Showing posts with label paternity test. Show all posts
Showing posts with label paternity test. Show all posts

Wednesday, 25 May 2016

When court should direct conduct of DNA test to ascertain paternity?


The ratio of all these judgments referred to above go to suggest that
D.N.A. Test cannot be ordered as a matter of routine. When Section 112 of the
Evidence Act was enacted at that time there was not even any contemplation of the
legislature to make provision regarding D.N.A. Test which is virtually the outcome
of advancement of modern science. It is perhaps needless to repeat that if D.N.A.
Test is done it will be clear if the petitioner is the biological father of the girl child or
not. At the same time it has to be kept in mind that a person cannot be compelled
to undergo D.N.A. Test. Here the petitioner himself voluntarily preferred to undergoD.N.A. Test. The question is he has also prayed for D.N.A. Test of child ‘Rithika’.
Since the divorce suit has been filed on the allegation of adultery in my view, the
Learned Court below ought to have allowed the said prayer of the petitioner. If the
opposite party, in whose custody the minor girl child is, refuses to place ‘Rithika’
for undergoing D.N.A. Test in that case concerned Court must draw a presumption
of the nature contemplated in Section 114 (H) of the Indian Evidence Act.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
(CIVIL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION)
C.O. 2940 of 2015
Ranatish Saha
 Vs.
 Smt. Soma Saha & Anr.
CORAM: The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Siddhartha Chattopadhyay

Judgment Delivered on : 24.09.2015.
Citation; AIR 2016 (NOC)268 CAl

Print Page

Thursday, 21 April 2016

UK High court allows paternity test for DNA disease analysis

Spencer v Anderson (Paternity Testing) [2016] EWHC 851 (Fam) – read judgment
A fascinating case in the Family Division throws up a number of facts that some may find surprising. One is that this is the first time the courts in this country have been asked to direct post-mortem scientific testing to establish paternity. The other is that DNA is not covered by the Human Tissue Act, because genetic material does not contain human cells. One might wonder why the statute doesn’t, given that DNA is the instruction manual that makes the  human tissue that it covers – but maybe updating the 2004 law to cover genetic material would create more difficulties than it was designed to resolve.
The facts can be briefly stated. The applicant had been made aware of his possible relationship to S, who had died of bowel cancer some years before. When S had presented with the disease, it turned out that there was a family history of such cancer. The hospital treating him therefore took a blood sample and extracted DNA from it to test for high-risk genes. If the applicant was the son of the deceased he would have a 50% risk of inherited predisposition to bowel cancer. This risk would be mitigated by biannual colonoscopies.
The applicant – who had been made aware made aware of the possibility that S might have been his father – therefore sought the consent of the deceased’s next of kin for testing of this DNA sample. S’s mother (one of the respondents in this case) refused.
  1. Weighing these matters up with appropriate caution, and seeking to strike a fair balance between the competing private and public interests, I have reached the conclusion that scientific testing should take place to seek to establish the paternity of Mr Spencer by using the stored DNA sample of the late Mr Anderson. These are my reasons:

  2. (1) If the application for a declaration of parentage had appeared to be speculative or opportunistic, the request for scientific testing would probably not have succeeded. However, the overall evidence here raises the real possibility that Mr Anderson was Mr Spencer's father, he having undeniably been in a relationship with Mr Spencer's mother at the time of conception.
    (2) It is common ground between the parties that there is a significant medical issue that turns on the possibility of a biological relationship between Mr Anderson and Mr Spencer. It is of course possible for Mr Spencer to be tested periodically by colonoscopy, but that is only a partial solution because he is surely entitled to know the reason why he should undergo those procedures, or to be relieved of the need to do so. As recently as February 2015, Mrs Anderson regarded it as "essential" that Mr Spencer's paternity should be established. It does not now lie easily in her mouth to say the opposite.
    (3) Although it is possible that the late Mr Anderson (like the alleged father in Jaggi) might have refused to consent to testing during his lifetime, there is no particular reason to regard that as likely. Whether or not he would have welcomed the possibility that he was a father, it may not do justice to his memory to assume that he would have withheld his support from a young man who might have inherited a serious medical condition from him.

    (4) The information, in the form of the DNA sample, is readily available and does not require physically intrusive investigations. In particular, it does not require exhumation, as to which particular considerations would undoubtedly arise.

    (5) There is no objection on behalf of the hospital, which might be seen as being a nominal representative of the public interest in this case.

    (6) The interests of third parties, and in particular those of Mrs Anderson to the extent that they may be engaged, are, with all respect, of lesser significance. There is no indication of any real risk of harm and the establishment of the truth carries greater weight than the question of whether it is palatable.
  3. I accordingly find that Mr Spencer's interest in knowing his biological parentage, the questions raised by the medical history, and the marked advantages of scientific testing as a means of resolving both issues, collectively carry more weight in the particular circumstances of this case than the counter-indicators to testing that undoubtedly exist. It is in the interests of justice that testing should take place, and it is a proper exercise of the court's inherent jurisdiction to secure this outcome.
    Case No: PR15P00702
    Neutral Citation Number: [2016] EWHC 851 (Fam)
    IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE
    FAMILY DIVISION
    15 April 2016
    Before:
    THE HONOURABLE MR JUSTICE PETER JACKSON
    Sitting at Manchester Civil Justice Centre
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

    Between :


    David Spencer
    -and-
    Carol Spencer
    -and-
    Darren Hall
    -and-
    Valerie Anderson
    (Personal Representative of the Estate of William Brian Anderson Deceased)
Print Page

Thursday, 22 October 2015

Whether court should order DNA test in exceptional cases?

We may observe here that any order passed by the Court for DNA Test, may affect an innocent child, who may have to suffer consequences of the test, inasmuch as, the result may bastardize the child, which should be kept in mind, while directing the DNA Test. The DNA test, even if, it is an accurate test for the parentage of the child, should be ordered on strong prima facie case, but with great caution, keeping in view the rights of the third parties, including the child.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
AT JAIPUR BENCH, JAIPUR


D.B. SPECIAL APPEAL (WRIT) NO.2083/2014
Anjana Saharawat Vs. State of Rajasthan & Ors.


Dated;30.01.2015


HON'BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR.SUNIL AMBWANI
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PRAKASH GUPTA



Reportable 
Print Page

Thursday, 19 February 2015

Supreme Court: DNA test should not be directed in routine course to ascertain adultery of wife


Deciding the issue of proving infidelity of a spouse, the bench of J.S. Khehar and R.K. Agrawal, JJ held that DNA test can be conducted to determine the veracity of the allegations of adultery. However, considering the fact that the said test will automatically determine the issue of legitimacy, the Court held that the presumption of legitimacy as given under Section 112 of the Evidence Act, 1872 will not be disturbed and that if the direction to hold such a test can be avoided, it should be so avoided as the legitimacy of the child should not be put to peril.
In the present case, the husband has sought divorce from his wife due to alleged infedility by her and had also named the person has fathered the child born to his wife, thereby making an application for DNA test to prove the paternity of the child in order to prove the alleged infidelity. The Court, hence explained the importance of DNA test by stating that DNA testing is the most legitimate and scientifically perfect means, which the husband could use, to establish his assertion of infidelity. The Court also said that DNA test should also simultaneously be taken as the most authentic, rightful and correct means also with the wife, for her to rebut the assertions made by the husband, and to establish that she had not been unfaithful, adulterous or disloyal.
The Court, hence, held that the wife shall be given the liberty to comply with or disregard the order of DNA test and in case, she declines to undergo the said test, the Court shall draw presumption as per Illustration (h) of Section 114 of the Evidence Act, 1872.

“REPORTABLE”
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 9744 OF 2014
(Arising out of SLP(C) No.5694 of 2013)
Dipanwita Roy Vs  Ronobroto Roy
Citation;AIR 2015 SC418
Print Page

Sunday, 15 February 2015

Whether DNA sample taken for criminal purposes can be used for paternity test?


X & Anor v Z (Children) & Anor [2015] EWCA Civ 34 – read judgment
The Court of Appeal has ruled that it would not be lawful for DNA originally collected by the police to be used by a local authority for the purposes of a paternity test. 
Factual and legal background
X’s wife had been found murdered.  The police took DNA from the crime scene.  Some of the DNA belonged to X’s wife and some was found to be X’s.  X was tried and convicted of his wife’s murder.
X’s wife had young children and they were taken into the care of the local authority.  During the care proceedings X asserted that he was the biological father of the children and said he wanted to have contact with them.  He refused to take a DNA test to prove his alleged paternity.  The local authority asked the police to make the DNA from the crime scene available so that it could be used in a paternity test.  The police, with the support of the Home Secretary, refused on the grounds that they did not believe that it would be lawful to do so.
Print Page

Saturday, 25 October 2014

Whether DNA test can be conducted to ascertain whether mother of child is living in adultery?



It is borne from the decisions rendered by this Court in Bhabani Prasad Jena (supra), and Nandlal Wasudeo Badwaik (supra), that depending on the facts and circumstances of the case, it would be permissible for a Court to direct the holding of a DNA examination, to determine the veracity of the allegation(s), which constitute one of the grounds, on which the concerned party would either succeed or lose. There can be no dispute, that if the direction to hold such a test can be avoided, it should be so avoided. The reason, as already recorded in various judgments by this Court, is that the legitimacy of a child should not be put to peril.
11. The question that has to be answered in this case, is in respect of the alleged infidelity of the Appellant-wife. The Respondent-husband has made clear and categorical assertions in the petition filed by him Under Section 13 of the Hindu Marriage Act, alleging infidelity. He has gone to the extent of naming the person, who was the father of the male child born to the Appellant-wife. It is in the process of substantiating his allegation of infidelity, that the Respondent-husband had made an application before the Family Court for conducting a DNA test, which would establish whether or not, he had fathered the male child born to the Appellant-wife. The Respondent feels that it is only possible for him to substantiate the allegations levelled by him (of the Appellant-wife's infidelity) through a DNA test. We agree with him. In our view, but for the DNA test, it would be impossible for the Respondent-husband to establish and confirm the assertions made in the pleadings. We are therefore satisfied, that the direction issued by the High Court, as has been extracted hereinabove, was fully justified. DNA testing is the most legitimate and scientifically perfect means, which the husband could use, to establish his assertion of infidelity. This should simultaneously be taken as the most authentic, rightful and correct means also with the wife, for her to rebut the assertions made by the Respondent-husband, and to establish that she had not been unfaithful, adulterous or disloyal. If the Appellant-wife is right, she shall be proved to be so.
12. We would, however, while upholding the order passed by the High Court, consider it just and appropriate to record a caveat, giving the Appellant-wife liberty to comply with or disregard the order passed by the High Court, requiring the holding of the DNA test. In case, she accepts the direction issued by the High Court, the DNA test will determine conclusively the veracity of accusation levelled by the Respondent-husband, against her. In case, she declines to comply with the direction issued by the High Court, the allegation would be determined by the concerned Court, by drawing a presumption of the nature contemplated in Section 114 of the Indian Evidence Act, especially, in terms of illustration (h) thereof. Section 114 as also illustration (h), referred to above, are being extracted hereunder:
114. Court may presume existence of certain facts - The Court may presume the existence of any fact which it thinks likely to have happened, regard being had to the common course of natural events, human conduct and public and private business, in their relation to the facts of the particular case.
Illustration (h) - That if a man refuses to answer a question which he is not compelled to answer by law, the answer, if given, would be unfavourable to him.
This course has been adopted to preserve the right of individual privacy to the extent possible. of course, without sacrificing the cause of justice. By adopting the above course, the issue of infidelity alone would be determined, without expressly disturbing the presumption contemplated Under Section112 of the Indian Evidence Act. Even though, as already stated above, undoubtedly the issue of legitimacy would also be incidentally involved.1
“REPORTABLE”
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 9744 OF 2014
(Arising out of SLP(C) No.5694 of 2013)
Dipanwita Roy V Ronobroto Roy
Jagdish Singh Khehar, J.
Dated;October 15, 2014.
Citation;AIR 2015SC418


Print Page