Showing posts with label profession. Show all posts
Showing posts with label profession. Show all posts

Friday, 14 April 2017

Whether other coparcener can claim partition of property purchased by person by income from his professional knowledge?

 Now it is not denied anywhere that the business started by Arjan Singh was not a commercial venture per se but a calling or profession, i.e. medical advice in respect of herbal remedies. The plaintiffs allege that such knowledge or expertise so acquired by Arjan Singh is not on account of his association with his father. The object of the said Act was to ensure that earning from acquired skills such as medical or legal practice, accountancy or in other avocations where individual effort and skill is necessary, should never be deemed as part of contribution by member of a joint family property so as to bring it within the HUF hotchpotch. This was to incentivize proficiency in such vocations and encourage people into acquiring greater skills and higher learning as in the absence of such safeguard, the danger of earnings acquired by the members of such joint families becoming available for division are very real. In such eventuality, the members of the joint family, who earn and toil hard were left with a miniscule portion of their earning gained entirely by individual skill and effort as the latter's share, the lion's share of which would have fallen to the other members of the family, who would possibly never work at all. In the present case, the suit expressly states that the funds for acquiring various properties in the name of Arjan Singh were out of his earnings as a medical professional, from out of M/s. Sewak Pharmacy. That clearly falls within the mischief of Section 3 of the Hindu Gains of Learning Act. Therefore, the claim for partition of such properties is expressly barred. 
Delhi High Court
Sh. Balbir Singh Uppal And Anr. vs Sh. Gurmeet Singh Uppal And Ors. on 22 April, 2010
Author: S.Ravindra Bhat
Print Page

Wednesday, 3 September 2014

Whether "commercial transaction" include "professional transaction." for purpose of S34 of CPC?


In view of this, 'profession' will have to be treated as different from 'industry', 'trade', and 'business'. There is a clear distinction between the profession on one hand, and industry, trade and business on the other. While dealing with the 'commercial transactions" for the purpose of Section 34, C.P.C. the Legislature has not used the word 'profession' along with the words, 'industry' 'trade, or 'business'. The commercial transactions which are strictly connected with the industry, trade or business alone are included for the purposes of Section 34, C.P.C. as provided in Explanation II. Though the 'commercial transaction" is inclusive of "industry, trade and business", but it is exclusive of "profession". The fact that the Legislature has not included the word 'profession' along with the, words "industry, trade and business" to specify the "commercial transaction" cannot be igorned. The proviso to Section 34, C.P.C. will, therefore, not govern the cases where the
loan is advanced for the 'profession' or for "professional transactions".
 In our opinion, the words "commercial transaction" do not include the "profession" or "professional transaction."
We, therefore, find that the learned trial Judge was right in holding in the absence of any evidence to that effect that the present loan is a professional loan, and cannot be termed as a commerical transaction. Awarding future interest at the rate of 6 p.c. p.a. cannot be said to be in contravention of the provisions of Section 34, C.P.C.

Bombay High Court
Dena Bank, Ahmednagar vs Prakash Birbhan Kataria And .
.. on 26 April, 1993
Equivalent citations: AIR 1994 Bom 343, 
1994 (1) BomCR 537, 1994 (1) MhLj 198

Bench: B Deshmukh, V Sirpurkar

Print Page