Showing posts with label setting aside auction sale. Show all posts
Showing posts with label setting aside auction sale. Show all posts

Sunday, 28 January 2018

Basic principles to be followed by court while setting aside sale of property sold in execution of decree

The law which governs the controversy involved in this appeal is laid down by this Court in the case of Saheb Khan v. Mohd. Yousufuddin and Ors. MANU/SC/2026/2006 : 2006 (4) SCC 406 (Three Judge Bench). While examining the scope of Order 21 Rule 90 of the Code, Justice Ruma Pal speaking for the Bench held as under:

12. We are unable to sustain the reasoning of the High Court. Order 21 Rule 90 of the Code of Civil Procedure allows, inter alia, any person whose interests are affected by the sale to apply to the court to set aside a sale of immovable property sold in execution of a decree on the ground of "a material irregularity or fraud in publishing or conducting" the sale. Sub-rule (2) of Order 21 Rule 90 however places a further condition on the setting aside of a court sale in the following language:

90. (2) No sale shall be set aside on the ground of irregularity or fraud in publishing or conducting it unless, upon the facts proved, the court is satisfied that the applicant has sustained substantial injury by reason of such irregularity or fraud.

13. Therefore before the sale can be set aside merely establishing a material irregularity or fraud will not do. The applicant must go further and establish to the satisfaction of the court that the material irregularity or fraud has resulted in substantial injury to the applicant. Conversely even if the applicant has suffered substantial injury by reason of the sale, this would not be sufficient to set the sale aside unless substantial injury has been occasioned by a material irregularity or fraud in publishing or conducting the sale. (See Dhirendra Nath Gorai v. Sudhir Chandra Ghosh MANU/SC/0018/1964 : (1964) 6 SCR 1001, Jaswantlal Natvarlal Thakkar v. Sushilaben Manilal Dangarwala MANU/SC/0190/1991 : 1991 Supp(2) SCC 691 and Kadiyala Rama Rao v. Gutala Kahna Rao MANU/SC/0112/2000 : (2000) 3 SCC 87)

14. A charge of fraud or material irregularity Under Order 21 Rule 90 must be specifically made with sufficient particulars. Bald allegations would not do. The facts must be established which could reasonably sustain such a charge.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 5988 of 2007

Decided On: 02.05.2017

Chilamkurti Bala Subrahmanyam  Vs. Samanthapudi Vijaya Lakshmi and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
R.K. Agrawal and Abhay Manohar Sapre, JJ.

Print Page

Wednesday, 20 September 2017

Basic principles for deciding application for setting aside auction sale in execution of decree

 Therefore before the sale can be set aside merely establishing a material irregularity or fraud will not do. The applicant must go further and establish to the satisfaction of the court that the material irregularity or fraud has resulted in substantial injury to the applicant. Conversely even if the applicant has suffered substantial injury by reason of the sale, this would not be sufficient to set the sale aside unless substantial injury has been occasioned by a material irregularity or fraud in publishing or conducting the sale. (See Dhirendra Nath Gorai v. Sudhir Chandra Ghosh MANU/SC/0018/1964 : (1964) 6 SCR 1001, Jaswantlal Natvarlal Thakkar v. Sushilaben Manilal Dangarwala MANU/SC/0190/1991 : 1991 Supp(2) SCC 691 and Kadiyala Rama Rao v. Gutala Kahna Rao MANU/SC/0112/2000 : (2000) 3 SCC 87)

14. A charge of fraud or material irregularity Under Order 21 Rule 90 must be specifically made with sufficient particulars. Bald allegations would not do. The facts must be established which could reasonably sustain such a charge. In the case before us, no such particulars have been given by the Respondent of the alleged collusion between the other Respondents and the auction-purchaser. There is also no material irregularity in publishing or conducting the sale. There was sufficient compliance with Order 21 Rule 67(1) read with Order 21 Rule 54(2).
 The law on the question involved herein is clear. It is not the material irregularity that alone is sufficient for setting aside of the sale. The judgment debtor has to go further and establish to the satisfaction of the Court that the material irregularity or fraud, as the case may be, has resulted in causing substantial injury to the judgment-debtor in conducting the sale. It is only then the sale so conducted could be set aside Under Order 21 Rule 90(2) of the Code. Such is not the case here.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 5988 of 2007

Decided On: 02.05.2017

Chilamkurti Bala Subrahmanyam Vs. Samanthapudi Vijaya Lakshmi and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
R.K. Agrawal and Abhay Manohar Sapre, JJ.
Citation:(2017) 6 SCC770
Print Page

Sunday, 11 June 2017

Whether mortgaged property belonging to joint family can be sold in auction?

 Upon hearing the learned Counsel, we find it quite shocking that against the upset price of Rs. 41,97,550/-, the property has been sold only for Rs. 5,50,000/-. It is an admitted fact that the property belonged to all the family members and the said property was not mortgaged by all, but was mortgaged only by a few family members to secure the debt of Respondent No. 6.
9. The above facts, which are not disputed, clearly reveal irregularities and therefore, the sale in favour of Respondent No. 10 must be set aside, but Respondent No. 10 should also be compensated as he had paid the purchase price of Rs. 5,50,000/- on 16.6.1998 to the Respondent Bank.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Civil Appeal Nos. 3812 of 2016.
Decided On: 29.03.2016
Olinda Femandes

Vs.
Goa State Co-operative Bank Ltd. and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Anil R. Dave and A.K. Goel, JJ.
Citation:(2016) 13 SCC298
Print Page

Friday, 5 May 2017

When auction sale of property in execution proceeding should not be set aside?

Looking to the above said facts and circumstances, when, the fraud alleged has not been established, this Court has to consider whether the judgment debtor has established under Order 21 Rule 90 of CPC that the applicant has sustained substantial injury due to the material irregularity in the conduct of Sale, and the applicant could have taken that ground on or before the date on which the proclamation was ordered.
22. As I have already narrated that mere existence of material irregularity, not by itself a ground for setting aside the sale under the said provision. Therefore, it is clear from the above said provisions that mere irregularity or fraud by themselves are not grounds for setting aside the same. Though irregularity or fraud is established, there must be a substantial injury occasioned by the irregularity or fraud. It depends however upon several relevant facts. There must be an express plea as to substantial injury suffered by the judgment debtor, however, it can also be ascertained if it is implicit in the allegations made in the application. It is the bounden duty of the Court to ascertain even otherwise on the basis of the overall facts and materials on record whether any substantial injury has been occurred due to the material irregularity or any fraud played in conducting the sale. If the Court is of the opinion that there is no substantial injury, even if it is established the existence of material irregularity or fraud, the Court cannot interfere with the sale proceeding.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
M.F.A. No. 1968/2016 (CPC)
Decided On: 10.02.2017
 L. Nanjunda Murthy and Ors.

Vs.
 S. Suresh Reddy and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

K.N. Phaneendra, J.
Citation:AIR 2017 Karnat
Print Page

Sunday, 16 April 2017

Whether auction sell can be set aside on ground of non publication of auction notice in vernacular language?

Non-compliance of statutory requirements of publication of possession notice and auction notice in vernacular language rendered the statutory requirement as farce. There should be purposeful compliance of the provisions of law and it cannot be reduced to an empty formality. The requirement to cause publication in ‘vernacular language’ in the newspaper is fundamental and the statutory requirement which cannot be compromised. It is not for the borrower or guarantor to establish that non-publication of the said notices in -‘vernacular language’ in the newspaper has caused any prejudice to its cause. It is for the Respondents to establish that non compliance of the statutory requirements has not caused any prejudice at all.
42. In view of the above, both the writ petitions succeed and are allowed. All proceedings subsequent to notice under Section 13(4) of the Act, 2002 being in flagrant violation of the statutory provisions are liable to be quashed. The case is squarely covered by the judgments of the Apex Court referred to above, wherein the Apex Court held that not following the statutory provisions itself is a good ground for quashing the confirmed sale.
In the High Court of Allahabad
(Before Mahesh Chandra Tripathi, J.)
Ashok Kumar v.
Authorized Officer, Punjab National Bank And Others .
And
Writ - C No. - 66988 of 2012

Decided on February 10, 2017, 
Citation: 2017 SCCONLINE ALL 333
Print Page

Saturday, 14 January 2017

When application under O 21 R 95 of CPC will not be barred by limitation?


Considering the facts of the present case in the light of the above
principles, in our view, the sale could not have become absolute till the
proceedings in the revision in C.R.P.No.2829/2002 was over and the
revision was disposed of. The judgment-debtor, as discussed earlier, had
filed two applications E.A.No.315/2001- (i) to set aside the sale alleging
that the property was sold for a lower price as a result of which substantial
injury was caused to him and (ii) another application in E.A. No.77/2002-
an application for appointing Advocate-Commissioner to assess the value
of the property. As against the order dismissing E.A.No.77/2002, the
judgment-debtor has filed the revision in C.R.P.No.2829/2002. So long as
the said revision was pending, the court auction sale was yet to become
absolute. For the sake of arguments, assuming that the said revision was
allowed, then in that case the court auction sale would have been set aside
on the ground that the property was sold for a lesser price. Therefore, till
the revision in C.R.P. No. 2829 of 2002 was disposed of in one way or the
other, the sale was yet to become absolute. Be it noted that in Article 134
of the Limitation Act, the legislature has consciously adopted the
expression “when the sale becomes absolute” and not when the sale
was confirmed. As against the order dismissing E.A No.77/2002 since the
revision was preferred by the judgment-debtor and the same came to be
disposed of on 9th July, 2003 the sale became absolute only on 9th July,

2003. The application filed under Order XXI Rule 95 C.P.C on 30th August,
2003 was well within the period of limitation. In our view, the High Court
was not right in holding that the application under Order XXI Rule 95 C.P.C
was barred by limitation and the impugned order cannot be sustained.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO.4204 OF 2007

UNITED FINANCE CORPORATION  Vs. M.S.M. HANEEFA 

Dated:January 11, 2017.
Print Page

Thursday, 26 May 2016

When Auction sale should not be set aside?

Above all, clause 2 of Rule 90, Order XXI CPC requires the J.Dr. to demonstrate the substantial injury sustained by him by reason of any irregularity or fraud either in publishing or conducting the sale of immovable property, for the Court to be satisfied to set aside the sale so conducted. It is thus, clear that it is not every irregularity, which can fetch a satisfaction for the Court to set aside the sale conducted. The irregularity must be of such a grave nature and magnitude that it should result in causing substantial injury to the interest of the J.Dr.
The Supreme Court has spelt out the principle in this regard in Saheb Khan v. Mohd.Yusufuddin and others in the following words of Justice Ruma Pal speaking for a three-Judge bench:
Therefore before the sale can be set aside merely establishing a material irregularity or fraud will not do. The applicant must go further and establish to the satisfaction of the court that the material irregularity or fraud has resulted in substantial injury to the applicant. Conversely even if the applicant has suffered substantial injury by reason of the sale, this would not be sufficient to set the sale aside unless substantial injury has been occasioned by a material irregularity or fraud in publishing or conducting the sale. (See: Dhirendra Nath Gorai and Suibal Chandra Shaw and Ors. v. Sudhir Chandra Ghosh and Ors.(1964) 6 SCC 101; Jaswantlal Natvarlal thakkar v. Sushilaben Manilal Dangarwala and Ors. (1991) Supp.2 SCC 691; Kadiyala Rama Rao v. Gutala Kahna Rao (dead) by L.Rs and others (2000)3 SCC 87).
In the instant case, no such substantial injury suffered by the J.Dr. was either urged or demonstrated.
Hence, I do not find any merit in the appeal preferred by the Judgment Debtor and hence it deserves to be dismissed.
Andhra High Court
Ch.Mahender vs D.Venkat Reddy And 3 Others on 21 August, 2015
THE HONBLE SRI JUSTICE NOOTY RAMAMOHANA RAO

CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL No.421 OF 2015 and batch         

Citation;AIR 2016 (NOC)287 HYD
Print Page