Thus, by now it is fairly settled that to constitute a judgment
rendered by a Criminal Court, it is not the operative part written in
the order sheet which would constitute the judgment but it is the
discussion on the merits of the prosecution evidence, the
arguments of both the sides and the findings based on reasons to
conclude the trial in conviction or acquittal, which would constitute
a judgment.
29. If the orders in the order sheet passed in the present cases would
constitute a judgment, then there is nothing to be appealed
against because there is no discussion at all of the prosecution
case and the reasons for recording of such finding which entitles
the accused to be acquitted.
30. In view of the authoritative pronouncements by the Supreme
Court in Jagdev Singh Talwandi (supra) and Yakub Abdul
Razak Memon (supra), the order passed in order sheet in favour
of each of the petitioner acquitting them of the charges by a two
line order would not constitute judgment, therefore, the trial has
not come to an end on the basis of such order. Moreover, the trial
Judge has mentioned in the order sheet that the judgment is
signed and dated in the open Court, however, there is no
judgment available in the record of the Court, therefore, the Judge
himself had construed that there is a separate document which he
has referred as judgment, which is distinct and separate than the
order in the order sheet wherein the acquittal is recorded.
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH, BILASPUR
WPCR No. 2796 of 2008
Smt. Kiran Singh
Versus
The State Of Chhattisgarh,
Coram:
Hon'ble Shri Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra
Dated:18 /02/2016
Citation: 2016 CRLJ2793
rendered by a Criminal Court, it is not the operative part written in
the order sheet which would constitute the judgment but it is the
discussion on the merits of the prosecution evidence, the
arguments of both the sides and the findings based on reasons to
conclude the trial in conviction or acquittal, which would constitute
a judgment.
29. If the orders in the order sheet passed in the present cases would
constitute a judgment, then there is nothing to be appealed
against because there is no discussion at all of the prosecution
case and the reasons for recording of such finding which entitles
the accused to be acquitted.
30. In view of the authoritative pronouncements by the Supreme
Court in Jagdev Singh Talwandi (supra) and Yakub Abdul
Razak Memon (supra), the order passed in order sheet in favour
of each of the petitioner acquitting them of the charges by a two
line order would not constitute judgment, therefore, the trial has
not come to an end on the basis of such order. Moreover, the trial
Judge has mentioned in the order sheet that the judgment is
signed and dated in the open Court, however, there is no
judgment available in the record of the Court, therefore, the Judge
himself had construed that there is a separate document which he
has referred as judgment, which is distinct and separate than the
order in the order sheet wherein the acquittal is recorded.
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH, BILASPUR
WPCR No. 2796 of 2008
Smt. Kiran Singh
Versus
The State Of Chhattisgarh,
Coram:
Hon'ble Shri Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra
Dated:18 /02/2016
Citation: 2016 CRLJ2793