Showing posts with label stay application. Show all posts
Showing posts with label stay application. Show all posts

Sunday, 15 November 2015

Whether session court can insist for presence of complainant for hearing of stay application after admitting appeal against conviction in cheque dishonour case?

 Be that as it may, this is a case where the learned Sessions Judge on July 28, 2014
passed an order in connection with Criminal Appeal No. 29/2014 and on that date, the
appeal has been admitted. However, he did not pass any order staying the operation of the
order of sentence and compensation. In all likely, the learned Sessions Judge has
overlooked the provision of sub-Section (2) of Section 357 Cr. P.C. According to the said
provision, if fine is imposed in a case which is subject to an appeal, no such payment shall
be made before the period allowed for presenting the appeal has elapsed, if an appeal be
presented, before the decision of the appeal. Therefore, according to the mandate of law,
since the appeal is admitted, the learned Sessions Judge was bound to stay the realization
of fine. Furthermore, the learned Judge might direct the petitioners to deposit a portion of
the compensation amount in the Trial Court but his approach in non-considering the
question of stay of the order of payment of fine and compensation, unless the complainant
appeared in court, is totally erroneous, improper and not in accordance with law. Judicial
discretion must always be supported by reason and justification and same cannot be
arbitrary and fanciful. When the learned Judge found merits in the appeal and categorically
recorded that there are grounds for admission and admitted the appeal, it is totally unjust
not to consider the question of stay of fine and compensation, more particularly, on the
face of provisions of sub-section 4 of section 357 CrPC. In any event, the learned Judge
should have taken up the matter for consideration of stay of fine and compensation, when
from the postal records, it is found that the complainant was avoiding the court process. 3
 Having regard to above, it is directed within a week from the date of communication
of this order the Appeal court shall dispose of the question of stay of fine and
compensation without insisting presence of the complainant.


In the High Court at Calcutta

Criminal Revisional Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present
The Hon’ble Justice Ashim Kumar Roy
CRR No. 3685 of 2014
Nand Kishore Bhagat @ N. K. Bhagat & Anr.
Versus
Biswakantha Dey & Anr.

Judgment on : 16-01-2015
Citation;2015(3)crimes 623 cal
Print Page

Wednesday, 6 March 2013

Leading judgment on Fixation of compensation by appellate court while granting stay to eviction decree


 What emerge from these are:-
(a) The basic burden lies upon the landlord to prove and support his case of reasonable compensation/ mesne profits. He must put on record material documents/ along with the affidavit to support his case of enhanced compensation. The material if placed by the landlord / Licensor / Owner, the Court needs to consider the said material by giving full opportunity to the tenant / Licensee / Occupant / trespasser / obstructionists. Keeping in mind the effect of valuation or architecture's report / opinion and its validity being expert's opinion, which can be subjected to challenge from other side, if case is made out. (Jawajee Nagnatham Vs. Revenue Divisional Officer, Adilabad, A.P. & Ors., (1994) 4, S.C.C. 595.).
595.)
(b) The valuation report / opinion may be at least one of the government recognized valuer, apart from private valuer report, if any. Both the parties are free to ( 13 )
submit their material on the record to support their case through their respective affidavits. (The Special Land Acquisition Officer Vs. Sri Siddappa Omanna Tumari & Ors., A.I.R. 1995 S.C.840).
(c) The Court also needs to consider the principle of Order 20 Rule 12 of the C.P.C. while determining this ad-interim compensation/ mesne profits. The Court also needs to keep in mind as observed in Para 8 in Atma Ram (supra) "quantified by this Court in this order, is only a tentative opinion formed by the Court on the basis of material made available for the parties".
(d) The Court, needs to consider and take note of (i) the Rent Control Legislation, governing the particular premises/ residential or non-residential. (ii) the Location/ area of the premises (iii) the age/ nature of construction of the building/premises (iv) the facilities in the premises and outside the premises, advantages and disadvantages (v) the market value and the rental value of the premises based on architecture / expert / valuation reports / opinion (vi) other instances of the rent / license fees of similarly situated premises (vii) the date of termination of the tenancy / license.
(e) The Court also needs to consider that the compensation was awarded as condition precedent should not be oppressive and unreasonable which in a given case, if tenant failed to pay, has no option but to ( 15 )
suffer the execution of a decree, as observed by the Apex Court. Niyas Ahmed (supra).
(supra) The user and the use
of the premises are also material.
(f) The market value changes with time. The stamp duty is also changes accordingly. The rent/ license fee/ compensation so fixed at the interim period, based upon the market value may in a given case needs to be changed or re-fixed if case is made out. It may go up or go down if market value changes drastically.
(g) One cannot overlook that at the time of basic agreement, both the parties mutually agreed to the particular rent/ Leave license fee irrespective of valuation of the property. Now, when the Court fixes the compensation/ license fee, after termination of the tenancy, there is no question of any agreed rent or compensation. The Court decides the same based upon the material available/ placed on the record read with other various factors as referred in the Judgment.
(h) One important aspect is that the Court, after giving opportunities to both the parties, needs to decide the interim and urgent issue of grant of provisional fair and reasonable compensation/occupation charges, based ( 16 )
upon authenticated material produced on the record, pending the Appeal, summarily. There is no question of detail trial, but it is an essential condition precedent to grant stay of the eviction decree/order on the footing of Order 41, Rule 5 of Civil Procedure Code. The final decision of the appeal should be uninfluenced by such tentative figure / order. Such provisional payment should be condition precedent but it is always adjustable. The amount so fixed in such proceedings is tentative figure. Such interim order/ payment is always subject to the final result of the appeal.
(i) The cases governing the leave and licence agreement as contemplated under the Mah. Rent Act need to be decided on the basis of the provisions of the Mah. Rent Act, as it provides and empowers the Competent Authority to pass an appropriate order that licensee, after expiry of leave and licence agreement, to pay double the agreed compensation/licence fee, pending the application for eviction. But there is no provision of such double licence fee pending the Appeal under the Mah. Rent Act. Therefore, in such cases in absence of any provision, the Appellate Court may pass appropriate order, considering various factors as referred above. ( 17 )




(j) The cases of trespasser, unauthorised occupant, obstructionist need to be dealt with again on different footing than that of a regular tenant/protected tenant/licensee as they are not governed by the Rent Control Legislation. Such unauthorised or illegal occupants, based upon the material produced on record, after giving opportunity to them may be directed to pay such occupation charges/compensation, pending the Appeal, at the current market rate/ rent which may be determined by the Court, taking note of interest of both the parties.

Bombay High Court
Chandrakant Dhanu  vs Sharmila Kapur on 7 January, 2009
Bench: Anoop V.Mohta
Citation:2009(2) MHLJ 243,2009(2) ALLMR73
Print Page