Showing posts with label HUF. Show all posts
Showing posts with label HUF. Show all posts

Sunday, 30 May 2021

Whether the property is HUF property if parties reside in their respective demarcated portions of the suit property?

Further, the appellant’s argument that the parties are residing in their respective demarcated portions of the suit property is contrary to his primary submission of an HUF. This Court is of the view that if the suit property was an HUF property, there was no question of any member of the family being an owner or any family member owning any specific share, as it is settled law that the essence of joint Hindu family property is unity of ownership and community of interest, and the shares of the members are not defined. {Para 28}

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

 RFA(OS) 37/2020

SHRI RAVI NARAYAN AGARWAL Vs  SHRI SUSHIL KUMAR AGARWAL & ORS. 


CORAM:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANMOHAN

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA

Author: MANMOHAN, J:

Date of Decision:16th December, 2020

Print Page

Saturday, 24 October 2020

Whether court can infer existence of joint family property if two brothers are carrying on business jointly?

 The law is well settled that the burden is on the person who alleges that the property is a joint property of an HUF to prove the same. Reference in this behalf may be made to the judgments of this Court in Bhagwan Dayal v. Reoti Devi MANU/SC/0374/1961 : AIR 1962 SC 287. Both the parties have placed reliance on the this judgment. In this case this Court held that the general principle is that a Hindu family is presumed to be joint unless the contrary is proved. It was further held that where one of the coparceners separated himself from other members of the joint family there was no presumption that the rest of coparceners continued to constitute a joint family. However, it was also held that at the same time there is no presumption that because one member of the family has separated, the rest of the family is no longer a joint family. However, it is important to note that this Court in Bhagwati Prasad Sah and Ors. v. Dulhin Rameshwari Kuer and Ors. MANU/SC/0060/1951 : (1951) 2 SCR 603, it held as follows:


.... Except in the case of reunion, the mere fact that separated coparceners chose to live together or act jointly for purposes of business or trade or in their dealings with properties, would not give them the status of coparceners under the Mitakshara law.


The Privy Council in Appalaswami v. Suryanarayanamurti MANU/PR/0051/1947 : I.L.R. 1948 Mad. 440 held as follows:


The Hindu law upon this aspect of the case is well settled. Proof of the existence of a joint family does not lead to the presumption that property held by any member of the family is joint, and the burden rests upon anyone asserting that any item of property was joint to establish the fact. But where it is established that the family possessed some joint property which from its nature and relative value may have formed the nucleus from which the property in question may have been acquired, the burden shifts to the party alleging self-acquisition to establish affirmatively that the property was acquired without the aid of the joint family property


The aforesaid view was accepted by this Court in Shrinivas Krishnarao Kango v. Narayan Devji Kango and Ors. MANU/SC/0126/1954 : (1955) 1 SCR 1. In D.S. Lakshmaiah and Ors. v. L. Balasubramanyam and Ors. MANU/SC/0639/2003 : (2003) 10 SCC 310 this Court held as follows:


The legal principle, therefore, is that there is no presumption of a property being joint family property only on account of existence of a joint Hindu family. The one who asserts has to prove that the property is a joint family property. If, however, the person so asserting proves that there was nucleus with which the joint family property could be acquired, there would be presumption of the property being joint and the onus would shift on the person who claims it to be self-acquired property to prove that he purchased the property with his own funds and not out of joint family nucleus that was available.


Similar view was taken in Mst Rukhmabai v. Lala Laxminarayan and Ors. MANU/SC/0186/1959 : (1960) 2 SCR 253 and Appasaheb Peerappa Chamdgade v. Devendra Peerappa Chamdgade MANU/SC/8597/2006 : (2007) 1 SCC 521. The law is thus well settled that the burden lies upon the person who alleges the existence of the Hindu Undivided Family to prove the same.


11. Normally, an HUF can only comprise of all the family members with the head of the family being karta. Some property has to be the nucleus for this joint family. There is cleavage of opinion as to whether two brothers of a larger group can form a joint family. But assuming that such a joint family could have been formed by Madhav Prashad and Umrao Lal the burden lies heavily on the Plaintiff to prove that the two of them joined together to form an HUF. To prove this, they will have to not only show jointness of the property but also jointness of family and jointness of living together.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal Nos. 6875 and 6876-6877 of 2008

Decided On: 03.04.2020

Bhagwat Sharan (Dead) thr. L.Rs.  Vs. Purushottam and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

L. Nageswara Rao and Deepak Gupta, JJ.

Citation: MANU/SC/0354/2020, 2021(1) MHLJ 485

Print Page

Sunday, 5 April 2020

Whether person who has taken benefit of part of will can dispute its remaining part?

 It is also not disputed that the plaintiff and defendant nos.
1-3 herein filed suit for eviction of an occupant in which he claimed
that the property had been bequeathed to him by Hari Ram.
According to the defendants the plaintiff having accepted the Will
of Hariram and having taken benefit of the same, cannot turn
around and urge that the Will is not valid and that the entire
property is a joint family property. The plaintiff and defendant nos.
1-3 by accepting the bequest under the Will elected to accept the
will. It is trite law that a party cannot be permitted to approbate
and reprobate at the same time. This principle is based on the
principle of doctrine of election. In respect of Wills, this doctrine
has been held to mean that a person who takes benefit of a portion
of the Will cannot challenge the remaining portion of the Will. In
The Rajasthan State Industrial Development and Investment
Corporation and Anr. vs . Diamond and Gem Development
Corporation Ltd. and Anr 11 AIR 2013 SC 1241, this Court made an observation that a party cannot be permitted to "blow hot and cold", "fast and loose"

or "approbate and reprobate". Where one party knowingly accepts
the benefits of a contract or conveyance or an order, it is estopped
to deny the validity or binding effect on him of such contract or
conveyance or order.
25. The doctrine of election is a facet of law of estoppel. A party
cannot blow hot and blow cold at the same time. Any party which
takes advantage of any instrument must accept all that is
mentioned in the said document. It would be apposite to refer to
the treatise 'Equity-A course of lectures' by F.W. Maitland,
Cambridge University, 1947, wherein the learned author
succinctly described principle of election in the following terms:-
“The doctrine of Election may be thus stated: That he who
accepts a benefit under a deed or will or other instrument
must adopt the whole contents of that instrument, must
conform to all its provisions and renounce all rights that
are inconsistent with it....’’
This view has been accepted to be the correct view in Karam
Kapahi and Ors. vs. Lal Chand Public Charitable Trust and
Ors(2010) 4 SCC 753. The plaintiff having elected to accept the Will of Hari Ram,by filing a suit for eviction of the tenant by claiming that the property had been bequeathed to him by Hari Ram, cannot now turn around and say that the averments made by Hari Ram that
the property was his personal property, is incorrect.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 6875 OF 2008

BHAGWAT SHARAN Vs  PURUSHOTTAM 

Dated:April 3, 2020
Deepak Gupta, J.
Citation: 2021(1) MHLJ 485
Print Page

Tuesday, 31 March 2020

What material facts are to be pleaded by a party claiming property to be joint family property?

I may note that the requirement of pleading in a clear cut manner as to how the HUF and its properties exist i.e. whether because of pre 1956 position or because of the post 1956 position on account of throwing of properties into a common hotchpotch, needs to be now mentioned especially after passing of the Benami Transaction (Prohibition) Act, 1988 (hereinafter referred to as "the Benami Act") and which Act states that property in the name of an individual has to be taken as owned by that individual and no claim to such property is maintainable as per Section 4(1) of the Benami Act on the ground that monies have come from the person who claims right in the property though title deeds of the property are not in the name of such person. An exception is created with respect to provision of Section 4 of the Benami Act by its sub-section (3) which allows existence of the concept of HUF. Once existence of the concept of HUF is an exception to the main provision contained in sub-sections (1) and (2) of Section 4 of the Benami Act, then, to take the case outside sub-sections (1) and (2) of Section 4 of the Benami Act it has to be specifically pleaded as to how and in what manner an HUF and each specific property claimed as being an HUF property has come into existence as an HUF property. If such specific facts are not pleaded, this Court in fact would be negating the mandate of the language contained in sub-sections (1) and (2) of Section 4 of the Benami Act."

 The clear legal position is that a party which claims that a particular property is joint family property must specifically plead the origin of the HUF, whether pre 1956 or post 1956, and give sufficient particulars as to the creation of the HUF as well as the ownership of the property by the HUF.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

CS (OS) 1214/2014

Decided On: 11.02.2020

 Rajeev Chawla  Vs. Deepak Chawla

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Prateek Jalan, J.


Print Page

Sunday, 19 January 2020

Whether it is mandatory to implead karta of HUF in eviction suit filed by co-owner of tenanted property?

 This, however, does not imply that for want of impleadment of
Karta, in the peculiar facts of the case, the suit is liable to be
dismissed. Indisputably, respondent Nos. 2 to 4 have been impleaded
as the plaintiffs to the suit in the capacity of the legal representatives
of the deceased plaintiff No.2. The learned counsel for the respondent
Nos.2 to 4 was justified in advancing a submission that a decree for
eviction was also sought on the ground of personal bonafide
requirement of the deceased plaintiff No.2 and his daughter Anjalirespondent
No.4 herein. Thus, the respondent No.4, in the capacity of
being a co-owner, is entitled to prosecute the suit irrespective of the
Karta being brought on record.
23. The aforesaid submission is required to be considered in the
backdrop of the proposition that a co-owner is entitled to institute a
suit for eviction for and on behalf of all the co-owners, unless it is
shown that the other co-owners were not agreeable to the ejectment
to the tenant. It is one thing to say that a member of the family
other than, or in the absence of, a Karta, may be permitted to
prosecute the suit on account of special circumstances of a given case.
And a completely different thing to claim that despite a Karta having
been appointed, he will not be impleaded to represent the HUF sans

the existence of special circumstances. In the latter case, the tenability
of the suit, without impleading the Karta, would be in issue.
24. Reverting to the facts of the case, as the respondent Nos.2 to 4
are already prosecuting the suit, either in the capacity of the coowner
or as the legal representatives of deceased plaintiff No.2 and,
at the same time, there is a cloud of doubt over the intendment of
the HUF to prosecute the suit for eviction of the tenant, especially on
account of the fact that there being material to show that a Karta has
indeed been appointed and there is an alleged non-compliance of an
order of Appellate Bench in Appeal No.306 of 2009 to bring the Karta
on record, steps will have been taken to implead the successor Karta
in the instant suit. It would be in the fitness of things to frame and
try the issue regarding the tenability of the suit, in the event of nonimpleadment
of the successor Karta. To this extent, the observations
of the Appellate Bench to the effect that the non-impleadment of the
successor Karta has no bearing whatsoever on the tenability of the
suit are unsustainable.
25. The question as to whether the HUF as such intends to
prosecute the suit for eviction is essentially for the HUF to answer. It

would be onerous for the defendants to plead and prove that the HUF
does not want to prosecute the suit. Therefore, it would be
appropriate to provide an opportunity to the HUF to make its stand
clear, if it desires to.
26. In the aforesaid peculiar circumstances, in my view, it would be
appropriate to provide an opportunity to the HUF to bring the
successor Karta on record, within a stipulated period, and, in the
event of default, frame and try the issue of tenability of the suit for
eviction at the instance of HUF, as such, without bringing Karta on
record, and plaintiff Nos. 2 to 4, in the capacity of the co-owners of
the demised premises.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
APPELLATE SIDE CIVIL JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO. 9267 OF 2019
IN
REVISION APPLICATION NO. 343 OF 2018
IN
EXHIBIT NO. 28
IN
R.A.E. SUIT NO. 119/171 OF 2011

Mrs. Madhuri Doulatram Choitram Vs  Lachmandas Tulsiram Nayar (HUF) by and through its Karta

CORAM : N.J. JAMADAR, J.

Pronounced on : 18th December 2019
Print Page

Wednesday, 30 October 2019

Whether there is presumption of existence of HUF after commencement of Hindu Succession Act 1956?

Also, as Order 6 Rule 4 CPC is attracted to suits where plaintiff claims that a coparcenary or Hindu Joint Family exists, (inasmuch as after coming into force of the Act, 1956, there is no presumption as to the existence of an HUF), detailed facts have to be averred. However, no averments have been made by factual references qua each property claimed to be a Hindu Joint Family property.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

CS (OS) 2223/2013, 

Decided On: 04.02.2019

Aarshiya Gulati  Vs.  Kuldeep Singh Gulati and Ors.
Print Page

Wednesday, 2 October 2019

Whether there can be blending of self acquired property with joint family property by making declaration in Income tax return?

B. Jupudi Venkata Vijaya Bhaskar Vs. Jupudi Kesava Rao (died) & Ors., MANU/AP/0032/1994 : AIR 1994 AP 134, where it has been held as under: -

"30......By declaring his status in the Income Tax and Wealth-tax returns as "Hindu Undivided Family", it could not be said that the first defendant had blended his private properties with that of the joint family properties....

31. Declaration of status in the Income Tax returns is not always decisive of the real status of the individual.... "

C. Madan Lal Vs. Controller of Estate Duty, MANU/RH/0069/1968 : [1969] 74 ITR 84(Raj) where it has been held as under:-

20.....In our opinion, in the absence of any other circumstances, the filing of returns and getting his property taxed on the basis of joint family property were not sufficient to show an intention of abandonment of his claim on the part of Sukhdoo. It has been observed in Govind Narain Mathur v. Mohini Devi MANU/RH/0153/1960 : ILR [1960] Raj 1219 that a statement in connection with the assessment of Income Tax that certain property was joint family property may be made for the purpose of getting some advantage under the law relating to Income Tax and that it could not be evidence of any unequivocal intention on the part of the assesses to waive his interest in the self acquired property.... "

(emphasis supplied)
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

CS (OS) 2223/2013, 

Decided On: 04.02.2019

Aarshiya Gulati  Vs.  Kuldeep Singh Gulati and Ors.
Print Page

Whether it can be presumed that there was joint family property if there was HUF Bank Account?

HUF BANK ACCOUNT IS NOT RELATABLE TO ANY PROPERTY. THEREFORE, IRRELEVANT

86. As regards the HUF Bank account opened on 22nd November, 1985, it is not relatable to any property. It is an admitted position that the Public as well as the Private Limited Companies, Partnership Firms and Family Members of the defendant No. 1 had been filing independent Income Tax Returns. Therefore, the said HUF Bank account is wholly irrelevant.

87. In any event, showing in Income Tax Return, a HUF Bank account is meaningless unless the sufficient income is shown from nucleus of Hindu Joint Family Properties. The consistent legal position is that once there is no sufficient nucleus in Savings Bank Account, as in the present case, it will not make a Business/Property as a Hindu Joint Family property.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

CS (OS) 2223/2013, 

Decided On: 04.02.2019

Aarshiya Gulati  Vs.  Kuldeep Singh Gulati and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Manmohan, J.

Citation: AIR 2019(NOC) 577 Del
Print Page

Necessary pleading to be made if claim is made that suit property is HUF property

 I would like to further note that it is not enough to aver a mantra, so to say, in the plaint simply that a joint Hindu family or HUF exists. Detailed facts as required by Order VI Rule 4 CPC as to when and how the HUF properties have become HUF properties must be clearly and categorically averred. Such averments have to be made by factual references qua each property claimed to be an HUF property as to how the same is an HUF property, and, in law generally bringing in any and every property as HUF property is incorrect as there is known tendency of litigants to include unnecessarily many properties as HUF properties, and which is done for less than honest motives. Whereas prior to passing of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 there was a presumption as to the existence of an HUF and its properties, but after passing of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 in view of the ratios of the judgments of the Supreme Court in the cases of Chander Sen (supra) and Yudhishter (supra) there is no such presumption that inheritance of ancestral property creates an HUF, and therefore, in such a post 1956 scenario a mere ipse dixit statement in the plaint that an HUF and its properties exist is not a sufficient compliance of the legal requirement of creation or existence of HUF properties inasmuch as it is necessary for existence of an HUF and its properties that it must be specifically stated that as to whether the HUF came into existence before 1956 or after 1956 and if so how and in what manner giving all requisite factual details. It is only in such circumstances where specific facts are mentioned to clearly plead a cause of action of existence of an HUF and its properties, can a suit then be filed and maintained by a person claiming to be a coparcener for partition of the HUF properties.

10. A reference to the plaint in the present case shows that it is claimed that ownership of properties by late Sh. Jage Ram in his name was as joint Hindu family properties. Such a bald averment in itself cannot create an HUF unless it was pleaded that late Sh. Jage Ram inherited the properties from his paternal ancestors prior to 1956 or that late Sh. Jage Ram created an HUF by throwing his own properties into a common hotchpotch. These essential averments are completely missing in the plaint and therefore making a casual statement of existence of an HUF does not mean the necessary factual cause of action, as required in law, is pleaded in the plaint of existence of an HUF and of its properties.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

CS (OS) No. 1737/2012

Decided On: 18.01.2016

 Surender Kumar  Vs.  Dhani Ram and Ors.
Print Page

Whether there is presumption as to existence of HUF after coming into force of Hindu Succession Act 1956?

The Supreme Court around 30 years back in the judgment in the case of Commissioner of Wealth Tax, Kanpur and Others Vs. Chander Sen and Others, MANU/SC/0265/1986 : (1986) 3 SCC 567, held that after passing of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 the traditional view that on inheritance of an immovable property from paternal ancestors up to three degrees, automatically an HUF came into existence, no longer remained the legal position in view of Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956. This judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Chander Sen (supra) was thereafter followed by the Supreme Court in the case of Yudhishter Vs. Ashok Kumar, MANU/SC/0525/1986 : (1987) 1 SCC 204 wherein the Supreme Court reiterated the legal position that after coming into force of Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, inheritance of ancestral property after 1956 does not create an HUF property and inheritance of ancestral property after 1956 therefore does not result in creation of an HUF property.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

CS (OS) No. 1737/2012

Decided On: 18.01.2016

 Surender Kumar  Vs.  Dhani Ram and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Valmiki J. Mehta, J.

Citation: MANU/DE/0126/2016 : 227 (2016) DLT 217 
Print Page

Saturday, 27 April 2019

Whether case against Hindu undivided family will abate on death of its Karta?

The matter can be looked at from another point of view also. Rule 10, Order 30. Civil P.C. provides that a Hindu undivided family carrying on business under any name, may be sued in such name or style as if it were a firm name, and, in so far as the nature of such case permits, all rules under Order 30 shall apply accordingly. Rule 4 of Order 30. Civil P.C. provides that notwithstanding anything contained in Section 45 of the Contract Act, 1872, where two or more persons may sue or be sued in the name of a firm under the foregoing provisions and any of such person dies, whether before the institution or during the pendency of any suit, it shall not be necessary to joint the legal representatives of the deceased as a party to the suit. It is not disputed that Messrs. Rai Bahadur Kishore Chand and Sons was a Joint Hindu family concern and had been sued through its Karta, Rai Bahadur Kishore Chand. In view of the said provision of Rule 4. on the death of the Karta, it was not necessary to bring on record his legal representatives because the joint Hindu family concern continues to be a party in spite of the death of the Karta. So the question of the abatement of the appeal did not arise and the name of the new Karta could be impleaded as a party any time. It is therefore, not possible to sustain the view of the learned single Judge that the appeal had abated on the death of Rai Bahadur Kishore Chand, the Karta of the joint Hindu family concern and the impugned judgment is accordingly reversed.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA

Decided On: 21.03.1983

 Shila Wanti  Vs. R.B. Kishore Chand and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
S.S. Sandhawalia, C.J. and Satya Parkash Goyal, J.

Citation: AIR 1984 P& H 35
Print Page

Sunday, 9 September 2018

Whether a person can claim that property standing in the name of wives of his nephews are belonging to him?

It is apparent that as per clause (1) of section 4 of BTA, no suit to enforce any right in respect of any property held benami against the person in whose name the property is held or against any other person shall lie on the plea that the property is held benami, with the exception that where the person, in whose name the property is held, is a 'coparcener' in the Hindu Undivided Family and the property is held for the benefit of the coparceners of the property or where the person in whose name the property is held is a trustee or stands in a fiduciary capacity to another.

7. From a reading of Section 4 of the Act, it is obvious that for a valid claim raised by the plaintiff, to bring the case in the exception provided in clause (a) of sub-Section (3) of Section 4 of the BTA, following three requisites are essential to be pleaded:-

(i) Existence of a Hindu Undivided Family;

(ii) Defendants in whose name the suit property are held, are a coparceners of the said Hindu Undivided Family; and

(iii) Suit property is held by the defendants for the benefit of the coparceners in the family.

8. In the instant case, the defendants are the wives of the nephew of the plaintiff and thus they are not the coparceners under the definition of Hindu Undivided Family and thus exception carved out by the BTA is not available to the plaintiff in the present case as the exception contained in Section 4 (3) (a) of the BTA restricts its benefits only to property held by a coparcener in a Hindu Undivided Family as opposed to any 'Member' of such family. It is so, because coparceners are recognized by law to jointly by birth inherit rights in the joint property of the family property and in the event such property stands in one of their names for the benefit of others, the BTA is declared to not come in the way. Such benefit however cannot be extended to all/any members of such family who do not have any vested right in the property. The plaintiff, being the brother of deceased father in law of the defendants is not a coparcener in the Hindu Undivided Family of his deceased brother. In view of the fact that requisite (ii) noted above is not fulfilled, exception contained in Section 4(3)(a) of the Act has no application in the instant case.


13. In view of the aforesaid settled law, the defendants in whose names the suit property stands as per the pleadings of the plaintiff himself, they are absolute owners of the suit property by virtue of section 14(1) of Hindu Succession Act, 1956. The plaintiff himself has pleaded in his plaint that the suit property was purchased in the names of wives of his nephew out of love and affection and if such fact is admitted in the plaint itself, it is not necessary for this court to go on trial to find out the fact or to lift the veil to come to the conclusion which is necessary for the parties by determining the question raised in the plaint. In my considered opinion once the plaintiff has admitted in his pleadings that the property had been purchased for the benefit of the defendants, he cannot be turned around at this stage and file a suit claiming himself as real owner/co owner of the property in question. Accordingly, I hold that the suit filed by the plaintiff is barred under BTA and Order 7 Rule 11(d) CPC and thus the same is accordingly rejected. Ordered accordingly. File be consigned to record room."

(underlining added)

4. I completely agree with the conclusions of the trial court contained in the impugned judgment, inasmuch as, there is no entitlement to claim a right in a property which is benami by virtue of Section 4(1) of the Act. Benami property means a property which is purchased in the name of one person and funds are paid for purchase by another person with the intention that the benami owner is only a nominal owner and the actual owner is the person who has paid the funds. The Benami Act was passed in the year 1988 to nullify benami transactions as most of the benami transactions had their roots in illegalities, including existence of unaccounted or illegal moneys. The only two exceptions to the bar contained in Sub-Sections (1) and (2) of Section 4 of the Benami Act are as per Section 4 (3) of the Benami Act when firstly where there exists an Hindu Undivided Family (HUF) and the property is in the name of a coparcener and secondly where the property is purchased by a person standing in a fiduciary capacity or as a trustee. In the present case the exception which is pleaded by the appellant/plaintiff to avoid the application of the provision of Section 4(1) of the Benami Act is the existence of HUF and which will not apply because respondents/defendants being females are not coparceners and the exception under Section 4(3) of the Benami Act applies if the property claimed to be an HUF is in the name of a coparcener.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

RFA No. 852/2017

Decided On: 10.10.2017

Lalsa Prasad Singh Vs.  Chanderwala and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Valmiki J. Mehta, J.

Citation: AIR 2018(NOC) 684 DELHI
Print Page

Friday, 19 May 2017

When partial partition of joint family property is permissible?

Even as a rule of Hindu Law, if the property is not joint family property and the parties are not coparceners but only co-owners or tenants-in-common the rule is not so rigid and partial partition may be allowed if there is not much inconvenience to the other sharers.
19. In addition to that, the partial partition is prohibited for a good reason as the partition has the effect of breaking up a joint Hindu family. If such a family is disrupted, it stands to reason that the family should break up completely and the whole family property should be divided.
20. However, even suits praying for partial partition have also been recognized under some of the following circumstances, namely:
(i) where different portions of family property are situated in different districts, separate suits for partition for lands of each district may be brought;
(ii) it may be allowed when portion of joint property at the time of the suit for partition is incapable of partition;
(iii) where the property left out from its very nature impartible;
(iv) where the property is held jointly with strangers who cannot be joined as parties to a general suit for partition the same may be left out; or
(v) where the co-owners by mutual agreement decide to make partition of the joint family property leaving some portion in common.(Refer: Harey Harey Singha Chowdhury vs. Hari Chaitanya Singha Chowdhury MANU/WB/0413/1936 : 40 CWN 1237; Mansharam vs. Ganesh MANU/WB/0404/1912 : 17 CWN 521; Panchanan Mallick vs. Shiv ChandraILR 14 Cal 805; Balaram vs. Ramchandra ILR 22 Bom 922; Abdul Karim vs. Badruddin ILR 28 Mad 216).
Therefore, it is not in all events that partial partition is impermissible.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA
R.S.A. No. 565 of 2012
Decided On: 01.04.2017
 Pradeep Chand Sharma Vs.  Budhi Devi and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Tarlok Singh Chauhan, J.

Citation: AIR 2017 HP73
Print Page

Friday, 14 April 2017

Whether other coparcener can claim partition of property purchased by person by income from his professional knowledge?

 Now it is not denied anywhere that the business started by Arjan Singh was not a commercial venture per se but a calling or profession, i.e. medical advice in respect of herbal remedies. The plaintiffs allege that such knowledge or expertise so acquired by Arjan Singh is not on account of his association with his father. The object of the said Act was to ensure that earning from acquired skills such as medical or legal practice, accountancy or in other avocations where individual effort and skill is necessary, should never be deemed as part of contribution by member of a joint family property so as to bring it within the HUF hotchpotch. This was to incentivize proficiency in such vocations and encourage people into acquiring greater skills and higher learning as in the absence of such safeguard, the danger of earnings acquired by the members of such joint families becoming available for division are very real. In such eventuality, the members of the joint family, who earn and toil hard were left with a miniscule portion of their earning gained entirely by individual skill and effort as the latter's share, the lion's share of which would have fallen to the other members of the family, who would possibly never work at all. In the present case, the suit expressly states that the funds for acquiring various properties in the name of Arjan Singh were out of his earnings as a medical professional, from out of M/s. Sewak Pharmacy. That clearly falls within the mischief of Section 3 of the Hindu Gains of Learning Act. Therefore, the claim for partition of such properties is expressly barred. 
Delhi High Court
Sh. Balbir Singh Uppal And Anr. vs Sh. Gurmeet Singh Uppal And Ors. on 22 April, 2010
Author: S.Ravindra Bhat
Print Page

Saturday, 25 March 2017

Whether there can death of HUF?

In appeal, the AAC had to consider the objection raised before him that the GTO was not justified in taking the status of an individual as against the status of HUF claimed in the return. According to him, the claim of HUF status was justified. However, he set aside the gift-tax assessment made by the GTO for the purpose of verifying whether the property in question was really ancestral and belonged to the HUF. There was an objection raised with regard to the assessment having been made on a dead person. On this issue, he observed that this contention was of no consequence because he had accepted the claim of the status of HUF and HUF never dies. 
Income Tax Appellate Tribunal - Chandigarh
Gift-Tax Officer vs Jagir Singh on 12 March, 1982
Equivalent citations: 1982 2 ITD 576 Chd
Bench: S Chander, F Rustagi
Print Page

Whether appeal filed by deceased karta of hindu undivided family is tenable?


Rule 10 of Order 30 provides that any person carrying on business in a name or style other than his own name or Hindu undivided family carrying on business under any name, may be sued in such name or style as if it were a firm name, and, insofar as the nature of such case permits, all rules under Order 30 shall apply accordingly. From bare perusal of this provision, it is clear that when a HUF is "to be sued", it may be sued in the name in which it carries business. In the present case the suit was filed against the HUF showing Kishanchand Gupta as its karta/manager and not in other name. In other words, the provision of rule 4(2) will apply only where a Hindu undivided family is carrying on business under any name, and is to be sued it could be sued in the name or style in which it carries its business. It needs to be noted that a HUF cannot appear as a HUF, and the manager/karta should, therefore, appear in his own name, though all subsequent proceedings could be continued in the name of HUF. A HUF need to be represented by its karta/manager in a suit/appeal and in the event of his death a successor karta/manager will have to represent the HUF and continue the proceedings. But, after disposal of a suit and at the time of filing an appeal if karta, who was representing the HUF in the suit dies, the successor karta will have to file the appeal. The appeal, in such eventuality cannot be filed in the name of HUF, showing the deceased karta/manager as its karta/manager. Such appeal would be a nullity. {Para 8}
Bombay High Court
Mrs.Nergish Minoo Pavri vs C/O. M/S.Bashimall Punnalal on 7 September, 2009
Bench: D.B.Bhosale

Dated : 7TH SEPTEMBER, 2009.
Citation: 2010(4) BomCR 475 Bom
Print Page

Sunday, 16 August 2015

Whether coparcener can unilaterally throw his separate property in common stock of joint family property?

 Further, the decision of Orissa High Court in Commissioner of Income Tax, Orissa v. Harish Chandra Gupta, decided on 02.02.1981 was relied upon by the learned counsel for the defendants, wherein, it was held as under:
"The separate property of a Hindu ceases to be separate property and acquires the characteristics of a joint family or ancestral property not by any physical mixing with his joint family or his ancestral property but by his own volition and intention by his waiving and surrendering his separate rights in it as a separate property. The act by which the coparcener throws his separate property in the common stock is a unilateral act. There is no question of either the family rejecting or accepting it. By his individual volition, he renounces his individual right in that property and treats it as a property of the family. No sooner than he declares his intention to treat his self- acquired property as that of the joint family property, the property assumes the character of joint family property. The doctrine of throwing into the common stock is a doctrine peculiar to the Mitakshara school of Hindu law".

Delhi High Court

Vineeta Sharma vs Rakesh Sharma And Ors. on 29 October, 2013
Author: M. L. Mehta
Citation;AIR 2015 (NOC)895 Delhi
Print Page

Sunday, 13 April 2014

Whether Wife can demand share in property of husband during his life time?

 The position of a wife even as regards the right of partition in Mitakshara law has been considered in Mulla's Hindu Law, Twentieth Edition, Volume I, paragraph 314 at page 579 thus:
314 WIFE:
(1) A wife cannot herself demand a partition, but if a partition does take place between her husband and his sons, she is entitled (except in Southern India) to receive a share equal to that of a son and to hold and enjoy that share separately even from her husband.
12. Consequently a wife has no share, right, title or interest in the HUF in which her husband is a coparcener with his brothers, father or sons (and after the amendment of Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act in 2005 with his sisters and daughters also).
13. The wife, such as the deceased, may be a member of a joint Hindu family. By virtue of being a member in the joint Hindu family she cannot get any share, right, title or interest in the joint Hindu property which that family owns. A joint Hindu family may own no property at all. If it owns property, a wife cannot demand partition unlike a daughter. She would get a share only if partition is demanded by her husband or sons and the property is actually partitioned. There has been no such demand and no consequent partition of any property. In fact there has been no partition in the HUF in which the husband is a coparcener. Hence the husband has not acquired any specific share in the coparcenary property-the bungalow in Ahmedabad-which could have become the property of his separate HUF consisting of his wife and children until the death of his wife, the deceased.
14. If there was a partition in the HUF of her husband's father, in which he is a coparcener, the husband would have got a share in that partition. That would have been ancestral property in his hands. That would have, therefore, been his HUF property. In that property the deceased who was a member of her husband's (the defendant's) HUF would have had a share. The deceased could not have demanded a partition. Had there been a partition upon the demand of the coparceners (the husband and children), she would have got a share thereunder. That share would have been her separate property bequeathable by her. She expired prior to such share being obtained. Since her husband did not expire, she would not have the rights of a widow also. Consequently she had no share and no bequeathable interest in any share which devolved upon her husband by survivorship until her death. Consequently the bequest of "my share" or the "monies" which may come to my share is wholly misconceived since her husband was alive on the date of her death and she was not a widow.
Bombay High Court

Jayamati Narendra Shah  vs Narendra Amritlal Shah on 18 January, 2014
CORAM : MRS. ROSHAN DALVI, J.


Citation; 2014 (2) MHLJ 739,2014(4)ALLMR616

Family - Entailment for Injunction - Demand of partition - Plaintiff had filed suit claimed partition of immovable properties and mandatory injunction directed to handover those properties to Plaintiff and usual permanent injunctions against alienation - Hence, this Notice of Motion - Whether Defendant had rightly filed notice of motion to oppose grant of adinterim reliefs - Held, it was only Hindu widow who got interest of her husband in coparcenary or joint family property upon death of her husband - There had been no partition in HUF in which husband was coparcener - Husband had not acquired any specific share in coparcenary property - In disputed property deceased who was member of her husband's (Defendant's) HUF would have share - However deceased could not have demanded partition - Thus claim by wife during life time of husband in share and interest which he had coparcener in his HUF was wholly premature and completely misconceived - Therefore injunction in respect of such property could not be granted as claimed - Hence Defendant should not alienate, encumber, part with possession or create any third party rights in equity shares held by deceased.

"Party shall not alienate, encumber, transfer, part with possession or otherwise create any third party rights, unless proves that party can make demand partition in HUF properties."
Print Page