Showing posts with label regularisation of encroachment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label regularisation of encroachment. Show all posts

Sunday, 24 April 2022

Whether Gram panchayat can give no objection for regularization of encroachment done over Gairan land by passing resolution?

  The petitioner is admittedly an encroacher

upon government “E” Class land, which is Gairan land.

It is the contention of Mr. Awachar, learned counsel for

the petitioner that the petitioner is a land less person,

who has encroached upon this land since the year 1991

and therefore, the petitioner is entitled for allotment of

the land encroached by him through its regularization.

He also submits that there is a Gram Panchayat

Resolution dated 30.06.1998, which gives no objection

for permanent allotment of government land to the

petitioner. {Para 2}

3. Mr. Patil, learned AGP for respondent Nos.1,

3 and 4 submits that under Section 22A of the

Maharashtra Land Revenue Code, 1966 (for short "the

Code of 1966"), no regularization for any private

purpose is permissible, as it could amount to diversion

of the Gairan land against the express provisions of law.

He also submits that even by the criteria laid down in

the case of Jagpal Singh (supra), the petitioner is not

entitled for any kind of regularization.

4. So far as Gram Panchayat resolution is

concerned, we must say that there was no business for

the Gram Panchayat to have passed a resolution, giving

its no objection for regularization of the encroachment

upon the government land, especially in view of the

provisions made under sub-Section (6) of Section 22A

of the Code of 1966. These provisions indicate that

powers of diversion, grant, lease of Gairan land under

Section 22A of the Code of 1966 shall be vested in the

State Government. Therefore, passing of any unwarrented

resolution in respect of the land, of which

Gram Panchayat is not the owner or the land which is

not vested in the Gram Panchayat, only amounts to

meddling with the affairs of the State Government, for

which purpose, appropriate action, if thought it

necessary, would have to be taken by the State

Government.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR.

CIVIL WRIT PETITION NO.2581 OF 2021

Ramdas s/o. Sambhaji Ghewande Vs. State of Maharashtra, through its Secretary,

Print Page

Whether petitioner can seek regularization of his encroachment over Gairan Land?

  It would be clear from the above provisions

of law that except for public purpose, the Gairan land

cannot be diverted or granted or leased out for any

other use. In the present case, the petitioner is seeking

allotment of the land on lease to him for private

purpose, which is not permissible under above referred

provisions of law. {Para 6}

7. In present case, admittedly, the

petitioner is not there on the land by virtue of some

Government Notification in his favour. Admittedly, the

petitioner is seeking regularization of his encroachment

for only private purpose. Therefore, as per the law laid

down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the

petitioner is not entitled for regularization of his

encroachment by allotting the land on lease to him.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR.

CIVIL WRIT PETITION NO.2581 OF 2021

Ramdas s/o. Sambhaji Ghewande Vs. State of Maharashtra, through its Secretary,


CORAM : SUNIL B. SHUKRE AND

ANIL S. KILOR, JJ .

DATE : 26th JULY, 2021.

Print Page

Friday, 31 March 2017

When encroachment on government land can not be regularized?

 We find no merit in this appeal. The appellants herein were trespassers who illegally encroached on to the Gram Panchayat land by using muscle power/money power and in collusion with the officials and even with the Gram Panchayat. We are of the opinion that such kind of blatant illegalities must not be condoned. Even if the appellants have built houses on the land in question they must be ordered to remove their constructions, and possession of the land in question must be handed back to the Gram Panchayat. Regularizing such illegalities must not be permitted because it is Gram Sabha land which must be kept for the common use of villagers of the village. The letter dated 26.9.2007 of the Government of Punjab permitting regularization of possession of these unauthorized occupants is not valid. We are of the opinion that such letters are wholly illegal and without jurisdiction. In our opinion such illegalities cannot be regularized. We cannot allow the common interest of the villagers to suffer merely because the unauthorized occupation has subsisted for many years.
14. In M.I. Builders (P) Ltd. vs. Radhey Shyam Sahu, 1999(6) SCC 464 the Supreme Court ordered restoration of a park after demolition of a shopping complex constructed at the cost of over Rs.100 crores. In Friends Colony Development Committee vs. State of Orissa, 2004 (8) SCC 733 this Court held that even where the law permits compounding of unsanctioned constructions, such compounding should only be by way of an exception. In our opinion this decision will apply with even greater force in cases of encroachment of village common land. Ordinarily, compounding in such cases should only be allowed where the land has been leased to landless labourers or members of Scheduled Castes/Scheduled Tribes, or the land is actually being used for a public purpose of the village e.g. running a school for the villagers, or a dispensary for them.
Reportable
Supreme Court of India
Jagpal Singh & Ors vs State Of Punjab & Ors on 28 January, 2011

Bench: Markandey Katju, Gyan Sudha Misra
Print Page

Sunday, 19 March 2017

Whether encroachment on E class land can be regularized relying on doctrine of legitimate expectation?

  
Madras City Wine Merchants' Association and another  Vs.  State of
T. N. and another (1994) 5 Supreme Court Cases 509:
“Legitimate expectation may arise­
(a) if there is an express promise given by a public
authority; or 
(b)   because   of   the   existence   of   a   regular   practice
which the claimant can reasonably expect to continue;
(c) Such   an   expectation   must   be   reasonable.
However, if there is a change in policy or in public
interest the position is altered by a rule or legislation,
no question of legitimate expectation would arise.”

                                                    (emphasis supplied)
10] In the light of aforesaid legal position, it is crystal clear that the
petitioners have no legal right whatsoever to insist for consideration of their
applications for regularization on the basis of Government Resolution dated
28­11­1991. Though it is a fact that the applications moved by the petitioners
were pursuant to the said Government Resolution, these applications were
pending when the State Government came up with a fresh policy by issuing
Government Resolution dated 12­7­2011. The mere fact that the petitioners
had applied for regularization in terms of the earlier policy and the said
applications were pending when the new policy came into force cannot be a
ground to hold that the said applications ought to have been considered as

per the earlier policy. The said applications, therefore, have been rightly
decided in the light of Government  resolution dated 12­7­2011 which is
holding the field. 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY NAGPUR BENCH
NAGPUR.
WRIT   PETITION    NO.   6466     OF     2015
Bhagwan Kisan Wagh
V
 State of Maharashtra,
CORAM: A.S. CHANDURKAR, J.
 DATED: 21­-07-­2016.
Citation: 2017(2) MHLJ 425
Print Page

Monday, 12 December 2016

Whether application for regularisation of encroachment can be decided as per provisions applicable on date of their disposal?

I have given due consideration to the respective submissions and
I have gone through the documents filed on record.   As per Government
Resolution   dated   28.11.1991   a   policy   decision   was   taken   by   the   State
Government   to   regularise   encroachments   made   between   01.04.1978   and
14.04.1990.   The manner in which such encroachments could be regularised
was stipulated therein.  In Jagpal Singh (supra) the Hon'ble Supreme Court
noticed   that   various   lands   that   vested   in   the   grampanchayats   had   been

encroached.   It was noticed that various State Governments had permitted
allotment of such lands to private persons and commercial enterprises on
payment of some money.  It was observed that such Government orders were
illegal.  In that background directions were issued to all State Governments to
prepare schemes for eviction of illegal/unauthorised occupants of such land.
It was observed that such schemes should provide for speedy eviction of
illegal occupants after giving show cause notice and brief hearing. 
Pursuant to this judgment, the State Government brought into
effect  Government  Resolution  dated  12.07.2011.    The  same   was  for   the
purpose of removal of encroachments on E­class lands.  A policy decision was
taken that in future   such lands should be utilised only for implementing
public   utility   services   and   for   implementing   the   policies   of   the   Central
Government and the State Government.  It was also resolved not to allot such
lands to any individual or any private institution.   
7] In R. V. Bhuskute (supra) the Division Bench of this Court while
entertaining   a   public   interest   litigation   in   the   matter   of   removal   of
encroachments issued directions to the State Government to publish a list of
persons who were entitled to take   benefit of Clause 10 of Government
Resolution dated 28.11.1991.  This order passed by the Division Bench was
considered subsequently by another Division Bench in  Bhaskar Bhagwant
Dikkar (supra).   It was observed that the order passed in  R. V. Bhuskute
(supra)  did not  refer  to  the  judgment  of the  Hon'ble  Supreme  Court  in
Jagpal   Singh (supra)  as   well   as   the   Government   Resolution   dated

12.07.2011.   The Division Bench thereafter proceeded to direct the State
Government to implement the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Jagpal   Singh (supra)   as   well   as   the   Government   Resolution   dated
12.07.2011.  A further direction was issued to all Collectors in the State to
recall any order of regularising any encroachment if made under Clause 9(1)
and 9(2) of Government Resolution dated 12.07.2011 and to take possession
of such lands for grazing purpose. 
8] It would be first necessary to consider whether the petitioners can
claim   a   vested   right   for   seeking   consideration   of   their   applications   for
regularization of encroachments in terms of Government Resolution dated
28­11­1991. This would have to be considered in the light of the fact that
when the applications for regularisation were pending, another Government
Resolution dated 12­7­2011 indicating a change in policy came into effect.
The question whether an applicant would have a vested right to
seek consideration of his request on the basis of the date when he had so
applied   has   been   considered   by   the   Hon'ble   Supreme   Court   in  Howrah
Municipal Corpn. v. Ganges Rope Co. Ltd. (2004) 1 SCC 663.  In said case, an
application for sanction for construction was made by a Company. As the
sanction was neither granted nor refused within the prescribed period, the
Company had approached the High Court in that regard. The High Court had
directed the Municipal Corporation to consider grant of sanction subject to
fulfillment of requirements.  When the application for sanction was pending,
the Building Rules were amended due to which the sanction as sought was

not   granted.     In   that   background   while   considering   the   question   as   to
whether any vested right had been created in favour of the Company despite
subsequent amendment to the Building Rules, it was observed by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court that with long usage the word “vest” has also acquired a
meaning as “an absolute or indefeasible right.”  What the Company had was
only a “legitimate” or “settled expectation” to obtain the sanction. The same
did not create any vested right to obtained the sanction.   The following
observations in para 37 of the aforesaid judgment clarify the position.
“37.............................................................................What   we
can understand from the claim of a “vested right” set up by
the respondent Company is that on the basis of the Building
Rules, as applicable to their case on the date of making an
application for sanction and the fixed period allotted by the
Court for its consideration, it had a “legitimate” or “settled
expectation”   to   obtain   the   sanction.     In   our   considered
opinion, such “settled expectation”, if any, did not crate any
vested right to obtain sanction.  True it is, that the respondent
Company   which   can   have   no   control   over   the   manner   of
processing   of   application   for   sanction   by   the   Corporation
cannot   be   blamed   for   delay   but   during   pendency   of   its
application for sanction, if the State Government, in exercise
of its rule­making power, amended the Building Rules and
imposed restrictions on the heights of buildings on G.T. Road
and other wards, such “settled expectation” has been rendered
impossible of fulfilment due to change in law. The claim based
on the alleged “vested right” or “settled expectation” cannot
be set up against statutory provisions which were brought into
force   by   the   State   Government   by   amending   the   Building
Rules and not by the Corporation against whom such “vested
right” or “settled expectation” is being sought to be enforced.
The “vested right' or settled expectation has been nullified not
only by the Corporation but also by the State by amending the
Building Rules, Besides this, such a “settled expectation” or
the so­called “vested right” cannot be countenanced against
public interest and convenience which are sought to be served
by amendment of the Building Rules and the resolution of the
Corporation issued thereupon.”

From the aforesaid observations, it is clear that the petitioners
merely had a   “settled expectation” in the matter of regularization of their
encroachment under Government Resolution dated 28­11­1991 and not any
vested right.
9. It is also equally well settled that consideration of an application
of the present nature would depend upon the provisions as are applicable on
the date of disposal of the application.   In case of a change in policy, the
application would be liable to be dealt with in the manner and procedure that
is prevailing on the date when such application is considered and decided.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY NAGPUR BENCH
NAGPUR.
WRIT   PETITION    NO.   6466     OF     2015

Bhagwan Kisan Wagh V State of Maharashtra,

CORAM: A.S. CHANDURKAR, J.

 DATED : 21­-07­-2016.
Citation: 2016 (5) ALLMR847
Print Page

Friday, 15 April 2016

Whether court should direct government to regularize encroachment on public land?

We are fortified in our above view on this subject by the

decision of Karnataka High Court in the case of Holeyappa & others
Vs. State of Karnataka represented by its Secretary & others
[ILR 2005 KARNATAKA 5437]. The observations made by the
Karnataka High Court in the said Judgment, the relevant portion of
which is quoted below, are apt in the present scenario:-
“.....................................................................................
...........No writ lies for issuing directions to the
Government or the officials of the Government to
compel them to act contrary to the statutory provisions.
Respondents are directed to ensure that if any standing
crop was there, it is harvested and the proceeds given
to such persons who had raised the crop and to ensure
that hence forth the land is retained as a gomal land,
that no unauthorised encroachments are allowed on the
land and land is preserved for the common utility of the
community of the village. It is hereby directed that the
respondents are bound to maintain the land as gomal
land. #Over a period of time, no doubt the number of
cattle might have got reduced but villagers still remain
agricultural based and farmers continue to depend on
cattle. Areas available for grazing of cattle, greenery,
have got reduced over all on account of vast extents of
lands becoming urbanised and rapid urbanization has
not spared villages either. Non agricultural activities
have proliferated and the demand for land has
increased day by day. Vast extents of land which has
been earmarked for such community purposes like
gomal land have become the prime target of the
greedy. Local politicians eye on it for their personal
gains, set up people to grab such lands; applications are
made by syndicates in benami and what not. Available
lands are grabbed by the powerful and greedy persons
and the like at the cost of community even when there
is absolute need for maintaining such lands as gomal
lands and to ensure that they sub-serve the common
interest of the community. Without any application of
mind or thought and at the behest of greedy political
bosses, bureaucrats threw to winds the relevant

statutory provisions, subvert the provisions and virtually
sell away Government lands in the guise of granting of
lands. To further compound the situation such persons
even seek aid of the Court praying for issue of
directions to the respondents to legitimise their illegal
activities and directions and mandamus are issued by
this Court. More often than not such directions come in
handy for conniving and fraud intent officials to put a
seal of legitimacy for their arbitrary and illegal actions.
…..”
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
NAGPUR BENCH : NAGPUR
Criminal Application [APL] No. 516 of 2015

Bhaskar son of Bhagwant Dikkar, V State of Maharashtra,

 CORAM : A.B. CHAUDHARI AND
P.N. DESHMUKH, JJ.

 Date : 14th August, 2015.
Citation; 2016 ALLMR(CRI)1077
Print Page