Showing posts with label maharashtra civil services(pension) rules. Show all posts
Showing posts with label maharashtra civil services(pension) rules. Show all posts

Sunday, 29 September 2019

Bombay High court(FB) : Second wife not entitled to get pension

 The matter is placed before this Full Bench upon the directions of the Hon'ble the Chief Justice. The reference was made by the Division Bench of this Court referring the following issue to the full bench, "In cases to which, Maharashtra Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1982, apply whether the second wife is entitled to claim family pension?"

Kamalbai and Ors. vs. The State of Maharashtra and Ors. (31.01.2019 - BOMHC) : MANU/MH/0776/2019 The view taken by the Division Bench of this Court in a case of Chanda Hinglas Bharti Vs. State of Maharashtra (supra) and Ramabai Gulabrao Jamnik Vs. State of Maharashtra (supra) so also the view of the learned Single in a case of Indubai Jaydeo Pawar and another Vs. Draupada @ Draupadi Jaydeo Pawar and others (supra) appears to be correct view. 

 The Three Judges Bench of the Apex Court in a case of Raj Kumari and another Vs. Krishna and others reported in MANU/SC/0397/2015 : (2015) 14 SCC 511 has also observed that normally pension is given to the legally wedded wife of a deceased employee. Same view is taken by the Apex Court in a case of Rameshwari Devi Vs. State of Bihar (supra) and it is held that the second wife is not entitled for family pension.

26. In view of the aforesaid discussion, we answer the reference as under:

"In cases to which Maharashtra Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1982 apply, the family pension can be claimed by a widow, who was legally wedded wife of the deceased employee. Second wife, if not a legally wedded wife would not be entitled for family pension and if the second wife is legally wedded wife, then should be entitled for the family pension."

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)

Writ Petition Nos. 9933, 11256 and 12308 of 2016

Decided On: 31.01.2019

 Kamalbai  Vs.  The State of Maharashtra and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
S.V. Gangapurwala, R.V. Ghuge and S.M. Gavhane, JJ.
Citation: 2019(3) MHLJ 921



Print Page

Saturday, 31 August 2019

Whether second wife is entitled to get family pension?

That from the aforesaid discussion, I hold and conclude:

(i) marriages covered by Section 11 of the Hindu Marriage Act are void i.e. void from inception and have to be ignored as not existing in law at all when such a question arises.

(ii) a woman performing the marriage with a Hindu Government servant during the lifetime of his wife cannot be said to be his "widow".

(iii) definition of "Family" under sub-rule 16 of Rule 116 of the Maharashtra Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1982 includes only wife and a judicially separated wife with a rider that judicial separation is not granted on the ground of adultery.

(iv) expression "Family pension is payable to more widows than one" in terms of sub-rule (6) clause (a) of Rule 116 of the Maharashtra Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1982 cannot be read in isolation but has to be read and understood in context of definition of "Family" defined under Rule 116(16) (b) of the Maharashtra civil Services Pension Rules, 1982, in as much as, pension is payable to the "Family of deceased",

(emphasis supplied).

Thus, taking into consideration the provisions of the scheme of "Family pension" under Rule 116 and the definition of "Family", I hold that a Hindu woman who marries a Hindu man during the subsistence of his first marriage is excluded from the scheme of Rule 116 of the Maharashtra Civil Services Pension Rules and thus not entitled to the family pension. I therefore answer Question no. 1 in negative.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Second Appeal No. 463 of 2014 and Civil Application No. 1067 of 2014

Decided On: 28.02.2019

 Kamal Mahaling Patil Vs.  Indubai Mahaling Patil and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Sandeep K. Shinde, J.

Citation: 2019(4) MHLJ 594
Print Page

Sunday, 16 June 2019

Whether departmental enquiry can be continued against Judicial officer even after retirement?



 A conjoint reading of the aforesaid subrules
of Rule 27
indicates that the appointing authority is invested with the
power to withhold or withdraw the pension, if in any
departmental or judicial proceedings, the pensioner is found
guilty of grave misconduct or negligence during the period of his
service. Good conduct of the pensioner is an implied condition
for the receipt of pension and if subsequently the pensioner is

found guilty of misconduct or negligence in relation to the acts
or omissions during the services rendered by the pensioner, the
pension can be withheld or withdrawn. The retirement of an
employee does not, therefore, completely preclude the
appointing authority from initiating action for dealing with the
misconduct of the employee during currency of the service.
The retirement does not confer complete immunity from the
action for the misconduct during period of employment. The
nature of the action is, however, restricted to withdrawal or
withholding of pension.
19. Clause (a) of Subrule
(2) in express terms provides that
the departmental proceedings referred to in subRule
(1), if
instituted while the Government servant was in service whether
before his retirement or during his reemployment,
shall, after
the final retirement of the Government servant, be deemed to be
proceedings under this rule and shall be continued by the
authority in the same manner as if the Government servant had
continued in service. The initiation or continuation of the
disciplinary proceedings, against a retired employee is, however,
subject to certain safeguards to protect the interest of the
employee. Clause (b) of subrule
(2) stipulates conditions for
continuation of the disciplinary proceedings if not instituted
while the Government servant was in service. Subrule
(3)

provides a timelimit
of four years so that the pensioner is not
under a threat of action for eternity. In all the cases, where the
departmental enquiry is instituted either before or after
retirement, subrule
(4) mandates sanction of provisional
pension as provided in Rule 130.
20. If we consider the fascicles of the provisions in Rule 27 of
the Pension Rules, 1982, it becomes evident that the rules do
envisage initiation of the disciplinary action even after
retirement of a Government servant, on superannuation or
otherwise, in addition to the continuation of the disciplinary
proceedings, which was instituted before the retirement of the
Government servant. The broad submission canvassed on
behalf of the Petitioner that after retirement of a Government
servant no disciplinary proceedings can be instituted/continued
runs counter to the express mandate of clause (a) of subrule
(2) of Section 27, extracted above, which incorporates a deeming
provision and, by a legal fiction, mandates that the disciplinary
proceedings instituted before the retirement shall be deemed to
be a proceedings under Rule 27 and continued and concluded
in the same manner as if the Government servant had
continued in service. The broad submission therefore cannot be
countenanced.

21. The legal position as regards the institution /
continuation of disciplinary proceedings after the retirement of
an employee, seems to have been crystallised to the effect that
the employer can institute/continue the disciplinary
proceedings against an employee who has retired, provided the
rules which govern the services of the employee permit such a
course of action.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO. 2820 OF 2019

 Mrs. Padmini Nandakumar Nair  Vs The Honourable High Court of Judicature at Bombay, through its
Registrar General, Mumbai

CORAM: R. M. BORDE & N. J. JAMADAR, JJ

PRONOUNCED ON; 14th JUNE, 2019

(Per N. J. JAMADAR, J.)
Print Page

Sunday, 16 December 2018

Whether government servant is entitled to get interest if payment of gratuity is delayed beyond his retirement?

 As has been held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Y.K. Singla (supra), consequent upon the acquittal of an employee, it would be erroneous to conclude that the gratuity payable to such employee on attaining the age of superannuation was withheld on account of some fault of the employee himself. In the present case, it is not as if the petitioner, was ultimately convicted in criminal prosecution launched against him, in which case, the petitioner, could have been held to be at fault. Therefore, applying the principle explained by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Y.K. Singla (supra), we hold that the delay in payment of gratuity to the petitioner beyond three months from the date of retirement was for no fault of the petitioner. In terms of Rule 129A of the MCS (Pension) Rules, 1982, read with clause 3 of the GR dated 6th May 1991 therefore, the petitioner is entitled to be paid interest for the period of delay beyond three months from the date of first retirement i.e. with effect from 1st July 1997.

35. In Prabhakar Dalal (supra), the Division Bench of this Court, in the context of Rules 129A, 130 (1)(c) of the MCS (Pension) Rules, 1982 and GR dated 23rd June 1986 has held that paragraph 3 of the GR will have to be construed to mean that on a person against whom disciplinary or judicial proceedings were pending, if he is discharged or the disciplinary authority comes to the conclusion that no punishment needs to be imposed and in case of judicial authority, such authority acquits such person, than in those cases, on the competent authority authorising the release of gratuity, it will be presumed that the gratuity is deemed to have been fallen due on the date immediately following the date of retirement for the purpose of interest. The Division Bench has commended harmonious construction of the statutory rules and the executive instructions in the GR, so that executive instructions would not fall foul of the rules.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Writ Petition No. 12966 of 2017

Decided On: 03.04.2018

 Vinodkumar Narayan Dixit Vs. The State of Maharashtra

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
V.K. Tahilramani, Actg. C.J. and M.S. Sonak, J.

Citation: 2018(6) MHLJ 696
Print Page

Sunday, 11 November 2018

Whether widower is entitled to get family pension if he has remarried?

As per Rule 116(5)(i) of the Pension Rules, in the case of a widower, the family pension is payable upto the date of his death or remarriage, whichever is earlier. The meaning of the word 'widower' as stated in Black's Law Dictionary, 9th Edition is "a man, whose wife has died and who has not remarried". It is true that the petitioner has not got remarried after the death of Sunanda, but indisputably, in view of his second marriage with some other woman during the life time of Sunanda, may be with the consent of Sunanda, he would not assume the status of 'widower', who has not performed marriage. He certainly continues to be the husband of the woman with whom he has performed second marriage. It would be rather a hyper-technical an approach to say that the petitioner, who has already performed a second marriage/remarriage, should not be called as a person "remarried" for the purpose of getting family pension, only because the said remarriage was not after the demise of his wife Sunanda. The intention underlying Rule 116(5)(i) of the Pension Rules is not to extend the benefit of family pension to a person, who is enjoying a marital life with some other woman than the deceased Government servant.

7. As stated above, the case of the petitioner certainly would not fall under Rule 116(5)(i) of the Pension Rules since he is enjoying the marital life even after the death of Sunanda. The petitioner would not be entitled to get family pension, claiming himself to be the widower of the deceased Sunanda, since he has remarried.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)

Writ Petition No. 6117 of 2007

Decided On: 13.11.2017

 Deelip  Vs. Government of Maharashtra and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
S.P. Deshmukh and Sangitrao S. Patil, JJ.
Citation: 2018(5) MHLJ 129
Print Page

Thursday, 2 March 2017

Whether family pension can be bequeathed by will?

Thus, the payment of pension is strictly governed by the service
rules   and,   therefore,   it   cannot   be   an   'estate'   disposable   by   will.
Though the Government employee has right to receive the pension, it
cannot be treated as a 'property'.  On this point, I rely on the case of
Jodh Singh (supra).   In the said case, the officer bequeathed his
movable and immovable property to his father during his life time
and nominated his parents for the Provident Fund, as his relation
with his wife was not cordial.   The Hon'ble Supreme Court while
dealing with the issue held that the pension is a retirement benefit
and is not payable in the life time of the employee and what is not
payable during the life time of the deceased over which he has no
power of disposition and cannot form part of his estate.   It is the
event   of   his   death   that   provides   the   eligibility   qualification   for
claiming special family pension.
24. In the case of Sundariya Bai Choudhary (supra), the Division
Bench of Madhya Pradesh High Court has taken a similar view that
the pension of deceased cannot be said to be an estate and it is not
transferable   and   cannot   be   bequeathed   by   Will.     However,   other
pensionary   benefits   like   Provident   Fund,   Gratuity   etc.   and   other
retiral dues or extra renumeration would be estate of the deceased
and that can be bequeathed by him.

25. In the case of Violet (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court had an
opportunity to deal with Railway Family Pension Rules and held that
pension cannot be bequeathed by will since it is not a part of estate of
the employee but it is for monetary benefit of wife and children.
26. After going through the facts of the cases and law laid down
therein which are referred above, it is pertinent to note that in these
cases, husbands have disposed of the property by will to other family
members by denying the claim of the wife and, therefore, the Courts
have taken a view that wife has prime claim over the pension of the
husband and that cannot be denied.  In the present case, Jaydeo has
bequeathed his pension to his first wife only.  It is a settled position of
law that pension is not a estate and so it cannot be bequeathed by
will, so to that extent, i.e., the portion of bequeath of pension in
favour of Draupada is bad in law, however, the statements made in
the   will   about   the   status   of   Draupada   and   his   final   wish   that
Draupada alone has right over his pension corroborates a fact of valid
nomination of Draupada as a first wife.
27. Thus, it is held that pension is not a estate or property and
cannot be disposed of and to that extent, the portion in the will
regarding bequeath is against the law.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
FIRST APPEAL NO.577 OF 2015
WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO.1770 OF 2015
Draupada @ Draupadi Jaydeo Pawar
and Others 
vs.
Indubai d/o. Kashinath Shivram Chavan
and Another 
CORAM : MRS.MRIDULA BHATKAR, J.
 Dated  : 10th FEBRUARY, 2016
Citation: 2017(1) ALLMR197
Print Page