Showing posts with label wakf. Show all posts
Showing posts with label wakf. Show all posts

Wednesday, 24 May 2023

Circumstances where gazette publication is not conclusive proof of immovable property being wakf property?

  It may be noted that Wakf Board is a statutory authority under the Wakf Act. Therefore, the official Gazette is bound to carry any notification at the instance of the Wakf Board but nonetheless, the State Government is not bound by such a publication of the notification published in the official Gazette merely for the reason that it has been so published. In State of Andhra Pradesh v. A.P. State Wakf Board and Ors. MANU/SC/0155/2022, this Court consisting of one of us (V. Ramasubramanian, J. as a Member) held that the publication of a notification in the official Gazette has a presumption of knowledge to the general public just like an advertisement published in the newspaper but such a notification published at the instance of the Wakf Board in the State Gazette is not binding upon the State Government. It means that the notification, if any, published in the official Gazette at the behest of the Wakf Act giving the lists of the wakfs is not a conclusive proof that a particular property is a wakf property especially, when no procedure as prescribed Under Section 4 of the Wakf Act has been followed in issuing the same.{Para 35}

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal Nos. 7467-7470 of 2014

Salem Muslim Burial Ground Protection Committee  Vs.  State of Tamil Nadu and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

V. Ramasubramanian and Pankaj Mithal, JJ.

Author: Pankaj Mithal, J.

Decided On: 18.05.2023.

Citation: MANU/SC/0597/2023.

Read full Judgment here: Click here

Print Page

Is the declaration of any immovable property as wakf valid if it was done without a survey of that property?

The another limb of the argument is that the suit land has been declared to be a wakf property vide notification dated 29.04.1959. In this regard, it has to be noted that such a declaration has to be in consonance with the provisions of the Wakf Act, 1954 or the Waqf Act, 1995. Both the aforesaid Acts lay down the procedure for issuing notification declaring any property as a wakf. {Para 30}


31. The Wakf Act, 1954, which actually is relevant for our purpose, provides that, first, a preliminary survey of wakfs has to be conducted and the Survey Commission shall, after such inquiry as may be deemed necessary, submit its report to the State Government about certain factors enumerated therein whereupon the State Government by a notification in the official Gazette direct for a second survey to be conducted. Once the above procedure of survey is completed and the disputes arising thereto have been settled, on receipt of the report, the State Government shall forward it to the Wakf Board. The Wakf Board on examining the same shall publish the list of wakfs in existence with full particulars in the official Gazette as contemplated Under Section 5 of the Act. Similar provisions exist under the Waqf Act, 1995.


32. A plain reading of the provisions of the above two Acts would reveal that the notification Under Section 5 of both the Acts declaring the list of the wakfs shall only be published after completion of the process as laid down Under Section 4 of the above Acts, which provides for two surveys, settlement of disputes arising thereto and the submission of the report to the State Government and to the Board. Therefore, conducting of the surveys before declaring a property a wakf property is a sine qua non. In the case at hand, there is no material or evidence on record that before issuing notification Under Section 5 of the Wakf Act, 1954, any procedure or the survey was conducted as contemplated by Section 4 of the Act. In the absence of such a material, the mere issuance of the notification Under Section 5 of the Act would not constitute a valid wakf in respect of the suit land. Therefore, the notification dated 29.04.1959 is not a conclusive proof of the fact that the suit land is a wakf property. It is for this reason probably that the Appellant Committee had never pressed the said notification into service up till 1999.


33. In Tamil Nadu Wakf Board v. Hathija Ammal (Dead) by Lrs. Etc. MANU/SC/0518/2001 : AIR 2002 SC 402, it was observed that the Wakf Board should follow the procedure as required Under Section 4, 5 and 6 or Section 27 of the Wakf Act before notifying the wakfs Under Section 5 of the Act.


34. In Madanuri Sri Rama Chandra Murthy v. Syed Jalal MANU/SC/0485/2017 : (2017) 13 SCC 174, it was observed as under:


16. Thus, it is amply clear that the conducting of survey by the Survey Commissioner and preparing a report and forwarding the same to the State or the Wakf Board precedes the final act of notifying such list in the Official Gazette by the State under the 1995 Act (it was by the Board under the 1954 Act). As mentioned supra, the list would be prepared by the Survey Commissioner after making due enquiry and after valid survey as well as after due application of mind. The enquiry contemplated Under Sub-section (3) of Section 4 is not merely an informal enquiry but a formal enquiry to find out at the grass root level, as to whether the property is a wakf property or not. Thereafter the Wakf Board will once again examine the list sent to it with due application of its mind and only thereafter the same will be sent to the Government for notifying the same in the Gazette....

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal Nos. 7467-7470 of 2014

Salem Muslim Burial Ground Protection Committee  Vs.  State of Tamil Nadu and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

V. Ramasubramanian and Pankaj Mithal, JJ.

Author: Pankaj Mithal, J.

Decided On: 18.05.2023.

Citation: MANU/SC/0597/2023
Print Page

Saturday, 17 September 2022

What is distinction between Muslim trust and wakf?

 There is a vast difference between Muslim Wakfs and Trusts created by Muslims. The basic difference is that Wakf properties are dedicated to God and the “Wakif” or dedicator, does not retain any title over the Wakf properties. As far as Trusts are concerned, the properties are not vested in God. Some of the objects of such Trusts are for running charitable organisations such as hospitals, shelter homes, orphanages and charitable dispensaries, which acts, though recognized as pious, do not divest the author of the Trust from the title of the properties in the Trust, unless he relinquishes such title in favour of the Trust or the Trustees. At times, the dividing line between Public Trusts and Wakfs may be thin, but the main factor always is that while Wakf properties vest in God Almighty, the Trust properties do not vest in God and the trustees in terms of Deed of Trust are entitled to deal with the same for the benefit of the Trust and its beneficiaries.

Reportable

Supreme Court of India
Maharashtra State Board Of Wakfs vs Shaikh Yusuf Bhai Chawla & Ors on 11 May, 2012
Author: A Kabir
Bench: Altamas Kabir, J. Chelameswar, Ranjan Gogoi

 Read full Judgment here: Click here                                        
Print Page

Sunday, 1 May 2022

Can a structure be treated as a place for offering namaz without proof of dedication?

The experts from the Archaeological Department have reported that the structure has no historical or archaeological importance. It is further contended that the Tehsildar, before the possession was delivered, had given an extensive report of each of the structure existing on the land proposed to be given. The lands for graveyard and other religious structures have been excluded from the lease. Therefore, the act of identification carried out years before raising of the dispute done by the revenue officials in the course of their official duties carry presumption of correctness. It shows that the structure had no religious value.

16. The letter dated 17.4.2012 by the Anjuman Committee is based upon hearsay and is not of any binding value.

17. Still further, there is no evidence at any given point of time that the structure was being used as a mosque. There is no allegation or proof of either of dedication or user or grant which can be termed as a waqf within the meaning of the Act. Section 3 (r) of the Act reads thus:-

“[(r) “waqf” means the permanent dedication by any person, of any movable or immovable property for any purpose recognised by the Muslim law as pious, religious or charitable and includes—

(i) a waqf by user but such waqf shall not cease to be a waqf by reason only of the user having ceased irrespective of the period of such cesser;

(ii) a Shamlat Patti, Shamlat Deh, Jumla Malkkan or by any other name entered in a revenue record;

(iii) xxx xxx”

18. The report of the experts is relevant only to the extent that the structure has no archaeological or historical importance. In the absence of any proof of dedication or user, a dilapidated wall or a platform cannot be conferred a status of a religious place for the purpose of offering prayers/Namaaz.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA 

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 2788 & 2789 OF 2022 

WAQF BOARD, RAJASTHAN Vs JINDAL SAW LIMITED & ORS.

Coram:  HEMANT GUPTA; V. RAMASUBRAMANIAN, JJ.

Author: HEMANT GUPTA, J.

Dated: APRIL 29, 2022 

Print Page

Tuesday, 2 November 2021

Under which circumstances Civil court will have jurisdiction regarding wakf property?

 A combined reading of Sections 68(6), 86, 90 and 93 goes to show that the bar of jurisdiction under Section 85 does not apply at least to the following matters, covered by Sections 68(6), 86 and 90 :
(i) Whenever a District Magistrate passes an order directing the removed mutawalli or removed members of a Committee of Management to deliver possession of the records, accounts and properties of the waqf, to the successor or successor Committee of Management, any person claiming that he has right, title and interest in the properties specified in the order so passed by the Magistrate can approach a civil court;
(ii) The Board itself may approach a civil court either to set aside the sale in execution of a decree of civil court, of an immovable property which is a waqf property, or to set aside the transfer of any immovable property made by the mutawalli without the sanction of the Board or to recover possession of the property so sold or transferred, as the case may be;
(iii) The mutawalli is also empowered to approach the civil court to recover possession of any immovable property which is a waqf property, but which had been transferred by the previous mutawalli without the sanction of the Board (this is implicit in Section 86);

(iv) A waqf property can be brought to sale in execution of a decree of a civil court or for the recovery of any revenue, cess, rates or taxes due to the Government or any local authority, but such a proceeding will be void if no notice thereof is given to the Board [this is implicit in Sections 90(2) & (3)]. {Para 47}

 

Supreme Court

JUSTICE Hemant Gupta JUSTICE V. Ramasubramanian

RASHID WALI BEG Vs. FARID PINDARI & ORS.

Civil Appeal No. 6336 of 2021

28th October 2021



Author: V. Ramasubramanian, J.

Citation: 2021 ALL SCR (ONLINE) 608

Print Page

Friday, 9 April 2021

Whether court can treat the tenanted property as joint family property if Karta is the tenant of said property?

 A perusal of the facts on record would show that it was a contract of tenancy entered upon by great grandfather of the plaintiff. Even if the great grandfather was maintaining the family out of the income generated from the hotel business, that itself would not make the other family members as coparceners in the hotel business. It was the contract of tenancy which was inherited by the grandfather of the plaintiff who later surrendered it in favour of the Wakf Board. The tenancy was an individual right vested with the grandfather of the plaintiff who was competent to surrender it to the landlord. The High Court has clearly erred in law by holding that since the grandfather was a tenant, the tenancy is a joint family asset. The contract of tenancy is an independent contract than the joint Hindu family business.{Para 32}

 REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 6149 OF 2015

KIRAN DEVI  Vs THE BIHAR STATE SUNNI WAKF BOARD

& ORS.

Author: HEMANT GUPTA, J.

Print Page

Wednesday, 7 October 2020

Whether Small causes court Act can deal with the dispute between landlord and tenant after enforcement of Waqf (Amendment) Act, 2013?

Suit for eviction of a tenant in the State of U.P. is cognizable by Judge Small Cause under the Provincial Small Cause Act, 1971. Thus, such cases have been taken out of jurisdiction of regular civil courts and have been entrusted to Small Cause Courts for ensuring early adjudication.


39. Learned counsel would submit that in view of the amendment in the Act after terminating tenancy, tenant becomes liable for ejectment and proceeding for eviction will be undertaken under the Wakf Act (as amended in 2013). Consequently, the civil court, namely, Small Cause court will have no jurisdiction and since the decree passed by Small cause court, impugned in the revision, is without jurisdiction, same deserves to be set aside.

46. Thus, it is manifest that by means of The Wakf (Amendment) Act, No. 27 of 2013 word "encroacher" was defined and power has been given to Wakf Tribunal to pass order of eviction. This amendment does not say anything about the pending proceeding.


47. Suit was filed on 20th March, 2009. Amendment has come into force on 1st November, 2013. Will amendment apply to the pending cases? There is no saving Clause in Amendment Act. There is nothing in the Act which makes the Amending Act retrospective.


48. Section 5 of The Wakf (Amendment) Act, No. 27 of 2013 says that " In section 3 of the principal Act (I) after clause (e), the following clause shall be inserted, namely (ee) "encroacher" means any person or institution, public or private occupying waqf property, in whole or part, without the authority of law and includes a person whose tenancy, lease or licence has expired or has been terminated by mutawalli or the Board. There is no indication that this clause was sought to be made retrospective.


49. Similarly, Section 32 of the Amending Act whereby it amends Section 54 of the principal Act, says nothing that makes it retrospective. Even otherwise declaring somebody an encroacher amounts to declaring the character of a person which ordinarily cannot be done retrospectively. There is no contrary legislative intention discernible from the language of the provision.


50. Amendment of Section 54 further contemplates that application to the Tribunal for grant of order of eviction or removing shall be moved which means that Tribunal will start working prospectively. Section 54 (4) of the Act makes this position further clear and shows that Tribunal will work prospectively.


51. Section 56 of the Amending Act gives the overriding effect. Section 108A does not say anything about the pending proceedings. Consequently, proceedings which are pending on the date of amendment will continue to be dealt with in accordance with the prevalent law.


52. It is evident that by virtue of amendment, specific jurisdiction has been conferred on the Tribunal. Obviously, this will be prospective and in the absence of any provision for transfer of pending cases to the Tribunal, same will continue to be dealt with by the courts in accordance with the prevalent law and amendment at the most can take effect from 01.11.2013. 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF ALLAHABAD (LUCKNOW BENCH)


S.C.C. Revision No. 62 of 2015


Decided On: 09.10.2015


 Sageer Ahmad  Vs.  Wakf Masjid Mohalla-Kazipura Wakf No. 9 and Ors.


Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

S.K. Saxena, J.

Citation: MANU/UP/1509/2015

Print Page

Monday, 4 May 2020

Notes on Wakf under Muslim law

Basic concept of Wakf



Wakf literally means dedication. In its legal sense,it means dedication in perpetuity of some specific property for a pious purpose.Perpetuity is the essence of a wakf. Once a wakf is created,the ownership of the Wakif that is the dedicator,is extinguished, and the wakf is irrevocable.




According to S 2(1) of the Mussalman Wakf Validating Act,1913."Wakf means the permanent dedication by a person professing the Mussalman faith,of any property,for any purpose recognised by the Mussalman law as religious,pious or charitable.
Print Page