Showing posts with label subsequent stage. Show all posts
Showing posts with label subsequent stage. Show all posts

Monday, 2 October 2017

Whether order bringing legal representatives on record would enure for subsequent stages of suit?

Let us now consider the question on principle. A combined reading of Order XXII, Rules 3, 4 and 11, of the Code of Civil Procedure shows that the doctrine of abatement applies equally to a suit as well as to an appeal. In the application of the said Rules 3 and 4 to an appeal, instead of "plaintiff" and "defendant", "appellant" and "respondent" have to be read in those rules. Prima facie, therefore, if a respondent dies and his legal representatives are not brought on record within the prescribed time, the appeal abates as against the respondent under r. 4, read with r. 11, of O. XXII of the Code of Civil Procedure. But there is another principle recognized by the Judicial Committee in the aforesaid decision which softens the rigour of this rule. The said principle is that if the legal representatives are brought on record within the prescribed time at one stage of the suit, it will enure for the benefit of all the subsequent stages of the suit. The application of this principle to different situations will help to answer the problem presented in the present case. (1) A filed a suit against B for the recovery of possession and mesne profits. After the issues were framed, B died. At the stage of an interlocutory application for production of documents, the legal representatives of B were brought on record within the time prescribed. The order bringing them on record would enure for the benefit of the entire suit. (2) The suit was decreed and an appeal was filed in the High Court and was pending therein. The defendant died and his legal representatives were brought on record. The suit was subsequently remanded to the trial Court. The order bringing the legal representatives on record in the appeal would enure for the further stages of the suit. (3) An appeal was filed against an interlocutory order made in a suit. Pending the appeal the defendant died and his legal representatives were brought on record. The appeal was dismissed. The appeal being a continuation or a stage of the suit, the order bringing the legal representatives on record would enure for the subsequent stages of the suit. This would be so whether in the appeal the trial Court's order was confirmed, modified or reversed. In the above 3 illustrations one fact is common, namely, the order bringing on record the legal representatives was made at one stage of the suit, be it in the suit or in an appeal against the interlocutory order or final order made in the suit, for an appeal is only a continuation of the suit. Whether the appellant order confirms that of the first Court, modifies or reverses it, it replaces or substitutes the order appealed against. It takes its place in the suit and becomes a part of it. It is as it were the suit was brought to the appellate Court at one stage and the orders made therein were made in the suit itself. Therefore, that order enures for the subsequent stages of the suit.

13. But the same legal position cannot be invoked in the reverse or converse situation. A suit is not a continuation of an appeal. An order made in a suit subsequent to the filing of an appeal at an earlier stage will move forward with the subsequent stages of the suit or appeals taken therefrom; but it cannot be projected backwards into the appeal that has already been filed. It cannot possibly become an order in the appeal. Therefore, the order bringing the legal representatives of the 7th respondent on record in the final decree proceedings cannot enure for the benefit of the appeal filed against the preliminary decree. We, therefore, hold that the appeal abated so far as the 7th respondent was concerned.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Miscellaneous Petition Nos. 2402 of 1964

Decided On: 01.03.1965

Rangubai Kom Shankar Jagtap Vs.  Sunderabai Bhratar Sakharam Jedhe and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
J.C. Shah, K. Subba Rao and R.S. Bachawat, JJ.
Citation:(1966)1 SCA 29,68 BOM LR 26
Print Page

Wednesday, 21 June 2017

Whether additional grounds can be raised in appeal at subsequent stage?

As regards the raising of additional grounds, it is the case of the applicants that they did not know the actual contents in the order dated 17.09.2014 in A.No.4969 of 2014 passed by the learned Master, as the copy of the same was not furnished to them. Only in the course of enquiry by this Court in the earlier Application Nos. 6809 to 6811 of 2014 etc., the respondent herein had filed a copy of the order dated 17.09.2014 in A.No.4969 of 2014 passed by the learned Master, in the typed set of papers dated 08.12.2014 before this Court. After knowing the text of the order dated 17.09.2014 passed in Application No. 4969 of 2014, by the learned Master, from the typed set of papers submitted by the respondent herein, dated 08.12.2014, the applicants herein have filed the Application No. 1160 of 2015 seeking permission to raise additional grounds in the appeal preferred by the applicants against the order dated 17.09.2014. Under such circumstances, I find that the applicants have given sufficient reason in the affidavit to raise additional grounds. Hence, I am of the opinion that as sufficient reasons have been shown, the application in A.No.1160 of 2015 for raising additional grounds, also deserves to be allowed and accordingly, the same is allowed as prayed for.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADRAS
A. Nos. 1156 to 1160 of 2015 in E.P. No. 48 of 1997 in C.S. No. 43 of 1962
Decided On: 16.06.2016
 S.V.R. Saroja and Ors.

Vs.

 S.V. Matha Prasad

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

R. Subbiah, J.


Citation: AIR 2017 (NOC) 145 Mad

Print Page

Saturday, 17 June 2017

Whether court can permit examination of party to suit at subsequent stage?

Learned counsel for the sole respondent, on the other hand, has
opposed the prayer and has placed reliance of the Order XVIII Rule 3-A of the
Code of Civil Procedure, which reads as follows :
“Party to appear before other witnesses - Where a party himself
wishes to appear as a witness, he shall so appear before any other
witness on his behalf has been examined, unless the Court, for
reasons to be recorded, permits him to appear as his on witness at a
later stage.”
It is submitted by the learned counsel for the sole respondent that
since two witnesses have already been examined in presence of the election
petitioner, the election petitioner himself cannot examine as a witness now. It is
submitted that if the election petitioner desired to be examined at a later stage, he
should have filed the application for the same on the same date, but he did not
seek the permission of the Court for his examination at a later stage and allowed
the other witnesses to be examined in his presence. Alternatively, it is submitted
by the learned counsel for the sole respondent that in any event, the election
petitioner should be examined after the examination of all the witnesses.
Having heard the learned counsels for both the parties, I am of the
considered view that the Order XVIII Rule 3-A of the Code of Civil Procedure is
not an absolute bar for examination of party to a suit at a later stage. There is
always a discretion of the Court to allow the party to be examined at the later
stage. Even Section 87 of the Representation of the People Act only states that the
procedure applicable under the Code of Civil Procedure for the trial of the suits
shall be followed by the High Court while trying an election petition, as nearly as
may be. There is no requirement of strict adherence to the provisions of CPC,
while trying an election petition.
In view of the aforesaid discussions, it is directed that the election
petitioner shall be examined in the case as witness on the next date. 
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
 E.P No. 11 of 2015

Krishna Nand Tripathi.
 V
Alok Chaurasiya .
CORAM :  MR. JUSTICE H. C. MISHRA

 Dated:19.8.2016.
Citation: AIR 2017 Jharkhand 22
Print Page