Imagine standing with friends when a dispute erupts, only to later face serious criminal charges—not for anything you did, but simply for being present. This exact dilemma, testing the line between presence and culpability, was the focus of Keshav Mahato v. State of Bihar, a case that reached the Supreme Court after the Patna High Court declined to intervene. The verdict delivers a powerful clarification on personal responsibility in criminal law.
Mere Presence Isn't a Crime: The Court Demands an "Overt Act"
In Bihar's Bhagalpur district, Keshav Mahato was charged under the stringent Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, or SC/ST Act, for being present with others during an altercation. When the case reached the Supreme Court, the justices asked the prosecution a single, piercing question: "What is the specific evidence against the appellant?"
Print Page