Showing posts with label provident fund. Show all posts
Showing posts with label provident fund. Show all posts

Sunday, 4 April 2021

Whether the employer can refuse to pay the amount of provident fund and leave encashment to the employee if he had issued the charge sheet of departmental enquiry to him after retirement?

  With respect the Provident Fund reliance is placed on the

judgement of the Supreme Court in Gorakhpur University & Ors. vs. Dr. Shitla Prasad Nagendra & Ors., (2006) 6 SCC 591, wherein the Court held that terminal benefits including Provident Fund cannot be withheld and the same are immune from attachment, deduction or adjustment even against any of the dues from the employee. To the same effect is the

decision of the Division Bench of the Bombay High Court in Ramdas Govind Bakhle vs. Maharashtra State Financial Corporation (2000)SCC OnLine Bom 9, wherein the Court relying on Bhagirathijena vs. Board of Directors, Orissa State Financial Corporation & Ors., (1993) 3 SCC 666, held that no amount from the Provident Fund of an employee can be deducted in the absence of service Regulations providing so and

the Court directed the Respondent therein to release the Provident Fund of the Petitioner.{Para 7}

13. A perusal of the provisions of Rule 7.7 makes it evident that before the Competent Authority can withhold the Leave Encashment of an employee, wholly or partly, a conscious decision must be taken to withhold the Leave Encashment due to the employee on account of there being a possibility of some money becoming recoverable from him, once the Disciplinary Proceedings conclude.

14. While interpreting the said Rule, the Division Bench held as

follows:-

“10. The aforesaid Rule would show that the competent

authority may wholly or partly, withhold leave encashment in

respect of a Government servant who retires on attaining the

age of superannuation, while under suspension or while

undergoing disciplinary or criminal proceedings, provided the

competent authority is of the view that there is a possibility of

some money becoming recoverable from him on the conclusion

of proceedings against him. In the present case, the respondents

have not produced any order to show that a conscious decision

has been taken by the Government to withhold the leave

encashment due to the petitioner upon his retirement, on

account of there being a possibility of some money becoming

recoverable from him on the conclusion of proceedings against

him. The nature of the charge levied against the petitioner also

does not support the withholding of the leave encashment. We

cannot agree with the submissions of learned counsel for the

respondents that if the charge against the petitioner is proved,

it could also have the effect of nullifying the examination

process in which the petitioner is alleged to have manipulated

the marks of some of the candidates. Pertinently, the said

examination took place in the year 2010. It is not the

respondent’s case that any of the successful candidates have

been put to notice in this regard. It is not claimed that the said

examination process has been assailed by any unsuccessful

candidate on account of the alleged misconduct of the

petitioner, or that the same has been set aside, or the challenge

is still pending. We are, therefore, of the view that withholding

of leave encashment of the petitioner is not justified.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

W.P.(C) 3114/2020 & CM 10817/2020

SH. S.B. SINGH Vs NATIONAL TEXTILE CORPORATION 

CORAM: HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE JYOTI SINGH

Pronounced on: 17.11.2020

Print Page

Thursday, 2 March 2017

Whether family pension can be bequeathed by will?

Thus, the payment of pension is strictly governed by the service
rules   and,   therefore,   it   cannot   be   an   'estate'   disposable   by   will.
Though the Government employee has right to receive the pension, it
cannot be treated as a 'property'.  On this point, I rely on the case of
Jodh Singh (supra).   In the said case, the officer bequeathed his
movable and immovable property to his father during his life time
and nominated his parents for the Provident Fund, as his relation
with his wife was not cordial.   The Hon'ble Supreme Court while
dealing with the issue held that the pension is a retirement benefit
and is not payable in the life time of the employee and what is not
payable during the life time of the deceased over which he has no
power of disposition and cannot form part of his estate.   It is the
event   of   his   death   that   provides   the   eligibility   qualification   for
claiming special family pension.
24. In the case of Sundariya Bai Choudhary (supra), the Division
Bench of Madhya Pradesh High Court has taken a similar view that
the pension of deceased cannot be said to be an estate and it is not
transferable   and   cannot   be   bequeathed   by   Will.     However,   other
pensionary   benefits   like   Provident   Fund,   Gratuity   etc.   and   other
retiral dues or extra renumeration would be estate of the deceased
and that can be bequeathed by him.

25. In the case of Violet (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court had an
opportunity to deal with Railway Family Pension Rules and held that
pension cannot be bequeathed by will since it is not a part of estate of
the employee but it is for monetary benefit of wife and children.
26. After going through the facts of the cases and law laid down
therein which are referred above, it is pertinent to note that in these
cases, husbands have disposed of the property by will to other family
members by denying the claim of the wife and, therefore, the Courts
have taken a view that wife has prime claim over the pension of the
husband and that cannot be denied.  In the present case, Jaydeo has
bequeathed his pension to his first wife only.  It is a settled position of
law that pension is not a estate and so it cannot be bequeathed by
will, so to that extent, i.e., the portion of bequeath of pension in
favour of Draupada is bad in law, however, the statements made in
the   will   about   the   status   of   Draupada   and   his   final   wish   that
Draupada alone has right over his pension corroborates a fact of valid
nomination of Draupada as a first wife.
27. Thus, it is held that pension is not a estate or property and
cannot be disposed of and to that extent, the portion in the will
regarding bequeath is against the law.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
FIRST APPEAL NO.577 OF 2015
WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO.1770 OF 2015
Draupada @ Draupadi Jaydeo Pawar
and Others 
vs.
Indubai d/o. Kashinath Shivram Chavan
and Another 
CORAM : MRS.MRIDULA BHATKAR, J.
 Dated  : 10th FEBRUARY, 2016
Citation: 2017(1) ALLMR197
Print Page

Thursday, 22 December 2016

Whether widow is entitled to get provident fund money of her deceased husband after her remarriage?

Mr.S.K.Mani, learned Counsel for the respondent agreed with regard
to the legal point raised by the learned Counsel for the appellant. In fact,
he very fairly produced the judgment of this Court in Selvi v. K.Alagarsamy
reported in 2010 (2) TN MAC 328, wherein, after discussing various provisions
of Hindu Succession Act, 1956 and Hindu Widows Re-marriage Act, 1856, the  
right of the widow not only to remarry, but also to inherit the property of
the late husband has been declared and the women including widows are treated 
as co-parcener on par with the males.
        5. Paragraph 24 of the said judgment is extracted hereunder:
        "24. The Honourable Supreme Court in Cherotte Suganthan (Died) through 
LRs. and others v. Cherotte Bharathi and others, 2008 (2) LW 102 analysed the
overriding effect of Hindu Succession Act (1956) on Hindu Widows Remarriage
Act, 1856. It was held that Section 2 of the Hindu Widows Remarriage Act,
1856 would not prevail over the provisions of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956
Act having regard to Sections 4 and 24 thereof. It is further held that Hindu
Widows were brought on equal footing in the matter of inheritance and
succession along with the male heirs. Section 14(1) of the Act, stipulates
that any property possessed by a female Hindu, whether acquired before or
after the commencement of the Act, will be held by her as a full owner
thereof. All the aforesaid Acts namely, Hindu Widows Remarriage Act, 1856,
Hindu Succession Act, 1956, Hindu Widow Remarriage (Repeal) Act, 1983 and Act   
39 of 2005 which deleted Section 24 of Hindu Succession Act with effect from
09.09.2005, recognise the right of the widows not only in remarriages but
also in inheriting the properties of the late husband. In nut-shell, the
women including widows are treated as co-parcener on par with the males."

        6. It is very disheartening to note that the appellant lost her second
husband within fifteen days of the remarriage and her position has not been
improved any more. 
        7. As stated above, she is entitled to a share in the Provident Fund
amount on par with the respondent, who is the mother of the deceased husband.
BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT               

DATED: 15.12.2016  

CORAM   

MR.JUSTICE N.KIRUBAKARAN             

C.M.A(MD)No.1397 of 2006   
and 
M.P(MD)No.1 of 2006  

Yashodha      Vs.  Chellammal                                     

Print Page