Showing posts with label mesne profits. Show all posts
Showing posts with label mesne profits. Show all posts

Saturday, 7 September 2024

Whether one co-sharer is entitled to get mesne profits from other co-sharer?

On the case of the petitioners themselves, they were co-sharers along with opposite party Nos. 1 to 3. The grievance of the petitioners is that opposite party Nos. 1 to 3 were in possession of the six rooms in spite of the order dated 10-10-1969 passed by the court below and on that basis as stated above, they claim mesne profits on the ground that they were deprived of the enjoyment of those six rooms to which they were entitled to in pursuance of the aforesaid order. But that alone, in our opinion, is not sufficient to entitle the petitioners to get mesne profits from opposite party Nos. 1 to 3. "Mesne profits" has been defined in sub-section (12' of Section 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, which is as follows:--


"Mesne profits" of property means those profits which the person in wrongful possession of such property actually received or might with ordinary diligence have received therefrom, together with interest on such profits, but shall not include profits due to improvements made by the person in wrongful possession."

A bare reading of this sub-section shows that a person in wrongful possession alone is liable to pay mesne profit. Was the possession of opposite party Nos. 1 to 3 wrongful ? The answer to that is certainly in the negative because they were, according to the case of the petitioners themselves, co-sharers of the six rooms. It is settled that possession of a co-sharer can never be wrongful as he had right and interest in every inch of the undivided property. It is not said by the petitioner that the property has been divided by metes and bounds and these six rooms have been allotted to his share. All that is said is that the petitioners are entitled to exclusive possession of these six rooms on account of the orders passed on 10-10-1969. But this order cannot be construed as to deprive opposite party Nos. 1 to 3 from enjoyment of the undivided property. For these reasons, in our view, the petitioners cannot claim mesne profits against opposite party Nos. 1 to 3. The application therefore, fails and is dismissed; but in the circumstances there will be no order as to costs.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF PATNA

Civil Revn. No. 1039 of 1977

Decided On: 16.08.1979

Shambhu Dayal Khetan and Ors. Vs. Motilal Murarka and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

S. Ali Ahmad and Maheshwar Pradesh Verma, JJ.

Citation: AIR 1980 Patna 106, MANU/BH/0026/1980.

Print Page

How the court should deal with issue of grant of mesne profits under different types of suits?

 It is necessary at the outset to distinguish between three different types of cases in which a question of profits or mesne profits might arise. (1) Suits for ejectment or recovery of possession of Immovable property from a person in possession without title, together with a claim for past or past & future mesne profits. (2) Suits for partition by one or more tenants-in-common against others with a claim for account of past or past & future profits. (3) Suits for partition by a member of a joint Hindu family with a claim for an account from the manager. In the first case, the possession of the defts. not being lawful, the plff. is entitled to recover "mesne profits" as defined in Section 2, Clause (12), Civ. P. C., such profits being really in the nature of damages. In the second case, the possession & receipt of profits by the deft, not being wrongful the plff's. remedy is to have an account of such profits making all just allowances in favour of the collecting tenant in common. In the third case, the plff. must take the joint family property as it exists at the date of the demand for partition and is not entitled to open up past accounts or claim relief on the ground of past inequality of enjoyment of the profit, except where the manager has been guilty of fraudulent conduct or misappropriation. The plff. would, however, be in the position of a tenant-in-common from the date of severance in status & his rights would have to be worked out on that basis. {Para 3}


4. Order 20, Rule 12, Civil P. C. deals with the first class of suit above referred to, while Order 20, Rule 18, Ideals with the second & the third categories. In view, however, of the considerable reliance placed on Order 20, Rule 12, Civil P. C. in Ghulusum Bivi v. Ahmadsa Rowther, 42 Mad. 296in dealing with the right of a plff. to profits accruing during the pendency of a partition suit, it is desirable to consider the scope of this provision. A claim for possession & a claim for past mesne profits have been held to be based on different causes of action, at any rate, in the decisions of this Court. Order 2, Rule 4, Civil P. C. however permits their joinder in one suit. There is a material difference between a claim for past & a claim for future mesne profits. Order 7, Rule 2, Civil P. C. & Section 7 Sub-section (1), Court fees Act, require that the amount of past mesne profits claimed should be approximately stated in the plaint & ad valorem court-fee should be paid on such amount. These provisions can have no application to future profits, for it is not possible for the plff. to predicate how long the litigation is going to last or give even an approximate statement of the amount of mesne profits that might become payable at the end. The cause of action for future mesne profits is the plff's. being kept out of possession during the suit & arises subsequent to the suit. In empowering Courts to award future mesne profits Order 20, Rule 12, Civ. P. C. makes an exception to the general rule that a plff. can only sue on such cause of action as has arisen on the date of instituting his suit. The object is to avoid the multiplicity of litigation that would result if persons, unlawfully kept out of possession of their lands were obliged to file suits every three years for mesne profits accruing after the institution of a suit in ejectment & during its pendency in the original & appellate Courts. But the plff. could not claim future mesne profits as a matter of right, the cause of action for such profits not having arisen to him at the date of the suit. Hence it is that the power of the Court to award mesne profits subsequent to the suit has been held to be discretionary & a mere omission, as distinguished from a refusal, to grant future mesne profits asked for, has been held not to bar a fresh suit for that relief. Doraiswami v. Subramania, 41 Mad. 188. In re Ekanathalingaswami, I.L.R. (1937) Mad. 284. Section 11, Court-fees Act, (as amended in Madras) requires payment of court-fee on future mesne profits only if the plff. desires to execute the decree awarding him such profits. The Judicial Committee interpreting the provisions of Section 196, Civ. P. C. of 1859 & this Court, construing the corresponding provisions of Order 20, Rule 12 held that whether a plaint contained or not a claim to future profits the Court has the power to grant them under these special provisions, Fakharuddin Mohamed Ashan v. Official Trustee of Bengal, 8 Cal. 178 & Kemgamswami v. Subbamma, 53 Mad. 838. When the Legislature has expressly empowered the Court to grant relief for future mesne profits, that is to say, in respect of a cause of action arising subsequent to the suit, there is no reason to circumscribe this power by importing a qualification that there must have been a specific prayer in the plaint for the recovery of such unascertainable & unpredictable profits. Future mesne profits could, we think, well be awarded as part of the general relief to which a plff. is entitled.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADRAS

FULL BENCH

Civil Revn Petn No. 1695 of 1948

Decided On: 02.02.1951

Babburu Basavayya and Ors. Vs. Babburu Guravayya and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

P.V. Rajamannar, C.J. Vishwanatha Sastri and A.S. Panchapakesa Ayyar, JJ.

Author: P.V. Rajamannar, C.J.

Citation: AIR 1951 Madras 938.

Print Page

Tuesday, 23 May 2023

Whether owner of property is entitled to get mesne profits or fair rent for the period when property was not in wrongful possession?

  At the outset, we may point out that there are different methods of valuation, namely, income/profit method, cost of construction method, rent method and contractors' method. In the present case, the arbitrator has applied the income/profit method. The above two issues are interconnected, as the arbitrator has assessed damages on the assumption that after 10.3.1987, the occupation and possession of the property was wrongful and illegal and in the nature of trespass. Accordingly, he has assessed damages on the footing that the respondent was entitled to mesne profits. This assumption was wrong as the appellant was given time by this Court to remain in possession up to 31.3.1993. In Law of Damages & Compensation by Kameshwara Rao (5th Edn., Vol. I Page 528], the learned author states that right to mesne profits presupposes a wrong whereas a right to rent proceeds on the basis that there is a contract. But there is an intermediate class of cases in which the possession though not wrongful in the beginning assumes a wrongful character when it is unauthorisedly retained and in such cases, the owner is not entitled to claim mesne profits but only the fair rent. In the present case, in view of the permission granted by this Court enabling the appellant to use and occupy the property up to 31.3.1993, it cannot be said that the possession of the appellant was illegal and wrongful and in the nature of trespass. In the circumstances, damages were claimable not on the basis of mesne profits but on the basis of fair rent. {Para 8}

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 1531 of 1999

Decided On: 12.04.2004

Union of India (UOI) and Ors.  Vs. Banwari Lal and Sons (P) Ltd.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

V.N. Khare, C.J., S.B. Sinha and S.H. Kapadia, JJ.

Authored By : S.H. Kapadia, S.B. Sinha

S.H. Kapadia, J.

Citation : (2004 )5SCC 304, MANU/SC/0331/2004

Print Page

Thursday, 7 July 2022

How to ascertain mesne profits or compensation while staying execution of eviction decree?

 Now, reverting on the issue of determination of the amount of

mesne profits @ Rs.2,50,000/per month is concerned, the guidance may be taken from the judgment of Marshall Sons & Co. (I) Ltd. vs. Sahi Oretrans (P) Ltd. and Another – (1999) 2 SCC 325, in which this Court held that once a decree for possession has been passed and the execution is delayed depriving the decree holder to reap the fruits, it is necessary for the Appellate Court to pass appropriate orders fixing reasonable mesne profits which may be equivalent to the market rent required to be paid by a person who is holding over the property. In the case of Atma Ram Properties (P) Ltd. vs. Federal Motors (P) Ltd. – (2005) 1 SCC 705, this Court held that Appellate Court does have jurisdiction to put reasonable terms and conditions as would in its opinion reasonable to compensate the decree holder for loss occasioned by delay in execution of the decree while granting the stay. The Court relying upon the provisions of the Delhi Rent Control Act, observed that on passing the decree for eviction by a competent Court, thetenant is liable to pay mesne profit or compensation for use and occupation of the premises at the same rate at which the landlord would have able to let out the premises in present and earn the profit if the tenant would have vacated the premises. The Court has explained that because of pendency of the appeal, which may be in continuation of suit, the doctrine of merger does not have effect of postponing the date of termination of tenancy merely because the decree of eviction stands merged in the decree passed by the superior forum at a later date. {Para 10}

11. Thus, after passing the decree of eviction the tenancy

terminates and from the said date the landlord is entitled for mesne profits or compensation depriving him from the use of the premises. The view taken in the case of Atma Ram (supra) has been reaffirmed in the case of State of Maharashtra vs. Super Max International Pvt. Ltd. and others (2009) 9 SCC 772 by threeJudges Bench of this Court. 

12. The basis of determination of the amount of mesne profit, in

our view, depends on the facts and circumstances of each case

considering place where the property is situated i.e. village or city or metropolitan city, location, nature of premises i.e. commercial or residential are and the rate of rent precedent on which premises can be let out are the guiding factor in the facts of individual case.

 REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NOS. 464647 OF 2022

M/s. Martin & Harris Private Limited & Anr. Vs Rajendra Mehta & Ors. 

Author: J.K. Maheshwari, J.

Dated: July 06, 2022

Print Page

Sunday, 5 January 2020

Whether appellate court should determine mesne profits for determining interim compensation while staying eviction decree?

 If this Court indulges in a threadbare analysis and judicially
determines the relative merits of the rival mesne profits reports at an
interlocutory stage—more so under Order 41, Rule 5 of CPC—that
preempts the trial Court’s legitimate adjudicatory powers under Order
20, Rule 12 of CPC. Here, what this Court intends, or requires, to do is
to use the “commonsense which is a cluster of life's experiences” rather
than depend on the rival facts presented by warring litigants.”
(g) Pragmatic Pursuit:
32. Indeed, any adjudication, if it were, under Order 41, Rule 5
of CPC involves an element of ad hocism, a permissible level of guess
work, and a dose of discretion. That provision is a step-in-aid in appeal
proceedings; it tries to keep both the rivals in the litigation on an even
keel. One has the reality of a decree; the other a possibility of its
reversal. The decree, say in an eviction suit, alters the characters of

parties. The tenant is no longer a tenant; he is, at best, an occupant.
And that occupation stands branded as unauthorised. The suspension
of the decree does not obliterate the judicial findings; it only keeps its
effect—its execution—at bay. So to have the legitimate judicial dictum
put on hold in the name of stay, the appellant needs to submit himself
to certain terms. The terms of, for example, paying monetary
compensation. A stay is not for mere asking. Nor can the appellant
paint himself a victim under Order 41, Rule 5 of CPC. That said, I
must also acknowledge that the appellate courts will not lose sight of
the distinction between what is ideal and what is practical; what is
discretionary and what is arbitrary; what is a fair guess and what is a
wild whim.
33. With judicial overload, docket explosion, and clogging
adjudicatory avenues at every echelon, we cannot expect a mini-trial
even under Order 41, Rule 5 of CPC, for fixing, say, an interim
compensation. It is ideal. But with the litigious multitude knocking at
the court’s doors clamouring for speedy justice, it is an unaffordable
legal luxury.
34. Here, in the revision, the appellant cannot insist on
reappreciation of his case on merits. This Court can only examine the
jurisdictional errors, if any, committed by the Appellate Bench.
Therefore, the tenant seeking to stall the execution of a decree from a
final court of fact has more burden to bear.
(h) The Result:
35. So, I reckon this Court’s interim arrangement needs no
interference, for this adjudication under Order 41, Rule 5 of CPC has no trappings of a judicial determination of mesne profits under Order
20, Rule 12 of CPC. The tenant will continue to pay Rs.25,000/- per
month to have the decree stayed, and the eviction stalled. Between the
two extremes of Rs.71,500/- per month and Rs.12,846/-, as projected
by the landlords and tenant respectively, my altering the figure
Rs.25,000/- can be nothing more than a cosmetic consideration. This
interim arraignment does not prevent the landlords from invoking
Order 20, Rule 12 of CPC. In that event, both the rival contenders can
invite a reasoned order from the trial Court.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL REVISION APPLICATION (ST.) NO.33250 OF 2018

Previn Govind Sharma Vs  Dinyar Jal Jamshedji

CORAM : DAMA SESHADRI NAIDU, J.
DATE : 21st JUNE 2019.
Print Page

Friday, 20 December 2019

Whether subsequent suit for mesne profits will be barred by O 2 R 2 of CPC?

"Taking into consideration the changes introduced by the present Civil Procedure Code to the old law, there is nothing to indicate that the changes have taken away the force of the old decisions hereinbefore referred to. A claim for mesne profits is not a claim under the same obligation compelling a trespasser to restore possession. A claim for mesne profits is also not based on the same cause of action as the claim for possession. A person may be in wrongful possession but even then may not be obliged to pay mesne profits if he has not received or might not have received with ordinary diligence profits from the property in wrongful possession. The liability to pay mesne profits arises from the profits a person has or might reasonably have made by his wrongful possession. Thus the obligation to pay mesne profits arises from a cause of action completely different from the obligation to restore possession of the immovable property to the rightful owner."
Although the said decision was concerned with whether the second suit was barred under Order II Rule 2 of the CPC, the court did not accept the contention that causes of action for recovery of possession and for mesne profits are the same. The court rejected the contention that where a claim for mesne profits was not included in a previous suit for possession of the property, a second suit for such mesne profits was barred under Order II Rule 2 of the CPC. The view taken by a learned Judge of this Court on 27th May, 1958 remains good law even after sixty years, despite numerous amendments to the CPC.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA

G.A. No. 102 of 2018 and C.S. No. 152 of 2017

Decided On: 30.01.2019

 Bahubali Promoters Private Limited  Vs.  Shyam Sel & Power Limited
Print Page

Sunday, 15 December 2019

Whether mesne profits can be awarded in obstructionist notice?

The Trial Court has also placed reliance on the
judgment of the Apex Court reported in 1999 Bom. R. C. 357 in the
matter of Marshall Sons & Co. (I) Ltd. Vs. Sahi Oretrans (P) Ltd.,
wherein the Apex Court has held that if the execution of a decree is
resisted by the obstructionist, then obstructionist is liable to pay mesne
profits equivalent to the market rate.

 It is an undisputed position that the Petitioner is in
occupation of the tenanted premises and in terms of the judgment of the
Apex Court in Marshall (supra), the obstructionist is liable to pay for such
occupation.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO.10003 OF 2015

Shri. Dnyandev Tukaram Kshirsagar Vs M/s. Pyramid Corporation 

CORAM : R.M. SAVANT, J.
DATE : 16th NOVEMBER, 2015

Print Page

Sunday, 1 December 2019

How to ascertain period for which mesne profits can be claimed under rent law?

As indicated above, in the instant case the decree passed by the Trial Court was set aside by the Appellate Bench of the Small Causes Court and was re-instated by virtue of the order passed in the Writ Petition. Hence the decree passed by the Trial Court had merged in the decree of dismissal passed by the Appellate Bench of the Small Causes Court and hence there was no decree till this Court allowed the Writ Petition No. 4053 of 1992 by the judgment and order dated 03/09/2002. The doctrine of merger has no application in so far as merger of the decree of the Trial Court in the judgment and order passed by this Court is concerned. Hence it is only on 03/09/2002 that there was a decree in favour of the Plaintiffs so as to entitle them to lay a claim for mesne profits. Once it is held that Article 113 of the Limitation Act is to apply, then the logical corollary of the same would be that the Plaintiffs would be entitled to mesne profits for the preceding three years i.e. up to 1999. The Appellate Bench of the Small Causes Court held that the judgment of the Trial Court does not merge in the judgment of the highest forum. However, the Appellate Bench by applying the law laid down by the Apex Court in Atma Ram Properties' case (supra) held that the Plaintiffs i.e. the Decree Holders would be entitled to mesne profits from 30/09/1991 i.e. when the decree was passed by the Trial Court. In my view, the Appellate Bench has erred in applying the judgment in Atma Ram Properties' case (supra) to a claim for mesne profits as the said judgment concerns the conditions that can be imposed at the time of granting stay to the decree passed by the Trial Court and therefore cannot be invoked to fix the date from which the Plaintiffs i.e. Decree Holders would be entitled for mesne profits. That apart, applying Atma Ram Properties' case (supra) would also militate against the provisions of the Limitation Act which specifically provide that a money claim can be made only for the preceding three years. Hence in so far as the impugned order holds that it is Article 113 that would apply no exception could be taken to the same however in so far as it holds that the Plaintiffs are entitled to mesne profits from the year 1991 is concerned the same is unsustainable and is accordingly required to be set aside to the said extent, and it is required to be declared that the Plaintiffs would be entitled to the mesne profits for the three years preceding 03/09/2002 i.e. from 03/09/1999.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Civil Revision Application No. 765 of 2015

Decided On: 07.03.2016

 Central Bank of India Vs. Anil Puranmal Bansal and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
R.M. Savant, J.
Print Page

Sunday, 24 November 2019

Whether judgment debtor can deduct income tax out of mesne profits paid under decree of court?

The above definition of rent makes it abundantly clear that rent is a payment by whatever name you call it for use of any land or building. Thus, merely because the rent awarded by the Court was called by the Court as damages mesne profits does not mean that it ceases to be income of the Decree Holder. Similarly, I consider that interest over the unpaid amount would qualify as income since the unpaid amount is treated as something lying deposited with the Judgment Debtor. As, a person has to pay income tax on his deposits in the bank or in FDs, he is liable to pay income tax on the interest received by him under Court orders for unpaid amounts. The judgments cited by the Decree Holder are of no help since the judgments deal with different facts and circumstances. In Haryana Urban Development Authority v. Dr. Ashok Kumar Aggarwal MANU/SC/0817/2004 : (2005) 9 SCC 524 the Supreme Court observed that TDS could not be deducted on the payments towards compensation/damages for mental agony and harassment. The Supreme Court was not dealing with mesne profits in lieu of occupation and use of the premises. The view taken by the Calcutta High Court in my opinion is not the correct view. Delhi High Court in case of Mrs. Kanti Singh and Ors. v. The Project and Equipment Corporation of India Ltd. 2001 III AD (Delhi) 686 had given no opinion about TDS and only stated that the Court cannot go behind the decree.

7. I, find no force in the plea taken by Decree Holder that Judgment Debtor could not have deducted tax at source and deposited it with the government when Judgment had to pay rent mesne profits under orders of the Court.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

Ex. Appl. No. 405/2009 in Ex. P. No. 351/2008

Decided On: 23.12.2009

Five Star Engg. and Agents Pvt. Ltd. Vs.  P.B. State Industrial Development Corporation

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
S.N. Dhingra, J.

Print Page

Saturday, 23 November 2019

Whether decree for mesne profits can be executed without payment of court fees?

The contention of learned Counsel for the appellants is that by virtue of Section 48 of the Administration of Evacuee Property Act the appellant is entitled to recover the amount of mesne profits decreed in the original suit notwithstanding that the Court fee has not yet been paid pursuant to the decree. It is printed cut that an order made by the trial Court in execution proceedings that the decree was not executable unless the deficiency in Court fee was made good restrains execution proceedings only and does not bar recovery by some other mode, such as recovery under Section 48 of the Administration of Evacuee property Act. In our opinion, reference to Section 46 can be of assistance to the appellant. The decree for payment of mesne profits cannot be said to have come it to operation. It is a conditional decree. The sum decreed as mesne profits is payable to the decree holder only if the full amount of Court fee is paid by him. The decree itself embodies that stipulation. The obligation on the part of the judgment debtor to pay the mesne profits accrues only on the satisfaction of that condition Admittedly, the deficiency in Court fee has not been removed. Plainly, therefore, the appellant is not entitled to payment of the mesne profits under the decree.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 1509 of 1970

Decided On: 25.07.1980

 Assistant Custodian-General of Evacuee Property Vs.  Lila Devi and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
O. Chinnappa Reddy and R.S. Pathak, JJ.

Citation : (1980 )4SCC 224


Print Page

How to determine forum of appeal if court grant mesne profits exceeding value of suit?

The Full Bench of Calcutta High Court has clearly laid down in the case of Bidyadhar Bachar and others v. Mahindra Nath Pas and others MANU/WB/0098/1925 : AIR1925Cal1076 that where a Judge has in the proper exercise of his jurisdiction passed a decree for possession and also a preliminary decree for mesne profits, he must be held to have jurisdiction to make a final decree in accordance with his decision. This jurisdiction is not limited. If, as a result of the inquiry directed by him, the mesne profits are found to exceed the amount of value of the suit, the suit is rightly entertained as within the jurisdiction of the Judge and a decree is passed, his power to grant the proper and adequate relief is not affected by any event which increases the value of the relief during the pendency of the suit.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY AT GOA

Civil Revision Application No. 75 of 1999 and Civil Rev. No. 76 of 1999

Decided On: 02.12.1999

Vishwanath Raghuvir Sinai Edo. Vs.  Ashok Dattatray Dande and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
R.M.S. Khandeparkar, J.

Citation:2000(4) BCR 734
Print Page

How to ascertain court fees in appeal if prayer for mesne profits is either decreed or dismissed?

Consequently for the reasons given above, our opinion on the question referred to this Bench is as follows:--

"If in a suit for past mesne profits, and possession the plaintiff also prays for a decree for future mesne profits then he is neither required to value the relief of future mesne profits nor pay any Court- fees thereon as in such cases he has no existing legal right to claim such future mesne profits and has no cause of action for them on the date of suit. Further, in our opinion, when in such a suit, in Which a prayer for future mesne profits is also made, the Court either decrees or refuses to grant future mesne profits, then in the event of an appeal either by the defendant or by the plaintiff court-fees on such mesne profits which may have be come due from the date of suit till the date of appeal are not payable."

IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH

Civil Revn. Nos. 41 of 42 of 1971

Decided On: 08.09.1972

Shivaji  Vs.  Deoji and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
S.P. Bahrgava and S.R. Vyas, JJ.

Citation : AIR 1974 MP 123

Print Page

Whether forum of appeal is determined by plaintiff's valuation in plaint or by amount decreed?

There is thus no manner of doubt that it is the value of the suit, that is, the value of the subject matter thereof that determines the court in which the suit is to be filed and also determines the forum of the appeal, meaning by that the Court to which the appeal lies. Now, the Suits Valuation Act, which otherwise as observed in Ahmedbhai Kadubhai v. Badurddin, AIR 1946 Bom 356, applies only to suits and not to appeals, prescribes the mode of making the valuation of the suits for the purpose of jurisdiction and in some case, the valuation is left entirely to the discretion of the plaintiff. In such cases, it is the plaintiff s valuation in the plaint that fixes the pecuniary Jurisdiction of the Court and not the amount which may be found and decreed.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (PANAJI BENCH, GOA)

First Civil Appeal No. 3 of 1986

Decided On: 18.11.1988

Francisco Luis Jose D Souza  Vs. Vithal Bhadu Tamboskar

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Dr. G.F. Couto and G.D. Kamat, JJ.

Citation : AIR 1989 Bom 303
Print Page

Leading Bombay HC judgment for determination of forum of appeal in suit for eviction and mesne profits

Tenancy - eviction - Sections 2 and 15 Order 6 Rule 17, Order 7, Order 20 Rules 12 (1) and 12 (2) (as applicable to Maharashtra) of Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 - suit for arrears of rent and mesne profits - decree for possession passed with direction for mesne profits - enquiry conducted under Order 20 Rule 12 for determination of mesne profits - appellant contended that forum of appeal would be determined as per final outcome of enquiry under Order 20 Rule 12 - contention of petitioner rejected - forum of appeal is determined with reference to value of suit and not amount decreed - held, forum of appeal to be determined as per valuation put by plaintiff when suit was filed.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

First Appeal No. 397 of 1993 arising out of decree dated 15-7-1993 in Mesne Profit Case No. 7 of 1986

Decided On: 30.11.1998

Syed Saifuddin Vs.  Kasturchand Abhayrajji Golchha

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
N.J. Pandya, J.N. Patel and A.B. Palkar, JJ.

Citation: 1999 ( 2 ) MhLJ 675,2000(4) B. C.R 582


N.J. Pandya, J.
Print Page

Thursday, 21 November 2019

Whether in partition suit plaintiff is entitled to get mesne profits and from which period?

In suit for partition plaintiff can claim mesne profits. the plaintiff must take the joint family property as it exists at date of the demand for partition and is not entitled to open up past accounts or claim relief on the ground of past inequality of enjoyment of the profit, except where the manager has been guilty of fraudulent conduct or misappropriation.
Madras High Court

D. Nataraja Achari vs Balambal Ammal on 13 March, 1979
Equivalent citations: (1979) 2 MLJ 234

Author: V Ratnam
Read full judgment here: Click here
Print Page

Wednesday, 30 October 2019

Whether court should grant reasonable mesne profits even if applicant has failed to lead evidence in that respect?

11. It is correct that the Appellant had not led any evidence on the issue of mesne profits though such an issue was specifically framed. However, in the interest of justice, the Appellant could have been granted some reasonable compensation for the wrongful possession of the premises from the Respondent herein.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 5855 of 2018 
Decided On: 23.02.2018

Bhag Singh Vs. Vikram Sandhu

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
A.K. Sikri and Ashok Bhushan, JJ.

Citation:(2018) 18 SCC 374
Print Page

Thursday, 29 August 2019

Whether court can grant enquiry for mesne profits even without prayer in this regard?

I do not find any substance in the submission of learned counsel for the appellant-UCO Bank that the respondents-original plaintiffs did not pray for such an inquiry for the mesne profit under Order 20, Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure and in absence of a specific prayer for inquiry into mesne profit, the Trial Court while deciding Small Cause Suit No. 39 of 2001, directed an inquiry into mesne profit under Order 20, Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Even in the case of Gulamhusain Asgaraly Vahanvaty (MANU/MH/0600/2011 : 2011 (4) Bom CR 169) (supra), relied upon by learned counsel for appellant-UCO Bank, this Court has taken a view that the relief of mesne profits is a consequential relief to the main relief and the trial court has to pass an order of holding inquiry into mesne profit when the suit is decreed. If such a suit for recovery of possession is dismissed, the question of payment of mesne profits does not arise and therefore, very often, issue of mesne profits is not framed since there is an independent provision in the CPC for holding an inquiry for mesne profits, and only when the suit is decreed further consequential relief is to be granted.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)

First Appeal No. 652 of 2006

Decided On: 03.05.2016

UCO Bank, Vs.  Asaram Mohanlal Samdani and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
V.K. Jadhav, J.

Citation: 2017(2) ALLMR 92
Print Page

Sunday, 28 April 2019

Whether court should grant mesne profit if plaintiff has not claimed it in plaint?

It was however pointed out by Shri S.P. Sinha that the High Court erred in awarding to the plaintiffs mesne profits even though there was no demand for the same in the plaint. The learned Solicitor General appearing for the plaintiffs conceded that there was no demand for mesne profits as such but urged that the claim for mesne profits would be included within the expression "awarding possession and occupation of the property aforesaid together with all the rights appertaining thereto." We are afraid that the claim for mesne profits cannot be included within this expression and the High Court was in error in awarding to the plaintiffs mesne profits though they had not been claimed in the plaint. The provision in regard to the mesne profits will therefore have to be deleted from the decree.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 583 of 2008 (Arising out of SLP (C) No. 18522 of 2004)

Decided On: 22.01.2008

 Ganapati Madhav Sawant  Vs. Dattur Madhav Sawant

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Dr. Arijit Pasayat and P. Sathasivam, JJ.

Citation:  2008(3) S.C.C. 183.
Print Page

Sunday, 3 February 2019

What reliefs can be claimed before small cause court?

 Mr. Sanghavi also submitted that in the plaint the plaintiff has claimed a sum of Rs. 35,625 by way of damages for trespass for the period June 1, 1970 till the date of the suit, that is, till April 1978, at the rate of Rs. 375 per month and for a sum of Rs. 375 per month from the date of the suit till possession of the said flat is handed over to the plaintiff either by way of future mesne profits or damages or compensation for wrongful use and occupation of the said flat. Mr. Sanghavi argued that Section 41 of the Presidency Small Cause Courts Act did not in terms include a suit for damages for trespass or for compensation for wrongful use and occupation or for mesne profits. In his submission, the section only related to recovery of licence fee or charges and that the licence having been determined, all that the plaintiff could recover from the defendant was either damages for trespass or compensation for wrongful use and occupation of the property or mesne profits. This argument by Mr. Sanghavi overlooks the language used in the said Section 41. The said Section 41 speaks of "all suits and proceedings between a licensor and licensee, or a landlord and tenant, relating to the recovery of possession of any immovable property situated in Greater Bombay". It is significant that the words used in the said Section 41 are "suits relating to the recovery of possession" and not "suits for possession". Rule 12 of Order 20 of the Civil P. C., 1908, provides as to how a Court is to proceed "Where a suit is for the recovery of possession of immovable property and for rent or mesne profits." The contrast between the language used in Order 20, Rule 12 and the said Section 41 immediately strikes one. The phrase "relating to the possession of any immovable property" is wider than the phrase "for the recovery of possession of any Immovable property." The words "relating to" are intentionally and designedly used in the said Section 41 not to confine the section only to a suit for the recovery of possession of immovable property situate in Greater Bombay but also to permit to be included within the ambit of such a suit all other reliefs which the plaintiff can claim in a suit for the recovery of possession of immovable property on the termination of a licence or a tenancy.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Short Cause Suit No. 890 of 1978

Decided On: 08.02.1979

Nagin Mansukhlal Dagli  Vs. Haribhai Manibhai Patel

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Balkrishna Narhar Deshmukh, C.J. and D.P. Madon, J.

Citation: AIR 1980 Bombay 123.
Print Page

Wednesday, 2 January 2019

How to ascertain court fees for appeal in suit for mesne profits?

 The same High Court in Dhanukdhari Prasad v. Ramadhikari, (MANU/BH/0122/1932 : ILR 12 Pat 188: AIR 1933 Pat 81) (H) held that, where the amount of mesne profits is definitely ascertained and embodied in a final decree, and an appeal is presented against that decree, the Appellant must pay on the memorandum of appeal ad valorem court-fee calculated on the amount of the decree, which is the subject-matter of the appeal and not merely on the value of the mesne profits claimed in the plaint. At page 194 (of ILR Pat): (at pp. 83-84 of AIR), James J. observed:

The question, therefore, to be considered in the present case is that of whether ad valorem court-fee is payable on the whole amount for which the Appellants seek to avoid liability or only on that portion of it which was included in the value of the plaint. It appears to me that the reasons given by the Division Bench for their decision in (MANU/BH/0055/1932 : ILR 11 Pat 532: AIR 1932 Pat 228) (G) should prevail, that an appeal differs from a mere application for ascertainment of mesne profits and that a memorandum of appeal of this kind is liable to ad valorem court-fee under Article 1 of Sch. I, Court-fees Act.

When mesne profits have once been definitely ascertained in execution, the Plaintiff is certainly capable for ascertaining the exact amount which he claims, and the Defendant knows definitely the amount of the liability which he is seeking to escape.

16. This case also accepts the principle that, where the amount is ascertained or ascertainable, ad valorem court-fee should be paid on the amount or the value of the subject-matter of the appeal.


18. Having regard to the provisions of the Court-fees Act and the decisions interpreting the said provisions, the law may be briefly stated thus: "In a suit for mesne profits whether past or future, if the mesne profits are ascertained and decreed, the party preferring an appeal should pay court-fee on the amount or value of the subject-matter in the appeal. If the Defendant files an appeal seeking to get rid of the decree in whole or in part, he will have to pay court-fee in whole or in part on the amount decreed which he seeks to vacate.

If a Plaintiff seeks to file an appeal questioning the correctness of the amount ascertained and decreed in his favour, the subject-matter of the appeal will be the excess amount he claims to have over that already awarded to him, and, therefore, he will have to pay ad valorem court-fee on the additional amount he claims. In either case, the mesne profits are ascertained and the party, be he a Plaintiff or a Defendant, know the exact amount, which is the subject-matter of appeal."

IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH

Stamp Register No. 3958 of 1956 (Appeal No. 368 of 1956)

Decided On: 26.03.1956

 In Re: Kudappa Subbamma

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
K. Subba Rao, C.J. and Vishwanatha Sastri, J.

 Citation : AIR 1957 AP 6

Print Page