Showing posts with label Assessment of damage. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Assessment of damage. Show all posts

Tuesday, 23 May 2023

Whether owner of property is entitled to get mesne profits or fair rent for the period when property was not in wrongful possession?

  At the outset, we may point out that there are different methods of valuation, namely, income/profit method, cost of construction method, rent method and contractors' method. In the present case, the arbitrator has applied the income/profit method. The above two issues are interconnected, as the arbitrator has assessed damages on the assumption that after 10.3.1987, the occupation and possession of the property was wrongful and illegal and in the nature of trespass. Accordingly, he has assessed damages on the footing that the respondent was entitled to mesne profits. This assumption was wrong as the appellant was given time by this Court to remain in possession up to 31.3.1993. In Law of Damages & Compensation by Kameshwara Rao (5th Edn., Vol. I Page 528], the learned author states that right to mesne profits presupposes a wrong whereas a right to rent proceeds on the basis that there is a contract. But there is an intermediate class of cases in which the possession though not wrongful in the beginning assumes a wrongful character when it is unauthorisedly retained and in such cases, the owner is not entitled to claim mesne profits but only the fair rent. In the present case, in view of the permission granted by this Court enabling the appellant to use and occupy the property up to 31.3.1993, it cannot be said that the possession of the appellant was illegal and wrongful and in the nature of trespass. In the circumstances, damages were claimable not on the basis of mesne profits but on the basis of fair rent. {Para 8}

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 1531 of 1999

Decided On: 12.04.2004

Union of India (UOI) and Ors.  Vs. Banwari Lal and Sons (P) Ltd.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

V.N. Khare, C.J., S.B. Sinha and S.H. Kapadia, JJ.

Authored By : S.H. Kapadia, S.B. Sinha

S.H. Kapadia, J.

Citation : (2004 )5SCC 304, MANU/SC/0331/2004

Print Page