Showing posts with label recurring cause. Show all posts
Showing posts with label recurring cause. Show all posts

Monday, 7 May 2018

Whether landlord is entitled to file fresh eviction suit if his previous suit was dismissed?


11. After giving our careful consideration to the facts and circumstances of the case, it appears to us that non-mention of a reasonable ground for eviction in the notice for eviction on the basis of which a claim for eviction is later on founded usually raises a suspicion about the existence of such ground but such non-mention by itself cannot disentitle a landlord to claim eviction on such ground. If a claim for eviction founded on such ground in the petition for eviction is proved to be well-founded and the same is consistent with the grounds on which eviction is permissible in law, the landlord will be entitled to a decree for eviction notwithstanding the fact that such ground was not mentioned in the notice for eviction, In our view, the appellate authority has rightly indicated in the facts of this case,, that the partnership business under the name and style of Govindammal and Company was in existence even prior to giving notice for eviction by the landlord. Such partnership business was registered and the licence for the business was obtained and the business had been subjected to assessments made by the income tax authorities. Hence, such business was not brought into existence only for the purpose of making a foundation for eviction of the tenant with mala fide intention. Hence, in the facts and circumstances of the case, it cannot be reasonably held that the claim of bona fide requirement on account of the said partnership business is per se mala fide and should not be taken into consideration simply because the case for bona fide requirement on that account had not been mentioned in the notice for eviction. There is no manner of doubt that the bona fide requirement is required to be considered objectively with reference to the materials on record and it is necessary to determine the real intention of the landlord on the basis of evidences adduced in a case. If the materials on record clearly justify a case of bona fide requirement, there will be no occasion for the court to hold that the landlord did not require the premises bona fide simply because on a previous occasion the action of the landlord for bringing an eviction case was not bona fide. It should be borne in mind that cause for eviction is a recurring cause of action and even if the existence of such cause of action had not been found in a previous proceeding for eviction, the same cannot be discarded if such claim is established by cogent evidences adduced by the landlord in a subsequent proceeding. It will not be correct to hold that only because after a tenant was evicted by the landlord on the ground of reasonable requirement for building and reconstruction, the landlord did not make the alleged reconstruction but let out the premises to another tenant after obtaining possession, any subsequent eviction case for the said premises deserves to be dismissed in limine. The landlord, in our view, may bring an action for eviction of the tenant on subsequent cause of action justifying a case of bona fide requirement. Similarly, rejection of a case for building and reconstruction by itself will not disentitle the landlord to get an order of eviction if the eviction on such ground can be founded in a changed circumstance. 

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 878 of 1994.

Decided On: 18.02.1994

K.S. Sundararaju Chettiar Vs. M.R. Ramachandra Naidu

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
K. Jayachandra Reddy and G.N. Ray, JJ.

Citation : AIR 1994 SC 2129
Print Page

Sunday, 25 February 2018

Whether landlord can file fresh proceeding for eviction of tenant on ground of non payment of rent and bonafide need?

In our view, the High Court ought to have considered the fact that in eviction proceedings under theRent Act the ground of bona fide requirement or non-payment of rent is a recurring cause and, therefore, landlord is not precluded from instituting fresh proceeding. In an eviction suit on the ground of bona fide requirement the genuineness of the said ground is to be decided on the basis of requirement on the date of the suit. Further, even if a suit for eviction on the ground of bona fide requirement is filed and is dismissed it cannot be held that once a question of necessity is decided against the landlord he will not have a bona fide and genuine necessity ever in future. In the subsequent proceedings, if such claim is established by cogent evidence adduced by the landlord, decree for possession could be passed. {Re: K.S. Sundararaju Chettiar vs. M.R. Ramachandra Naidu [(1994) 5 SCC 14 (para 10)] and Surajmal vs. Radhe Shyam [(1988) 3 SCC 18]}.

Supreme Court of India
N. R. Narayan Swamy vs B. Francis Jagan on 31 July, 2001

Bench: M.B. Shah, R.P. Sethi
           CASE NO.:
Appeal (civil) 4800  of  2001
Citation:AIR2001SC2469 


Print Page