Showing posts with label wakf board. Show all posts
Showing posts with label wakf board. Show all posts

Thursday, 17 February 2022

Whether State Government can invoke the writ jurisdiction against the action of the Wakf Board to declare the land as wakf property?

 Thus, the State Government, as a juristic entity, has a right to protect its property through the writ court, just as any individual could have invoked the jurisdiction of the High Court. Therefore, the State Government is competent to invoke the writ jurisdiction against the action of the Wakf Board to declare the land measuring 1654 acres and 32 guntas as wakf property.

{Para 125}

(3) Whether the State is estopped to challenge the notification inter-alia on the ground that Government Pleader was present before the Nazim Atiyat and before the High Court in proceedings against the order passed by Nazim Atiyat and that the notification was published in State Government Gazette?

129. It is to be noted that the presence of the Government Pleader before the Nazim Atiyat was for a limited purpose as the grants were to be paid by State Government. The State was not a party either before the Nazim Atiyat or before the High Court. The State would be bound by the orders, if it was impleaded as party as it is likely to be affected on account of the orders passed. The liability of State for payment of grant was not in dispute but the question was as to whom the grants would be payable. Thus, the presence of Government Pleader was for the limited purpose of facilitating the implementation of the orders passed.

Supreme Court

JUSTICE HEMANT GUPTA JUSTICE V. RAMASUBRAMANIAN

STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH (NOW STATE OF TELANGANA) Vs. A. P. STATE WAKF BOARD & ORS.

Print Page

Whether notification issued by wakf board in official gazette is binding on state government?

 Admittedly, the Government is reflected as the owner of the land in question since the year 1912-13. The Government has exercised its rights of ownership as a successor of the Sovereign. Consequent to Abolition Regulation and payment of commutation under the Commutation Regulation, the State Government had transferred land to the Corporation. A public notice was also issued to invite objections, if any, to the allotment of the land but since none were received, the Corporation made further allotment to various corporate entities. The Wakf Board is a statutory authority established under the Act and is a “State” within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution. A constitution Bench of this Court in a judgment reported as Rajasthan State Electricity Board, Jaipur v. Mohan Lal & Ors., AIR 1967 SC 1857 held “that the expression “other authorities” in Article 12 will include all constitutional or statutory authorities on whom powers are conferred by law. It is not at all material that some of the powers conferred may be for the purpose of carrying on commercial activities”.{Para 120}


122. Since, the Wakf Board is state, it has act to act fairly and reasonably. This Court in a judgment reported as Dwarkadas Marfatia and Sons v. Board of Trustees of the Port of Bombay, (1989) 3 SCC 293 held that the action of a statutory authority must be reasonable and taken only upon lawful and relevant grounds of public interest. 

125. Thus, the State Government, as a juristic entity, has a right to protect its property through the writ court, just as any individual could have invoked the jurisdiction of the High Court. Therefore, the State Government is competent to invoke the writ jurisdiction against the action of the Wakf Board to declare the land measuring 1654 acres and 32 guntas as wakf property.



(3) Whether the State is estopped to challenge the notification inter-alia on the ground that Government Pleader was present before the Nazim Atiyat and before the High Court in proceedings against the order passed by Nazim Atiyat and that the notification was published in State Government Gazette?

129. It is to be noted that the presence of the Government Pleader before the Nazim Atiyat was for a limited purpose as the grants were to be paid by State Government. The State was not a party either before the Nazim Atiyat or before the High Court. The State would be bound by the orders, if it was impleaded as party as it is likely to be affected on account of the orders passed. The liability of State for payment of grant was not in dispute but the question was as to whom the grants would be payable. Thus, the presence of Government Pleader was for the limited purpose of facilitating the implementation of the orders passed.

130. A perusal of the record of the Wakf Board, as extracted above, shows that the Errata notification was published when the same was sent by the Chief Executive Officer of the Wakf Board to the Commissioner, Government Printing Press on 13.03.2006. This publication of notification was made under Section 5(2) of the 1995 Act under the authority of the Chief Executive Officer of the Wakf Board. Hence, the notification was not at the instance of the State Government but was an act of the Wakf Board alone.

131. The argument raised that since the Errata notification was published in State Government Gazette, therefore, the State cannot turn around to say that they had no knowledge or that they are not bound by the notification so published is not tenable. We find that the purpose, object and scope of the publications in the Official Gazette is not what is sought to be contended. The Court is to presume the genuineness of any documents published in any Official Gazette as contemplated by Section 81 and Section 114 (e) of the Evidence Act, 1872. The publication in the Official Gazette is not only for the affairs of the State but has multiple uses. In fact, this question has been examined by a Division Bench of Delhi High Court in a judgment reported as Universal Cans & Containers Ltd. v. Union of India, 1991 SCC On Line Del 784, wherein the Court has quoted various parts of the Gazette required to be published by the Central Government. Section 4, Part III of the Gazette is meant for Miscellaneous Notifications including Notifications, Orders, Advertisements and Notices issued by Statutory Bodies, whereas Part IV is meant for Advertisements and Notices issued by Private Individuals and Private Bodies. Similar scheme of the publication in the Gazette would be available in the States as well. The High Court held as under:-
“8. Under Section 3(39) of the General Clauses Act, 1897, “Official Gazette” or “Gazette” shall mean the Gazette of India or the Official Gazette of a State. What is Official Gazette and under what authority it is published? is yet another question. A Gazette is generally understood as an Official Government Journal containing public notices and other prescribed matters. Legal Glossary (1983 Edition) issued by the Legislative Department of the Ministry of Law, Justice and Company Affairs, Government of India, defines Gazette as “an official newspaper containing lists of Government appointments, legal notices, dispatches, etc
xxx xxx

20. Under Section 81 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, the Court shall presume the genuineness of every document purporting to be in Official Gazette, and read with Section 114 of the said Act and Illustration (e) there to, the court can presume that the Official Gazette was notified on the date as appearing in the Official Gazette. However, this is only a rebuttable presumption. It can be rebutted by the evidence to the contrary. As noted above, in the present case it has been shown that the Official Gazette was notified on a date after the date appearing on the Gazette. Section 5 of the General Clauses Act, 1897, provides that where any Central Act is not expressed to come into operation on a particular day, then it shall come into operation on the day on which it receives the assent of the President. This is not applicable in the present case. Here we are concerned with a notification in the Official Gazette”.

 132. The Wakf Board is a statutory authority under the 1954 Act as well as under the 1995 Act. Thus, the Official Gazette had to carry any notification at the instance of the Wakf Board. Therefore, the State Government is not bound by the publication of the notification in the Official Gazette at the instance of the Wakf Board only for the reason that it has been published in the Official Gazette. The publication of a notice in an Official Gazette has a presumption of knowledge to the general public as an advertisement published in a newspaper. Therefore, mere reason that the notification was published in the State Government gazette is not binding on the State Government.

Supreme Court

JUSTICE HEMANT GUPTA JUSTICE V. RAMASUBRAMANIAN

STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH (NOW STATE OF TELANGANA) Vs. A. P. STATE WAKF BOARD & ORS.

Print Page

Whether the government can acquire land dedicated for religious purposes?

  The land dedicated for pious and religious purpose is not immune from its vesting with the State. In Khajamian Wakf Estates v. State of Madras, (1970) 3 SCC 894 the validity of the Madras Inam Estates (Abolition and Conversion into Ryotwari) Act, 1963 (Madras Act 26 of 1963); the Madras Lease-holds (Abolition and Conversion into Ryotwari) Act, 1963 (Madras Act 27 of 1963) and the Madras Minor Inams (Abolition and Conversion into Ryotwari) Act, 1963 (Madras Act 30 of 1963) was subject matter of challenge on the ground that the material provisions in those Acts are violative of Articles 14, 19(1)(f) and 31 of the Constitution. The impugned Acts were said to be providing for the acquisition by the State of the “estate” as contemplated by Article 31-A. These legislations were undertaken as a part of agrarian reform. In regard to the Inams belonging to the religious and charitable institutions, the impugned Acts did not provide for payment of compensation in a lump sum but on the other hand provision is made to pay them a portion of the compensation every year. The Constitution Bench held as under: -

“12. It was next urged that by acquiring the properties belonging to religious denominations, the Legislature violated Article 26(c) and (d) which provide that religious denominations shall have the right to own and acquire movable and immovable property and administer such property in accordance with law. These provisions do not take away the right of the State to acquire property belonging to religious denominations. Those denominations can own, acquire properties and administer them in accordance with law. That does not mean that the property owned by them cannot be acquired. As a result of acquisition they cease to own that property. Thereafter their right to administer that property ceases because it is no longer their property. Article 26 does not interfere with the right of the State to acquire property.”{Para 196}

Supreme Court

JUSTICE HEMANT GUPTA JUSTICE V. RAMASUBRAMANIAN

STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH (NOW STATE OF TELANGANA) Vs. A. P. STATE WAKF BOARD & ORS.

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 10770 OF 2016

7th February 2022

Citation: 2022 ALL SCR (ONLINE) 140

Print Page

Sunday, 26 June 2016

What will be limitation for filing suit if dispute is between wakf board and strangers?

    The first substantial
question of law as framed is with regard to the aspect whether the suit as
filed was barred by limitation in view of the provisions of Section 6(1) of the
Act of 1954. Under Section 6(1) of the Act of 1954 if any question arises
whether a particular property described as wakf property in the list of wakfs
is wakf property or not, the Board or the mutawalli of the wakf or any person
interested therein can institute a suit in the civil Court.  However, as per the
first proviso to Section 6(1) of the Act of 1954,   no such suit     can be
entertained by the civil Court after the expiry of one year from the date of
publication of the list of wakfs under Section 5(2) of the Act of 1954.   In
Board of Muslim Wakfs (supra) it was held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court that
the provisions of Section 6(1) of the Act of 1954  relate only to those persons
who are interested in the wakf.  The purpose of Section 6 of the Act of 1954
was to confine  disputes between the Wakf Board, mutawalli  and the person
interested in the wakf.  It was held in the aforesaid decision that the Act of
1954 deals with wakf,  its institutions  and  its  properties and therefore it
would be logical and reasonable to infer that said provisions empower only
those who are interested in the wakf to institute suits.   The judgment in
Board of Muslim Wakf (supra) was considered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court
in its subsequent judgment in Punjab Wakf Board (supra).  By following the
earlier law, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Punjab Wakf Board (supra) made a
clear distinction between a dispute amongst the wakf and the mutawalli or
the   persons   claiming   under   him   and   a   dispute   with   a   stranger.     It   is,

therefore, clear that the period of limitation as prescribed by the proviso of
Section 6(1) of the Act of 1954 would apply only to those who are interested
in the wakf.  
In the present case the original defendants were not persons who
were interested in the wakf.  The dispute was between the wakf board and
strangers.   Thus considering the ratio of the judgment in  Board of Muslim
Wakf (supra) it will have to be held that the period of limitation of one year
commencing from the date of the  notification would not be applicable in the
present case.   The appellate Court though   referred to the decision in the
Board of Muslim Wakf (supra), it failed to apply the ratio of aforesaid decision
in the proper perspective.  The appellate Court  fell into an error when it held
that the plaintiff should have filed the suit within a period of one year from
the notification dated 06/03/1975 and as the same was not done, the suit
was barred by limitation. The finding recorded by the appellate Court against
point no.1 is therefore liable to be set aside.  Accordingly substantial question
of law no. 1 is answered by holding that the proviso to Section 6(1) of the
Act of 1954 would not apply in the present case and the suit as filed was not
barred by limitation. 
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY NAGPUR BENCH
NAGPUR.
SECOND   APPEAL   NO.   431     OF     1994
Maratwada Wakf Board

VERSUS
Vibhawari wd/o Deepak
Deshpande, aged 45 yrs. 

CORAM:   A. S. CHANDURKAR  J.
      
        Dated :  February   26,  2016.
Citation: 2016(3) MHLJ753
Print Page

Sunday, 19 April 2015

When wakf board is liable to pay maintenance to divorced muslim wife?




    Both   the   learned   Judicial   Magistrate   First   Class 

Pathri   and   the   learned   Sessions   Judge,   Parbhani,   who   decided 

Criminal   Revision,   found   that,   the   petitioner   is   liable   to   pay 
monthly maintenance of Rs.300/­ to the respondent no.1 in view 
of the Provisions of Section 4 (2) of Muslim Women (Protection of 
Rights on Divorce) Act, 1986.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE OF BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD

CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO.578 OF 2000


District Wakf Officer,

VERSUS
 Zulakhabee d/o Aminkhan


CORAM : V.M.DESHPANDE, J. 
Dated    : July 24, 2014
Citation;2015 ALLMR(CRI)964
Print Page