Showing posts with label private person. Show all posts
Showing posts with label private person. Show all posts

Sunday, 24 April 2022

Whether the government can allot Gairan land to a private person?

 After having heard the learned advocate, it is quite apparent that the petitioner is seeking allotment of a portion of Gairan land. The Supreme Court in the case of Jagpal Singh & Ors. Vs. State of Punjab & Ors. reported in (2011) 11 SCC 396, has specifically prohibited such allotment of a Gairan land to individuals. Pursuant thereto, the State Government has also issued a circular dated 12.07.2011, implementing the directions of the Supreme Court and regulating the allotment of portion of gairan land for public use. {Para 4}

5. In view of such specific directions of the Supreme Court and the subsequent decision by the State Government prohibiting private use of a Gairan land, ex-facie there is no apparent illegality in the impugned communication whereby the learned Collector has rejected the proposal of the petitioner.

 Bombay High Court

Ramesh Asaram Shelke vs The State Of Maharashtra And ... on 7 December, 2020
Bench: Mangesh S. Patil
Print Page

Tuesday, 30 June 2020

Whether prosecution under the Prevention of Corruption Act is maintainable against a private person as the only accused?

 The contention raised by learned counsel for the appellant that a public servant needs to be named for maintaining a case under Section 8 of PC Act is fallacious and no longer res integra. The Supreme Court in State through CBI, New Delhi v. Jitender Kumar Singh reported as MANU/SC/0083/2014 : (2014) 11 SCC 724 held as under:

(ii) A private person can be the only accused person in an offence under Section 8 or Section 9 of the said Act. And it is not necessary that a public servant should also be specifically named as an accused in the same case. Notwithstanding the fact that a private person is the only accused in an offence under Section 8 or Section 9, it can be tried only by a Special Judge.

30. Thus, the scheme of the PC Act makes it quite clear that even a private person who is involved in an offence mentioned in Section 3(1) of the PC Act, is required to be tried only by a Special Judge, and by no other Court. Moreover, it is not necessary that in every offence under the PC Act, a public servant must necessarily be an accused. In other words, the existence of a public servant for facing the trial before the Special Court is not a must and even in his absence, private persons can be tried for PC as well as non-PC offences, depending upon the facts of the case. We, therefore, make it clear that it is not the law that only along with the junction of a public servant in array of parties, the Special Judge can proceed against private persons who have committed offences punishable under the PC Act."

(emphasis added)

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

Crl. A. 168/2013

Decided On: 04.05.2020

 Sandeep Deshwal Vs.  State Govt. of NCT of Delhi

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Manoj Kumar Ohri, J.

Print Page

Monday, 4 May 2015

Whether sting operation by private person is justified?


In important remarks made in April, the Supreme Court said that if there is no public interest behind a sting operation, it is unjustifiable. A sting operation has serious legal implications. If it exposes the corruption of a public servant, the journalist or citizen journalist responsible for it wins popularity. If not, it exposes him/her to criminal charges. Many people are unaware that Article 19 (2) states that freedom of expression is not available when a person misuses it to incite a crime. Both bribe giving and taking are criminal wrongs.
In a sting operation where a person lures another to accept a bribe while secretly video recording the act, it is entrapment, which could be legal or criminal depending on the intention and motive of the bribe giver and all those who supported the operation.
The case that was before the Supreme Court last April needs to be understood by journalists for it lays out the legal implications and risks involved in a sting operation. The Supreme Court explained these issues in Rajat Prasad v CBI which involved a sting operation. A news item in the Indian Express on November 16, 2003 said that Dalip Singh Judeo, Union Minister of State for the Environment and Forests (deceased) accepted a bribe of Rs 9 lakhs.
Print Page

Sunday, 7 September 2014

Whether vesting of land give an absolute right to municipal corporation to transfer said land to private person?


An analysis of Rajasthan Urban Areas (Sub-Division, Reconstruction and Improvement of Plots) Rules, 1975 would make it clear that an approved and sanctioned plan
under the Rules has a statutory character. No deviation from the approved plan is permissible unless the plan is revised under Rule 32 on the ground as provided therein. Such scheme/ plans make a provision for open space/ spaces for park, garden etc. intended to be used by the public, an area for providing educational facility or any other facility which is deemed necessary. Roads and public streets arc also provided as per the standards. From the Rules, it is also clear that the site/sites of open space are intended to be used by the public and [hey form a different category from the area reserved for educational facilities or any other facility. There is a basic distinction in two categories. In case of open space falling in the first category, ownership shall vest in UIT and now in JDA after the approval of sub-division of plots as provided in Sub-Rule (2) of Rule 30, while the area reserved for educational facilities or any other facility falling in the second category remains in the ownership of the developer. In the latter case, the developer can transfer the site/area to any private person or body for the same purpose for which the area was reserved. To illustrate, if an area is reserved for a school in the approved plan, the same can be transferred by the developer to any private person or body for the purposes of establishing a school. But, an open space or spaces intended to be used by the public in general stand dedicated to the public for common use and must, therefore, remain with the State or its instrumentalities, such as JDA, Municipal Board/Council/Corporation or any other public authority. Therefore, the areas of open space reserved in the approved plan, though are vested in UIT or JDA, but the same cannot be allotted to any private person or body. Their user cannot be changed or converted by UIT or JDA. Such open space/spaces are meant for the use of a park, garden, lawn or any other form of open space intended to be used by the public. The vesting of such area in JDA or UIT is for a specific purpose i.e. to develop and maintain such areas for the purpose they are earmarked or reserved in the approved scheme. This vesting does not give an absolute right to UIT or JDA to allot/transfer such area to a private person or body for establishment of a school. Such deviation is not contemplated or permissible as per the Rules, as an open space is dedicated to the public and is intended to be used by the public. Hence, the site of open space could not be allotted by the JDA to the Modern School.

Rajasthan High Court
Nizam And Ors. vs Jaipur Development Authority And ... on 12 April, 1993
Equivalent citations: AIR 1994 Raj 87, 1993 (2) WLC 169


N.L. Tibrewal, J.
Print Page