Showing posts with label witness list. Show all posts
Showing posts with label witness list. Show all posts

Sunday, 24 August 2025

Supreme Court: Whether filing of charge sheet, existence of lengthy witness lists, or prospect of prolonged trial can justify grant of bail in heinous offences

 Whether mere filing of charge sheet, existence of lengthy witness lists, or prospect of prolonged trial can justify grant of bail in heinous offences -- Held, mere filing of the charge sheet, existence of a long list of witnesses, or possibility of delay in trial, cannot, by themselves, constitute valid reasons to dilute the gravity of the offence or to disregard the case put forth by the prosecution -- Such factors are not standalone grounds for the grant of bail in heinous offences involving murder -- Penal Code, 1860, S.302.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal Nos. 3528-3534 of 2025 

Decided On: 14.08.2025

State of Karnataka Vs. Darshan and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

J.B. Pardiwala and R. Mahadevan, JJ.

Author: R. Mahadevan, J.

Citation: 2025 KHC 6693: 2025 INSC 979, MANU/SC/1098/2025.

Read full judgment here: Click here.

Print Page

Sunday, 8 December 2019

Delhi HC: Parties should not be permitted to commence evidence unless they file witness list

 In respect of the first issue, there is no doubt that without filing of the list of witnesses, parties ought not to be permitted to commence the recording of evidence. Filing the list of witnesses is mandatory, as held by this Court in Zile Singh v. Santosh @ Santra & Ors. [CM (M) 1296/2018, decided on 6th November, 2019]:
However, it is noticed that the general practice that has been followed in the Trial Courts is to permit the commencement of evidence without insisting for lists of witnesses being filed by the parties. However, such a practice is contrary to law and is required to be stopped with immediate effect.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

CM (M) 1656/2019

Decided On: 22.11.2019

 Ganga Ram  Vs.  Shekhar Kumar

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Prathiba M. Singh, J.

Print Page

Thursday, 28 November 2019

Whether court can refuse permission to examine witness if witness list is not filed?

Considering the procedure laid down in Order XVI, Rule 1(1)(2) and (3) of Code of Civil Procedure, it is clear that the party desirous of examining any witness has to obtain summons for his attendance in the Court and this exercise has to be done in respect of the witnesses whose names are included in the list submitted by the party. As per Order XVI, Rule 1(3) of the Code of Civil Procedure, the Court may permit the party to call any other witness, provided the party who desires to examine any such witness whose name is not included in the list of witnesses, show sufficient cause for the omission to mention the name of such witness in the said list and the Court has to record reasons for permitting the party to examine the witness whose name is not included in the list submitted as per sub-rule (1) of Rule 1.

5. It is undisputed that in the present case, the petitioner/original plaintiff has no supplied the list of the witnesses. The applications (Exhibits 228 and 229) filed by the petitioner praying for permission to examine the witnesses and for issuance of witness summons do not show any reason to enable the Court to record its reasons for permitting the original plaintiff/petitioner to examine the witnesses or to issue the witness summons. The trial Court has properly considered the matter. Apart from this, the civil suit is of year 1994 and the trial Court has observed that the petitioner/plaintiff is unnecessarily protracting the matter. Be that as it may, the plaintiff has not been able to point out any irregularity in the impugned orders. The only submission made on behalf of the petitioner is that if the petitioner/original plaintiff is not permitted to examine the witnesses named by him in the applications, Exhibits 228 and 229, then it will cause prejudice to him. This submission cannot be accepted in view of the provisions of sub-rules (1), (2) and (3) of Rule 1 of Order XVI of Code of Civil Procedure. Sub-rule (4) of Rule 1 of Order XVI lays down that the summons referred to in this rule may be obtained by the parties on an application to the Court within five days of presenting the list of witnesses under sub-rule (1) as mentioned above.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

W.P. No. 4928 of 2013

Decided On: 16.06.2014

Anil Ramesh Bhusari  Vs.  Bhaskar Ramesh Bhusari

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Z.A. Haq, J.

Citation: 2015(1) ALLMR 724
Print Page

Sunday, 29 September 2019

Whether it is mandatory for party to give reasons for examination of particular witness?

The moot question for consideration is that whether the petitioner was under obligation to disclose the importance and relevance of Murarilal Verma as a witness in the application or not.
The question involved in the present petition is no more res integra.
The Supreme Court in the case of Kokkanda B. Poondacha and others vs. K.D. Ganapathi & another reported in (2011) 12 SCC 600 has held as under:-
"18. We may add that if the parties to the litigation are allowed to file the list of witnesses without indicating the purpose for summoning the particular person(s) as witness(es), the unscrupulous litigants may create a situation where the cases may be prolonged for years together. Such litigants may include the name of the advocate representing the other side as a witness and if the court casually accepts the list of witnesses, the other side will be deprived of the services of the advocate. Therefore, it would be a prudent exercise of discretion by the court to insist that the party filing the list of witnesses should briefly indicate the purpose of summoning the particular person as a witness."
Thus, it is clear that the litigants must indicate briefly the purpose of summoning the particular person as a witness in the application itself. Furthermore, merely because Murarilal Verma had appeared as a witness in a proceeding which is under challenge in the civil suit by itself would not be sufficient to hold that Murarilal Verma is relevant and important witness.
Considering the submissions made by the counsel for the petitioner this Court is of the view that the Trial Court did not commit any jurisdictional error by rejecting the application filed under Order 16 Rule 1 of CPC.
Madhya Pradesh High Court
Anek Singh Tomar vs Dhaniram S/O Shri Bhagchand ... on 15 November, 2018
    
Print Page

Friday, 28 October 2016

When application of plaintiff for summoning of witness should not be allowed?

In   the   instant   case,   as   indicated   above,   the   application   dated
17/08/2004 is bereft of any reason as to why the names of the said two
witnesses whom the Plaintiff wanted to examine were not made part of the list
of witnesses and filed in the Court.  The said application is also bereft of any
reasons as to why the Plaintiff wanted to examine them after his examination
was over.  Since the pre­requisite for permitting examination of the witnesses is
on the basis of the Plaintiff showing sufficient cause. In the absence of Plaintiff
showing sufficient cause in the instant case, as the application is bereft of any
reason, the Plaintiff could not be allowed to examine the witnesses even under
Rule 1­A of Order XVI of the CPC. The Trial Court as can be seen has totally

glossed over the fact that Rule 1­A of Order XVI is controlled by sub­rule 3.  It
is only if  the  Plaintiff  satisfies the court by showing sufficient cause  then
powers can be exercised under Rule 1­A. In the instant case, as indicated
above, the application in question is bereft of any reason and therefore the
Plaintiff cannot be said to have shown sufficient cause and therefore the Trial
Court had erred in allowing the Plaintiff to examine the witnesses by having
recourse to Rule 1­A of Order XVI of the CPC. 
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
 CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO.3282 OF 2005
 Shri Sanjay Sham Bagade 
v
 Shri Ramesh Hari Madan 
CORAM : R. M. SAVANT, J.
DATE   : 11th November 2013
Citation: 2014 (4) ALLMR 19
Print Page

Friday, 6 March 2015

Whether plaintiff can be permitted to examine witness when he has not submitted witness list?



It   is   undisputed   that   in   the   present   case,   the 
petitioner/original   plaintiff   has   not   supplied   the   list   of   the 
witnesses.  The applications (Exhibits 228 and 229) filed by the 
petitioner praying for permission to examine the witnesses and 

for issuance of witness summons do not show any reason to 
enable   the   Court   to   record   its   reasons   for   permitting   the 
original plaintiff/petitioner to examine the witnesses or to issue 
the witness summons.  The trial Court has properly considered 
the matter.   Apart from this, the civil suit is of year 1994 and 
the   trial   Court   has   observed   that   the   petitioner/plaintiff   is 
unnecessarily  protracting   the  matter.    Be  that  as  it  may,  the 
plaintiff has not been able to point out any irregularity in the 
impugned orders.  The only submission made on behalf of the 
petitioner   is   that   if   the   petitioner/original   plaintiff   is   not 
permitted   to   examine   the   witnesses   named   by   him   in   the 
applications, Exhibits 228 and 229, then it will cause prejudice 
to   him.     This   submission   cannot   be   accepted   in   view   of   the 
provisions of sub­rules (1), (2) and (3) of Rule 1 of Order XVI 
of Code of Civil Procedure. 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY,
NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR.
Anil Ramesh Bhusari
 v
Bhaskar Ramesh Bhusari


CORAM : Z. A. HAQ, J.
Citation;2015(1)ALLMR724
DATE : JUNE 16, 2014
Print Page

Friday, 27 September 2013

Rules for interpretation whether a document is sale deed or mortgage deed

 The Proviso to this clause was added by Section 19 of the Transfer of Property (Amendment) Act, 1929 (XX of 1929). The Proviso was introduced in this clause only to set at rest the controversy about the nature of the document; whether the transaction would be a sale or a mortgage. It has been specifically provided by the Amendment that the document would not be treated as a mortgage unless the condition of repurchase was contained in the same document.
49. The basic principle is that the form of transaction is not the final test and the true test is the intention of the parties in entering into the transaction. If the intention of the parties was that the transfer was by way of security, it would be a mortgage. The Privy Council as early as in Balkishen Das and Ors. v. Legge, 27 Indian Appeals 58, had laid down that, as between the parties to the document, the intention to treat the transaction as an out and out sale or as a mortgage has to be found out on a consideration of the contents of document in the light of surrounding circumstances. The decision of this Court in Bhaskar Woman Joshi v. Shrinarayan Rambilas Agarwal and P.L. Bapuswami v. N. Pattay Gounder
are also to the same effect.

Supreme Court of India
Vidhyadhar vs Manikrao & Anr. on 17 March, 1999
Equivalent citations: AIR 1999 SC 1441, 1999 (3) ALT 1 SC, JT 1999 (2) SC 183
Print Page