Showing posts with label revenue authorities. Show all posts
Showing posts with label revenue authorities. Show all posts

Friday, 19 February 2021

Whether revenue authorities have jurisdiction to decide the issue of the genuineness of will during mutation proceeding?

                   If an application under Section 110 of MPLR

       Code is filed for mutation of the name of all the legal

       heirs, then it would certainly be a proceeding under the

       MPLR Code because the question of title is not

       involved and all the legal heirs of the deceased/owner

       will be brought on record without any further

       adjudication but whether the adjudication of the title of

       the parties on the basis of a ''Will'' can be said to be a

       proceeding under the Act or not, is a moot question

       which requires consideration.

      

      (26) It is well-established principle of law that the

      burden is on the propounder of the ''Will'' to prove that

      the ''Will'' was executed in his favour by the testator.

      Even if the ''Will'' is not challenged by anybody, but

      still the propounder of the ''Will'' has to discharge his

      burden and no decree can be passed even by the Civil

      Court merely on the ground that the respondents have

      chosen not to appear before it or have failed to file their

      written statement as provided under Order 8 Rule 10

      CPC.”


9.    Further, the similar view which was taken by this Court on the


earlier occasion has also been affirmed by the Division Bench of this


Court in the Writ Appeal in the case of Murari (supra). Thus, it is


clear that the revenue authorities have no jurisdiction to decide the


correctness and genuineness of a “Will” and if the propounder of the


“Will” wants to take advantage of the “Will”, then he has to get his


title declared from the Civil Court of competent jurisdiction.

       

            THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH

                    Writ Petition No.6695/2013

               Smt. Ramkali Vs. Banmali and another


Gwalior, Dated :17/02/2021


     

Print Page