Showing posts with label relinquish. Show all posts
Showing posts with label relinquish. Show all posts

Friday, 1 May 2015

Whether wife can be denied maintenance on the ground that she relinquished maintenance as per agreement?


In view of above, when scheme of Section 125
of Code of Criminal Procedure is considered, it saddles
a person with duty to maintain his legitimate or
illegitimate minor child subject to conditions laid down
therein. The provision vests corresponding right in the
child to claim maintenance from his father in the event
the child is unable to maintain itself. The obligation of
father to maintain his child does not at any point of
time shift to any other person including mother having
custody of the child. In other words, even if the child is
temporarily living with mother or in custody of any
other person,
the father
continues
to be under
statutory duty to maintain the child. As such, the right
with which the child is vested under Section 125
cannot
be
bartered
away,
surrendered, even by his mother.
compromised
or
The language of
Section 125(1)(b) makes abundantly clear that the law
makers under this Section has cast duty upon father
to maintain the child.
Having this in mind, reference
to “legitimate or illegitimate child” has been made in
10)
Section 125(b) and (c) of Code of Criminal Procedure.
The case of petitioner based on compromise
arrived at between him and respondent no.1 in H.M.P.
No.51/2005 can in no way hamper the right of
no.2 to claim maintenance from the
respondent
vagrancy
Procedure
of
is
Criminal
petitioner. As the spirit of Section 125 of the Code of
divorced
to
prevent
wife,
any
starvation
compromise
and
or
agreement by any of the parties to the marriage would
in fact be against the spirit of law and would also be
opposed to the public policy as it would be against the
social order.
It is a basic principle of law that an
agreement which is opposed to public policy cannot be
enforced in a Court of law.
Section 23 of the Indian
Contract Act, 1872 renders such an agreement void if
its consideration or object is unlawful. If the object or
consideration of an agreement would defeat the
provisions of any law and if it is opposed to public
policy, the agreement would be treated as unlawful
and consequently void.
Therefore, a clause in an
agreement that the wife shall not be entitled to claim
maintenance from the husband cannot be used as a
defence to proceedings under Section 125 of the Code
of Criminal Procedure. The relinquishment of the right
to maintenance by the wife will not bar proceedings
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
NAGPUR BENCH : NAGPUR
CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO.676 OF 2013
Ankush s/o Sheshrao Wayal,
Vs
Sau. Ranjana w/o Ankush Wayal
Date of pronouncing the judgment : 13/10/2014
CORAM :     P.N. DESHMUKH, J. 
 
                                    DATED  :    OCTOBER 13,  2014 
Citation; 2015 ALLMR(cri)1560
Print Page

Whether mother can relinquish claim for maintenance of child?



Having considered the above facts, I find no
substance in the criminal writ petition since it is based
on the fact of respondent no.1 being mother of
respondent no.2, relinquishing the right of respondent
no.2 to claim maintenance from her father as mother
cannot be competent to relinquish such right.
I am,
therefore, of the opinion that the agreement reached
between petitioner and respondent no.1 before the
learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Buldhana would
not operate as a bar to maintainability of maintenance
case of respondent no.2.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
NAGPUR BENCH : NAGPUR

Ankush s/o Sheshrao Wayal,
Vs
 Sau. Ranjana w/o Ankush Wayal

Date of pronouncing the judgment : 13/10/2014

CORAM :     P.N. DESHMUKH, J. 
  
            DATED  :    OCTOBER 13,  2014 
Citation; 2015 ALLMR(CRI)1560
Print Page

Thursday, 12 March 2015

Whether co-sharer of joint family property can surrender/relinquish his share orally at the time of partition?


if the suit property was self-acquired property and not the joint family property it could not be relinquished/surrendered without registered instrument - A co-parcener or a sharer in joint family property can surrender his share orally at the time of partition - Oral relinquishment of share in a joint family property is valid - In the present case, since the oral relinquishment was of a self acquired property, it was invalid and the grandfather of the Plaintiff continued to be the owner and no title under the alleged surrender ever vested in the Plaintiff or Defendant No. 2 - On the death of the owner the property devolved on the father of the Plaintiff and acquired the status of joint family property - Partition deed effected of the said property is hence valid and conclusive as to the shares allotted to everyone including the Plaintiff - Further, the suit filed against the said partition was also dismissed and hence the present suit filed by Plaintiff is barred by the principle of res-judicata - No error committed by Courts below - Appeal dismissed

“If an immovable property is the self acquired property then it can be transferred only by way of registered instrument and cannot be transferred by oral agreement but if it is a joint family property then the co-sharer can surrender/relinquish his share orally at the time of partition.”
Bombay High Court
Shri Gangadhar Pandhari Harde vs Uttam S/O Pandhari Harde And ... on 14 January, 2008
Equivalent citations: 2008 (2) BomCR 1, 2008 (110) Bom L R 489, 2008 (2) MhLj 334, 2008(3)ALLMR152,

Bench: C Pangarkar

Print Page