Showing posts with label works contract. Show all posts
Showing posts with label works contract. Show all posts

Wednesday, 15 December 2021

Can Municipal corporations include a term in the works contract that they will make payments to the contractor as and when funds in a particular budget head are available?

  As per Himani Alloys Ltd. v. Tata Steel Ltd. (2011) 15 SCC 273 cited by the Corporation, the test for the invoking of Order XII Rule 6 of the CPC being that the admission so made must clear and unequivocal, on the face of which it is impossible for the party making it to succeed. In the light of the stand in the written statement, there is a clear admission as to the final bill amount as also that the Contractor has to wait in a queue. Thus the Trial Court has rightly invoked the provisions of Order XII Rule 6.{Para 55}

Conclusions and Findings

56. The General Conditions of Contract i.e., clauses 7 and 9 which are admittedly part of the work orders issued by both the NrDMC and the EDMC are being tested in these batch of cases. A contract which stipulates that the consideration would be paid in an unforeseen time in the future based on certain factors which are indeterminable, would in effect be a contract without consideration. Even if the contract is held to be a valid contract, then the concept of `reasonableness' has to be read into the same. Section 46 of the Contract Act and the explanation thereto is clear that “what is a reasonable time is a question of fact in each case.” A Corporation which gets works executed cannot therefore include terms in the contract which are per se unconscionable and unreasonable as -

a) There is no fixed time period as to when the funds would be available;

b) There is also no fixed mechanism to determine as to when and in what manner the head of account is to be determined and as to how the Contractor would acquire knowledge of these two facts;

c) There is also no certainty as to how many persons are in the queue prior to the Contractor and for what amounts;

d) There is enormous ambiguity in the receipt under the particular heads of accounts.

57. These clauses in effect say that the Contractor is left with no remedy if the Corporation does not pay for the work that has been executed. Such a Clause would be illegal and contrary to law. Such clauses, even in commercial contracts, would be contrary to Section 25 read with Section 46 of the Contract Act.

58. The clauses do not specify an outer time limit for payment. The expression reasonable time has to be `a time'. The concept of time itself is ensconced with specificity and precision. Clause 9 is the opposite of being precise. It is as vague and ambiguous as it could be because it depends on factors which are totally extraneous to the contract, namely -

 Allotment of funds to the Corporation by the Government;

 Allotment of funds in a particular head;

 Allotment of funds for payments who are in queue prior to the contractor;

59. Thus, these factors, which are beyond the control of the Contractor and which would govern the payment of consideration, make the said clauses of the contract completely unreasonable. The clauses have to thus, be read or interpreted in a manner so as to instill reasonableness in them.

60. By applying the above said principles, in respect of final bills raised by Contractors for works executed, that have been approved by the Engineer-in-Charge, the Clauses have to be read in the following manner:

a) Reasonable time for making of payments of final bills in respect of work orders up to Rs.5 lakhs shall be 6 months and work orders exceeding Rs.5 lakhs shall be 9 months from the date when the bill is passed by the Engineer-in-Charge.

b) The queue basis can be applicable for the payments to be made in chronology. However, the outer limit of 6 months and 9 months cannot be exceeded, while applying the queue system.

c) The payments are held to become due and payable immediately upon the expiry of 6 months and 9 months and any non-payment would attract payment of interest for the delayed periods.

d) A conjoint reading of Clauses 7 & 9 along with the amendment dated 19th May, 2006, clearly shows that for the payment of bills, the contractors have to follow the queue basis and as and when the amount is available under the particular head of account, the amount would be payable. The amendment does not, however, have a condition that no interest is payable for delayed payment. Such a condition exists only in Clause 7. Clause 9, therefore, when read with the amendment has to mean that the Corporation itself considers 6 months and 9 months to be the reasonable periods for which the payments of the final bills can be held back.

e) To the extent that queue basis is applied only for clearing of payments which do not extend beyond the period of 6 months and 9 months period, it is reasonable. However, if the queue basis is applied in order to make Contractors wait for indefinite periods for receiving payments, then the same would be unreasonable and would have to therefore be read down.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

 RFA 160/2017 & CM APPL. 5807/2017 (Stay)

NORTH DELHI MUNICIPAL CORPORATION  Vs VIPIN GUPTA 

Print Page

Sunday, 23 October 2016

When bank can not refuse to make payment to contractor in works contract?

After execution of the work, contractor, plaintiff-respondent No.1, herein instituted a suit for recovery of security amount, balance due, payment of final amount along with interest. 
It was pleaded in the plaint that the contractor, plaintiff-respondent, herein was always ready and willing to do remaining wooden work, but since the bills raised were not paid, therefore, the wooden work could not be carried by the contractor.
Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties, this Court is of the view that if there was a delay in execution of the work and the contractor had not commenced the work within four-&-half months, the period stipulated for completion of the work, the defendant-appellants always had the option to annul or cancel the work order. To their best of wisdom, the defendant-appellants persisted that the contractor should execute the work. 
This Court cannot become oblivious of the fact that the Bank had also given a provisional extension to the contractor to complete the work, hence, the Bank cannot rue for the delay on the part of the plaintiff-respondents. Furthermore, since the Bank itself had not cleared the bills, therefore, an impediment was caused for the contractor not to complete the wood work. 
Reportable
In the High Court of Judicature for Rajasthan at Jaipur Bench Jaipur

S.B. Civil First Appeal No.85 of 1996
Rajasthan State Cooperative Bank Limited and Others
V
Sh. Ramavtar Sharma and another
Dated:    15.02.2016

Hon'ble Mr. Justice Kanwaljit Singh Ahluwalia
Citation: AIR 2016 (NOC)657 Raj
Print Page

Saturday, 20 June 2015

How to determine damages when there is breach of contract in case of works contract?

 The arbitrator has awarded 10% of the profit on the incomplete work in all these three contracts, and this is alleged to be a bias on the part of the arbitrator. In M/s. A.T. Brijpal Singh & Bros. v. State of Gujarat MANU/SC/0081/1984 : AIR1984SC1703 , the Supreme Court has held that in a works contract, when there was breach of contract on account of which the contractor could not complete the work, he is entitled to claim damages on the basis of the expected profit on the balance of the in-completed work. In that case, 15% of the value of the balance of the work, was awarded as damages. So, when the contract of the second respondent herein was illegally terminated before the completion of the work certainly the contractor is entitled to claim damages on the basis of the expected profit in the unfinished work. When such a right is available to the contractor under law and the quantum fixed by the arbitrator is only 10%, which according to the arbitrator is a reasonable compensation, the Court cannot, set aside this finding of the arbitrator as illegal or biased.
Madras High Court
The Superintending Engineer ... vs A.V. Rangaraju And Another on 8 April, 1994

Bench: Rengasamy
Citation: AIR1994Mad217

Print Page