Showing posts with label summary dismissal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label summary dismissal. Show all posts

Sunday, 18 February 2018

Whether appellate bench of small causes is bound to give reasons while summarily dismissing appeal?

Apart from this, matters which arise under the Rent act are very importance and often involve large claims important, rights. Even court it has got revision jurisdiction in the such matters. If no reasons are assigned the High Courts is not in a position to ascertain how the court without assistance from the judgment of the subordinate court has to waste much time in investigating the matter which can hardly be justified. In order that the appeal court should assist the High court it ought to record its reasons in short even when it dismisses the appeal summarily.

(9) The effect of not requiring to give reasons can be appreciated in case like the present. The trial court held that the notice was bad on the ground that it was only by the notice that the permitted increases were demanded by the landlord. In the view of the trial court, before a notice is given there must be an earlier intimation of the increase in the standard rent which apparently, is not warranted by the Rent Act. Certainly the question is very important question and unless the Appellate court gave it reasons why it agreed with the trial court the High court would not be in apposition to know how the appeal was disposed of. We may also incidentally point out that in Rajpati Sudama v. Taj Mohamed Rustom Khan 66 Bom LR 258, this court disagreed with the small causes court and held after considering the relevant provisions of the Rent act that it is not necessary to give intimation of the permitted increases and of the permitted incensing before sending a formal notice to the before the filing of suit.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Civil Revn. Appln No. 953 of 1960

Decided On: 27.11.1964

 Gangabai Tokarsy Vs. Gaurishankar Chhintarmal Gupta

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
D.V. Patel and V.D. Tulzapurkar, JJ.

Citation: AIR 1966 Bom 34
Print Page

Wednesday, 20 January 2016

Whether appeal filed by victim can be summarily dismissed?

 Thus,
appeal preferred by the accused against his conviction under
Section 374 can also be dismissed summarily after following
procedure prescribed under Section 384 of Cr. P.C.  In other
words, that appeal also need not be automatically admitted for
final hearing.   Hence, it cannot be accepted that an appeal
against   acquittal   filed   by   the   victim   cannot   be   summarily
dismissed. The presumption of innocence of acquitted accused

is   more   strong   and   hence   in   appeal,   scope   of   interference
therewith lies in narrow compass.
Section   372   of   Cr.   P.C.   only   dispenses   with
procedural requirement of securing leave.  Earlier, in absence
of that leave, the appeal presented by such victim could not
have been touched.   After such leave is granted in terms of
provisions   contained   in   High   Court   Appellate   Side   Rules
(supra), the petition seeking leave itself becomes an appeal as
it is entertained by High Court.  Section 372 of Cr. P.C. which
gives right of appeal to victim, therefore, does not expect him
to obtain leave of High Court for that purpose.  However, the
question whether that appeal has any merit or not or in other
words whether it can be summarily dismissed under Section
384 or not, can still be examined by this Court.  Hearing for
admission inherent in unamended provisions of Cr. P.C. read
with Chapter XXVI of High Court Appellate Side Rules, 1960,
is not deleted while giving the victim, a right of appeal under
new Section 372 of Cr. P.C.  It cannot be said that appeal of
victim is placed at higher pedestal or in any way becomes
superior   as   compared   with   appeal   of   accused   against   his

conviction or any other appeal against acquittal of accused.
Therefore, mere deletion of requirement of obtaining leave by
conferring a right of appeal upon the accused, does not mean
that such appeal is automatically admitted for final hearing.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
NAGPUR BENCH
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.  156  OF  2015

Manikrao s/o Bapurao Kale,

Versus
 Vasantrao Vishwasrao Charjan,

         CORAM :   B.P. DHARMADHIKARI &
P.N. DESHMUKH, JJ.

DATE OF PRONOUNCEMENT   : JULY  08, 2015.
Citation;2015 ALLMR(CRI)4754
Print Page