Showing posts with label principal sum. Show all posts
Showing posts with label principal sum. Show all posts

Sunday, 29 July 2018

When appropriation of payment first towards interest and then towards principal amount is not permissible?

After referring to the relevant portion of the decision in Gurpreet Singh's case, in Bharat Heavy Electricals Ltd. v. R.S. Avtar Singh and Co. MANU/SC/0837/2012 : (2013) 1 SCC 243, this Court summarized the principles emerging as under:

31. From what has been stated in the said decision, the following principles emerge:

31.1. The general Rule of appropriation towards a decretal amount was that such an amount was to be adjusted strictly in accordance with the directions contained in the decree and in the absence of such directions adjustments be made firstly towards payment of interest and costs and thereafter towards payment of the principal amount subject, of course, to any agreement between the parties.

31.2. The legislative intent in enacting Sub-rules (4) and (5) is a clear pointer that interest should cease to run on the deposit made by the judgment-debtor and notice given or on the amount being tendered outside the court in the manner provided in Order 21 Rule 1(1)(b).

31.3. If the payment made by the judgment-debtor falls short of the decreed amount, the decree-holder will be entitled to apply the general Rule of appropriation by appropriating the amount deposited towards the interest, then towards costs and finally towards the principal amount due under the decree.

31.4. Thereafter, no further interest would run on the sum appropriated towards the principal. In other words if a part of the principal amount has been paid along with interest due thereon as on the date of issuance of notice of deposit interest on that part of the principal sum will cease to run thereafter.

31.5. In cases where there is a shortfall in deposit of the principal amount, the decree-holder would be entitled to adjust interest and costs first and the balance towards the principal and beyond that the decree-holder cannot seek to reopen the entire transaction and proceed to recalculate the interest on the whole of the principal amount and seek for reappropriation.

18. As held in Constitution Bench judgment in Gurpreet Singh's case followed in BHEL's case, if there is a direction in the decree as to the mode of appropriation of payment, then appropriation of any payment made by the judgment-debtor has to be strictly in accordance with the direction contained in the decree. If there is no such direction in the decree, then the general principle is that where a judgment-debtor makes payment without making any indication as to how the payment is to be adjusted, it is the option of the creditor to make adjustment firstly towards the interest and then towards the principal. But if the judgment-debtor has indicated the manner in which the appropriation is to be made, then the creditor has no choice to apply the payment in a different manner. The general principle of mode of appropriation firstly in payment of interest and thereafter in payment of principal amount is subject to the exception i.e. the parties may agree to the adjustment of the payment in any other manner despite the decree.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal Nos. 3164-3165 of 2017

Decided On: 09.03.2018

 Kerala State Electricity Board and Ors. Vs. Kurien E. Kalathil and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Ranjan Gogoi and R. Banumathi, JJ.

Citation: (2018) 4 SCC 793
Print Page

Sunday, 10 September 2017

Whether amounts awarded under arbitral award are to be appropriated towards interest or principal sum?

In dealing with the first question as to whether the payment made by the judgment-debtor is to be appropriated first towards discharge of the principal or towards discharge of the interest, the Division Bench noted the decision of this court in M/s I.C.D.S. Ltd. Vs. Smithaben H. Patel & Ors.
[(1999) 3 SCC 80], wherein, this Court had held that Sections 59 and 60 of the Contract Act, 1872, would only be applicable at the pre-decretal stage and not thereafter and that post-decretal payments would have to be made either in terms of the decree or in accordance with the agreement arrived at between the parties, though, on the genuine principles indicated in Sections 59 and 60 of the aforesaid Act. After referring to various other decisions of this Court and the Lahore High Court, the Division Bench of the High Court referred to the decision in Meghraj Vs. Mst. Bayabai & others, [AIR 1970 SC 161], wherein the law in this regard was laid down by this Court that the general rule of appropriation of payment towards a decretal amount is that such an amount is to be adjusted firstly strictly in accordance with the directions contained in the decree and in the absence of such direction, adjustments would have to be made firstly towards payment of interest and costs and, thereafter, in payment of the principal amount. It was, however, indicated that such a principle would be subject to an exception when the parties might agree to the adjustment of the payment in any manner despite the decree. It was, accordingly,  held that unless the Respondent herein was able to show that the parties had either impliedly or expressly agreed to adjustment of the said sum of Rs.89,78,84,930/- towards the principal amount, the Appellant herein would be entitled to appropriate the said amount fully towards the payment of interest.
The philosophy behind the principle set out in Meka Venkatadri's case (supra) and as reiterated in Rai Bahadur Seth Nemichand's case (supra) and also in Smithaben's case (supra) and then consistently followed by this Court, is that a debtor cannot be allowed to take advantage of his default to deny to the creditor the amount to which he would be entitled on account of such default, by way of elimination of the principal amount due itself, unless, of course, the provisions of Section 59 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, were attracted or there was a separate agreement between the parties in that regard. That is not so in the instant case and, accordingly, the creditor cannot be denied its dues on a unilateral stipulation that the amount of Rs.89.78 crores was being deposited as against the  principal sum due in terms of the Award. Since the said amount was accepted by the Appellant on protest, it would be entitled to appropriate the same against the interest which was due and payable till that date on the principal amount, as has been asserted by it.
Reportable
Supreme Court of India
Leela Hotels Ltd vs Housing & Urban Dev.Corp.Ltd on 15 November, 2011

Bench: Altamas Kabir, Cyriac Joseph, Surinder Singh Nijjar
Print Page

Saturday, 22 September 2012

Meaning of principal sum adjudged for charging interests by banks

(1) Subject to a binding stipulation contained in a voluntary contract
between the parties and/or an established practice or usage interest on
loans and ad-vances may be charged on periodical rests and also capitalised
on remaining unpaid. The principal sum actually advanced coupled with the
interest on periodical rests so capitalised is capable of being adjudged as
principal sum on the date of the suit.

(2) The principal sum so adjudged is 'such principal sum' within the
meaning of Section 34 of the Code of Civil Procedure Code, 1908 on which
interest pendente lite and future interest i.e. post-decree interest, at
such rate and for such period which the Court may deem fit, may be awarded
by the Court.

Supreme Court of India

CENTRAL BANK OF INDIA vs. RAVINDRA AND ORS.

DATE OF JUDGMENT: 18/10/2001

BENCH:DR. A.S. ANAND CJ &  K.T. THOMAS & R.C. LAHOTI & N. SANTOSH HEGDE & S.N.
VARIAVA
Citation : (2002)1 SCC 367
Case No. : Special Leave Petition (civil)  2421 of 1993

Print Page