With respect the Provident Fund reliance is placed on the
judgement of the Supreme Court in Gorakhpur University & Ors. vs. Dr. Shitla Prasad Nagendra & Ors., (2006) 6 SCC 591, wherein the Court held that terminal benefits including Provident Fund cannot be withheld and the same are immune from attachment, deduction or adjustment even against any of the dues from the employee. To the same effect is the
decision of the Division Bench of the Bombay High Court in Ramdas Govind Bakhle vs. Maharashtra State Financial Corporation (2000)SCC OnLine Bom 9, wherein the Court relying on Bhagirathijena vs. Board of Directors, Orissa State Financial Corporation & Ors., (1993) 3 SCC 666, held that no amount from the Provident Fund of an employee can be deducted in the absence of service Regulations providing so and
the Court directed the Respondent therein to release the Provident Fund of the Petitioner.{Para 7}
13. A perusal of the provisions of Rule 7.7 makes it evident that before the Competent Authority can withhold the Leave Encashment of an employee, wholly or partly, a conscious decision must be taken to withhold the Leave Encashment due to the employee on account of there being a possibility of some money becoming recoverable from him, once the Disciplinary Proceedings conclude.
14. While interpreting the said Rule, the Division Bench held as
follows:-
“10. The aforesaid Rule would show that the competent
authority may wholly or partly, withhold leave encashment in
respect of a Government servant who retires on attaining the
age of superannuation, while under suspension or while
undergoing disciplinary or criminal proceedings, provided the
competent authority is of the view that there is a possibility of
some money becoming recoverable from him on the conclusion
of proceedings against him. In the present case, the respondents
have not produced any order to show that a conscious decision
has been taken by the Government to withhold the leave
encashment due to the petitioner upon his retirement, on
account of there being a possibility of some money becoming
recoverable from him on the conclusion of proceedings against
him. The nature of the charge levied against the petitioner also
does not support the withholding of the leave encashment. We
cannot agree with the submissions of learned counsel for the
respondents that if the charge against the petitioner is proved,
it could also have the effect of nullifying the examination
process in which the petitioner is alleged to have manipulated
the marks of some of the candidates. Pertinently, the said
examination took place in the year 2010. It is not the
respondent’s case that any of the successful candidates have
been put to notice in this regard. It is not claimed that the said
examination process has been assailed by any unsuccessful
candidate on account of the alleged misconduct of the
petitioner, or that the same has been set aside, or the challenge
is still pending. We are, therefore, of the view that withholding
of leave encashment of the petitioner is not justified.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
W.P.(C) 3114/2020 & CM 10817/2020
SH. S.B. SINGH Vs NATIONAL TEXTILE CORPORATION
CORAM: HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE JYOTI SINGH
Pronounced on: 17.11.2020
Print Page

