Showing posts with label commercial transaction. Show all posts
Showing posts with label commercial transaction. Show all posts

Friday, 31 August 2018

Notes on S 34 of CPC- Payment of interest

S 34 of CPC makes provision for payment of interest in cases where the decree is for payment of money.
In any suit for money,the interest which may be awarded to a plaintiff may be divided into following three heads:
a). Interest prior to institution of suit: This is actually a matter of substantive law and not procedural.If parties have stipulated the rate of such interest,the court will normally allow that rate.If that rate is excessive,it will be scaled down by court under money lender'sAct or usurious loans Act or S 74 of Indian contract Act.
Print Page

Saturday, 6 June 2015

Whether purchase of medicine by government is commercial transaction?


 In M/s.Meenakshi Pharma Distributors V.
State of Karnataka and others (AIR 1999 Karnataka
192), the State of Karnataka purchased medicines from
the plaintiff for the purpose of distribution among
government hospitals. The parties agreed that rate of
interest will be 15% per annum on the amount due. In
the suit filed by the supplier of medicines, the trial court
awarded interest only at the rate of 6% per annum from
the date of suit till the date of realisation. Challenging
the same, the plaintiff (supplier) filed appeal. Dismissing
the appeal, the Karnataka High Court held thus:-
“ the definition of the commercial transaction has to be
taken in conjunction with the person against whom the
liability has arisen. The person who has incurred the
liability is not the person who is the claimant of the money
or interest. It means when we have to judge the
commercial transaction, it has to be looked into whether
the person incurring the liability under the transaction has
incurred the liability in the context of trade or business or
industry. The respondent in this case purchased medicines
from the plaintiff - appellant and incurred the liability for
sums claimed. In ordinary course, Government purchases
medicines for being distributed among the Government
Hospitals. In Government Hospitals, the medicines are
provided to the ordinary people, common people as well as
to those who are down-trodden and for the betterment of
the people. By examining the nature of transaction it
cannot be said to be connected with any industry, trade or
business of the party who has incurred the liability, and
cannot be said to be commercial transaction as the
Government's Health Department purchased the same to
supply the medicines to various Government Hospitals for
the benefit of citizens and to be provided to common
persons subjected to various ailments.
Therefore, in my opinion, this transaction cannot be
termed as a commercial transaction. In this view of the
matter, the proviso of Section 34 will not be applicable to
the present transaction because when the medicines have
been purchased by the Government, it is nobody's case
that they were purchased to sell. It is no doubt that
Government purchases medicines to provide them to the
Government Hospitals for the welfare of the people as it
is the duty and responsibility of the Government to
ensure public health i.e the duty of the State under the
Constitution of India”.


IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT:
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K.T.SANKARAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P.D.RAJAN
THURSDAY, THE 16TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2014
AS.No. 533 of 2000 ( )
-----------------------

 THE SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER,
Vs
 m p varghese
Citation;AIR 2015(NOC)530 kerala
Print Page

Wednesday, 3 September 2014

Whether "commercial transaction" include "professional transaction." for purpose of S34 of CPC?


In view of this, 'profession' will have to be treated as different from 'industry', 'trade', and 'business'. There is a clear distinction between the profession on one hand, and industry, trade and business on the other. While dealing with the 'commercial transactions" for the purpose of Section 34, C.P.C. the Legislature has not used the word 'profession' along with the words, 'industry' 'trade, or 'business'. The commercial transactions which are strictly connected with the industry, trade or business alone are included for the purposes of Section 34, C.P.C. as provided in Explanation II. Though the 'commercial transaction" is inclusive of "industry, trade and business", but it is exclusive of "profession". The fact that the Legislature has not included the word 'profession' along with the, words "industry, trade and business" to specify the "commercial transaction" cannot be igorned. The proviso to Section 34, C.P.C. will, therefore, not govern the cases where the
loan is advanced for the 'profession' or for "professional transactions".
 In our opinion, the words "commercial transaction" do not include the "profession" or "professional transaction."
We, therefore, find that the learned trial Judge was right in holding in the absence of any evidence to that effect that the present loan is a professional loan, and cannot be termed as a commerical transaction. Awarding future interest at the rate of 6 p.c. p.a. cannot be said to be in contravention of the provisions of Section 34, C.P.C.

Bombay High Court
Dena Bank, Ahmednagar vs Prakash Birbhan Kataria And .
.. on 26 April, 1993
Equivalent citations: AIR 1994 Bom 343, 
1994 (1) BomCR 537, 1994 (1) MhLj 198

Bench: B Deshmukh, V Sirpurkar

Print Page

Wednesday, 26 June 2013

Supreme Court:Precaution to be taken by court while deciding application for grant of declaration and injunction relating to commercial transactions

Undoubtedly declaration of the rights or status is one of discretion of the court under Section 34 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963. Equally the grant or refusal of the relief of declaration and injunction under the provision of that Act is discretionary. The plaintiff cannot claim the relief as of right. It has to be granted according to sound principles of law and ex debito justicia. The court cannot convert itself into an instrument of injustice or vehicle of oppression. While exercising its discretionary power, the court must keep in its mind the well settled principles of justice and fair play and the discretion would be exercised keeping in view the ends of justice since justice is the hall mark and it cannot be administered in vacuum.
24. Grant of declaration and injunction relating to commercial transactions tend to aid dishonesty and perfidy. Conversely refusal to grant relief generally encourages candour in business behaviour, facilitates free Row of capital, prompt compliance of covenants, sustained growth of commerce and above all inculcates respect for the efficacy of judicial adjudication. Before granting or refusing to grant of relief of declaration or injunction or both the court must weigh pros and cons in each case, consider the facts and circumstances in its proper perspective and exercise discretion with circumspection to further the ends of justice. From the back-drop fact situation we have no hesitation to hold that the relief of declaration granted is unjust and illegal. It tended to impede free flow of capital, thwarted the growth of merchantile business and deflected the course of justice.

Supreme Court of India
American Express Bank Ltd. vs Calcutta Steel Co. And Ors. on 18 December, 1992
Equivalent citations: 1993 76 CompCas 768 SC, 1992 (3) SCALE 536

Bench: A Ahmadi, M Punchhi, K Ramaswamy

Print Page