Showing posts with label certified copy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label certified copy. Show all posts

Thursday, 19 March 2026

⁠What is the status of Bank entries?

  The status of bank entries in India is that they are relevant and admissible as prima facie evidence, but they are generally not by themselves conclusive proof of liability. For a Judicial service interview, you should explain them through the combined scheme of the Bankers’ Books Evidence Act, 1891 and the rule on entries in books of account under the law of evidence.

Core concept

Print Page

Sunday, 30 March 2025

Bombay HC: Whether detailed ingredients mentioned in clause 8 of S. 2 of Bankers' Books Evidence Act, 1891 for qualifying to be certified copy are mandatory?

 Admittedly, the bank statements are not accompanied by certificate under the Bankers Book Evidence Act, however, bears the seal of Bank of Baroda and signature of the official. In Radheshyam G. Garg vs. Safiyabai Ibrahim Lighwalla (MANU/MH/0368/1988), this Court held the certificate under Bankers Book Evidence Act to be directory as under:


"The lower appellate Court by placing reliance on section 2(8) of the Bankers' Books Evidence Act, 1891 has held that 'certified copy' means a copy of any entry in the books of a Bank, together with a certificate written at the foot of such copy that it is a true copy of such entry, that such entry is contained in one of the ordinary books of the bank and was made in the usual and ordinary course of business, and that such book is still in the custody of the bank, such certificate being dated and subscribed by the principal accountant or manager of the Bank with his name and official title. According to the learned Judge since the said extracts of statement of account had not been signed by the principal accountant or manager as required and since the same did not bear any date or official seal, the same could not be treated as certified copy and consequently the same could not be read in evidence.


In my judgment the aforesaid view of the learned Judge of the lower appellate Court was hypertechnical. The said extract of account was duly signed by the Agent of the bank. Implicit in it was a certificate that it was a true copy of an entry contained in one of the ordinary books of the bank and was made in the usual and ordinary course of business and that such book was in the custody of the bank. The detailed ingredients mentioned in the defining clause 8 of section 2 of Bankers' Books Evidence Act, 1891 for qualifying to be 'certified copy' are not mandatory but merely directory." {Para 29}


30. In the present case, the original bank statements were not per se inadmissible in evidence. What was objected was to the mode and manner of proof. As held by this Court in the decision cited above, the detailed ingredients of Section 2(8) of Bankers Book Evidence Act are merely directory. The bank statements are the original bank statements bearing the seal and signature of the bank. PW-1 has deposed about the cheque payments made through Bank of Baroda and corroborated the same by producing original bank statement. The bank statements could be received as prima facie evidence of existence of such entries. Further, the Plaintiff was cross examined by the Defendant. Once the document is used in cross examination, then the document gets proved and can be read in evidence as held by the Apex Court in case of Ram Janki Devi vs. Juggilal Kamlapat [MANU/SC/0533/1971 : 1971:INSC:35 : 1971 (1) SCC 477]. The Apex Court in that case had held that it is not possible to accept complaint of lack of proof when the documents are shown in cross examination to the witness.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

First Appeal No. 1841 of 2024

Decided On: 21.02.2025

Yasin Khan and Ors. Vs. Ajit Developers Pvt. Ltd. and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Sharmila U. Deshmukh, J.

Citation: MANU/MH/1001/2025,2025:BHC-AS:8423.

Read full Judgment here: Click here.

Print Page

Saturday, 28 September 2024

Whether an appeal shall be barred by limitation if a party fails to obtain certified copy of judgment within limitation even if it is entitled to get free copy of judgment?

The import of Section 12 of the Limitation Act and its explanation is to assign the responsibility of applying for a certified copy of the order on a party. A person wishing to file an appeal is expected to file an application for a certified copy before the expiry of the limitation period, upon which the "time requisite" for obtaining a copy is to be excluded. However, the time taken by the court to prepare the decree or order before an application for a copy is made cannot be excluded. If no application for a certified copy has been made, no exclusion can ensue. In fact, the explanation to the provision is a clear indicator of the legal position that the time which is taken by the court to prepare the decree or order cannot be excluded before the application to obtain a copy is made. It cannot be said that the right to receive a free copy Under Section 420(3) of the Companies Act obviated the obligation on the Appellant to seek a certified copy through an application. 

The act of filing an application for a certified copy is not just a technical requirement for computation of limitation but also an indication of the diligence of the aggrieved party in pursuing the litigation in a timely fashion. 

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 3327 of 2020

Decided On: 22.10.2021

V. Nagarajan Vs. SKS Ispat and Power Ltd. and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Dr. D.Y. Chandrachud, Vikram Nath and B.V. Nagarathna, JJ.

Author: Dr. D.Y. Chandrachud, J.

 Citation: 2021 INSC 663,MANU/SC/0956/2021.

Print Page

Monday, 17 June 2024

Whether Motor accident claim tribunal can rely on certified copy of F.I.R. and spot panchnama if insurance company has not contested the claim on the issue of negligence?

 The documents in question, i.e., certified copy of F.I.R. and spot panchnama were produced by the original claimants along with the claim petition. In para 28 of the claim petition, reference is made to the fact that claimants were relying upon the documents which were produced along with application. In the written statement which is filed by the appellants, there is no dispute raised as regards the documents which are produced along with the application. It appears from the record that the claim application was not defended by the insured and the same was contested by the appellant as per order below in application at Exh. 34 passed under the provisions of Section 170 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. By the said order permission was granted in favour of the appellant to take all defences and to contest the claim on merits. On 24.7.2002, the said application was allowed. After the said application was allowed, additional written statement or further written statement was not filed by the appellant. The evidence was recorded by the Claims Tribunal and on 5.8.2002, the evidence close pursis was filed by the advocate for the appellant. On the next date, i.e., 12.8.2002 written submissions were filed on behalf of appellant and on 21.8.2002 the learned Member of the Claims Tribunal heard the oral submissions made by the advocate for the claimants and the matter was closed for judgment. Thus, no oral submissions were made on behalf of the appellant. I have perused the written submissions of appellant at Exh.  A1. The written submissions are filed raising only dispute as regards quantum of compensation payable to the claimants. Not a single submission is made on behalf of the appellant on the issue of negligence. In the written submissions, it is stated that considering the evidence on record, total income of the deceased will be Rs. 22,000 per annum and after deducting 1/3rd from his income and applying multiplier of 15 years, compensation payable will be Rs. 2,19,000 plus Rs. 10,000 for conventional amount and Rs. 5,000 for funeral. It is very clear that appellant insurance company did not contest claim as far as issue of negligence is concerned. Only contest was on the quantum of amount payable to the claimants. Therefore, a specific case is made out that the respondent Nos. 1 to 4 are entitled to compensation of only Rs. 2,19,000. Though opportunity was granted to the insurance company to defend the claim on behalf of insured both on the issue of negligence and quantum, the said opportunity was not availed of and the contest by the insurance company was restricted only to the quantum of amount of compensation. There were clear averments made in the application as regards negligence by the driver of the jeep. The driver and owner of the jeep though served did not file the written statement. Appellant insurance company even after leave was granted did not contest the case on the issue of negligence. It is obvious that as there was no contest by the appellant on the issue of negligence, the claimants did not examine any eyewitness and did not examine any witness to prove the certified copy of the spot panchnama or F.I.R. {Para 6}


7. In this view of the matter, the contention raised by the appellants that the panchnama and F.I.R. was not admissible in the evidence for want of proof cannot be considered.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

F.A. No. 524 of 2003

Decided On: 11.08.2004

Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Sangita Dattatraya Jamdade and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Abhay Shreeniwas Oka, J.

Citation:  MANU/MH/1406/2004,2006 ACJ 971 Bom.

Print Page

Tuesday, 14 May 2024

Telangana HC: Procedure to be followed by the court when accused files copy of bail order downloaded from E- court Website

 Hence, this Court feels that an alternative mechanism shall be evolved to address the plight of these under-trial prisoners/accused.


(a) Parties/Advocates shall download the order copy from the High Court's Website along with case details which are available in the case status information.


(b) While filing the memo on behalf of accused for furnishing sureties, the Advocate shall state in the Memo that he/she has downloaded the order copy from the High Court's Website. The Administrative Officer/Chief Ministerial Officer of the Court concerned shall verify the order from the High Court's Website and make an endorsement to that effect and then shall place the same before the Court.


(c) The Public Prosecutor shall also obtain necessary instructions in this regard and assist the Court.


(d) The Presiding Officer, on the same day, shall dispose of the same and dispatch the release order to the jail authorities concerned forthwith through e-mail or any other electronic mode.


(e) In cases of anticipatory bail, the burden to verify the authenticity of the copy is on the Station House Officer concerned and if necessary, he should obtain necessary instructions from the Public Prosecutor's Office and complete the process on the same day expeditiously as per law.


(f) The jail authorities on receipt of the release order shall release the accused forthwith. {Para 14}

IN THE HIGH COURT OF STATE OF TELANGANA

Criminal Petition No. 8108 of 2021

Decided On: 15.11.2021

V. Bharath Kumar Vs. The State of Telangana

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Lalitha Kanneganti, J.

Citation: MANU/TL/0912/2021.

Print Page

Sunday, 4 February 2024

Supreme Court: Accused in cheque bounce case can disprove his signature on cheque by producing its certified copy

 Certified copy of a document issued by a Bank is itself

admissible under the Bankers’ Books Evidence Act, 1891 without

any formal proof thereof. Hence, in an appropriate case, the

certified copy of the specimen signature maintained by the Bank

can be procured with a request to the Court to compare the same

with the signature appearing on the cheque by exercising powers

under Section 73 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. {Para 15}

16. Thus, we are of the view that if at all, the appellant was

desirous of proving that the signatures as appearing on the cheque issued from his account were not genuine, then he could have procured a certified copy of his specimen signatures from the Bank and a request could have been made to summon the concerned Bank official in defence for giving evidence regarding the genuineness or otherwise of the signature on the cheque.

17. However, despite having opportunity, the accused appellant

did not put any question to the bank official examined in defence

for establishing his plea of purported mismatch of signature on the cheque in question and hence, we are of the firm opinion that the appellate Court was not required to come to the aid and assistance of the appellant for collecting defence evidence at his behest. The presumptions under the NI Act albeit rebuttable operate in favour of the complainant. Hence, it is for the accused to rebut such presumptions by leading appropriate defence evidence and the Court cannot be expected to assist the accused to collect evidence on his behalf.

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

Criminal Appeal@SLP(Crl.) No(s). 16641 of 2023

AJITSINH CHEHUJI RATHOD Vs STATE OF GUJARAT & ANR.

Author: Mehta, J.

Citation: 2024 INSC 63.

Dated: January 29, 2024.
Print Page

Saturday, 28 October 2023

Whether the court can permit any party to prove certified copy of Sale deed as secondary evidence?

 Having regard to all the aforesaid circumstances and in the light of the various provisions of the Evidence Act mentioned hereinbefore we will firstly consider the question whether the Appellant/Plaintiff had succeeded in proving the contents of Ext.A1. Going by Section 65(e) when the original of a document is a public document within the meaning of Section 74, secondary evidence relating its original viz., as to its existence, condition or contents may be given by producing its certified copy. Ext.A1, indisputably is the certified copy of sale deed No. 1209/1928 dated 27.08.1928 of SRO Andipatti. In terms of Section 74(2) of the Evidence Act, its original falls within the definition of public document and there is no case that it is not certified in the manner provided under the Evidence Act. As noticed hereinbefore, the sole objection is that what was produced as Ext.A1 is only a certified copy of the sale deed and its original was not produced in evidence. The hollowness and unsustainability of the said objection would be revealed on application of the relevant provisions under the Evidence Act and the Registration Act, 1908. It is in this regard that Section 77 and 79 of the Evidence Act, as extracted earlier, assume relevance. Section 77 provides for the production of certified copy of a public document as secondary evidence in proof of contents of its original. Section 79 is the provision for presumption as to the genuineness of certified copies provided the existence of a law declaring certified copy of a document of such nature to be admissible as evidence. When that be the position under the aforesaid provisions, taking note of the fact that the document in question is a registered sale deed, falling within the definition of a public document, the question is whether there exists any law declaring such certified copy of a document as admissible in evidence for the purpose of proving the contents of its original document. Sub-section (5) of Section 57 of the Registration Act is the relevant provision that provides that certified copy given Under Section 57 of the Registration Act shall be admissible for the purpose of proving the contents of its original document. In this context it is to be noted that certified copy issued thereunder is not a copy of the original document, but is a copy of the registration entry which is itself a copy of the original and is a public document Under Section 74(2) of the Evidence Act and Sub-section (5) thereof, makes it admissible in evidence for proving the contents of its original. There is no case that foundation for letting in secondary evidence was not laid and as noted earlier, both the trial Court and the First Appellate Court found it admissible in evidence. Thus, the cumulative effect of the aforementioned Sections of the Evidence Act and Section 57(5) of the Registration Act would make the certified copy of the sale deed No. 1209/1928 dated 27.08.1928 of SRO Andipatti, produced as Ext.A1 admissible in evidence for the purpose of proving the contents of the said original document. When this be the position in the light of the specific provisions referred hereinbefore under the Evidence Act and the Registration Act, we have no hesitation to hold that the finding of the High Court that the certified copy of Ext.A1 owing to the failure in production of the original and proving through an independent witness is inadmissible in evidence, is legally unsustainable. In the other words, the acceptance of the admissibility of Ext.A1 found in favour of the Appellant/Plaintiff by the trial Court and confirmed by the First Appellate Court was perfectly in tune with the provisions referred hereinbefore and the High Court had committed an error in reversing the finding regarding the admissibility of Ext.A1. {Para 29}

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 14630 of 2015 

Decided On: 20.09.2023

Appaiya Vs. Andimuthu and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

B.R. Gavai and C.T. Ravikumar, JJ.

Author: C.T. Ravikumar, J.

Citation:  MANU/SC/1034/2023.

Print Page

Saturday, 31 December 2022

Bombay HC: Advocates Appointed By Legal Aid Or Court Exempt From Filing Certified Copies Of Judgement In Appeal

 The learned counsel Mr. Pawan Mali has strenuously preparedthe Appeal Memo along with the Application for condonation of delay.It appears that the office has not permitted him to file the Appeal and

Application, mentioning.doc rather has not accepted his papers on the ground that he has not furnished the certified copy of the impugned judgment. In fact the learned counsel was never given a certified copy of the said judgment by the Legal Aid Services Authority. {Para 3}

4. In view of this, the learned counsel Mr. Pawan Mali is exempted

from filing of the certified copy of the judgment and order in Sessions Case No.41 of 2016. Office to accept the papers and register the same as in other proceedings.

5. These directions would be applicable to all Advocates who are

appointed either by the Court or by the Legal Aid Services Authority.

Non-filing of the certified copy of the judgment shall not be an

impediment to accept the papers and register the Appeals by the

office.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. OF 2022

Babi Krushna Pawar  Vs The State of Maharashtra .

CORAM: SMT. SADHANA S. JADHAV &

MILIND N. JADHAV,J.

DATE MARCH 30, 2022.

Print Page

Sunday, 9 January 2022

Whether an appellant can claim condonation of delay in insolvency appeal if it has not made an application for a certified copy within limitation?

D. Conclusion

21. The answer to the two issues set out in Section C of the judgement- (i) when will the clock for calculating the limitation period run for proceedings under the IBC; and (ii) is the annexation of a certified copy mandatory for an appeal to the NCLAT against an order passed under the IBC – must be based on a harmonious interpretation of the applicable legal regime, given that the IBC is a Code in itself and has overriding effect. Sections 61(1) and (2) of the IBC consciously omit the requirement of limitation being computed from when the “order is made available to the aggrieved party”, in contradistinction to Section 421(3) of the Companies Act. Owing to the special nature of the IBC, the aggrieved party is expected to exercise due diligence and apply for a certified copy upon pronouncement of the order it seeks to assail, in consonance with the requirements of Rule 22(2) of the NCLAT Rules. Section 12(2) of the Limitation Act allows for an exclusion of the time requisite for obtaining a copy of the decree or order appealed against. It is not open to a person aggrieved by an order under the IBC to await the receipt of a free certified copy under Section 420(3) of the Companies Act 2013 read with Rule 50 of the NCLT and prevent limitation from running. Accepting such a construction will upset the timely framework of the IBC. The litigant has to file its appeal within thirty days, which can be extended up to a period of fifteen days, and no more, upon showing sufficient cause. A sleight of interpretation of procedural rules cannot be used to defeat the substantive objective of a legislation that has an impact on the economic health of a nation.

22. On the second question, Rule 22(2) of the NCLAT Rules mandates the certified copy being annexed to an appeal, which continues to bind litigants under the IBC. While it is true that the tribunals, and even this Court, may choose to exempt parties from compliance with this procedural requirement in the interest of substantial justice, as re-iterated in Rule 14 of the NCLAT Rules, the discretionary waiver does not act as an automatic exception where litigants make no efforts to pursue a timely resolution of their grievance. The appellant having failed to apply for a certified copy, rendered the appeal filed before the NCLAT as clearly barred by limitation.

 

Supreme Court

JUSTICE DR. DHANANJAYA Y. CHANDRACHUD JUSTICE VIKRAM NATH JUSTICE B. V. NAGARATHNA

V. Nagarajan Vs. SKS Ispat and Power Ltd.& Ors.

Civil Appeal No. 3327 of 2020

22nd October 2021

Author: Dr. Dhananjaya Y. Chandrachud, J.

Citation: 2021 ALL SCR (ONLINE) 588

Print Page

Sunday, 21 November 2021

Supreme court: HC to ensure that certified copy of judgment are issued as per S 76 of Evidence Act

Before parting, it may be noted that in the case of the accused Libnus, the State of Maharashtra while filing the Appeal before this Court had not produced the certified copy of the judgment of the High Court, however, had produced a copy of a certified copy, wherein the High Court had recorded acquittal of the accused for the offence under Sections 8, 10 and 12 of the POCSO Act, while maintaining his conviction under Sections 448 and 354-A(1)(i) of the IPC, whereas in the copy of the impugned judgment of the High Court downloaded by the respondent-accused produced on record by the learned Advocate for the accused, the High Court had recorded the conviction of the accused for the offence under Sections 448 and 354-A(1)(i) of the IPC read with Section 12 of the POCSO Act. There being a discrepancy in the said two copies of the impugned judgment of the High Court, the learned Advocate for the respondent-accused had filed an I.A. bringing to the notice of the Court about such discrepancy. The Court, therefore, had vide its order dated 27.10.2021 directed the Registrar of the High Court to send the certified copy of the decision of the High court dated 15.01.2021 passed in Criminal Appeal No. 445 of 2020. Accordingly, the Assistant Registrar of the High Court of Bombay, Nagpur Bench, has sent the certified copy of the said judgment.{Para 48}

49. It is very surprising to note that the Registry of High Court of Bombay, Nagpur Bench, has certified the copy of the impugned judgment by affixing the stamp on the back side of every page of the judgment which is blank. The said copy of the judgment appears to have been downloaded from the website and, therefore, does not bear even the signature or the name of the concerned judge at the end of the judgment. The certificate that the said copy is a true copy of the judgment, is also not written at the foot of the judgment as contemplated in Section 76 of the Indian Evidence Act. Such a practice, if followed by the Nagpur Bench of the Bombay High Court, may allow the miscreants to manipulate or commit mischief in the judicial orders which are used as the public documents having great significance in the judicial proceedings. The Registrar General of the Bombay High Court, therefore, is directed to look into the matter and ensure that proper procedure for preparing the certified copies of the judgments/orders of the Court in accordance with law is followed.
Supreme Court

JUSTICE UDAY UMESH LALIT JUSTICE BELA M. TRIVEDI JUSTICE S. RAVINDRA BHAT

ATTORNEY GENERAL FOR INDIA Vs. SATISH & ANR.

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 1410 OF 2021

18th November 2021


Author: BELA M. TRIVEDI, J.

Citation: 2021 ALL SCR (ONLINE) 664

Print Page

Sunday, 25 April 2021

How to ascertain the limitation of filing the petition if the party entitled to get a free copy of the order as per statute has not received it?

  Therefore, it is true, as contended by the Appellants, that the period of limitation of 45 days prescribed in Section 421(3) would start running only from the date on which a copy of the order of the Tribunal is made available to the person aggrieved. It is also true that Under Section 420(3) of the Act read with Rule 50, the Appellants were entitled to be furnished with a certified copy of the order free of cost.{Para 13}


14. Therefore if the Appellants had chosen not to file a copy application, but to await the receipt of a free copy of the order in terms of Section 420(3) read with Rule 50, they would be perfectly justified in falling back on Section 421(3), for fixing the date from which limitation would start running. But the Appellants in this case, chose to apply for a certified copy after 27 days of the pronouncement of the order in their presence and they now fall back upon Section 421(3).


15. Despite the above factual position, we do not want to hold against the Appellants, the fact that they waited from 25.10.2019 (the date of the order of NCLT) upto 21.11.2019, to make a copy application. But atleast from 19.12.2019, the date on which a certified copy was admittedly received by the counsel for the Appellants, the period of limitation cannot be stopped from running.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal Nos. 3007-3008 of 2020

Decided On: 18.09.2020


 Sagufa Ahmed   Vs. Upper Assam Plywood Products Pvt. Ltd. and Ors.

Print Page

Friday, 13 November 2020

Whether claimant in a motor accident case can prove his case by producing certified copy of deposition of witness recorded in a criminal case?

In all these authorities this Court as well as the Hon'ble Apex Court reiterated the basic principle that is required to be established in motor accident claim petition, that the burden is on the claimant to prove the accident including the involvement of the vehicle/s, as the case may be. Here, in this case, in order to prove the said involvement of the vehicle owned by respondent No. 1 and insured with respondent No. 2 the claimants have relied on police papers only. Important point to be noted is that the First Information Report is admittedly lodged by an eye witness i.e. Niraj Kothari, who was the rider of motorcycle, on which, deceased was the pillion rider. Claimants have not given any reason, as to why Niraj Kothari has been kept out of the witness box before the Tribunal. At this stage itself, it can also be considered that now the appellants intend to produce the certified copy of deposition of Niraj taken in criminal case. In fact, when in this case, he has not been examined, his deposition in criminal case cannot be read in evidence. From the said document it appears that he was examined before the criminal Court on 27.03.2018, whereas this petition was decided by the Tribunal on 31.03.2018. Even if, we take this fact liberally and allow the deposition of Niraj to be read in evidence in this case, yet in the examination-in-chief itself, he has merely stated that his vehicle was dashed by a bullet motorcycle, but then he has further stated, that he cannot give number of the bullet vehicle and he will not be about to identify the bullet rider. Surprisingly, though his First Information Report appears to have been exhibited before the Criminal Court, yet the prosecution has not resorted to the proceeding as contemplated under Section 145 of the Indian Evidence Act, when it can be said that witness was not supporting the prosecution. Therefore, even after allowing such document to be produced on record, yet it cannot be stated that the involvement of the vehicle could be proved by the claimants.

14. As regards those applications, wherein the claimants intending to produce certified copies on record, it can be again said that no reason has been assigned by the claimants, as to why they could not produce these documents, when the matter was before the Tribunal. If they want to invoke the provisions of Order 41 Rule 27 of CPC, the first and the foremost ingredient that is required to be considered is, that they were not having custody of that document or they could not procure it even after due diligence, when the matter was before the Tribunal. The reason, that has been tried to be stated that there was inadvertent omission on the part of their Advocate in not placing those documents on record. They have not come with a case that during the pendency of the claim petition they had given those documents in the custody of their Advocate but Advocate did not produce those documents on record. If the procurement of the documents is itself after the decision in the matter, then the reasons given by them cannot be said to be sufficient. Merely because they are the certified copies in another litigation they cannot be allowed to produce those documents on record, in order to fill up the lacuna in leading evidence by them before the Tribunal.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)

First Appeal No. 396 of 2019, 

Decided On: 25.09.2019

 Kalpana Rajendra Kothari  Vs. Santosh Arvind Jangam and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Vibha Kankanwadi, J.

Citation: MANU/MH/2713/2019,2020(2) MHLJ 561

Print Page

Tuesday, 8 September 2020

Leading Supreme Court on obtaining information from courts under RTI, Confidential Information and Data Protection

In order to consider the contentions urged by the learned Senior Counsel for the Appellant and Mr. Prashant Bhushan, let us briefly refer to the various categories of information held by the High Court, which are broadly as under:

(a) information held by the High Court relating to the parties to the litigation/proceedings - pleadings, documents and other materials and memo of grounds raised by the parties;

(b) orders and judgments passed by the High Court, notes of proceedings, etc.;

(c) In exercise of power of superintendence over the other courts and tribunals, information received in the records submitted/called for by those courts and tribunals like subordinate judiciary, various tribunals like Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Customs Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal and other tribunals;

(d) information on the administrative side of the High Court viz. appointments, transfers and postings of the judicial officers, staff members of the High Court and the district judiciary, disciplinary action taken against the judicial officers and the staff members and such other information relating to the administrative work.

(e) Correspondence by the High Court with the Supreme Court, Government and with the district judiciary, etc.;
and

(f) information on the administrative side as to the decision taken by the collegium of the High Court in making recommendations of the Judges to be appointed to the High Court; information as to the assets of the sitting Judges held by the Chief Justice of the High Court.

25. Information under the categories (a), (b) and (c) and other information on the judicial side can be accessed/certified copies of documents and orders could be obtained by the parties to the proceedings in terms of the High Court Rules and the parties to the proceedings are entitled to the same. So far as the third parties are concerned, as of right, they are not entitled to access the information/obtain the certified copies of documents, orders and other proceedings. As per Rules framed by the High Court, a third party can obtain the certified copies of the documents, orders or judgments or can have access to the information only by filing an application/affidavit and by stating the reason for which the information/copies of documents or orders are required. Insofar as on the administrative side i.e. categories (d), (e) and (f), one can have access to the information or copies of the documents could be obtained under the Rules framed by the various High Courts or under the Rules framed by the High Court under the RTI Act. Insofar as the disclosure of information as to the assets of the Judges held by the Chief Justice of the High Court, the same is now covered by the judgment of the Constitution Bench reported in Central Public Information Officer, Supreme Court of India v. Subhash Chandra Agrawal MANU/SC/1561/2019 : 2019 (16) SCALE 40.


27. Rule 151 of the Gujarat High Court Rules, 1993 requires a third party applicant seeking copies of documents in any civil or criminal proceedings to file an application/affidavit stating the reasons for which those documents are required. As such, the High Court Rules do not obstruct a third party from obtaining copies of documents in any court proceedings or any document on the judicial side. It is not as if the information is denied or refused to the applicant. All that is required to be done is to apply for the certified copies with application/affidavit stating the reasons for seeking the information. The reason insisting upon the third party for stating the grounds for obtaining certified copies is to satisfy the court that the information is sought for bona fide reasons or to effectuate public interest. The information is held by the High Court as a trustee for the litigants in order to adjudicate upon the matter and administer justice. The same cannot be permitted by the third party to have access to such personal information of the parties or information given by the Government in the proceedings. Lest, there would be misuse of process of court and the information and it would reach unmanageable levels. If the High Court Rules framed Under Article 225 provide a mechanism for invoking the said right in a particular manner, the said mechanism should be preserved and followed. The said mechanism cannot be abandoned or discontinued merely because the general law - RTI Act has been enacted.

28. As discussed earlier, the object of the RTI Act itself recognizes the need to protect the institutional interest and also to make optimum use of limited fiscal resources and preservation of confidentiality of sensitive information. The procedure to obtain certified copies under the High Court Rules is not cumbersome and the procedure is very simple - filing of an application/affidavit along with the requisite court fee stating the reasons for seeking the information. The information held by the High Court on the judicial side are the "personal information" of the litigants like title cases and family court matters, etc. Under the guise of seeking information under the RTI Act, the process of the court is not to be abused and information not to be misused.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal Nos. 1966-1967 of 2020 

Decided On: 04.03.2020

Chief Information Commissioner Vs.  High Court of Gujarat and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
R. Banumathi, A.S. Bopanna and Hrishikesh Roy, JJ.

Author:R. Banumathi, J.
Citation:(2020) 4 SCC 702
Print Page

Sunday, 28 June 2020

Whether Court can give a certified copy of the statement of the victim recorded U/S 164 of CRPC to accused before the filing of chargesheet?

 In this decision, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that copy of the statement under Section 164 of the Code should be handed over to the Investigating Officer immediately with a specific direction that the contents of such statement under Section 164 of the Code should not be disclosed to any person till the charge-sheet/report under Section 173 of the Code is filed. So, it is clear from the dictum that, in the case of rape the statement recorded under Section 164 of the Code of a prosecutrix has to be kept in secret till the final report is filed. That was intended to protect the interest of the prosecutrix and also taking into account the possibility of threat to her life, if such statement has been disclosed to others at that stage.  So in view of the observations made by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the decision cited supra State of Karnataka by Nonavinakere Police v. Shivanna @ Tarkari Shivanna MANU/SC/0400/2014 : 2014 KHC 4321 : 2014 (2) KHC SN 47 : 2014 (6) SCALE 30 : 2014 (2) KLT 767, the learned Magistrate was perfectly justified in rejecting the prayer for issuing certified copy of Section 164 statement recorded by the Magistrate of the prosecutrix to the accused as he is not entitled for the same at this stage as of right and I do not find any reason to interfere with the same. So this petition is liable to be dismissed.


Ratio-  Section 164 CRPC -An accused is not entitled to get a certified copy of the deposition recorded under S. 164 during the stage of investigation.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA

Crl. M.C. No. 2627 of 2014

Decided On: 13.08.2014


 Shakkeer M.K. Vs.   State of Kerala

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

K. Ramakrishnan, J.

Citation;2014 CRLJ 4430 Kerala

Print Page

Thursday, 5 March 2020

Supreme Court: If party can obtain certified copy,they should not file application under RTI

43. We summarise our conclusion:-
(i) Rule 151 of the Gujarat High Court Rules stipulating
a third party to have access to the
information/obtaining the certified copies of the
documents or orders requires to file an
application/affidavit stating the reasons for seeking
the information, is not inconsistent with the provisions
of the RTI Act; but merely lays down a different
procedure as the practice or payment of fees, etc. for
obtaining information. In the absence of inherent
inconsistency between the provisions of the RTI Act
and other law, overriding effect of RTI Act would not
apply.
(ii) The information to be accessed/certified copies on
the judicial side to be obtained through the
mechanism provided under the High Court Rules, the
provisions of the RTI Act shall not be resorted to.

REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO(S).1966-1967 OF 2020

CHIEF INFORMATION COMMISSIONER Vs  HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT 

R. BANUMATHI, J.
Dated:March 04, 2020.
Print Page

Saturday, 28 December 2019

Bom HC: Document obtained under RTI can not be treated as public document if original is private document

Under RTI, usually the applicant gets photostat copies of the documents which are certified as true copies. They cannot be equated with certified copies mentioned in the Evidence Act. In other words, if the official under RTI certifies and supplies a private document, it still remains a private document. Thus, the RTI Act does not affect the nature of a document.

36. In Datti Kameswari, a learned Single Judge of the High Court of Andhra Pradesh has held that the copies obtained under the Right to Information Act certified by the Authorised Information Officer cannot be termed public documents or primary evidence. Only if the original qualifies to be a public document, then does its certified copy. But if the original is a private document, its copy secured under RTI Act does not get transformed into a public document. In that event, that certified copy of the private document must satisfy the provisions of Evidence Act for secondary evidence.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Writ Petition No. 8764 of 2018

Decided On: 07.08.2019

 Kumarpal N. Shah Vs.  Universal Mechanical Works Pvt. Ltd.
Print Page

Sunday, 3 November 2019

Supreme Court:Limitation for filing appeal is to be computed on the basis of endorsement contained in certified copy

The appellate Court as also the High Court have proceeded
on the basis of the endorsement on the certified copy of the order
under appeal and proceeded to hold that the appeal was within
limitation, since in computing limitation, the time required for
obtaining the certified copy is required to be excluded. The
reasoning as of the Appellate Court confirmed and reiterated by the
High Court is unexceptionable. Whether the certified copy was
actually made ready before the date shown on the reverse of the
certified copy; what are the circumstances on which the certified
copy to the party was supplied earlier but later to another party
though the applications were filed on the same date, are not issues
which can be decided in these proceedings. Nor could the same have
been decided by the High Court in a Writ Petition. The Courts are
obliged to compute the limitation on the basis of the endorsement
as contained in the certified copy. If there is any suspicion of
unfair and/or improper practice, the remedy lies in initiating a
domestic inquiry or may be criminal investigation against the
concerned staff of the Court responsible for supply of certified
copies.
S U P R E M E C O U R T O F I N D I A
RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS
Petition for Special Leave to Appeal (C) No.24862/2019

MUKESH RAMDEVJI AGARWAL Vs BALMUKUND DHRUVANARAYAN LOHIYA (HUF) 

CORAM : HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE INDIRA BANERJEE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.R. SHAH
Dated: 25 -10-2019
Print Page

Sunday, 28 July 2019

What right a party acquires if a person who is directed to produce his title deed fails to produce it?

 In so far as the first reason is concerned it is not disputed that the plaintiff had caused summonses to be served upon the witness who had custody of the original and was called upon to produce it. The witness, however, did not comply with the order of the Court. The plaintiff subsequently applied for the issue of a warrant against the witness but no process-fee was paid for service of the writ. This does not, in our opinion, amount to default on the part of the plaintiff. As was pointed out by this Court in the case of Bhagabat Prasad Singh v. King Emperor 14 C.L.J. 120 : 11 Ind. Cas. 794 under Section 130of the Indian Evidence Act, no witness who is not a party to a suit can be compelled to produce his title-deed to any property, or any document in virtue of which he holds any property as pledgee or mortgagee or any document the production of which might tend to incriminate him, unless he has agreed in writing to produce them with the person seeking the production of such deed or some person through whom he claims. It cannot be disputed that the lessee under the perpetual lease of the 21st December 1874 was entitled to urge that the document was his title-deed, and that he was not bound to produce the original except in the event contemplated by Section 130 of the Indian Evidence Act. It is not alleged that the lessee had agreed with the plaintiff in writing to produce the original in Court. Consequently, if, after service of summons upon him, he did not pro duce the original, the plaintiff became entitled to use the certified copy as secondary evidence. The first reason assigned by the Subordinate Judge in support of his order of rejection of the document cannot, therefore be supported.

Calcutta High Court
Imrit Chamar vs Sridhar Panday And Ors. on 29 August, 1911
Equivalent citations: 13 Ind Cas 120
Bench: Mookerjee, Carnduff
Print Page

Tuesday, 16 July 2019

Whether application for execution of decree is tenable even though certified copy of decree is not filed along with execution application?

This takes us to examine the next question,
namely, what is the effect of not filing the copy of
the decree along with the execution application filed
by the appellant. In our view, even though the
appellant did not file the certified copy of the decree
along with the execution application for the reason
that the same was not passed by the Court, yet the
execution application filed by the appellant, in our
view, was maintainable. Indeed, so long as the
formal decree was not passed, the order dated
01.06.2012 was to be treated as a decree during the
interregnum period by virtue of Order 20 Rule 6A (2)
of the Code. In other words, notwithstanding the
fact that the decree had not been passed, yet by
virtue of principle underlined in Order 20 Rule 6A(2)
of the Code, the order dated 01.06.2012 had the

effect of a decree till the date of actual passing of
the decree by the Court for the purposes of
execution or for any other purpose. This empowered
the Executing Court to entertain the execution
application and decide the objections raised by the
respondent on merits.

REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL No.5534 OF 2019

Sir Sobha Singh And Sons Pvt. Ltd Vs Shashi Mohan Kapur(Deceased) Thr. L.R.
Abhay Manohar Sapre, J.
Dated:July 15, 2019.
Print Page

Monday, 1 July 2019

When certified copy of public document is presumed to be authentic?

Section 114 of the Evidence Act enables the Court to presume the existence of any fact which it thinks likely to have happened, regard being had to the common course of natural events, human conduct an public and private business, in their relation to the fact of the particular case. The illustrations to the section state that the Court may presume, inter alia, that judicial and official acts have been regularly performed. In respect of public documents which form the acts or records of the acts of the sovereign authority, official bodies and Tribunals, and of public officers, legislative, judicial and executive, the presumption can be and is, in fact, invariably drawn. It is necessary, however, to appreciate that the source of the presumption is S. 114.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Suit No. 1108 of 1981

Decided On: 28.06.1982

Om Prakash Berlia  Vs. Unit Trust of India and Ors

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
S.P. Bharucha, J.


Citation:AIR 1983 Bom 1
Print Page