Showing posts with label summons case. Show all posts
Showing posts with label summons case. Show all posts

Tuesday, 25 June 2024

Questions and answers on law(Part 71)

 Q 1:- What is basic concept of universal donee?

Ans:- Section 128 in The Transfer Of Property Act, 1882

128. Universal donee.—

Subject to the provisions of section 127, where a gift consists of the donor’s whole property, the donee is personally liable for all the debts due by and liabilities of the donor at the time of the gift to the extent of the property comprised therein.Q 2 :- What is difference between  warrant and summons case?
Print Page

Tuesday, 27 July 2021

Under which circumstances Magistrate can stop proceeding in summons case U/S 258 of CRPC(Old S 249 of CRPC)?

 That order was challenged in the High Court of Bombay at Nagpur and it was held that: -

"Where the Magistrate comes to the conclusion that no case, not even a prima facie case, under Section 447, I.P.C., was made out, he is perfectly justified in stopping the proceedings under Section 249, Criminal P.C. without first following the procedure under Sections 242 to 244, Criminal P.C. The words of Section 251-A (2), Criminal P.C., cannot be read into Section 249, Criminal P.C., and the Magistrate before releasing the accused under Section 249, need not hear the accused and the complainant".

It was also held that the use of the word "discharge" by the Magistrate in his order under Section 249, merely amounts to a release of the accused and stopping of the proceedings without a conviction or an acquittal. This appears to be quite a contrary view to the one taken by the Madhya Pradesh High Court in the case of 1962 (1) Cri LJ 817 (MP), referred to hereabove and relied upon by the learned Sessions Judge. To say that in every such case where the summons procedure is to be followed contemplated under Chapter XX, the case must necessarily proceed and must end in acquittal or conviction of the accused, can make Section 249 nugatory. It will be of no consequence if no such power existed in the Magistrate. There may arise cases in which on the face of it taking all the averments made in the accusation contained in the complaint may not constitute any offence at all or where any such complaint would become invalid for want of any particular formality to be gone into. There may arise cases where on account of certain technical defects in any such prosecution there would not arise any purpose for proceeding with the matter till the end. At the same time there may arise some cases in which after the evidence of the complainant is over, and which does not help his case, it may not require to call upon the accused to meet the accusation as was found in the Bombay Case and in those circumstances which can be characterised as Special or unusual which make it difficult or impossible to proceed in the normal way or that by reason of such circumstances the Court considers highly necessary to proceed further in the matter in which event it will be open to the Magistrate to exercise such powers and stop the proceedings without pronouncing any judgment either of acquittal or conviction and would be justified in releasing the accused. With respect, therefore, while I amendment unable to agree with the view taken by the High Court of Madhya Pradesh in the decision referred to hereabove, I agree with the view taken by the High Court of Bombay in the decision referred to above and at the same time observe that such powers have to be sparingly used and that too particularly in the exceptional or unusual circumstances attending the case. The order of releasing the accused, therefore, under Section 249 cannot be said to be in any way so illegal or wrong on a consideration of the effect of Section 249 of the Code.

Gujarat High Court
The State Of Gujarat vs Sanghar Ibrahim Ladha on 9 March, 1970
Equivalent citations: AIR 1971 Guj 148, 1971 CriLJ 949, (1971) 0 GLR 503

Bench: N Shelat
Print Page

Friday, 25 October 2019

Supreme Court: Court can not discharge accused in summons case

The next challenge of the learned counsel for the appellant made to the finding of the High Court that once a plea is recorded in a summons case it is not open to the accused person to seek a discharge cannot also be accepted. The case involving a summons case is covered by Chapter XX of the Code which does not contemplates a stage of discharge like Section 239 which provides for a discharge in a warrant case. Therefore, in our opinion the High Court was correct in coming to the conclusion once the plea of the accused is recorded under Section 252 of the Code the procedure contemplated under Chapter XX has to be followed which is to take the trial to its logical conclusion.

17. As observed by us in Adalat Prasad's case the only remedy available to an aggrieved accused to challenge an order in an interlocutory stage is the extraordinary remedy under Section 482 of the Code and not by way of an application to recall the summons or to seek discharge which is not contemplated in the trial of a summons case.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 1253 of 2002

Decided On: 17.09.2004

Subramanium Sethuraman Vs. State of Maharashtra and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
N. Santosh Hegde, S.B. Sinha and Tarun Chatterjee, JJ.

Citation: (2004) 13 SCC 324
Print Page

Friday, 2 December 2016

Whether court can discharge accused in summons case?

Since the present case is a case instituted upon

a complaint, the court below was perfectly correct in

holding that since the case was being tried following the

procedure for summons case, the court below had no

jurisdiction to discharge the revision petitioner after his

appearance before the court in response to the summons

issued from the court.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

                                                PRESENT:

                   MR. JUSTICE B.SUDHEENDRA KUMAR

          10TH DAY OF MARCH 2016

                                    Crl.Rev.Pet.No. 27 of 2012 

      ALIYAR, 
Vs

         THE FOOD INSPECTOR
          Citation: 2016 CRLJ4255 Kerala
Print Page

Sunday, 11 October 2015

Whether dismissal of complaint case for non-appearance of complainant in warrant trial will amount to discharge of accused?

So far as the accused is concerned, dismissal of a complaint for non-appearance of the complainant or his discharge or acquittal on the same ground is a final order and in the absence of any specific provision in the Code, a Magistrate cannot exercise any inherent jurisdiction."
From the aforesaid judgment of the Apex Court no doubt is left and rather law has been settled that dismissal of a complaint for non-appearance of the complainant in the warrant case would result in discharge and that would be final order and similarly the dismissal of the complainant for non-appearance of the complainant in the summons case would result in acquittal and the same would be final order and in the absence of any specific provision in the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, the Magistrate cannot revive the said order. That being the settled legal position, making of an application by the complainant on 21-9-1991 for restoration of the complaint was wholly misplaced and misconceived and therefore cannot be said to be done in good faith and the order passed by the trial Court on that application restoring and reviving the complaint was also not only erroneous but without jurisdiction and further proceedings pursuant thereto were also non est and void.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Criminal Application No. 1061 of 1994
Decided On: 17.08.1995

Narayandas Gulabchand Agrawal Vs. Rakesh Kumar S/o Nem Kumar Porwal

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

R.M. Lodha, J.

Citation: 1996 CivilCC 592, 1996 CriLJ 29, 1996(2)MhLJ463


Print Page