Showing posts with label co-sharer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label co-sharer. Show all posts

Monday, 20 April 2026

What is ouster of co-sharer? which law is related to it?

A three judge bench of this Court in P. Lakshmi Reddy v. R. Lakshmi Reddy AIR 1957 SC 1789, while examining the necessary conditions for applicability of doctrine of ouster to the shares of co-owners, held as follows: {Para 22}


4. Now, the ordinary classical requirement of adverse possession is that it should be nec vi nec clam nec precario. (See Secretary of State for India v. Debendra Lal Khan [MANU/PR/0072/1933 : (1933) LR 61 IA 78, 82]). The possession required must be adequate in continuity, in publicity and in extent to show that it is possession adverse to the competitor. (See Radhamoni Debi v. Collector of Khulna [(1900) LR 27 IA 136, 140]). But it is well-settled that in order to establish adverse possession of one co-heir as against another it is not enough to show that one out of them is in sole possession and enjoyment of the profits of the properties. Ouster of the non-possessing co-heir by the co-heir in possession who claims his possession to be adverse, should be made out. The possession of one co-heir is considered, in law, as possession of all the co-heirs. When one co-heir is found to be in possession of the properties it is presumed to be on the basis of joint title. The co-heir in possession cannot render his possession adverse to the other co-heir not in possession merely by any secret hostile animus on his own part in derogation of the other co-heir's title. (See Cores v. Appuhamy [(1912) AC 230)]. It is a settled rule of law that as between co-heirs there must be evidence of open assertion of hostile title, coupled with exclusive possession and enjoyment by one of them to the knowledge of the other so as to constitute ouster. This does not necessarily mean that there must be an express demand by one and denial by the other.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal Nos. 1858-1859 of 2016 

Decided On: 26.02.2016

 Nagabhushanammal  Vs. C. Chandikeswaralingam

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Kurian Joseph and Rohinton Fali Nariman, JJ.

Author: Kurian Joseph, J.

Citation: MANU/SC/0231/2016.

Read full judgment here: Click here

Print Page

Saturday, 7 September 2024

Whether one co-sharer is entitled to get mesne profits from other co-sharer?

On the case of the petitioners themselves, they were co-sharers along with opposite party Nos. 1 to 3. The grievance of the petitioners is that opposite party Nos. 1 to 3 were in possession of the six rooms in spite of the order dated 10-10-1969 passed by the court below and on that basis as stated above, they claim mesne profits on the ground that they were deprived of the enjoyment of those six rooms to which they were entitled to in pursuance of the aforesaid order. But that alone, in our opinion, is not sufficient to entitle the petitioners to get mesne profits from opposite party Nos. 1 to 3. "Mesne profits" has been defined in sub-section (12' of Section 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, which is as follows:--


"Mesne profits" of property means those profits which the person in wrongful possession of such property actually received or might with ordinary diligence have received therefrom, together with interest on such profits, but shall not include profits due to improvements made by the person in wrongful possession."

A bare reading of this sub-section shows that a person in wrongful possession alone is liable to pay mesne profit. Was the possession of opposite party Nos. 1 to 3 wrongful ? The answer to that is certainly in the negative because they were, according to the case of the petitioners themselves, co-sharers of the six rooms. It is settled that possession of a co-sharer can never be wrongful as he had right and interest in every inch of the undivided property. It is not said by the petitioner that the property has been divided by metes and bounds and these six rooms have been allotted to his share. All that is said is that the petitioners are entitled to exclusive possession of these six rooms on account of the orders passed on 10-10-1969. But this order cannot be construed as to deprive opposite party Nos. 1 to 3 from enjoyment of the undivided property. For these reasons, in our view, the petitioners cannot claim mesne profits against opposite party Nos. 1 to 3. The application therefore, fails and is dismissed; but in the circumstances there will be no order as to costs.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF PATNA

Civil Revn. No. 1039 of 1977

Decided On: 16.08.1979

Shambhu Dayal Khetan and Ors. Vs. Motilal Murarka and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

S. Ali Ahmad and Maheshwar Pradesh Verma, JJ.

Citation: AIR 1980 Patna 106, MANU/BH/0026/1980.

Print Page

Saturday, 26 October 2019

Whether co-sharer can sell specific portion of property?

11. Thus, it is clear that when the property in dispute is joint in nature, then although the co-sharer can sell the property to the extent of his share, but he cannot sell the specific piece of land. A co-sharer can alienate the property only to the extent of his share and alienation of the property beyond his share is void. 

 It is well established principle of law that unless and until the property is partitioned, the co-sharer can only sell to the extent of his share, but he cannot sell any specific portion of the land.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH (GWALIOR BENCH)

Second Appeal No. 373 of 2001

Decided On: 07.03.2019

 Parmal Singh  Vs.  Ghanshyam and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Gurpal Singh Ahluwalia, J.

Citation: AIR 2019 MP 131
Print Page

Wednesday, 3 January 2018

Whether court can call fresh court commissioner report if new party is added to suit?

At this juncture it would be relevant to extract para 6 of the order of this Court dated 27.01.2009 made in C.R.P. No. 3438 of 2008 while allowing the impleading petitions of the revision petitioners, wherein this Court has held as follows:

"I would like to recollect and call up, the common or cardinal Principle of law that in partition suits, even third parties could be allowed to be impleaded as parties so that whatever shares the third parties acquired in the suit property from the co-sharers, they would be able to work out their equities. Such third parties cannot put forth any new plea, but only pray for equities and nothing more".
17. The above order made by this Court envisages that justice and equity are paramount. Only on taking into the said fact this Court has earlier allowed the revision petitioners impleading application and thereby the revision petitioners were impleaded in the year 2009, whereas the records disclose that the earlier report has been submitted on 03.01.2008 itself, i.e., prior to the impleadment of the revision petitioners. In this context the contention of the revision petitioners that since the revision petitioners were not parties to the original partition suit, whereas they were only impleaded at final decree proceedings and hence all their efforts and their case put forth before the Advocate Commissioner was not considered, deserves to be considered. Therefore this Court in the interest of justice is of the view that only a proper report submitted after due consideration of all relevant documents and noting down of the physical features of the suit properties in the presence of all the parties to the suit, either was a party or was impleaded subsequently, will enable the Trial Court to arrive at a correct and just decision. It is to be noted that in the case on hand since the reissuance of warrant is prayed in respect of the very same Advocate Commissioner, to inspect the suit property, this Court do not have any hesitation to allow the revision petitioners' application. 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADRAS

CRP(PD) No. 1308 of 2013 and M.P. No. 1 of 2013

Decided On: 25.01.2017

 M. Ammasayappan and Ors. Vs. Muthusamy and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
M.V. Muralidaran, J.
Citation: AIR 2017 Madras 246
Print Page

Sunday, 3 July 2016

Whether exclusive possession of property by one co-owner amounts to adverse possession against other co-owner?

 It has been contended by the learned Counsel for the respondent that if the sale deed was a sham document, not intended to be acted upon. Marappa should have established his possession of the lands under the sale deed to the exclusion of Doraisamy. We may indicate here that there is no finding by the High Court as to the exclusive possession of either of the party. Even if it is accepted that Doraisamy had exercised possession over the land covered by the sale deed, such possession may be explained by indicating that Doraisamy obtained interest to the extent of half share by virtue of the will executed by Karuppanna. Hence, as a co-sharer, he was expected to possess the lands not partitioned between the parties. Exclusive possession of a co-sharer does not amount to adverse possession against other co-sharers unless such possession is exercised by ousting the other co-sharers. There is no such case of ouster of a co-sharer and thereafter exercise of exclusive possession openly and as of right by Doraisamy. That apart, the sale deed was executed by Marappa in September 1984 and the suit was instituted by Marappa for declaration of the sale deed as sham and invalid document in 1985. Hence, question of title by adverse possession did not arise.
Supreme Court of India
Sadasivam vs K. Doraisamy on 9 February, 1996
Equivalent citations: 1996 IIAD SC 355, AIR 1996 SC 1724, JT 1996 (2) SC 400, 1996 (2) SCALE 89, (1996) 8 SCC 624, 1996 2 SCR 336

Bench: G Ray, B Hansaria
Print Page

Tuesday, 10 November 2015

Whether suit for partition is maintainable when all co-sharers are not party to suit?

We have already mentioned above that the plaintiff filed a suit for partition by joining the defendant nos. 1 and 2 therein as co-sharers in the suit property.
It is settled principle of law that the suit for partition cannot be maintained unless all the co-sharers are joined as parties in the suit.
Here is the case where we find that the defendant no.1 disclosed in his application for vacating the interim order that he had transferred part of his interest in the suit property to four purchasers as named above before filing of the suit.
Having regard to the fact that when one of the admitted co-sharers transferred a portion of his share in the suit property, the purchaser automatically became co-sharer by virtue of purchase. As such, in the absence of those co-sharers, the suit for partition cannot be held to be maintainable.
Kolkata High Court (Appellete Side)
Sk. Riyasat Ali vs Sk. Safiuddin Ahamed & Ors on 25 June, 2015
Author: Jyotirmay Bhattacharya
Citation;AIR 2015(NOC)1094 cal
Print Page

Thursday, 12 March 2015

Whether co-sharer of joint hindu family can sell property more than his share?

  Therefore, what the appellant has claimed is only half share of the said property. The said issue has been considered at length by the High Court in its impugned judgment. The High Court has recorded the statement made by the counsel appearing for the defendant No. 3- Ramdass (appellant herein) that the action of the Additional District Judge in declaring that the said sale deed as null and void was not proper to the extent of the shares of plaintiff- Sitabai in the Gat No. 19 area admeasuring 2.56H of Mouza Padoli. Therefore, the fact that the plaintiff-Sitabai was entitled to her half share in the aforesaid property is an admitted position and on that basis the consent decree was passed. Even otherwise, we are of the considered opinion that the appellant herein having purchased only undivided share in the aforesaid property could not have purchased, owned and claimed for more than half share in the said property nor the appellant could have claimed possession in respect of the entire property. The appellant herein has further claimed relief on the ground of equity. However, we do not find any reason to hold in favour of the appellant even on the ground of equity as the appellant herein himself is responsible for his act in purchasing undivided share in a part of the suit property without the knowledge and consent of the co- sharer. Besides, indisputably and as held by the Trial Court, the land in Gat No. 19 is extremely valuable and, therefore, the question of equity does not arise as we would be doing injustice to one having title and ownership if we accept the prayer of the appellant.


Supreme Court of India
Ramdas vs Sitabai & Ors on 29 May, 2009

Bench: Mukundakam Sharma, B.S. Chauhan
Citation: AIR2009SC2735, 2009 (76) ALR 165, 2009 AWC(Supp)3665SC, 2009(5)BomCR290, JT2009(8)SC224, 2009(5)KCCR3321, 2009(6)MhLJ886(SC), 2009MPLJ597(SC), 2009(8)SCALE654, (2009)7SCC444, 
Print Page

Whether co-sharer of joint family property can surrender/relinquish his share orally at the time of partition?


if the suit property was self-acquired property and not the joint family property it could not be relinquished/surrendered without registered instrument - A co-parcener or a sharer in joint family property can surrender his share orally at the time of partition - Oral relinquishment of share in a joint family property is valid - In the present case, since the oral relinquishment was of a self acquired property, it was invalid and the grandfather of the Plaintiff continued to be the owner and no title under the alleged surrender ever vested in the Plaintiff or Defendant No. 2 - On the death of the owner the property devolved on the father of the Plaintiff and acquired the status of joint family property - Partition deed effected of the said property is hence valid and conclusive as to the shares allotted to everyone including the Plaintiff - Further, the suit filed against the said partition was also dismissed and hence the present suit filed by Plaintiff is barred by the principle of res-judicata - No error committed by Courts below - Appeal dismissed

“If an immovable property is the self acquired property then it can be transferred only by way of registered instrument and cannot be transferred by oral agreement but if it is a joint family property then the co-sharer can surrender/relinquish his share orally at the time of partition.”
Bombay High Court
Shri Gangadhar Pandhari Harde vs Uttam S/O Pandhari Harde And ... on 14 January, 2008
Equivalent citations: 2008 (2) BomCR 1, 2008 (110) Bom L R 489, 2008 (2) MhLj 334, 2008(3)ALLMR152,

Bench: C Pangarkar

Print Page