Showing posts with label pension. Show all posts
Showing posts with label pension. Show all posts

Sunday, 3 September 2023

Whether government servant who retired before commencement of GR can take benefit of said GR for claiming higher pension?

It also cannot be disputed that the amendment

in the rules as made vide notification dated 12.6.2018 was

to come into force from the date of its publication in the

Rajpatra of Himachal Pradesh. {Para 7}

8. The question thus arises whether the petitioner

who had retired on 31.8.2017 would be entitled to the

benefit of notification dated 12.6.2018?

9. In my considered view the question deserves to

be answered in affirmative for the reason that pension is

earned by a government servant in lieu of the services

rendered by him. It is the security for which he serves the

public besides what he earns by way of monthly

emoluments during service. The rules prescribing the

norms for disbursement of the amount of pension have to

be considered in that perspective. Since it is a beneficial

provision for the government servant, therefore, any

narrow construction will render the purpose of granting the

same otiose.

10. Since, the notification dated 12.6.2018 was for

the benefit of an entire class i.e. class III and IV employees

of the State Government it could not be construed to

benefit only those who would retire after the issuance of

the notification for such a classification will clearly be

discriminatory. The pension is a recurring benefit to a

retired government servant, therefore, the notification

dated 12.6.2018 promulgating a beneficial rule will also

enure for benefit of petitioner, who still was entitled to

pension on the date of such promulgation.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA

CWPOA No. 7658 of 2020

Veena Devi  Vs State of H.P. &others 

Coram:

The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Satyen Vaidya, Judge.

Decided on : 28.8.2023.

Print Page

Sunday, 29 January 2023

Kerala HC: Special Pay of Judicial Officer is Part Of Pay, Should Be Reckoned To Calculate Pension

 The learned counsel appearing for the petitioners

contends that the action of the respondents in issuing

Government Orders which are completely at variance with the

directions contained in the judgment of this Court amounts to

an open challenge to the orders and authority of this Court and

that the said directions are completely illegal and violative of

the directions of this Court. {Para 14}

15. I have considered the contentions advanced. This

Court in the earlier round of litigation had specifically

considered the nature of the special pay granted to judicial

officers pursuant to the directions of the Shetty Commission.

It was found that special pay would come within the definition

of pay under Rule 12(23). Special Pay is a benefit which is

granted to officers posted in specific posts having

administrative responsibilities for the extra work which is done

by them. The argument that grant of special pay to some

officers will lead to a junior-senior anomaly had been agitated

in the earlier litigation also but did not find favour with this

Court. The argument cannot be sustained for a moment in

view of the fact that the principles on which a difference in pay

between a senior and junior is to be considered to be an

anomaly are provided in the very same Rule itself. Grant of

special pay for administrative duties would not, by any stretch

of imagination, result in any junior-senior anomaly since it is a

special emolument given for extra work done.

16.  We hope and trust that the appellants would put a

quietus to this issue, so that, objections of this nature are not

unnecessarily raised as against the judicial officers concerned.”

The impugned orders passed by the Government,

without considering the declaration of law by this Court, are

completely unsustainable. The contention of the respondents

that special pay cannot be reckoned for the purpose of fixation

of pension is without any merit whatsoever. The said

contentions are repelled. The orders and letters impugned in

these writ petitions are, therefore, set aside. It is declared that

the special pay granted to judicial officers is a part of their pay

and that it is to be reckoned for the purpose of calculation of

pension. The respondents shall take appropriate steps to see

that the pension of the judicial officers who drew special pay at

the time of their retirement is revised and the arrears are

disbursed to them forthwith, at any rate, within three months

from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

WP(C) NO.694 OF 2022

 CHERIAN VARGHESE Vs STATE OF KERALA,

PRESENT

 MRS. JUSTICE ANU SIVARAMAN

Dated:  18TH DAY OF JANUARY 2023 

Print Page

Sunday, 19 December 2021

Whether government can refuse to grant disability pension to employee if he has waived his right to claim disability pension?

 As held by this Court, a Right to Equality guaranteed

under Article 14 of the Constitution of India would also apply

to a man who has no choice or rather no meaningful choice,

but to give his assent to a contract or to sign on the dotted

line in a prescribed or standard form or to accept a set of

rules as part of the contract, however unfair, unreasonable

and unconscionable a clause in that contract or form or rules

may be. We find that the said observations rightly apply to

the facts of the present case. Can it be said that the mighty

Union of India and an ordinary soldier, who having fought for

the country and retired from Regular Army, seeking reemployment

in the Territorial Army, have an equal

bargaining power. We are therefore of the considered view

that the reliance placed on the said document would also be

of no assistance to the case of the respondents.

25. The respondents herein are directed to grant disability

pension to the appellant in accordance with the rules and

regulations as are applicable to the Members of the

Territorial Army with effect from 1st January 2012. The

respondents are directed to clear arrears from 1st January

2012 within a period of three months from the date of this

judgment with interest at the rate of 9% per annum. {Para 23}

 REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 2275 OF 2019

PANI RAM  Vs  UNION OF INDIA 

Author: B.R. GAVAI, J.

Dated: DECEMBER 17, 2021.

Print Page

Tuesday, 7 December 2021

Supreme Court: Pension payable to an employee on retirement shall be determined on the rules existing at the time of retirement

  While we accept the settled position of law that

the rule applicable in matters of determination of

pension is that which exists at the time of

retirement, we are unable to find any legal basis in

the action of the respondent University of

selectively allowing the benefit of Rule 25 (a). The

law, as recognized by this Court in Deoki Nandan

Prasad and Syed Yousuddin Ahmed (supra) unequivocally

states that the pension payable to an employee on

retirement shall be determined on the rules existing

at the time of retirement. However, the law does not

allow the employer to apply the rules differently in

relation to persons who are similarly situated. {Para 32}

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO.6994/2021

DR. G. SADASIVAN NAIR Vs COCHIN UNIVERSITY OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY 

Author: NAGARATHNA J.

Dated: 1st December, 2021.

Print Page

Sunday, 28 February 2021

Whether the state is liable to pay interest to government servant for delayed payment of salaries and pension?

The direction for the payment of the deferred portions of the salaries and pensions is unexceptionable. Salaries are due to the employees of the State for services rendered. Salaries in other words constitute the rightful entitlement of the employees and are payable in accordance with law.

Likewise, it is well settled that the payment of pension is for years of past service rendered by the pensioners to the State. Pensions are hence a matter of a rightful entitlement recognised by the applicable rules and regulations which govern the service of the employees of the State. The State

Government has complied with the directions of this Court for the payment

of the outstanding dues in two tranches. Insofar as the interest is concerned,

we are of the view that the rate of 12% per annum which has been fixed by

the High Court should be suitably scaled down. While learned counsel for the

respondents submits that the award of interest was on account of the action

of the Government which was contrary to law, we are of the view that the

payment of interest cannot be used as a means to penalize the State

Government. There can be no gainsaying the fact that the Government which has delayed the payment of salaries and pensions should be directed to pay interest at an appropriate rate.

Reportable

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

Civil Appeal No 399 of 2021


The State of Andhra Pradesh Vs Smt Dinavahi Lakshmi Kameswari 

Dated: February 8, 2021

Print Page

Saturday, 27 February 2021

Whether a party can rely on customary divorce in the absence of a declaration of validity of said divorce by the civil court?

 In the utter absence of any evidence, let alone conclusive, that the divorce decree executed purportedly between respondent no.11 and her deceased husband was endorsed by any valid custom, the exception envisaged in Section 29(2) of the 1955 Hindu Marriage Act would not be attracted. Thus, the spouses had to revert back to Section 13 of the Act, which sanctions dissolution of marriage only by a decree of divorce, for the dissolution of marriage to be valid in the eye of law.


25. Such facts, coupled with the fact that pension was granted earlier in

favour of respondent no.11 upon a valid sanction being issued by the

respondent-authorities, it would be unjust to deprive respondent

no.11 from such pension at the behest of the petitioner, merely on the

basis of the petitioner’s assertion on oath in this writ petition that a

deed of divorce, supported by valid and recognized customs, was

executed between respondent no.11 and her deceased husband.

 In the High Court at Calcutta

Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction

Appellate Side

WPA No. 2346 of 2018

Smt. Krishna Veni Vs. The Union of India and others


Judgment on : 18.02.2021

Coram: The Hon’ble Justice Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya

Print Page

Friday, 20 November 2020

Supreme court: Retired employee can file a petition regarding stoppage of his pension at the place where he is residing and getting pension

 As noted above, the learned single Judge has also observed that Petitioner ought to have filed the writ petition in Jharkhand High Court where his earlier writ petition was pending. The earlier writ petition which was initially filed in 2006 in Patna High Court was for refund of the amount as noted above. After dismissal of the writ petition by Patna High Court on the ground of lack of territorial jurisdiction, Shri B.N. Mishra had filed a Writ Petition No. 4930 of 2013 in Jharkhand High Court for the relief which was claimed in Writ Petition No. 13955 of 2006. As noted above, the cause of action for filing the Writ Petition No. 5999 of 2014 was entirely different. Stoppage of pension and asking for refund of more than Rs. 08 lakhs amount had serious adverse effect on the Petitioner, who was staying at his native place Darbhanga. A retired employee, who is receiving pension, cannot be asked to go to another court to file the writ petition, when he has a cause of action for filing a writ petition in Patna High Court. For a retired employee convenience is to prosecute his case at the place where he belonged to and was getting pension. The submission of the learned Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 1 to 3 on principle of forum non conveniens has no substance.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 3630 of 2020 

Decided On: 05.11.2020


 Shanti Devi Vs. Union of India (UOI) and Ors.


Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Ashok Bhushan, R. Subhash Reddy and M.R. Shah, JJ.

Citation: MANU/SC/0842/2020
Print Page

Friday, 26 June 2020

Whether government servant or judicial officer can be denied pension if judicial proceeding is pending against him?

The petitioner retired on 31.12.2007 as District Judge. At the time of retirement no disciplinary action was pending against him On 5.2.2008, subsequent to his retirement a First Information Report was lodged at Police Station Kavi Nagar, Ghaziabad under Sections 409, 420, 467, 468, 471, 477-A, 120-B IPC and Section 13(1) and 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act which was registered at Case Crime No. 152 of 2008. In view of the aforesaid criminal case only 90% of his gratuity amounting to Rs. 3.15 lacs out of total Rs. 3.5 lacs was released in his favour on 6.1.2012 on completion of necessary formalities.
2. The Government Order dated 4th November, 2010, issued on the basis of the Justice E. Padmanabhan Committee report dated 17.7.2009 which was accepted by the Supreme Court vide its orders dated 19.7.2010, 29.7.2010 and 2.8.2010 the State Government provided that all judicial officers retiring on 1.1.2006 or thereafter would be entitle to gratuity/death cum retirement gratuity of Rs. 10 lacs.


3. The petitioner had retired on 31.12.2007 and, as such, became entitled to gratuity of Rs. 10 lacs as per the aforesaid Government Order in place of Rs. 3.50 lacs.


8. It is settled in law that payment of post retirement dues including gratuity are not bounty and that they cannot be withheld unless the rules provide for it. In other words, in the absence of any rules permitting withholding of post retiral dues including gratuity, the Government cannot withhold the same.

9. Learned counsel for the respondent Nos. 1 and 2 is unable to place before us any rule or statutory provision permitting withholding of post retiral dues due to pendency of a criminal case.

10. Civil Services Regulations vide Regulation 919-A(3) provides that no death-cum-retirement gratuity shall be paid to the Government servant until the conclusion of the departmental proceedings or the enquiry by the Administrative Tribunal and issue of final orders thereon.

12. A simple reading of the aforesaid provision reveals that the bar on payment of death-cum-retirement gratuity is until the conclusion of the departmental proceedings or the enquiry by the Administrative Tribunal. This bar is not applicable where a criminal case is pending as it is not a departmental proceeding or an enquiry by the Administrative Tribunal.

13. In the case at hand, there is no departmental proceedings or any enquiry by the Administrative Tribunal pending against the petitioner. The petitioner is only facing criminal proceedings and there is certainly no provision which puts a rider on the payment of death-cum-gratuity to a Government servant or a judicial officer merely for the reason that criminal proceedings are pending against him.

14. A Division Bench of this Court in State of U.P. and three others v. Faini Singh (Special Appeal No. 416 of 2014 decided on 25.4.2014) while considering the provisions of Regulation 919-A(3) of Civil Services Regulations observed that the power of withholding or withdrawing pension is to be used in cases where allegations are of serious nature or grave misconduct and of causing pecuniary loss and it cannot be exercised mechanically merely on the pendency of any judicial proceedings without considering the allegations against the retired Government servant. In other words, pendency of even judicial proceedings has not been recognized as a matter of right to withhold the pension.


15. In Bangali Bahu Misra v. State of U.P., MANU/UP/1042/2002 : 2003(3) AWC 1760, a Division Bench of this Court seized of a similar controversy held that in the absence of any provision under law even if the petitioner is subjected to punishment in criminal proceedings that would not be a ground for withholding the post retiral benefits admissible to him.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF ALLAHABAD

Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 937 of 2013

Decided On: 23.10.2017

 Radhey Shyam Chaubey  Vs.  High Court of Judicature and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Pankaj Mithal and Irshad Ali, JJ.

Citation: 2018 (3) AWC 2521.
Print Page

Sunday, 14 June 2020

Whether Judicial officer is entitled to get medical reimbursement in respect of the medical treatment of his parents if they are getting a pension?

Service - Medical Reimbursement - Family member - Rule 2(3)(Seven) of Maharashtra Civil Services (Medical Attendance) Rules, 1961 - Respondent refused to medical Reimbursement of expenses spend by Petitioner, on treatment of his mother - Hence present petition - Whether petitioner entitled to medical reimbursement - Held, according to Rule 2 (3)(Seven) of Rules, father and mother of Government employee who received pension more than Rs. 3500/- per month would not be considered wholly dependent - In present case, mother of Petitioner was getting pension more than amount specified in above clause - But following ratio of State of M.P. & others v. M.P. Ojha & Anr and Nand Rani, Principal Govt. Sr. v. The State of Punjab & Ors., observed that expression "wholly dependent" could not be confined to mere financial dependence - Therefore, Petitioner's mother being 85 years old, and both, physically and financially dependent on him, was wholly inadequate to meet her medical expenses - Hence, Petitioner entitled medical reimbursement - Petition allowed.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Writ Petition No. 8899 of 2012

Decided On: 03.04.2013

Anil Dattatraya Kulkarni Vs.   State of Maharashtra

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
V.M. Kanade and F.M. Reis, JJ.

Citation;2013(5)ABR717, 2013(6)ALLMR804, 2013LabIC3612

Print Page

Monday, 24 February 2020

Right to receive pension is right to property - Cannot be taken away by executive fiat of administrative instructions.

 From the discussion three things emerge: (i) that pension is neither a bounty nor a matter of grace depending upon the sweet will of the employer and that it creates a vested right subject to 1972 Rules which are statutory in character because they are enacted in exercise of powers conferred by the proviso to Article 309 and clause (5) of Article 148 of the Constitution; (ii) that the pension is not an ex gratia payment but it is a payment for the past service rendered; and (iii) it is a social welfare measure rendering socio-economic justice to those who in the hey-day of their life ceaselessly toiled for the employer on an assurance that in their old age they would not be left in lurch..”
[emphasis supplied]
13.6 The right to receive pension has been held to be a right to property protected under Article 300A of the Constitution even after the repeal of Article 31(1) by the Constitution (Forty-Fourth Amendment) Act, 1978 w.e.f. 20.06.1979, as held in State of West Bengal v. Haresh C. Banerjee and Ors.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
Civil Appeal No.1677-1678 of 2020

DR. HIRA LAL Vs  STATE OF BIHAR 

INDU MALHOTRA, J.
Dated:February 18, 2020.
Print Page

Sunday, 29 September 2019

Bombay High court(FB) : Second wife not entitled to get pension

 The matter is placed before this Full Bench upon the directions of the Hon'ble the Chief Justice. The reference was made by the Division Bench of this Court referring the following issue to the full bench, "In cases to which, Maharashtra Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1982, apply whether the second wife is entitled to claim family pension?"

Kamalbai and Ors. vs. The State of Maharashtra and Ors. (31.01.2019 - BOMHC) : MANU/MH/0776/2019 The view taken by the Division Bench of this Court in a case of Chanda Hinglas Bharti Vs. State of Maharashtra (supra) and Ramabai Gulabrao Jamnik Vs. State of Maharashtra (supra) so also the view of the learned Single in a case of Indubai Jaydeo Pawar and another Vs. Draupada @ Draupadi Jaydeo Pawar and others (supra) appears to be correct view. 

 The Three Judges Bench of the Apex Court in a case of Raj Kumari and another Vs. Krishna and others reported in MANU/SC/0397/2015 : (2015) 14 SCC 511 has also observed that normally pension is given to the legally wedded wife of a deceased employee. Same view is taken by the Apex Court in a case of Rameshwari Devi Vs. State of Bihar (supra) and it is held that the second wife is not entitled for family pension.

26. In view of the aforesaid discussion, we answer the reference as under:

"In cases to which Maharashtra Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1982 apply, the family pension can be claimed by a widow, who was legally wedded wife of the deceased employee. Second wife, if not a legally wedded wife would not be entitled for family pension and if the second wife is legally wedded wife, then should be entitled for the family pension."

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)

Writ Petition Nos. 9933, 11256 and 12308 of 2016

Decided On: 31.01.2019

 Kamalbai  Vs.  The State of Maharashtra and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
S.V. Gangapurwala, R.V. Ghuge and S.M. Gavhane, JJ.
Citation: 2019(3) MHLJ 921



Print Page

Friday, 12 July 2019

Whether Classification Of Pensioners By Providing Cut-Off Date For The Purpose Of Grant Of Revised Pension is constitutional?

Even otherwise on merits also, we are of the firm opinion
that there is no valid justification to create two classes, viz., one
who retired pre1996
and another who retired post1996,
for the
purpose of grant of revised pension, In our view, such a
classification has no nexus with the object and purpose of grant

of benefit of revised pension. All the pensioners form a one class
who are entitled to pension as per the pension rules. Article 14 of
the Constitution of India ensures to all equality before law and
equal protection of laws. At this juncture it is also necessary to
examine the concept of valid classification. A valid classification
is truly a valid discrimination. It is true that Article 16 of the
Constitution of India permits a valid classification. However, a
very classification must be based on a just objective. The result
to be achieved by the just objective presupposes the choice of
some for differential consideration/treatment over others. A
classification to be valid must necessarily satisfy two tests.
Firstly, the distinguishing rationale has to be based on a just
objective and secondly, the choice of differentiating one set of
persons from another, must have a reasonable nexus to the
objective sought to be achieved. The test for a valid classification
may be summarised as a distinction based on a classification
founded on an intelligible differentia, which has a rational
relationship with the object sought to be achieved. Therefore,
whenever a cutoff
date (as in the present controversy) is fixed to
categorise one set of pensioners for favourable consideration over
others, the twin test for valid classification or valid discrimination

therefore must necessarily be satisfied. In the present case, the
classification in question has no reasonable nexus to the
objective sought to be achieved while revising the pension. As
observed hereinabove, the object and purpose for revising the
pension is due to the increase in the cost of living. All the
pensioners form a single class and therefore such a classification
for the purpose of grant of revised pension is unreasonable,
arbitrary, discriminatory and violative of Article 14 of the
Constitution of India. The State cannot arbitrarily pick and
choose from amongst similarly situated persons, a cutoff
date for
extension of benefits especially pensionary benefits. There has to
be a classification founded on some rational principle when
similarly situated class is differentiated for grant of any benefit.
8.1 As observed hereinabove, and even it is not in dispute that
as such a decision has been taken by the State Government to
revise the pension keeping in mind the increase in the cost of
living. Increase in the cost of living would affect all the
pensioners irrespective of whether they have retired pre1996
or
post1996.
As observed hereinabove, all the pensioners belong to
one class. Therefore, by such a classification/cutoff
date the
equals are treated as unequals and therefore such a classification

which has no nexus with the object and purpose of revision of
pension is unreasonable, discriminatory and arbitrary and
therefore the said classification was rightly set aside by the
learned Single Judge of the High Court. At this stage, it is
required to be observed that whenever a new benefit is granted
and/or new scheme is introduced, it might be possible for the
State to provide a cutoff
date taking into consideration its
financial resources. But the same shall not be applicable with
respect to one and single class of persons, the benefit to be given
to the one class of persons, who are already otherwise getting the
benefits and the question is with respect to revision.
9. In view of the above and for the reasons stated above, we
are of the opinion that the controversy/issue in the present
appeal is squarely covered by the decision of this Court in the
case of D.S. Nakara (supra). The decision of this Court in the
case of D.S. Nakara (supra) shall be applicable with full force to
the facts of the case on hand. The Division Bench of the High
Court has clearly erred in not following the decision of this Court
in the case of D.S. Nakara (supra) and has clearly erred in
reversing the judgment and order of the learned Single Judge.
The impugned judgment and order passed by the Division Bench

is not sustainable and the same deserves to be quashed and set
aside and is accordingly quashed and set aside. The judgment
and order passed by the learned Single Judge is hereby restored
and it is held that all the pensioners, irrespective of their date of
retirement, viz. pre1996
retirees shall be entitled to revision in
pension at par with those pensioners who retired post1996.

REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 10857 OF 2016

All Manipur Pensioners Association  Vs  The State of Manipur and others .
M.R. SHAH, J.
Dated:JULY 11, 2019.
Print Page

Friday, 28 June 2019

Whether court should direct government to delay discharge of government employee for few days so that he can get pension?

 In this particular case, the applicant is short of 10 years’ of service by 22 days. In this situation, when the livelihood of an individual is getting adversely affected, it is expected from a Government Organization to be magnanimous and considerate to its employee, and in this case, the same could have been achieved by delaying the discharge by 22 days. Hence, we are of the considered opinion that in the interest of substantial justice, the applicant is to be notionally treated in service till he completes 10 years of service and he should be granted invalid pension. 

In the Armed Forces Tribunal
(Before SVS Rathore, Member (Judicial) and Air Marshal SVS Rathore, Member (Administrative))
Regional Bench Lucknow
No. 2804886N Ex Sepy Jadhav Nilesh Dinkar Vs  Union of India,

Original Application No. 266 of 2018
Decided on March 26, 2019

Citation: 2019 SCC OnLine AFT 1028
Print Page

Sunday, 16 June 2019

Whether departmental enquiry can be continued against Judicial officer even after retirement?



 A conjoint reading of the aforesaid subrules
of Rule 27
indicates that the appointing authority is invested with the
power to withhold or withdraw the pension, if in any
departmental or judicial proceedings, the pensioner is found
guilty of grave misconduct or negligence during the period of his
service. Good conduct of the pensioner is an implied condition
for the receipt of pension and if subsequently the pensioner is

found guilty of misconduct or negligence in relation to the acts
or omissions during the services rendered by the pensioner, the
pension can be withheld or withdrawn. The retirement of an
employee does not, therefore, completely preclude the
appointing authority from initiating action for dealing with the
misconduct of the employee during currency of the service.
The retirement does not confer complete immunity from the
action for the misconduct during period of employment. The
nature of the action is, however, restricted to withdrawal or
withholding of pension.
19. Clause (a) of Subrule
(2) in express terms provides that
the departmental proceedings referred to in subRule
(1), if
instituted while the Government servant was in service whether
before his retirement or during his reemployment,
shall, after
the final retirement of the Government servant, be deemed to be
proceedings under this rule and shall be continued by the
authority in the same manner as if the Government servant had
continued in service. The initiation or continuation of the
disciplinary proceedings, against a retired employee is, however,
subject to certain safeguards to protect the interest of the
employee. Clause (b) of subrule
(2) stipulates conditions for
continuation of the disciplinary proceedings if not instituted
while the Government servant was in service. Subrule
(3)

provides a timelimit
of four years so that the pensioner is not
under a threat of action for eternity. In all the cases, where the
departmental enquiry is instituted either before or after
retirement, subrule
(4) mandates sanction of provisional
pension as provided in Rule 130.
20. If we consider the fascicles of the provisions in Rule 27 of
the Pension Rules, 1982, it becomes evident that the rules do
envisage initiation of the disciplinary action even after
retirement of a Government servant, on superannuation or
otherwise, in addition to the continuation of the disciplinary
proceedings, which was instituted before the retirement of the
Government servant. The broad submission canvassed on
behalf of the Petitioner that after retirement of a Government
servant no disciplinary proceedings can be instituted/continued
runs counter to the express mandate of clause (a) of subrule
(2) of Section 27, extracted above, which incorporates a deeming
provision and, by a legal fiction, mandates that the disciplinary
proceedings instituted before the retirement shall be deemed to
be a proceedings under Rule 27 and continued and concluded
in the same manner as if the Government servant had
continued in service. The broad submission therefore cannot be
countenanced.

21. The legal position as regards the institution /
continuation of disciplinary proceedings after the retirement of
an employee, seems to have been crystallised to the effect that
the employer can institute/continue the disciplinary
proceedings against an employee who has retired, provided the
rules which govern the services of the employee permit such a
course of action.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO. 2820 OF 2019

 Mrs. Padmini Nandakumar Nair  Vs The Honourable High Court of Judicature at Bombay, through its
Registrar General, Mumbai

CORAM: R. M. BORDE & N. J. JAMADAR, JJ

PRONOUNCED ON; 14th JUNE, 2019

(Per N. J. JAMADAR, J.)
Print Page

Monday, 27 May 2019

Whether pension of district Judge can be withheld if there is misconduct in recruitment process of class 3 and class 4 employees?

In view of the above, the action of the High Court in recommending
withholding of 50% pension of the petitioner and in exonerating all the
other five officers is nothing but discrimination between equals who fall
under the same class, for no recorded reasons and as such the punishment
imposed upon the petitioner by the Hon'ble Governor is not tenable in law.
This apart, as already discussed, the aforesaid punishment was
inflicted upon the petitioner finding him guilty of misconduct in conducting
the recruitment of class-III and class-IV employees. Thus, the punishment
was on the cumulative effect of the misconduct in respect of both the
recruitments and if one of them is deleted, it would certainly not have the
same impact so as to impose a punishment which had been inflicted upon
the petitioner. In respect of the recruitment of class-IV employees, the
inquiry has been held to be without jurisdiction as it was barred by time and
was without the proper sanction of the Hon'ble Governor. Accordingly, the
gravity of the misconduct stands reduced and in that respect of the matter,
the punishment ex-facie turns out to be excessive and disproportionate to
the charge proved.
In the overall facts and circumstances of the case, our considered
conclusion is that the order of punishment dated 07.11.2012 withholding
50% of the pension of the petitioner is unsustainable and deserves to be
quashed.
It is accordingly quashed and the writ of certiorari to that effect is
directed to be issued.

ALLAHABAD HIGH COURT
Delivered on 22.05.2019

Case :- WRIT - A No. - 19813 of 2013

Petitioner :- Shyam Babu Vaish
Respondent :- State Of U.P.And Anr.

Coram:
Hon'ble Pankaj Mithal,J.
Hon'ble Prakash Padia,J.
Print Page

Sunday, 26 May 2019

Whether government servant can be denied pension if he is compulsorily retired?

In the present case, the qualifying service for getting the pension is of 10 years' duration, as prescribed under Regulation 14 of the Pension Regulations. The right to get the pension accrues as soon as an employee completes 10 years of his service. It cannot be denied to him unless it is shown that he is either disqualified for getting the pension or the past service rendered by him is forfeited under any of the statutory provisions. Under the service jurisprudence, normally an employee, who is terminated, dismissed or removed from service by way of punishment, is disqualified for getting the pension. On tendering resignation upon rendering qualifying service, an employee incurs forfeiture of his past service. The voluntary retirement, after rendering qualified service, or compulsory retirement, would not result either in disqualification for getting the pension or forfeiture of the past service rendered.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

Writ Petition No. 2348 of 2017

Decided On: 21.09.2018

 Vandana Vs. State Bank of India and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
R.K. Deshpande and Arun D. Upadhye, JJ.

Citation: 2019(2) MHLJ 197
Print Page

Sunday, 19 May 2019

Whether charges for unlawful retention of government quarter can be recovered after it is deposited in bank account of pensioner?

The question is whether the respondent No. 3 was competent to direct the respondent No. 1- Bank to deduct an amount of Rs. 96,475/- from the pension account of the petitioner with it and further to remit it by way of deduction for unlawful retention of the Government quarter for the period from 1-4-1991 to 26-2-1998.

4. We are not entering into the controversy as to whether there was in fact retention of the quarter or that it was an illegal retention for the period from 1-4-1991 to 26-2-1998 by the husband of the petitioner. The reliance is placed upon Rule 72(6)(ii)(b) of the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972, which runs as under:

Rule 72(6)(ii)(b):

"(ii) ... (b) after the word "Estates", the following shall be added, namely:-

"Any amount becoming due on account of Licence fee for retention of Government accommodation beyond four months after retirement and remaining unpaid may be ordered to be recovered by the Directorate of Estates through the concerned Accounts Officer from the dearness relief without the consent of the pensioner. In such cases no dearness relief shall be disbursed until full recovery of such dues have been made."

In our view, in terms of the aforesaid Rule, the amount of clearness allowance could have been recovered before depositing the amount of pension in the Bank account of the petitioner. It is not in dispute that such amount was not deducted. Once the amount of pension is disbursed and deposited in the Bank account of the petitioner, we do not find that any power is conferred upon the respondent No. 3- the Assistant Estate Manager under the aforesaid provision to direct the Bank to deduct such amount from the pension account of the petitioner and to remit it back to him. The recovery of the amount from the pension account of the petitioner is, therefore, unlawful and without any authority. The same cannot, therefore, be sustained and will have to be quashed and set aside.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

Writ Petition No. 685 of 2006

Decided On: 24.11.2018

 Mrinal  Vs.  State Bank of India and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
R.K. Deshpande and Vinay Joshi, JJ.

Citation: 2019(2) MHLJ 686
Print Page

Saturday, 13 April 2019

Whether court may attach pension of husband for recovery of maintenance to wife?

The above said Section shows that in civil disputes
pensions cannot be attached at the instance of creditors.
Commentary relied on by learned counsel for the
applicant/husband at serial No.16 under head of attachment shows
that, “maintenance allowance granted to wife cannot be considered
as debt – She is not a creditor hence exemption under S.11 cannot
be granted to husband. (1985)87 Punk LR 682 : (1985) 12 Cri LT
219”. The said commentary itself shows that pensions can be
attached to recover amount of maintenance. Hence, the stand
taken by learned counsel for the applicant/husband that pensions
cannot be attached is not digestible.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY,
NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR
CRIMINAL REVISION APPLICATION NO.202 OF 2018


Bhagwant s/o Pandurang Narnawre, Vs Radhika w/o Bhagwant Narnawre,


CORAM : M.G.GIRATKAR, J.
DATE : APRIL 5, 2019.

Print Page

Friday, 1 March 2019

Whether monthly pension received by judgment debtor is exempt from attachment in execution of decree?

In the light of the decisions cited supra, I am of the view that the petitioner/judgment debtor who receives a monthly pension of Rs. 12000/- will be treated as capital income and when it reaches the hands of the petitioner, it will be treated as his income. The contention of the petitioner that the monthly pension received by him cannot be considered as his income and it is exempted from attachment has no relevance in the light of the aforesaid decisions. Moreover, there is absolutely no evidence to prove that the other members of his family are depending fully on the petitioner. The attempt of the petitioner is to avoid payment of the decree debt to the respondent and this kind of nature of the petitioner/judgment debtor cannot be accepted by a court of law. In the result, this petition fails and the same is accordingly dismissed.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

OP(C) No. 771 of 2015

Decided On: 21.05.2018

 Muralee Mohan Pillai Vs.  T.V. Varghese

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Annie John, J.

Citation: AIR 2019(NOC) 41 Kerala
Print Page

Wednesday, 3 January 2018

Whether old age pension can be stopped without following principles of natural justice?

Reality of the matter is that the impugned order dated 24.04.2015 of the 2nd Respondent, stopping the payment of Old Age Pension to the Appellant from October 2014, without issuance of prior notice or hearing the objections/representation of the Appellant, is invalid and illegal, because of the simple reason that not only by stopping the payment of Old Age Pension to the Appellant, it concerns of 'Civil Consequences' and also that the impugned order is in negation of the Principles of Natural Justice, as opined by this Court.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADRAS

W.A. No. 1362 of 2015

Decided On: 16.02.2016

R. Senbagam  Vs. Collector of Nagapattinam District and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Satish K. Agnihotri and M. Venugopal, JJ.

Citation:AIR 2017(NOC) 1144 MAD
Print Page