Showing posts with label second revision. Show all posts
Showing posts with label second revision. Show all posts

Saturday, 18 May 2024

Bombay HC: Second revision filed by a party who is aggrieved by order of Session judge in revision is maintainable

A plain reading and construction of these two provisions shows that the Legislature intended that an aggrieved person choosing the forum before the Sessions Judge shall be bound by his verdict which shall be final so far he is concerned and he shall be precluded from filing another revision before the High Court and by necessary implication it further means that so far as unsuccessful or aggrieved person by the order the Sessions Judge is concerned, the decision is not conclusive or final for him and a remedy of a revision to the High Court is not barred. If the Legislature really intended to make no distinction between an unsuccessful or successful party before the Sessions Judge in revision and intended that there shall be no further or second revision in any event irrespective of who moved the Sessions Judge and who wins and who loses before the Sessions Judge, the Legislature could have enacted that if an application for revision has been made by any party to the Sessions Judge or to the High Court, no further application shall be entertained by either of them.


19. We are, therefore, of the view that a revision to the High Court would be tenable at the instance of a party who is unsuccessful before the Sessions Judge, or who is aggrieved by his order. In other words, a concurrent finding of the Sessions Judge and of the Courts below becomes final, but when the Sessions Judge reverses the order of the Court below in revision the defeated party is not precluded from moving the High Court. The consensus of judicial opinion as can be seen supports only this view.


20. We, therefore, hold that these two criminal applications filed here by the persons who were non-applicants before the Sessions Judge in the Criminal Revisions and who are aggrieved by the decisions of the Sessions Judge are tenable and competent. There is no need to convert these petitions into applications under Section 482 of the Code. These criminal revisions shall be dealt with and disposed of by the learned single Judge according to law.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Criminal Revn, Appl. Nos. 120 of 1978 and 158 of 1977

Decided On: 14.04.1980

Inayatullah Rizwi Vs. Rahimatullah and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

P.G. Palshikar and M.R. Waikar, JJ.

Author: M.R. Waikar, J.

Citation: MANU/MH/0015/1980,1981 Cri L J 1398 (Bom) (DB).

Print Page

Allahabad HC: Second revision against the same order by different party maintainable.

Interpreting the provisions of Section 397(3) of the Code, the Apex Court in the case of Dharampal MANU/SC/0214/1993 (supra) has held that even within the scope of inherent powers under Section 482 of the Code, a power cannot be exercised by the Court which is expressly barred under the Code and a second revision at the instance of the same party is not maintainable. In the case of Ramesh Chandra Saxena 1998 All LJ 1553 : 1988 Cri LJ 3794 (supra), the learned Single Judge of this Court has followed the same principles. He has, however, with the help of Full Bench decision of this Court in H. K. Raval v. Nidhi Prakash MANU/UP/0432/1989 has also observed that once a revisional power has been exercised on the application of the accused recourse to second revision by exercising power under Section 482, Cr. P. C. cannot be bad. In Dharam Pal's case (supra), the Apex Court has laid down the principle that second revision application before the High Court should not be entertained in the garb of a petition for exercise of its inherent powers under Section 482, Gr. P, C. but at the same time this bar has been created for the party who had moved the revisional Court of Sessions Judge and the second revision is also filed by him before the High Court. It has been observed in para 4 of the Judgment "Hence, the High Court had clearly erred in entertaining the second revision at the instance of first party." {Para 8}

9. In the present case, the first party Shri Ram Chaubey had filed revision against the order of the Magistrate dated 21-12-1985 and the revisionist before this Court is the second party-Kailash Nath; therefore, this revision at the instance of the second party cannot be said to be not maintainable.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF ALLAHABAD

Criminal Revn. No. 886 of 1986

Decided On: 10.12.2003

Kailash Nath Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Umeshwar Pandey, J.

Citation: – 2004 (1) Crimes 459 (All),MANU/UP/0986/2003.
Print Page

Under which circumstances second revision is maintainable before high court?

On the maintainability of the revision application before it, the High Court took an erroneous view. The provisions of Sub-section (3) of Section 397, relied upon, are in the following terms:

(3) If an application under this section has been made by any person either to the High Court or to the Sessions Judge, no further application by the same reasons shall be entertained by the other of them.

The main judgment of the Judicial Magistrate upholding the Appellants claim for maintenance was in her favour and there was no question of her challenging the same. Her challenge before the Sessions Judge was confined to the part of the order assessing the amount of maintenance, and this issue could not have been raised again by her. Subject to this limitation she was, certainly entitled to invoke the revisional jurisdiction of the High Court, the decision on the merits of her claim went against her for the first time before the Session Judge, and this was the subject matter of her revision before the High Court. She could not, therefore, be said to be making a second attempt when she challenged this order before the High Court. The fact that she had moved before the Sessions Judge against the quantum of maintenance could not be used against her in respect of her right of revision against the Session Judge's order. Accordingly the decision of the High Court on this question is set aside and it is held that the revision petition of the Appellant before the High Court, except the prayer for enhancing the amount was maintainable. {Para 3}

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 579/86

Decided On: 27.01.1988

Bakulabai and Ors. Vs. Gangaram and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Ranganath Misra and L.M. Sharma, JJ.

Author: L.M. Sharma, J.

Citation: (1988) 1 SCC 537.

Print Page

Tuesday, 14 May 2024

Orissa HC: Second revision against fresh order passed by lower court after remand by revisional court maintainable.

It is not understood as to how the Sessions Judge could apply this provision to hold that the revision before the Sessions Judge was barred Under Section 397(3). Cr. P.C. The earlier Criminal Revision which had been filed before the Higli Court had been disposed of directing the trial Court to re-consider the matter and thereafter the trial Court after reconsideration passed a fresh order rejecting the application for recalling the witness. Against the said order, revision was filed before the Sessions Judge. The question as to whether such a revision before the Sessions Judge was maintainable in view of the bar contained in Section 397(2), Cr. P.C. is another matter which need not detain us. The fact remains that the Sessions Judge has not considered the question of maintainability of the revision on the ground of bar Under Section 397(2), but Under Section 397(3), Cr. P.C. Law is well settled that Section 397(3), Cr. P.C. bars a second revision at the instance of the same petitioner. In other words, if an order of the trial Court is challenged before the Sessions Judge or the High Court in revision and such revision is dismissed on merit, a further revision cannot be filed before the High Court or the Sessions Judge, as the case may be, by the party who had unsuccessfully filed the first revision. This does not mean that where a revision has been disposed of with a direction for reconsideration and fresh order is passed by the trial Court on reconsideration, the same cannot be subject to another revision.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA

Original Jurisdiction Case No. 9288 of 1999

Decided On: 06.08.1999

Indrajeet Roy Vs. Republic of India

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

P.K. Misra and R.K. Patra, JJ.

Authored By : P.K. Misra, R.K. Patra

Citation: 1999 CRLJ 4727 (Orissa),MANU/OR/0173/1999.

Print Page