therefore, the police cannot refuse to
register an FIR if a cognizable offence is made out in the
complaint, even if the complaint is forwarded from a foreign
country. In these circumstances, the rejection of Annexure A7
complaint made by the petitioner on the ground that it was
unsigned and sent through e-mail from Australia cannot be
justified. {Para 3}
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
CRL.MC NO. 4778 OF 2020
SOYA Vs STATE OF KERALA
PRESENT
DR. JUSTICE KAUSER EDAPPAGATH
Citation: 2025:KER:44462
Wednesday, 25 June 2025
Withdrawal of Prosecution in Indian Criminal Law: From CrPC Section 321 to BNSS Section 360 - Provisions, Procedures and Key Reforms
Yes, there is a provision for withdrawal of prosecution cases in the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC) under Section 321, which has now been replaced by Section 360 in the new Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023.
Provision for Withdrawal in CrPC
Saturday, 21 June 2025
Maharashtra's Manodhairya Scheme: Rehabilitation Support for Sexual Crime Victims Amid Controversial Recovery Provisions
Introduction
The Manodhairya Scheme stands as Maharashtra's flagship initiative to provide comprehensive support to victims of sexual crimes and acid attacks. While designed to offer financial assistance and rehabilitation services, recent modifications have introduced controversial recovery provisions that have sparked debate among women's rights advocates and legal experts.
Genesis of the Scheme
Tragic Catalyst
The scheme emerged in response to the horrific gang rape incident at Mumbai's Shakti Mills in August 2013. Launched on October 2, 2013, by the Department of Women and Child Development (DWCD), Government of Maharashtra, it was implemented following directives from the Hon'ble Supreme Court for providing financial assistance to victims of sexual crimes.
Saturday, 7 June 2025
Comprehensive Guide to Bail Applications in POCSO Act Cases: Legal Framework and Judicial Guidelines
Mandatory Notice Requirements for Victim and Legal Representatives
The Bombay High Court has established crucial procedural requirements for bail applications in POCSO cases4. It is mandatory to issue notice of hearing of case and bail application to victim of an offence under POCSO Act. The court declared that Section 40 of the POCSO Act read with Rule 4 of the POCSO Rules necessarily require that the Legal Representative of the Child Victim, Parents, or Guardians as the case may be, is heard before releasing the suspected offender on Bail.
Friday, 6 June 2025
Supreme Court Recognizes Complainant as Victim, Grants Unconditional Appeal Right in Cheque Bounce Acquittals
Background
In a significant judgment delivered on April 8, 2025, the Supreme Court of India addressed a crucial legal question: Can a complainant in a cheque dishonour case under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, appeal an acquittal order as a "victim" under the proviso to Section 372 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC), without seeking special leave under Section 378(4) of the CrPC? This issue arose in the case of M/s. Celestium Financial v. A. Gnanasekaran & Others, where the appellant, a financial firm, sought to challenge the acquittal of borrowers who had defaulted on multiple loans and whose cheques were dishonoured due to insufficient funds.
Read full judgment here: Click here.
Factual Matrix
Print PageSupreme Court: Complainant In S.138 NI Act Case Can File Appeal Against Acquittal As 'Victim' Under S.372 Proviso CrPC
A person who is a complainant under Section 200 of the CrPC who complains about the offence committed by a person who is charged as an accused under Section 138 of the Act, thus has the right to prefer an appeal as a victim under the proviso to Section 372 of the CrPC.
10. As already noted, the proviso to Section 372 of the CrPC was inserted in the statute book only with effect from 31.12.2009. The object and reason for such insertion must be realised and must be given its full effect to by a court. In view of the aforesaid discussion, we hold that the victim of an offence has the right to prefer an appeal under the proviso to Section 372 of the CrPC, irrespective of whether he is a complainant or not. Even if the victim of an offence is a complainant, he can still proceed under the proviso to Section 372 and need not advert to sub-section (4) of Section 378 of the CrPC.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NOS. OF 2025
M/s. CELESTIUM FINANCIAL Vs A. GNANASEKARAN ETC.
Citation: 2025 INSC 804.
Dated: APRIL 08, 2025.
Print Page
Monday, 20 January 2025
Supreme Court: Bodily Injuries Not Necessary To Prove Sexual Assault; Victims Respond To Trauma In Different Ways
We must caution that bodily injuries are not necessary to
prove sexual assault1 and neither it is important to raise a hue or
cry. In this regard, the Supreme Court’s Handbook on Gender
stereotypes(2023) provides as under:
“Different people react differently to traumatic
events. For example, the death of a parent may
cause one person to cry publicly whereas another
person in a similar situation may not exhibit any
emotion in public. Similarly, a woman’s reaction
to being sexually assaulted or raped by a man may
vary based on her individual characteristics.
There is no “correct” or “appropriate” way in
which a survivor or victim behaves.” {Para 8}
9. It is a common myth that sexual assault must leave injuries.
Victims respond to trauma in varied ways, influenced by factors
such as fear, shock, social stigma or feelings of helplessness. It
is neither realistic nor just to expect a uniform reaction. The
stigma associated with sexual assault often creates significant
barriers for women, making it difficult for them to disclose the
incident to others.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 1005 OF 2013
DALIP KUMAR @ DALLI APPELLANT(S) Vs STATE OF UTTARANCHAL
Dated: JANUARY 16, 2025.
Print PageSunday, 29 December 2024
Supreme Court: Mandatory To Hear Informant/Victim Before Granting Bail In Rape Offences, SC/ST Act Cases
In the instant case, it appears to be that the
concerned respondents – accused had not impleaded the
present appellant as the party – respondent in the bail
proceedings filed by them before the High Court, and the
concerned Public Prosecutor also had not informed the
appellant – victim about the said proceedings. {Para 5}
6. It is pertinent to note that as per Section 439(1A)
of Cr.P.C., the presence of the informant or any person
authorised by him or her is obligatory at the time of
hearing of the application for bail to the person under
sub-section (3) of Section 376 or Section 376AB or Section
376DA or Section 376DB of the IPC. Similarly, it is also
mandatory on the part of the Special Public Prosecutor of
the State Government to inform the victim about the court
proceedings, including bail proceedings as contemplated in
sub-section (3) of Section 15A of the Scheduled Castes and
Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989.
7. In the instant case, there is gross violation of the
said statutory provisions contained in Section 439(1A) of
Cr.P.C. and Section 15A(3) of the SC/ST Act, at the
instance of the respondents. The High Court also in the
impugned order has not considered the said mandatory
requirement of both the Acts and granted bail to the
concerned respondents in a very casual and cursory manner
and without assigning any cogent reasons, though the
concerned respondents are prima facie involved in a very
serious offences.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.5385 OF 2024
(Arising out of SLP(Crl.) No.5027 of 2024)
X Vs THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH & ANR.
Dated: 13TH DECEMBER, 2024.
Print PageSunday, 22 December 2024
Supreme Court: High court should not release accused on bail by looking into the deposition of the victim
Over a period of time, we have noticed two things, i.e., (i)
either bail is granted after the charge is framed and just
before the victim is to be examined by the prosecution before
the trial court, or (ii) bail is granted once the recording of the
oral evidence of the victim is complete by looking into some
discrepancies here or there in the deposition and thereby
testing the credibility of the victim. {Para 15}
16. We are of the view that the aforesaid is not a correct
practice that the Courts below should adopt. Once the trial
commences, it should be allowed to reach to its final
conclusion which may either result in the conviction of the
accused or acquittal of the accused. The moment the High
Court exercises its discretion in favour of the accused and
orders release of the accused on bail by looking into the
deposition of the victim, it will have its own impact on the
pending trial when it comes to appreciating the oral evidence
of the victim. It is only in the event if the trial gets unduly
delayed and that too for no fault on the part of the accused,
the Court may be justified in ordering his release on bail on
the ground that right of the accused to have a speedy trial
has been infringed.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
EXTRAORDINARY APPELLATE JURISDICTION
SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CRIMINAL) NO. 13378 OF 2024
X Vs STATE OF RAJASTHAN & ANR.
Dated: 27th November, 2024.
Citation: 2024 INSC 909.
Read full Judgment here: Click here.
Print PageSupreme Court: Bail Should Not Be Granted Ordinarily In Serious Offences Like Rape & Murder Once Trial Starts
Ordinarily in serious offences like rape, murder, dacoity,
etc., once the trial commences and the prosecution starts
examining its witnesses, the Court be it the Trial Court or the
High Court should be loath in entertaining the bail
application of the accused. {Para 14}
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
EXTRAORDINARY APPELLATE JURISDICTION
SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CRIMINAL) NO. 13378 OF 2024
X Vs STATE OF RAJASTHAN & ANR.
Dated: 27th November, 2024.
Citation: 2024 INSC 909.
Print PageSaturday, 9 November 2024
Bombay HC: What precautions Session Judge should take while putting question U/S 313 of CRPC to accused?
I have perused the 313 Cr. P.C. statements of the appellants recorded by the learned Judge. While recording the 313 Cr. P.C. statements of the appellants, the learned Judge did not frame proper questions. The material part of the incriminating evidence adduced by the prosecution was not put to the appellants. In this context, it is necessary to see some of the questions framed by the learned Judge. As stated above, the proof of the identity of the appellants, being the perpetrators of the crime, was the fact in issue. The learned Judge was required to frame proper questions on the basis of the available evidence of the witnesses with regard to their identification. As stated above, the identification of the appellants was established by pointing out their photographs to the prosecutrix. It was not put to the appellants that they were identified by the victim before the Court in a particular manner. The incriminating part of her evidence with regard to the identification of the appellants in the Test Identification Parade was not specifically put to the appellants. It is further seen that the CA reports and the DNA report, being the important pieces of evidence, ought to have been put to them specifically in their 313 statements. Question No. 35 is common for both the appellants. It needs to be extracted. It is as follows:
“Q. No. 35. It has come in the evidence of PW-10 Satish K. Farkade (Ex.97) during investigation he prepared spot panchanama, seizure panchanama. He seized motor cycle, sickle, chapple, godahdi, clothes on the person of victim and muddemal sent for C.A. and obtain C.A. report. What do you have to state about it ?”{Para 29}
30. Perusal of this question would show that the incriminating material in the form of CA reports was put to the appellants in this manner. Perusal of 313 Cr. P.C. statements of the appellants would show that the DNA report was not at all put to them. Even if the appellants had admitted the DNA report, the learned Judge was required to put the same to the appellants in their 313 Cr. P.C. statements. It needs to be stated that, in this case, the appellants have not admitted the DNA report. It is pertinent to mention that, time and again, it has been observed that proper care is not taken while framing the questions in the 313 Cr. P.C. statement of the accused on the basis of the incriminating material. Sometimes, the composite questions are framed. The answer to the part of the question may be in the affirmative and the answer to the part of the question may be in the negative. Such a composite question needs to be avoided. The appellants are the rustic villagers. Similarly, the victim is also a rustic villager. The incriminating circumstances related to the CA and DNA reports had not been put to them. Failure of the learned Judge to follow the provisions of law has caused miscarriage of justice. It has prejudiced not only the appellants but also the victim.
31. In this case, the DNA report has not been put to the appellants. The Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra [(1984) 4 SCC 116 : AIR 1984 SC 1622] has held that incriminating piece of evidence, if not put to the accused in his 313 Cr. P.C. statement, cannot be made the basis of the conviction of the accused. It has to be excluded from consideration. It is to be noted that, while recording the evidence, the learned Prosecutor and the learned Judge adopted a very casual and careless approach. The DNA Expert and the Chemical Analyzer have not been examined. The learned Judge, while examining the accused under Section 313 of the Cr. P.C., did not even care to frame a proper question and put the DNA report to the accused so as to enable them to explain it. This has caused prejudice to the appellants. Similarly, it has proved prejudicial to the prosecutrix, who had suffered the ordeal of a horrible incident. She was not at fault. This has resulted into miscarriage of justice.
In the High Court of Bombay
(Before G.A. Sanap, J.)
Criminal Appeal No. 155 of 2022
Puranlal Sakaru Dhurve. Vs State of Maharashtra,
Criminal Appeal No. 155 of 2022 and Criminal Appeal No. 352 of 2022
Decided on September 30, 2024
Citation: 2024 SCC OnLine Bom 3437.
Read full Judgment here: Click here.
Print Page


