Showing posts with label pensionary benefits. Show all posts
Showing posts with label pensionary benefits. Show all posts

Saturday, 14 September 2024

Supreme Court : Motor accident claim tribunal can not allow deductions from the amount of compensation on account of insurance, pensionary benefits, gratuity or grant of employment to a kin of the deceased

 The law is well settled that deductions cannot be allowed from the amount of compensation either on account of insurance, or on account of pensionary benefits or gratuity or grant of employment to a kin of the deceased. The main reason is that all these amounts are earned by the deceased on account of contractual relations entered into by him with others. It cannot be said that these amounts accrued to the dependents or the legal heirs of the deceased on account of his death in a motor vehicle accident. The claimants/dependents are entitled to 'just compensation' under the Motor Vehicles Act as a result of the death of the deceased in a motor vehicle accident. Therefore, the natural corollary is that the advantage which accrues to the estate of the deceased or to his dependents as a result of some contract or act which the deceased performed in his life time cannot be said to be the outcome or result of the death of the deceased even though these amounts may go into the hands of the dependents only after his death. {Para 12}


13. As far as any amount paid under any insurance policy is concerned whatever is added to the estate of the deceased or his dependents is not because of the death of the deceased but because of the contract entered into between the deceased and the insurance company from where he took out the policy. The deceased paid premium on such life insurance and this amount would have accrued to the estate of the deceased either on maturity of the policy or on his death, whatever be the manner of his death. These amounts are paid because the deceased has wisely invested his savings. Similar would be the position in case of other investments like bank deposits, share, debentures etc.. The tort-feasor cannot take advantage of the foresight and wise financial investments made by the deceased.


14. As far as the amounts of pension and gratuity are concerned, these are paid on account of the service rendered by the deceased to his employer. It is now an established principle of service jurisprudence that pension and gratuity are the property of the deceased. They are more in the nature of deferred wages. The deceased employee works throughout his life expecting that on his retirement he will get substantial amount as pension and gratuity. These amounts are also payable on death, whatever be the cause of death. Therefore, applying the same principles, the said amount cannot be deducted.


15. As held by the House of Lords in Perry v. Cleaver MANU/UKHL/0008/1969 : 1969 ACJ 363 the insurance amount is the fruit of premium paid in the past, pension is the fruit of services already rendered and the wrong doer should not be given benefit of the same by deducting it from the damages assessed.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal Nos. 10588-89 of 2018.

Decided On: 12.10.2018

Sebastiani Lakra and Ors. Vs. National Insurance Company Ltd. and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Madan B. Lokur, S. Abdul Nazeer and Deepak Gupta, JJ.

Author: Deepak Gupta, J.

Citation:  MANU/SC/1162/2018,(2019) 17 SCC 465.

Print Page

Thursday, 6 May 2021

Bombay HC: The Claim tribunal should not deduct from deceased's salary towards insurance, pensionary benefits, gratuity while awarding compensation for a motor accident

 In my view, the assessment of compensation made by

the Tribunal is against the settled position in law. It is well settled

position in law that except the statutory deduction to be made

towards income tax, professional tax, no other deduction is

permissible under law. The deduction from salary of the deceased towards insurance, pensionary benefts, gratuity or grant of employment to kin of deceased is not permissible. In this context, the learned counsel for the appellant has placed reliance upon the decision in the case of Sebastiani Lakra & others v. National Insurance Company Ltd. & another reported at 2018 ALL SCR 2175 wherein the Apex Court has observed in paragraph nos.12 to16 as under:-

“12. The law is well settled that deductions cannot be

allowed from the amount of compensation either on

account of insurance, or on account of pensionary

benefts or gratuity or grant of employment to akin of the

deceased. The main reason is that all these amounts are

earned by the deceased on account of contractual

relations entered into by him with others. It cannot be

said that these amounts accrued to the dependents or

the legal heirs of the deceased on account of his death in

a motor vehicle accident. The claimants/dependents are

entitled to ‘just compensation’ under the Motor Vehicles

Act as a result of the death of the deceased in a motor

vehicle accident. Therefore, the natural corollary is that

the advantage which accrues to the estate of the

deceased or to his dependents as a result of some

contract or act which the deceased performed in his life

time cannot be said to be the outcome or result of the

death of the deceased even though these amounts may

go into the hands of the dependents only after his death. {Para 13}

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

BENCH AT AURANGABAD

FIRST APPEAL NO.754 OF 2012

Anita  Arun Memane, Vs  The Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation,

CORAM: V.L. ACHLIYA, J.

Dated : 24.07.2020

Citation: 2021(2) MHLJ 396

Print Page

Thursday, 7 September 2017

Whether Judges appointed after 1st November 2005 are entitled to get pensionary benefits?

 We   hold   that   the   impugned   Government   Resolution
dated 31st October, 2015 is not applicable to the Judicial

Officers in the State who were appointed on or after 1st
November 2005.  The said officers will be entitled to the
same   pensionary   benefits   which   are   available   to   the
judicial officers appointed before 1st  November 2005.
However, the judicial officers who are appointed on or
after 1st November 2005 will have an option to continue
under the New Scheme;
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
PUBLIC INTEREST LITIGATION NO.188 OF 2015
Vihar Durve  V  The State of Maharashtra and Ors. 

CORAM  :  A.S. OKA & A.K. MENON, JJ.

DATED: 11th AUGUST 2017
JUDGMENT (PER A.S. OKA, J.):­
Print Page

Sunday, 16 April 2017

Whether employer has right to recover excess payments from pensionary benefits of employee?

In the present case, the declaration of the petitioner that Learned Counsel for the State has relied on is as follows:-
“I do hereby agree that the payments of the monthly bills and arrear pay bills drawn in the revised scale of pay are ‘Provisional’ and are subject to subsequent adjustment and that the over-drawals, if any, in this regard be recovered forthwith from my salary bill” (emphasis is mine).
14. The form of declaration clearly means that even at the highest, recovery of excess payment could be made by the State from the salary bill of the petitioner during the tenure of his service. In my opinion, such a declaration would not entitle the State to recover any over-drawals from the pensionary benefits of the petitioner. Pensionary benefits are paid to a superannuated person by way of social welfare measure to enable him to live a life of dignity which is now recognized as a fundamental right of a citizen of India. Retiral benefits are not to be lightly interfered with. Any right of the employer to recover from the pensionary benefits of an employee any excess payment received by the employee due to no fault, fraud or misrepresentation on his part is to be strictly construed. Of course, it will be a different thing altogether if the employee has fraudulently induced the employer to make the excess payment. In such a case the employer's right to recover the excess payment from the pensionary benefits of the employee cannot be doubted since fraud unravels everything. But it is not the case of the State that the petitioner in the present case has received excess payment by practising fraud or making misrepresentation nor that the petitioner was conscious that he was receiving more than he was entitled to. Moreover, it is common knowledge that such declarations are signed by an employee under compelling circumstances with no real choice in the matter. As a Learned Judge observed in one case, the choice is like choosing between the devil and the deep sea. 
In the High Court of Calcutta
(Before Arijit Banerjee, J.)
WP 29979 (W) of 2016
Shiba Rani Maity
v.
The State of West Bengal

Decided on January 18, 2017
Citation: 2017 SCC OnLine Cal 109
Print Page

Thursday, 2 March 2017

Whether family pension can be bequeathed by will?

Thus, the payment of pension is strictly governed by the service
rules   and,   therefore,   it   cannot   be   an   'estate'   disposable   by   will.
Though the Government employee has right to receive the pension, it
cannot be treated as a 'property'.  On this point, I rely on the case of
Jodh Singh (supra).   In the said case, the officer bequeathed his
movable and immovable property to his father during his life time
and nominated his parents for the Provident Fund, as his relation
with his wife was not cordial.   The Hon'ble Supreme Court while
dealing with the issue held that the pension is a retirement benefit
and is not payable in the life time of the employee and what is not
payable during the life time of the deceased over which he has no
power of disposition and cannot form part of his estate.   It is the
event   of   his   death   that   provides   the   eligibility   qualification   for
claiming special family pension.
24. In the case of Sundariya Bai Choudhary (supra), the Division
Bench of Madhya Pradesh High Court has taken a similar view that
the pension of deceased cannot be said to be an estate and it is not
transferable   and   cannot   be   bequeathed   by   Will.     However,   other
pensionary   benefits   like   Provident   Fund,   Gratuity   etc.   and   other
retiral dues or extra renumeration would be estate of the deceased
and that can be bequeathed by him.

25. In the case of Violet (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court had an
opportunity to deal with Railway Family Pension Rules and held that
pension cannot be bequeathed by will since it is not a part of estate of
the employee but it is for monetary benefit of wife and children.
26. After going through the facts of the cases and law laid down
therein which are referred above, it is pertinent to note that in these
cases, husbands have disposed of the property by will to other family
members by denying the claim of the wife and, therefore, the Courts
have taken a view that wife has prime claim over the pension of the
husband and that cannot be denied.  In the present case, Jaydeo has
bequeathed his pension to his first wife only.  It is a settled position of
law that pension is not a estate and so it cannot be bequeathed by
will, so to that extent, i.e., the portion of bequeath of pension in
favour of Draupada is bad in law, however, the statements made in
the   will   about   the   status   of   Draupada   and   his   final   wish   that
Draupada alone has right over his pension corroborates a fact of valid
nomination of Draupada as a first wife.
27. Thus, it is held that pension is not a estate or property and
cannot be disposed of and to that extent, the portion in the will
regarding bequeath is against the law.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
FIRST APPEAL NO.577 OF 2015
WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO.1770 OF 2015
Draupada @ Draupadi Jaydeo Pawar
and Others 
vs.
Indubai d/o. Kashinath Shivram Chavan
and Another 
CORAM : MRS.MRIDULA BHATKAR, J.
 Dated  : 10th FEBRUARY, 2016
Citation: 2017(1) ALLMR197
Print Page

Sunday, 12 February 2017

Whether brother of government servant above 18 years can claim pensionary benefits?

The learned Standing Counsel appearing for the respondent would draw the attention of this Court to the counter affidavit and also invited the attention of this Court to the Rule 45(5) of the Tamil Nadu Pension Rules and would submit that as per the said sub-rule, the family in relation to the Government Servants means brothers below the age of 18 years including the step brothers and admittedly the petitioner, even at the time of nomination, has crossed that age and as such, he cannot be given pensionary benefits and prays for dismissal of the writ petition.
 As rightly pointed out by the learned Counsel appearing for the respondent, as per sub rule 5 of Rule 45 of the Tamil Nadu Pension Rules, the petitioner herein cannot be considered as a family member unless at the time of nomination he was below the age of 18 years and admittedly it was not so. Though it is the vehement submission of the learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner that in terms of Rule 48 of the Tamil Nadu Pension Rules, the petitioner falls under the category of specified nominee, in the considered opinion of this Court, the said stand lacks merits and substance for the reasons that the proviso should be read inconsonance with the main provision and it cannot fall on exception and in the light of the definition of family members as per Rule 45(5), Rule 48 should be read in consonance with Rule 45 and therefore, the petitioner herein cannot be construed as a family member, though he was nominated along with his brother-in-law Sundaramoorthy, who according to the petitioner is no more.
In the High Court of Madras at Madurai
(Before M. Sathyanarayanan and J. Nisha Banu, JJ.)
B. Senthil Kumar 
v.
The District and Sessions Judge, III Additional District Court, District Court Premises, Madurai-625 020 .

W.P.(MD) No. 5372 of 2013
And
M.P.(MD) No. 1 of 2013
Decided on November 14, 2016
Citation: 2016 SCC OnLine Mad 10391
Print Page

Saturday, 12 July 2014

Whether deemed wife can be granted pensionary benefits?

While deciding the question that in a scenario where the marriage is proved but held to be illegal, whether the wife can claim the benefits of family pension, the Court observed that a long cohabitation would draw the presumption of marriage and on that score the deemed wife would be entitled to receive the pension benefits as claimed for. 
The second appeal arose from the situation where after the demise of the husband, the petitioner via her counsel Mr M.P.Senthil claimed for the family pension as the nominee, but was refused by the appellate Court on the ground that her marriage to the deceased was illegal as there were no records of the dissolution of deceased’s first marriage. The respondent’s counsel Mr K.K.Senthilvelan argued that deceased’s first marriage did not dissolve in the court hence the petitioner’s marriage is illegal thus rendering her ineligible to claim family pension. The counsel for the petitioner presented documents ascertaining the existence of the marriage in question. 
The Court relying upon Andrahennedige Dinohamy v. Wijetunge Liyanapatabendige Balahamy, AIR 1927 PC 185 and Mohabbat Ali v. Khan Muhammad Ibrahim Khan, AIR 1929 PC 135, observed that the law presumes in favour of marriage and against concubinage when a man and a woman have cohabited continuously for a number of years. The Court also observed that the concept of marriage to constitute the relationship of husband and wife may require strict interpretation whereas the claims for civil rights, right to property etc., may follow a liberal approach, thus a financially dependent woman cannot be denied the benefits.
Therefore, heavy burden lies on the person, who seeks to prove that no marriage has taken place. The concept of marriage to constitute the relationship of husband and wife may require strict interpretation were claims for civil rights, right to property etc., may follow or flow and a liberal approach and different perception cannot be an anathema when the question of curbing the social evil is concerned. In RAMESH CHANDRA RAMPRATHAPJI DAGA Vs. RAMESHWARI RAMESH CHANDRA DAGA reported in AIR 2005 SC 422, wherein it is held that the Hindu Marriages continued to be bigamous in spite of the enactment of Hindu Marriage Act, 1995. No doubt, those marriages are illegal as per the provision of the Act, they are not immoral and hence a financially dependent woman cannot be denied the benefits on that ground.

Madras High Court
S. Muthulakshmi vs The Record Officer on 24 June, 2014



BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT
DATED: 24/6/2014
CORAM
 Mrs.JUSTICE PUSHPA SATHYANARAYANA
Second Appeal (MD) No.1068 of 2009
Print Page