Showing posts with label recruitment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label recruitment. Show all posts

Tuesday, 17 December 2019

Supreme Court: Candidate Not Estopped From Challenging Selection Process if there is misconstruction of statutory rules

The maintainability of

the very challenge by the appellant has been questioned on the ground
that she having partaken in the selection process cannot later challenge it
due to mere failure in selection. The counsel for respondents relied upon a
catena of decisions of this Court to substantiate his objection.
17. It is well settled that the principle of estoppel prevents a candidate
from challenging the selection process after having failed in it as iterated
by this Court in a plethora of judgements including Manish Kumar
Shahi v. State of Bihar (2010) 12 SCC 576, observing as follows:
“16. We also agree with the High Court that after having taken part
in the process of selection knowing fully well that more than 19%
marks have been earmarked for viva voce test, the appellant is not
entitled to challenge the criteria or process of selection. Surely, if the
appellant's name had appeared in the merit list, he would not have
even dreamed of challenging the selection. The appellant invoked
jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India only after he found that his name does not figure in the merit
list prepared by the Commission. This conduct of the appellant
clearly disentitles him from questioning the selection and the High
Court did not commit any error by refusing to entertain the writ
petition.” See also: Madan Lal v. State of J&K [(1995) 3 SCC], Marripati Nagaraja v. State of A.P.[(2007) 11
SCC 522], Dhananjay Malik v. State of Uttaranchal [(2008) 4 SCC 171] and K.A.
Nagamani v. Indian Airlines [(2009) 5 SCC 515]
The underlying objective of this principle is to prevent candidates from
trying another shot at consideration, and to avoid an impasse wherein
every disgruntled candidate, having failed the selection, challenges it in the  hope of getting a second chance.
18. However, we must differentiate from this principle insofar as the
candidate by agreeing to participate in the selection process only accepts
the prescribed procedure and not the illegality in it. In a situation where a
candidate alleges misconstruction of statutory rules and discriminating
consequences arising therefrom, the same cannot be condoned merely
because a candidate has partaken in it. The constitutional scheme is
sacrosanct and its violation in any manner is impermissible.

REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO.9482 OF 2019

Dr. (Major) Meeta Sahai  Vs  State of Bihar 

Author:
SURYA KANT, J.
Print Page

Monday, 27 May 2019

Whether pension of district Judge can be withheld if there is misconduct in recruitment process of class 3 and class 4 employees?

In view of the above, the action of the High Court in recommending
withholding of 50% pension of the petitioner and in exonerating all the
other five officers is nothing but discrimination between equals who fall
under the same class, for no recorded reasons and as such the punishment
imposed upon the petitioner by the Hon'ble Governor is not tenable in law.
This apart, as already discussed, the aforesaid punishment was
inflicted upon the petitioner finding him guilty of misconduct in conducting
the recruitment of class-III and class-IV employees. Thus, the punishment
was on the cumulative effect of the misconduct in respect of both the
recruitments and if one of them is deleted, it would certainly not have the
same impact so as to impose a punishment which had been inflicted upon
the petitioner. In respect of the recruitment of class-IV employees, the
inquiry has been held to be without jurisdiction as it was barred by time and
was without the proper sanction of the Hon'ble Governor. Accordingly, the
gravity of the misconduct stands reduced and in that respect of the matter,
the punishment ex-facie turns out to be excessive and disproportionate to
the charge proved.
In the overall facts and circumstances of the case, our considered
conclusion is that the order of punishment dated 07.11.2012 withholding
50% of the pension of the petitioner is unsustainable and deserves to be
quashed.
It is accordingly quashed and the writ of certiorari to that effect is
directed to be issued.

ALLAHABAD HIGH COURT
Delivered on 22.05.2019

Case :- WRIT - A No. - 19813 of 2013

Petitioner :- Shyam Babu Vaish
Respondent :- State Of U.P.And Anr.

Coram:
Hon'ble Pankaj Mithal,J.
Hon'ble Prakash Padia,J.
Print Page

Friday, 14 August 2015

Whether selection of candidate is vitiated on the ground that all candidate's were called for interview?

 Furthermore, we find that there is no rule of law as to
the ratio of number of vacancies to the number of
candidates for being called for interview; although it may
be a rule of prudence. This Court has found in Mohinder
Sain Garg Vs. State of Punjab and Ors., (1991) 1 SCC 662,
as also in Ashok Kumar Yadav Vs. State of Haryana, (1985) 4
SCC 417, that although it may be improper for the Selection
Committee to call such large number of candidates for
interview, but selection cannot be vitiated merely on this
ground if such an action is not tainted by mala fide or
oblique motive. In Mohinder Sain Garg (supra), this Court
gave one more reason not to accept this argument which
squarely applies to this case as well; this Court found
that the Respondents stood no chance of being called for
interview if candidates upto three times the number of
posts were called for interview. In the case on hand, on
this score, learned counsel for the State of Uttar Pradesh
has made a similar contention. Even the appellants herein
have not presented a case that had they been called for
interview, being only four times the number of vacancies,
they would have been short listed in that list. Thus, we
find this argument as a misplaced one.

REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO.6549 OF 2014
HC Pradeep Kumar Rai and Ors. ...Appellant(s)
:Versus:
Dinesh Kumar Pandey and Ors. ...Respondent(s)
Citation;AIR 2015 SC2342
Print Page

Monday, 26 May 2014

Whether rules of recruitment can be relaxed by govt?


 A Division Bench of this Court (in which I was also a member) in Dr. Rajeev Ranjan Mishra and others v. State of U.P. and others,MANU/UP/1506/2007 : 2008(1) AWC 810, referring to some of above authorities, has said:
The distinction between rule of "recruitment" and "condition of service" is no more res integra having already been settled by the Apex Court in a catena of cases. In State of M.P. v. Shardul Singh, MANU/SC/0510/1969 : 1970(1) SCC 108, the Apex Court held that the term "conditions of service" means all those conditions which regulate the holding of a post by a person right from the time of his appointment till retirement and even pension etc. It was reiterated in I.N. Subbareddy v. State of A.P., 1997(1) SCC 554. In Syed Khalid Rizvi v. Union of India, MANU/SC/0682/1992 : 1993 Supp (3) SCC 575, the Apex Court held where a rule permits relaxation of provisions pertaining to "conditions of service", the same would be applicable to the condition after appointment to the service in accordance with rules. It also held that that "conditions of recruitment" and "conditions of service" are distinct and the latter is preceded by an appointment according to rules, the former cannot be relaxed.
Part 3, 4 and 5 contain rules of recruitment which includes rules pertaining to reservation, eligibility and other qualifications with respect to nationality, educational qualifications, age, character, marital status, physical Fitness etc. and procedure for recruitment. The rules pertaining to Recruitment' cannot be relaxed by exercising power under Rule 26 since such rules are not relaxable.
Citation: 2013(11)ADJ534, (2014)1UPLBEC224
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ALLAHABAD
Civil Misc. Writ Petition Nos. 1689, 2051, 2856, 3309 and 6801 of 2011
Decided On: 12.09.2013
Appellants: Raj Kumar Pandey and Others
Vs.
Respondent: State of U.P. and Others


Sudhir Agarwal, J.
Print Page