Showing posts with label offence against child. Show all posts
Showing posts with label offence against child. Show all posts

Saturday, 24 June 2017

Whether Parent Would Risk Daughter’s Honor By Filing False Rape Cases To Settle Minor Scores?

It is pertinent to note that it has come in the evidence that appellant was
residing in the house of prosecutrix and was having cordial relations with
the family of prosecutrix and the above-said evidence remains
unchallenged and so, in the instant case, no prudent person can conclude
that appellant has been falsely implicated because he objected to children
of prosecutrix’s mother defecating in front of house or because of quarrel 
on this count. Neither parent would stake the honour of their minor
daughter and the family, to level such a serious accusation of rape against
appellant, to settle the scores on account of such a trivial quarrel,
particularly when the relations were cordial.
 IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: June 16, 2017
CRL.A. 533/2016
PRAVEEN @ BABLU 
v
STATE 
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUNIL GAUR

Print Page

Thursday, 29 December 2016

When offence against child will not be triable before children's court?

.In the case in question, the petitioner is alleged to have

  committed the offences under Sections 279,337 and 338.

  Causing hurt or grievous hurt by rash and negligent driving is

  the ingredient of those offences.            In Cambridge Advanced

  Learner's Dictionary, Third Edition, the word 'rash' when used as



  adjective means careless or unwise, without thought for what

  might happen or result, meaning thereby that while doing

  something, the person did not think about the costs involved. In

  Cambridge Advanced Learner's Dictionary Third Edition, the

  word 'negligence' when used as adjective means not being

  careful or giving enough attention to people or things that are

  your responsibility. Therefore, when the allegation was to the

  effect that a person has acted in a rash and negligent manner, it

  cannot be said that he has acted intentionally. In view of the

  above, the petitioner in the case on hand cannot be said to have

  acted intentionally while causing injury to the victim. Or in

  other words, hurt or grievous hurt was caused to the child not by

  any intentional act of the petitioner. Without the juncture of the

  mental element like intention, infringement or violation of a right

  is not possible. Contextually, hurt or grievous hurt was caused

  to the child in the motor accident resulted from the rash and



  negligent driving by the petitioner. But the right of the child

  cannot be said to have been infringed or violated by the

  petitioner by his act. The incident in which the child has

  sustained injuries can only be said to be caused accidentally out

  of rashness and negligence on the part of the petitioner. In such

  circumstances,       the petitioner cannot be said to have

  intentionally caused hurt or grievous hurt to the child in the case

  on hand to put the same within the jurisdiction of the Sessions

  Court, Pathanamthitta.        Therefore, the     Sessions   Court,

  Pathanamthitta, which is designated as the children's court

  cannot be said to have any authority to try the case. The Judicial

  First Class Magistrate Court, Pathanamthitta, which is the

  committal court is the appropriate court to try the case.

  13. In Abdul Aziz's case (supra), a Single Bench of this Court

  had occasion to deal with a situation of similar nature and held as

  follows:-



              "..........Even if the victim in an accident case is
              aged below 18 years, such cases registered under
              Sections 279,337,338 or 304(A) of IPC, being cases
              arising out of an accident need not be tried by the
              Children's Court, constituted under Section 25 of
              the Central Act 4/2006. But, other cases involving
              violation of 'child rights', acts done with the
              intention to violate or infringe the 'child rights' if
              done with the knowledge that by his act the child
              right is likely to be violated then such offences are
              to be tried by the Children's Court. The learned
              Magistrates, before whom such charge sheets are
              filed, are to apply their minds and find whether
              offences complained of involve violation of the
              'child rights'. If so, such cases are to be committed
              to the Court of Sessions (The children's Court),
              following the procedure prescribed under Sections
              207 to 209 Cr.P.C. "


  14.In view of the discussion hereinabove made and in view of

  the aforesaid dictum, this Court is of the view that Annexure A1

  committal order will not sustain in the eye of law.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

                                PRESENT:

             MRS. JUSTICE MARY JOSEPH

         7TH DAY OF JUNE 2016
                        Crl.MC.No. 2910 of 2013
                  

            P.M.MATHEW,
        V 

            STATE OF KERALA,
           Citation:2016 CRLJ 4766
Print Page