Showing posts with label perpetual injunction. Show all posts
Showing posts with label perpetual injunction. Show all posts

Monday, 19 September 2022

Whether suit for perpetual or mandatory injunction is to be valued as per market value of immovable property involved in it?

 The High Court has not even considered the overall circumstances of the present case where the Plaintiff has valued the reliefs of mandatory and prohibitory injunction at the nominal Rs. 250 but, at the same time, has also valued the suit with reference to the claim of damages at Rs. 1 lakh and had paid the Court fees accordingly. It is apparent on the face of the record that despite unquestionable principle of law that such a suit for mandatory and prohibitory injunction is not required to be valued at the market value of the property, the High Court has relied only upon the market value of the property to hold the valuation of the present suit to be "arbitrary". Such a conclusion of the High Court neither stands in conformity with law nor with the frame and the nature of the present suit. {Para 10}

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 4577 of 2022 

Decided On: 16.06.2022

 Bharat Bhushan Gupta   Vs.  Pratap Narain Verma and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Dinesh Maheshwari and Vikram Nath, JJ.

Author: Dinesh Maheshwari, J.

Citation: MANU/SC/0783/2022,2022 ALL SCR 1485

Print Page

Thursday, 31 October 2019

Whether court can direct removal of construction made during the period from dismissal of suit and allowing of appeal?

However, an examination of Order XXI Rule 32 C.P.C., reveals that Order XXI Rule 32(5) of C.P.C., is to the following effect.

32. Decree for specific performance for restitution of conjugal rights, or for an injunction

(5) Where a decree for the specific performance of a contract or for an injunction has not been obeyed, the Court may, in lieu of or in addition to all or any of the processes aforesaid, direct that the act required to be done may be done so far as practicable by the decree-holder or some other person appointed by the Court, at the cost of the judgment-debtor, and upon the act being done the expenses incurred may be ascertained in such manner as the Court may direct and may be recovered as if they were included in the decree.

12. Therefore, there is a power to compel the defendants to act under Order XXI Rule 32(5) C.P.C., which is in addition to the other powers which are prescribed under Order XXI Rule 32(1)(2)(3) and (4).


15. If this case is examined against the back drop of this legal position, it is clear that the construction was made after the suit was dismissed. Throughout the period of the litigation, the decree holder had access to the site and there was no gate. The judgment debtors cannot take advantage of the dismissal of the suit and now say that the judgments passed by the Appellate Court as confirmed by the Second Appellate Court cannot be executed. of all the judgments cited by the revision petitioner, this Court is of the opinion that B. Gangadhar's case (supra), has the closest applicability. The following passage from Para 5 is relevant although the facts are a little different:

".........If any obstruction is raised by putting up a construction pendente lite or prevents the passage or right to access to the property pendente lite, the plaintiff has been given right and the decree-holder is empowered to have it removed in execution without tortuous remedy of separate suit seeking mandatory injunction or for possession so as to avoid delay in execution or frustration and thereby defeat the decree. The Executing Court, therefore, would be justified to order its removal of unlawful or illegal construction made pendente lite so that the decree for possession or eviction, as the case may be, effectually and completely executed and the delivery of possession is given to the decree holder expeditiously. Admittedly, pending suit the petitioner had constructed shops and inducted tenants in possession without permission of the Court. The only course would be to decide the dispute in the execution proceedings and not by a separate suit."
16. In view of the cases referred to earlier this Court is of the opinion that this is a fit case whether the inherent power of the Court must be used and should be used to undo the wrong that was committed namely, the construction of the wall in the plot 'LP and the removal of the gate.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH AT AMARAVATI

CRP No. 4388 of 2012

Decided On: 10.04.2019

Valluru Samba Siva Rao Vs. Krishna Apartments Association and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
D.V.S.S. Somayajulu, J.

Citation: AIR 2019 AP 43
Print Page

Monday, 1 July 2019

Whether court should grant perpetual injunction to a person who has failed to prove actual physical possession over suit premises?

 As discussed earlier, in a suit filed under Section 38 of
the Specific Relief Act, possession on the date of suit is a
must for grant of permanent injunction. When the first
respondent-plaintiff has failed to prove that he was in actual
possession of the property on the date of the suit, he is not
entitled for the decree for permanent injunction.
18. Upon appreciation of the oral and documentary
evidence, the trial court rightly held that the first respondentplaintiff
failed to prove his actual and physical possession

over the suit property on the date of the suit. When the
finding of the trial court was based on oral and documentary
evidence, the First Appellate Court and the High Court were
not right in setting aside the judgment of the trial court by
drawing inference of possession from Purshis Ex.-41.

REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 1509 OF 2019

BALKRISHNA DATTATRAYA GALANDE  Vs  BALKRISHNA RAMBHAROSE GUPTA

R. BANUMATHI, J.
Dated:February 06, 2019.
Citation: 2020(1) MHLJ 137
Print Page

Saturday, 19 May 2018

SHORT NOTES ON SPECIFIC RELIEF ACT PART 2


Chapter 3 Rectification of instruments

S 26. When instrument may be rectified:-
Sub S 1. When through fraud or mutual mistake of parties,a contract or other instrument in writing does not express real intention of parties, then-
a) either party or his representative in interest may institute a suit to have instrument rectified.
Sub S 2. Court may direct rectification of instrument so as to express that intention,so far as this can be done without prejudice to rights acquired by third person in good faith and for value.
Sub S 3. A contract in writing may first be rectified, and then if the party claiming rectification has so prayed in his pleading and the court thinks fit,may be specifically enforced.
Sub S 4. No relief is to be granted unless prayed. If not prayed court can allow amendment to incorporate said prayer.
Print Page