Showing posts with label fair rent. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fair rent. Show all posts

Tuesday, 23 May 2023

Whether owner of property is entitled to get mesne profits or fair rent for the period when property was not in wrongful possession?

  At the outset, we may point out that there are different methods of valuation, namely, income/profit method, cost of construction method, rent method and contractors' method. In the present case, the arbitrator has applied the income/profit method. The above two issues are interconnected, as the arbitrator has assessed damages on the assumption that after 10.3.1987, the occupation and possession of the property was wrongful and illegal and in the nature of trespass. Accordingly, he has assessed damages on the footing that the respondent was entitled to mesne profits. This assumption was wrong as the appellant was given time by this Court to remain in possession up to 31.3.1993. In Law of Damages & Compensation by Kameshwara Rao (5th Edn., Vol. I Page 528], the learned author states that right to mesne profits presupposes a wrong whereas a right to rent proceeds on the basis that there is a contract. But there is an intermediate class of cases in which the possession though not wrongful in the beginning assumes a wrongful character when it is unauthorisedly retained and in such cases, the owner is not entitled to claim mesne profits but only the fair rent. In the present case, in view of the permission granted by this Court enabling the appellant to use and occupy the property up to 31.3.1993, it cannot be said that the possession of the appellant was illegal and wrongful and in the nature of trespass. In the circumstances, damages were claimable not on the basis of mesne profits but on the basis of fair rent. {Para 8}

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 1531 of 1999

Decided On: 12.04.2004

Union of India (UOI) and Ors.  Vs. Banwari Lal and Sons (P) Ltd.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

V.N. Khare, C.J., S.B. Sinha and S.H. Kapadia, JJ.

Authored By : S.H. Kapadia, S.B. Sinha

S.H. Kapadia, J.

Citation : (2004 )5SCC 304, MANU/SC/0331/2004

Print Page

Sunday, 2 February 2020

Whether landlord can make application for fixation for fair rent?

The Constitution Bench judgment in M/s. Raval &
Co.’s case as well as seven-Judge Bench judgment in V.
Dhanapal Chettiar’s case are binding which
categorically had laid down that application for
determination of fair rent can be made both by the
landlord and tenant which can be made even during
currency of contractual tenancy. 

REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO.710 OF 2020

N. MOTILAL  Vs FAISAL BIN ALI 

ASHOK BHUSHAN,J.
Dated:January 30, 2020.
Print Page

Tuesday, 8 May 2018

Whether application for fair rent can be rejected if age of construction of building is not mentioned?

 I have considered the submissions advanced by learned Counsel for the petitioners and perused the record and the judgment relied upon. In Shantilal Shah's case (supra) learned Single Judge of this Court dismissed the petition filed by the petitioner/landlord challenging the order passed by the authorities under Rent Control Order dismissing the application. Learned Single Judge has held that in an application for fixation of fair rent filed by the landlord he is bound to plead the age of construction of the house since in terms of Clauses 4, 5, 6 and 7 of the Rent Control Order the determination of fair rent depends upon the age of construction of the house. After considering the effect of Clauses 4, 5, 6 and 7 of the Rent Control Order, the learned Single Judge has held that in the absence of pleadings with regard to the age of construction of the house, the application for fixation of fair rent was liable to be dismissed. Perusal of the application filed by respondents 1 to 4 discloses that the age of construction of the suit house has not been mentioned. Therefore, the ratio in Shantilal Shah's case (supra) is squarely applicable in the present case. No doubt, since the matter proceeded ex parte, the petitioners have neither taken this point before the Rent Controller nor before the Appellate Authority. However, since the point goes to the root of the matter that is, to the maintainability of the application for fixation of the fair rent, in my considered opinion, the petitioners are entitled to urge this ground for the first time in the writ petition. Since respondents 1 and 4 have not pleaded regarding the age of the construction of the suit house, the application filed by respondents 1 to 4 was not maintainable. Consequently, the impugned orders passed by the Rent Controller as well as Additional Collector, Nagpur are liable to be quashed and set aside.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

W.P. No. 287 of 2001

Decided On: 08.09.2008

Nandkumar S/o B.H. Naidu and Ors. Vs. Thanwardas S/o Hasanand Janyani and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
A.P. Lavande, J.

Print Page

Sunday, 1 February 2015

Whether different fair rent can be fixed in respect of similarly situated building?


   The building in occupation of

tenant in RCR No.422/2012 is facing MG Road.        There is

not much difference in rooms in occupation of the

tenants in RCR Nos.420 and 422 of 2012.         It is to be

noted that there is no challenge by the tenant in RCR

No.421/2012 as against fair rent fixation.         The fair

rent fixed in respect of the premises in R.C.R.No.

421/2012 is Rs.27/- per sq.ft.         We consider, in such


circumstances, uniformity of fair rent fixation of

similarly situated buildings is warranted and fixing

different fair rent in respect of similarly situated

building having same advantage of commercial potential

is   unsustainable.        The  activities of  tenants are

commercial      and    buildings   were  let out  for  non

residential purpose. Advantages and disadvantages of

the building from commercial point of view are one and

the same. The slender advantages and disadvantages on

comparison cannot be a reason to fix different rate of

fair rent. Therefore, uniformity of the rate of fair

rent is appropriate in the facts and circumstances.
  IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

                                                      PRESENT:

                          THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K.T.SANKARAN
                                                            &
                   THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A.MUHAMED MUSTAQUE

             THURSDAY, THE 23RD DAY OF OCTOBER 2014

                                           RCRev..No. 420 of 2012 ()
                                              

            K.S.KADAR PILLAI, 
Vs
            M/S. GOVEN TRAVELS
            Citation;AIR 2015(NOC)24 kerala
Print Page

Whether rent control court can grant periodical enhancement of fair rent?


 Next    common     question is  whether the  Rent

Control    Court    is    justified   in granting  periodical

enhancement at the rate of 10% in every two years.        In

Sreekumaran Nair v.Ponnuswami Chettiyar [2010 (3) KLT

444], this Court held as follows:

           "The question that survives for consideration

      is    whether     the    decision  of   the   statutory

      authorities to allow 10% increase per year can be

      approved.       The learned Rent Control Appellate

      Authority noticed several relevant aspects such as

      the value of money being on decline, corresponding

      increase in the value of land, inflationary trends

      in the economy and also the regular growth of the

      city as a whole etc.       These reasons, we also feel,


      are good reasons which can justify the decision to

      allow increase on the fair rent at a reasonable

      rate at regular intervals."

     6.    We are also of the view that those factors can

be taken note of for periodical enhancement.       But those

general factors are to be shown to exist while granting

periodical enhancement.        The Rent Control Courts cannot

routinely allow reasonable modification to rates so

fixed.    It has to be remembered that the right of the

landlord is not foreclosed by fixing a fair rent by the

Rent Control Court to approach the Court again for fair

rent fixation.      The cause of action to fix fair rent is

a recurring cause of action depending upon factors that

warrant fixation of the fair rent.          In extreme case,

there may warrant reduction of the fair rent so fixed

on account of the decrease in market transactions,

change of main avenue, shift of commercial activities,

diversion     of    main    road etc.,  therefore,  in   such

situation it is not safe to award periodical increase.

We do not find any reason has been assigned by the Rent

Control     Court    in    granting periodical   enhancement.


Therefore, we affirm the decision of the Appellate

Authority in setting aside the periodical enhancement.
  IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

                                                      PRESENT:

                          THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K.T.SANKARAN
                                                            &
                   THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A.MUHAMED MUSTAQUE

             THURSDAY, THE 23RD DAY OF OCTOBER 2014

                                           RCRev..No. 420 of 2012 ()
                                       
            K.S.KADAR PILLAI, 
Vs
            M/S. GOVEN TRAVELS
           Citation;AIR2015(NOC) 24 kerala
Print Page

When fair rent can be fixed from date of filing of application?


  This Court in George v.T.K.Saidu

Muhammed [2013 (2) KHC 326] held that fixation of fair

rent is to be ordered by the Rent Control Court from


the date of application or petition.           We are of the

view that rights and liabilities to the parties to the

lis have to be determined with reference to the date of

filing    of   the    petition.      However,  in  the  matter

relating to the fair rent fixation there can be a

departure from such rule on finding that reliance

placed by the Landlord to fix the fair rent is based on

a material that has arisen subsequent to the filing of

petition.        The   fair   rent   is  fixed  based on  the

prevailing rate of rent in the locality for the similar

building.     The components of the fair rent depend upon

the market criteria related to fixation of fair rent.

These     components       are    liable   for   changes   and

fluctuations. The court has to advert to the market

criteria     that   might     have  become  prevalent in  the

locality and the date of commencement of such criteria

by marshalling the factors that require to establish

fair rent fixation.          If those conditions exist as on

the date of application for fixation of fair rent,

necessarily, the court has to fix the fair rent as on

the date of application.            In this case, documents


produced by the landlord clearly indicate that the rent

at the rate of Rs.30/- per sq.ft. was prevailing before

the application for fair rent.         In such circumstances,

we are of the view that the fair rent that should have

been    fixed,     is    from    the  date  of   application.

Accordingly, we affirm the decision of the Rent Control

Court and vacate the order passed by the Appellate

Authority, restricting fair rent from the date of

order.
  IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

                                                      PRESENT:

                          THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K.T.SANKARAN
                                                            &
                   THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A.MUHAMED MUSTAQUE

             THURSDAY, THE 23RD DAY OF OCTOBER 2014

                                           RCRev..No. 420 of 2012 ()
                                           
            K.S.KADAR PILLAI, 
Vs

            M/S. GOVEN TRAVELS
          Citation;AIR 2015(NOC)24 kerala
Print Page