Showing posts with label licence fee. Show all posts
Showing posts with label licence fee. Show all posts

Thursday, 8 June 2023

Is every claim for a license fee for the remainder of a lock-in period in a leave and license agreement considered a claim for damages?

 (e) Every claim for license fee for the remainder of a lock-in period in a leave and license agreement is not per se a claim for damages, liquidated or unliquidated. In a given case, it may be in the nature of either, or in the nature of a penalty, or it may simply be a component of the contractual consideration and therefore a debt properly so-called when the contingency in contemplation comes to pass. This will depend on an interpretation of the contract in question and an assessment of the conduct of the parties.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Company Petition No. 496 of 2013

Decided On: 28.02.2014

 Indiabulls Properties Pvt. Ltd.  Vs. Treasure World Developers Pvt. Ltd.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

G.S. Patel, J.

Citation: MANU/MH/0249/2014,2014 SCCOnLine Bom 4768.

Read full Judgment here: Click here

Print Page

Is a contractual provision for a lock-in period in a leave and license agreement illegal?

The result of this discussion, in summary, is that for the purposes of Section 433 of the Companies Act, 1956:


(a) The liability of the respondent-company must be certain. Where the liability is to be adjudged, i.e., where it remains to be decided by a court whether or not the respondent-company is liable in the first place, there can be no 'debt' within the meaning of the section. The liability of a company is its obligation to pay. The debt is the amount that it is liable to pay.


(b) The debt must an ascertained, or definitely ascertainable, amount, not one that requires adjudication. 13 A claim in damages is no debt. 14


(c) The debt must be a debt now due at the time of presentation of the petition. Any contingency contemplated must be one that has come to pass; it cannot be one yet to occur. 15 It is on the happening of a contingency that a company can be said to be 'indebted'. Should the contingency never happen, there can be no debt .24


(d) A contractual provision in a leave and license agreement for a lock-in period is not per se illegal, unlawful, void or even voidable.


(e) Every claim for license fee for the remainder of a lock-in period in a leave and license agreement is not per se a claim for damages, liquidated or unliquidated. In a given case, it may be in the nature of either, or in the nature of a penalty, or it may simply be a component of the contractual consideration and therefore a debt properly so-called when the contingency in contemplation comes to pass. This will depend on an interpretation of the contract in question and an assessment of the conduct of the parties. {Para 64}

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Company Petition No. 496 of 2013

Decided On: 28.02.2014

 Indiabulls Properties Pvt. Ltd.  Vs. Treasure World Developers Pvt. Ltd.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

G.S. Patel, J.

Citation: MANU/MH/0249/2014,2014 SCCOnLine Bom 4768.

Print Page

Sunday, 15 March 2020

Whether court can grant maintenance charges along with license fees as per O 15A of CPC?

From the aforesaid averments it is clear that the plaintiff has
admitted that it is liable to pay maintenance charges of Rs.25,000/- per
month during the period of Leave and Licence agreement. As stated above
the said agreement specifically refers to various amenities provided by the
licensor and with a view to enable the licensee to enjoy the same the plaintiff
is required to pay Rs.25,000/- per month.
10. The provisions of Section 7(14) of the said Act define the term
“standard rent”. The standard rent in the present case has not been
determined under Section 8 of the said Act. However reading of both the
agreements on the basis of which the plaintiff has been inducted as a
licensee indicates that besides the amount of licence fees, it is also liable to
pay maintenance charges and failure to pay maintenance charges gives a
cause of action to the licensor to terminate the licence.

In Puspa Sen Gupta vs. Susma Ghose (1990) 2 SCC 651 while
considering the provisions of West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1956 and
the question whether the tenant was liable to pay amount of Rs.8/- per
month towards electricity besides Rs.32/- as rent, it was observed that the
expression “rent” was not defined under relevant Act. However on reading
the entire Act, the word “rent” would also include payment in respect of
amenities or services provided by the landlord under the term of tenancy. It
was observed that considering various provisions a tenancy would carry with
it amenities to be provided or services to be maintained by the landlord and
hence the amount of rent would include the amount of electricity charges.
Drawing support from the aforesaid observations it can be said in the facts of
the present case that the plaintiff was liable to pay maintenance charges
besides license fees. This has in fact been admitted by the plaintiff in its
written statement to the counter-claim. In that view of the matter the trial
Court was not justified in refusing to direct the plaintiff to pay Rs.25,000/-
per month towards maintenance charges. The impugned order therefore is
liable to be modified accordingly.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR.
WRIT PETITION NO.3553 OF 2019

 Daksha Jyotindra Patel Vs   Big V. Telecom Pvt. Ltd.


CORAM : A. S. CHANDURKAR, J.

Judgment pronounced on : November 08, 2019
Print Page

Saturday, 22 December 2018

Whether arbitrator can decide claim for recovery of licence fees?

The claim of the applicant for licence fee would fall within the exclusive jurisdiction of Small Causes Court as per section 26 of the Act of 1887 in view of the judgment given by the Full Bench of this Court in the case of Central Warehousing Corporation, Mumbai v. Fortpoint Automotive Pvt. Ltd., Mumbai (supra). There is a dispute as to whether claim in respect of service charges and water charges would also fall within exclusive jurisdiction of Small Causes Court. The learned Advocate for the applicant has submitted that these claims would not fall within the jurisdiction of Court of Small Causes and, therefore, as per Clause (30) of the licence agreement it will have to be resolved by arbitration. The learned Advocates for the non-applicants have submitted that the claim in respect of service charges and the claim in respect of water charges would also fall within the exclusive jurisdiction of Small Causes Court as per section 26 of the Act of 1887. It is submitted that term "charges" used in section 26(1) of the Act of 1887 is wide enough and covers the ancillary charges in addition to the licence fees/charges. As far as the claim of the applicant in respect of penalty is concerned, there is dispute as to whether the claim would fall within exclusive jurisdiction of Small Causes Court.

10. In the above situation, when undisputedly, the claim for recovery of licence fee falls within exclusive jurisdiction of Small Causes Court and as per the proposition laid down in the judgment given by the Full Bench of this Court in the case of Central Warehousing Corporation, Mumbai v. Fortpoint Automotive Pvt. Ltd., Mumbai (supra) in my view, the non-applicant was justified in not taking any steps as per Clause (30) of the licence agreement.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

Misc. Civil Appln. Nos. 1385 to 1395 of 2017

Decided On: 05.04.2018

 Concept Resources, Nagpur Vs. Om Associates, Nagpur

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Z.A. Haq, J.

Citation: 2018(6) MHLJ 207
Print Page

Wednesday, 6 March 2013

Leading judgment on Fixation of compensation by appellate court while granting stay to eviction decree


 What emerge from these are:-
(a) The basic burden lies upon the landlord to prove and support his case of reasonable compensation/ mesne profits. He must put on record material documents/ along with the affidavit to support his case of enhanced compensation. The material if placed by the landlord / Licensor / Owner, the Court needs to consider the said material by giving full opportunity to the tenant / Licensee / Occupant / trespasser / obstructionists. Keeping in mind the effect of valuation or architecture's report / opinion and its validity being expert's opinion, which can be subjected to challenge from other side, if case is made out. (Jawajee Nagnatham Vs. Revenue Divisional Officer, Adilabad, A.P. & Ors., (1994) 4, S.C.C. 595.).
595.)
(b) The valuation report / opinion may be at least one of the government recognized valuer, apart from private valuer report, if any. Both the parties are free to ( 13 )
submit their material on the record to support their case through their respective affidavits. (The Special Land Acquisition Officer Vs. Sri Siddappa Omanna Tumari & Ors., A.I.R. 1995 S.C.840).
(c) The Court also needs to consider the principle of Order 20 Rule 12 of the C.P.C. while determining this ad-interim compensation/ mesne profits. The Court also needs to keep in mind as observed in Para 8 in Atma Ram (supra) "quantified by this Court in this order, is only a tentative opinion formed by the Court on the basis of material made available for the parties".
(d) The Court, needs to consider and take note of (i) the Rent Control Legislation, governing the particular premises/ residential or non-residential. (ii) the Location/ area of the premises (iii) the age/ nature of construction of the building/premises (iv) the facilities in the premises and outside the premises, advantages and disadvantages (v) the market value and the rental value of the premises based on architecture / expert / valuation reports / opinion (vi) other instances of the rent / license fees of similarly situated premises (vii) the date of termination of the tenancy / license.
(e) The Court also needs to consider that the compensation was awarded as condition precedent should not be oppressive and unreasonable which in a given case, if tenant failed to pay, has no option but to ( 15 )
suffer the execution of a decree, as observed by the Apex Court. Niyas Ahmed (supra).
(supra) The user and the use
of the premises are also material.
(f) The market value changes with time. The stamp duty is also changes accordingly. The rent/ license fee/ compensation so fixed at the interim period, based upon the market value may in a given case needs to be changed or re-fixed if case is made out. It may go up or go down if market value changes drastically.
(g) One cannot overlook that at the time of basic agreement, both the parties mutually agreed to the particular rent/ Leave license fee irrespective of valuation of the property. Now, when the Court fixes the compensation/ license fee, after termination of the tenancy, there is no question of any agreed rent or compensation. The Court decides the same based upon the material available/ placed on the record read with other various factors as referred in the Judgment.
(h) One important aspect is that the Court, after giving opportunities to both the parties, needs to decide the interim and urgent issue of grant of provisional fair and reasonable compensation/occupation charges, based ( 16 )
upon authenticated material produced on the record, pending the Appeal, summarily. There is no question of detail trial, but it is an essential condition precedent to grant stay of the eviction decree/order on the footing of Order 41, Rule 5 of Civil Procedure Code. The final decision of the appeal should be uninfluenced by such tentative figure / order. Such provisional payment should be condition precedent but it is always adjustable. The amount so fixed in such proceedings is tentative figure. Such interim order/ payment is always subject to the final result of the appeal.
(i) The cases governing the leave and licence agreement as contemplated under the Mah. Rent Act need to be decided on the basis of the provisions of the Mah. Rent Act, as it provides and empowers the Competent Authority to pass an appropriate order that licensee, after expiry of leave and licence agreement, to pay double the agreed compensation/licence fee, pending the application for eviction. But there is no provision of such double licence fee pending the Appeal under the Mah. Rent Act. Therefore, in such cases in absence of any provision, the Appellate Court may pass appropriate order, considering various factors as referred above. ( 17 )




(j) The cases of trespasser, unauthorised occupant, obstructionist need to be dealt with again on different footing than that of a regular tenant/protected tenant/licensee as they are not governed by the Rent Control Legislation. Such unauthorised or illegal occupants, based upon the material produced on record, after giving opportunity to them may be directed to pay such occupation charges/compensation, pending the Appeal, at the current market rate/ rent which may be determined by the Court, taking note of interest of both the parties.

Bombay High Court
Chandrakant Dhanu  vs Sharmila Kapur on 7 January, 2009
Bench: Anoop V.Mohta
Citation:2009(2) MHLJ 243,2009(2) ALLMR73
Print Page