Showing posts with label voters list. Show all posts
Showing posts with label voters list. Show all posts

Sunday, 14 August 2016

What is duty of court if he is allowing production of voter list at stage of final argument?

Exhibit Nos. 6, 7 and 8 are the certified copies of voter
list of village-Kudahansa of the year 1973, 1980 and 1983
respectively. Those were admitted into evidence and marked as
exhibits at the stage of the argument. Thus, defendants had no
opportunity to adduce any rebuttal evidence to the same or crossexamine
the witnesses of the plaintiffs in that regard. Exhibits 6, 7
and 8 are public documents and admissible in evidence. But that by
itself does not prove the entries made in it. Onus is on the plaintiffs
to prove the entries made in Exhibits 6, 7 and 8. The Court has
discretion under Order 13 Rule 1 C.P.C. to accept any document 
produced belatedly if good cause is shown to its satisfaction. This
Court in the case of Bhikari Charan Patra vs Basanti Bewa And
Ors., reported in AIR 1985 Ori 49 held as under:-
11. Whereas the object of Order 13, Rule 1 is
to lay down the stage when a party shall file
documentary evidence so that each knows on
what document the other seeks to rely and gets
ready for the trial, Order 13, Rule 2 makes
provision for meeting certain contingencies. The
object of the rules is not to penalize the party
but to secure a fair trial of the case, Where
Order 13, Rule 2 is invoked mala fide, where the
move is to cause delay or is vexatious, the cause
shown cannot be held to be good cause shown to
the satisfaction of the Court. The doors of the
discretionary jurisdiction should be closed.
Where, however, the document is vital and
would assist the Court in coming to a decision,
the doors should not be shut out.”
Where however, documentary evidence is sought to be introduced,
the Court has duty to scrutinize the cause shown by the party
seeking introduction of documentary evidence before exercising the
discretion and also to give opportunity to the adversary to explain
the documents so produced by adducing rebuttal evidence. This view
gets support from decisions of this Court in the case of Keshaba
Padhan alias Sukru and others Vs. Mst. Padma Padhani
(having died) Upasi Gurandi and others, reported in 1976 (1)
CWR 154 and Property Association of Baptist Churches Private
Limited and another Vs. State of Orissa and others, reported in
1984 (I) OLR 166.11
In the instant cases, no good reason has been assigned
by learned trial Court to accept Exts. 6, 7 and 8 at the stage of
argument of the suit. it is also not clear as to whether any prayer for
seeking leave of the Court was made to adduce further documentary
evidence at a belated stage. In addition to it, neither any opportunity
was given to the defendant to cross-examine the plaintiffs on Exts. 6,
7 and 8 nor they were allowed to adduce rebuttal evidence on the
same.
Further, the entries in Exts. 6, 7, and 8 does not by
itself conclusively prove that plaintiff No.1 was the son of Dubraj
through his first wife. Learned Civil Judge has not made any
endeavour to find out as to whether Basi has ever married to Dubraj.
There is also no reliable evidence available on record to come to such
conclusion. When the relationship of Basi and Dubraj is not proved,
the plea that plaintiff No.1 was the son of Dubraj through Basi
cannot be accepted. In that view of the matter, the answer to Issue
No.5 is erroneous and cannot be accepted.
HIGH COURT OF ORISSA: CUTTACK
 F.A. NO. 174 OF 1988

Hema Majhi (dead) represented
by LRs and others 

 -VersusDubraj
Majhi …
 Date of Judgment: 20.04.2016

P R E S E N T:
 THE HONOURABLE SHRI JUSTICE K.R. MOHAPATRA
Citation:AIR 2016 (NOC)477 Orissa

Print Page

When relationship of father son is not proved by production of voter list at belated stage?

Exhibit Nos. 6, 7 and 8 are the certified copies of voter
list of village-Kudahansa of the year 1973, 1980 and 1983
respectively. Those were admitted into evidence and marked as
exhibits at the stage of the argument. Thus, defendants had no
opportunity to adduce any rebuttal evidence to the same or crossexamine
the witnesses of the plaintiffs in that regard. Exhibits 6, 7
and 8 are public documents and admissible in evidence. But that by
itself does not prove the entries made in it. Onus is on the plaintiffs
to prove the entries made in Exhibits 6, 7 and 8. The Court has
discretion under Order 13 Rule 1 C.P.C. to accept any document 
produced belatedly if good cause is shown to its satisfaction. This
Court in the case of Bhikari Charan Patra vs Basanti Bewa And
Ors., reported in AIR 1985 Ori 49 held as under:-
11. Whereas the object of Order 13, Rule 1 is
to lay down the stage when a party shall file
documentary evidence so that each knows on
what document the other seeks to rely and gets
ready for the trial, Order 13, Rule 2 makes
provision for meeting certain contingencies. The
object of the rules is not to penalize the party
but to secure a fair trial of the case, Where
Order 13, Rule 2 is invoked mala fide, where the
move is to cause delay or is vexatious, the cause
shown cannot be held to be good cause shown to
the satisfaction of the Court. The doors of the
discretionary jurisdiction should be closed.
Where, however, the document is vital and
would assist the Court in coming to a decision,
the doors should not be shut out.”
Where however, documentary evidence is sought to be introduced,
the Court has duty to scrutinize the cause shown by the party
seeking introduction of documentary evidence before exercising the
discretion and also to give opportunity to the adversary to explain
the documents so produced by adducing rebuttal evidence. This view
gets support from decisions of this Court in the case of Keshaba
Padhan alias Sukru and others Vs. Mst. Padma Padhani
(having died) Upasi Gurandi and others, reported in 1976 (1)
CWR 154 and Property Association of Baptist Churches Private
Limited and another Vs. State of Orissa and others, reported in
1984 (I) OLR 166.11
In the instant cases, no good reason has been assigned
by learned trial Court to accept Exts. 6, 7 and 8 at the stage of
argument of the suit. it is also not clear as to whether any prayer for
seeking leave of the Court was made to adduce further documentary
evidence at a belated stage. In addition to it, neither any opportunity
was given to the defendant to cross-examine the plaintiffs on Exts. 6,
7 and 8 nor they were allowed to adduce rebuttal evidence on the
same.
Further, the entries in Exts. 6, 7, and 8 does not by
itself conclusively prove that plaintiff No.1 was the son of Dubraj
through his first wife. Learned Civil Judge has not made any
endeavour to find out as to whether Basi has ever married to Dubraj.
There is also no reliable evidence available on record to come to such
conclusion. When the relationship of Basi and Dubraj is not proved,
the plea that plaintiff No.1 was the son of Dubraj through Basi
cannot be accepted. In that view of the matter, the answer to Issue
No.5 is erroneous and cannot be accepted.
HIGH COURT OF ORISSA: CUTTACK
 F.A. NO. 174 OF 1988

Hema Majhi (dead) represented
by LRs and others 

 -VersusDubraj
Majhi …
 Date of Judgment: 20.04.2016

P R E S E N T:
 THE HONOURABLE SHRI JUSTICE K.R. MOHAPATRA
Citation:AIR 2016 (NOC)477 Orissa

Print Page

Tuesday, 13 October 2015

CIC; voters must be informed before deletion of their names from voters list

CENTRAL INFORMATION COMMISSION

Prof. M. Sridhar Acharyulu (Madabhushi Sridhar)
Information Commissioner
CIC/SA/C/2015/000157
Sumit Vs. Chief Election Officer

Decision:   29-­07­-2015
Summary:  The voter has a right to know, first that his name was deleted, then the reasons for
decision to delete his name from the voter’s list. Such an arbitrary deletion and denial of information
even after deletion, followed by non­response to RTI request for reasons for that deletion would
certainly amount to denial of a very significant Constitutional & statutory right to vote and right to
information under RTI Act. 
Principles of Natural Justice, Section 22 of Representation of People Act 1950, Section 21A of the
Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 and the ratio in landmark judgment of Justice L Narasimha
Reddy   of   Andhra   Pradesh   High   Court   demand   that   a   valid   voter  is   expected  to  get  adequate
opportunity of being heard by the authority before deletion of name of voter.   The Commission
records its appreciation for appellant, the young boy for his anguish at the unjust denial of opportunity
to cast his vote in recent Assembly elections in Delhi, showing  greater concern for the right to vote
and choosing the path of RTI to seek the reasons and restoration of right lost. In fact, he was
performing his duty as alert citizen of this democratic country to secure his most valuable right, i.e.,
right to vote. 
The Commission directs CPIO of the Public Authority (Chief Election Officer) to show cause why
penalty should not  be imposed for not furnishing the information to the complainant within the
prescribed period, to inform appellant the reasons for deletion of his name from the voter’s list, to
inform if any inquiry was conducted into such deletion after deletion, if not to conduct an inquiry into
arbitrary  deletion of his name, to inform what action was  proposed to be taken against officer
responsible for deleting his name, to inform when his name and right to vote will be restored, to
prepare a set of guidelines to follow before deleting names, to inform fact of proposed deletion,
grounds for such  action  of  deletion,  and provision  of  adequate opportunity to  affected  voter to
represent his case etc, and post the same on official website, along with FAQs on the subject, and to
pay Rs 10,000/­ compensation on the grounds that appellant was not informed about deletion, not
informed about the grounds/reasons for deletion which amounted to violation of right, and he was not
given any response to his RTI application within 30 days as stipulated by RTI Act.
Parties Present:   
Print Page