Showing posts with label English. Show all posts
Showing posts with label English. Show all posts

Friday, 26 June 2026

Best Websites for Converting Marathi Judgments into English

 Converting a Marathi court judgment into English is now easier because several websites allow the user to upload the full PDF and receive an English version in return. This is particularly useful where judgments are downloaded from the eCourts portal in text-based PDF form and a quick working translation is needed for reading, review, or research.

At the same time, not every translation website is equally suitable for legal documents. A good platform for this purpose should support full-document upload, Marathi-to-English translation, layout preservation, and, ideally, better handling of court orders or legal terminology.

Why website-based conversion is useful

Print Page

Sunday, 14 October 2018

Whether court can direct litigant to furnish English translation of pleading if it is in Marathi language?

 We have heard the learned Counsel for petitioner. The
petitioners are aggrieved by a circular which is annexed at Exh.A
and B issued by the Civil Judge, Senior Division, Panvel. By the
said circular, the Civil Judge, Senior Division Panvel has directed all
litigants and Advocates that all pleadings which are to be filed in the
Panvel Court should be in Marathi language only. In our view, the
said circular is patently illegal, since English is also the language of
the Court. As such, we direct the Civil Judge, Senior Division, Panel
to accept all the pleadings which are in English language. However,
pleadings in Marathi language be also accepted with undertaking to

furnish English translation of the same if required.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO.4102 OF 2017

Mrs. Neelam Abhijeet Kadam Vs The State of Maharashtra 

CORAM : V.M.KANADE &
C.V.BHADANG, JJ.
DATE : 2nd May 2017.

Print Page

Sunday, 21 January 2018

Procedure to be followed by court if there is conflict between Hindi and English version of law

"Under Article 345, the Legislature of a State may adopt any one or more of the languages in use in the State or Hindi as the language or languages to be used for all or any of the official purpose of the State. This power is subject to Articles 346 and Article 347 of the Constitution of India. It is, apparently, in terms of Article 345 that the Uttar Pradesh Legislature has passed the two laws, which we have adverted to namely, Uttar Pradesh Language (Bills and Acts) Act, 1950 and Uttar Pradesh Official Language Act, 1951. By virtue of these laws, undoubtedly, the State has adopted Hindi as the language for the purpose of enacting laws be they plenary or subordinate legislation, but it is hedged in with the limitation contained in Article 348(3) of the Constitution. Under Article 348(3), it becomes the duty to publish the translation of the law, which is made in the official language other than English. The publication of the translation is to be done under the authority of the Governor of the State in the official gazette of the State. Sub Article (3) of Article 348 further declares unambiguously that it shall be deemed to be the authoritative text of the English language under Article 348. It must be remembered that Article 348(1) provides that the authoritative texts of all Bills and Acts, inter alia, are to be in English language. It is to provide for the contingency where a State adopts any other language as its official language that the founding fathers provided for a translation to be made of the law into English, which is made by the Legislature in a language other than English. This English version is, undoubtedly, to be treated as the authoritative text within the meaning of Sub Article 1 of Article 348 of the Constitution of India."
21. Having thus referred to the various provisions of law, we must consider the effect of any ambiguity, which may exist between the two versions, namely, (i) English language and (ii) any other language, which may be the official language of the State concerned. There can be broadly two situations to our mind. As in the case of Nityanand Sharma (supra) and Prabhat Kumar Sharma (supra), the original version of a law may be published in the English language. It may be followed by the Hindi version of the same. The second possibility is where the law may be made in the official language of the State concerned, as in the case of State of Uttar Pradesh where Hindi is the official language. A law may be made in Hindi language; it must be followed by an English translation within the meaning of Article 348(3), which is to be treated as authoritative text under Article 348(1). In a case where a law is made in English language and a confusion arises on account of the translation found in the Hindi version, quite clearly, dominance would be accorded to the English version. When a law is made, however, in the official language, other than English language as say the Hindi language as in the facts of this case and a discrepancy occurs when the translation takes place, it can give rise to two broad situations again. The first situation would be on account of the inadequacy or ineptitude of the translator, a doubt or ambiguity may be created by virtue of the translation made under Article 348(3) of the Constitution. While, it is true that Article 348(1) declares that the translation published under Article 348(3) will be the authoritative text within the meaning of Article 348(1), as the duty of the Court is to give effect to the intention of the Legislature, every effort must be made to reconcile the differences. An attempt must be made to find out the intention of the law-giver. Both the Hindi version and the English version can be looked into and the Court would be acting within its powers in adopting the version, which best accords with the intention of the Legislature, applying various Rules of interpretation and in particular, the purpose Rule.

22. The second category of cases is those cases, where there is a conflict between the two versions, namely, the Hindi and the English. If there is a conflict between the Hindi version and the English version, it is our view that it is the translation published under Article 348(3), of the law, in English, which would prevail. This view of ours is arrived at by following what has been laid down by not only the Hon'ble Apex Court in Park Leather Industry's case (supra) but also by the seven Judges Bench of the Allahabad High Court in Mata Badal Pandey's case (supra).

IN THE HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL

Special Appeal No. 593 of 2017

Decided On: 18.09.2017

Shahjahan Baigam Vs.  District Magistrate Udham Singh Nagar and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
K.M. Joseph, C.J. and Alok Singh, J.

Citation: AIR 2017 Uttar 200
Print Page

Monday, 5 September 2016

Whether execution of will in English can be doubted on ground that testator was not knowing English language?


The lack of knowledge of English even if can be

attributed to the testator would not fundamentally alter the

situation inasmuch as before registration of the Will the

contents thereof can be understood to have been explained
to the testator or ascertained from her by the Sub
Registrar, PW-4, who had deposed that such a practice is
normally adhered to. 

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 9282 OF 2010
LEELA RAJAGOPAL & ORS
V
KAMALA MENON COCHARAN & ORS.(S)

Citation:(2015) 8 SCC 615


RANJAN GOGOI, J.

Print Page

Thursday, 17 September 2015

Whether it is permissible to use language other than English in High court?

Gujarat High Court. In a Criminal Revision Application before it under Section 397 r/w Section 401 of Cr.P.C., where the applicant wanted to appear party-in-person and present and argue his case in Hindi before the High Court and had also brought another friend to assist in Gujarati, the High Court decided against allowing use of any language other than English to be used in the proceedings before the Court.
The High Court held that Article 348(1) and (2) of the Constitution of India r/w Rule 31A and 37 of the Gujarat High Court Rules, 1993 clearly lay down that no language other than English could be used in a proceeding before it since the Language of the Court under Article 348(1) is English and Article 348(2) allows any other language to be used only if there is authorization by the Governor with previous consent of the President of India to this effect. However there is no such previous authorization of the Governor, in effect, in State of Gujarat. The High Court also held that Rule 31A of Gujarat High Court allows a party-in-person to assist the Court only if he has the ability to both understand and express in English. The Court can, in specific cases, allow written submissions to be in Gujarati as laid down in Rule 37; however, oral submissions have always to be in English only, which is the lahnguage of the Court under Article 348(1) of the Constitution.
The Court also relied on various Supreme Court judgments to drive home its point viz. Dr. Vijay Laxmi Sadho v. Jagdish (2001) 2 SCC 247, where the Governor of M.P., under Article 348(2), with the consent of the President, had authorized use of Hindi language in the court proceedings. So the language could be thus used.
However, in Madhu Limaye v. Ved Murti (1970) 3 SCC 738, when Mr. Raj Narain insisted for arguing in Hindi and the learned advocate for the other side and the members of the Bench were unable to understand his argument in Hindi, the Supreme Court provided three options and since none was acceptable to him, his intervention was cancelled. 
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
Criminal Reference No. 4 of 2015 in Criminal Revision Application (for Maintenance) No. 201 of 2015,
Decided On: 08.07.2015

Manish Kanaiyalal Gupta Vs. State of Gujarat and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Print Page

Sunday, 30 August 2015

Whether information under RTI is to be supplied in Hindi even though information is in English?

This aspect needs clarification. It is true that the
proceedings in a High Court are in English language.
Therefore by and large “records” are in English. Yet is the
public information officer also bound to supply the “record”
in “Hindi”, even when it is specifically requisitioned though
originally the records are in English. The answer to this
would be in negative. This is not the intent or the mandate of
the Act. This is for two reasons. Firstly, the definition of
“right to information” itself states that a citizen has access to
information which is “held” by or under the control of any
public authority. Obviously since the “information” in the
form of a record is “held” by the public authority in English,
it has to be supplied in that language. Secondly, even Section
4 (4) of the Act, which has been referred above, states that
the obligation of the Public Authority is to “disseminate” 16
“information” in local language but with considerations of
“local language” as well as “cost effectiveness” alongwith
other consideration. The cost of translation of all record in
“Hindi” would be immense and would be practically not
possible. As such the records can only be given as they exist.
The public authority i.e. High Court in the present case, is
not obliged to translate records into Hindi, and furnish them
even when requisition is so made.”
IN THE HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
SPECIAL APPEAL NO. 62 of 2010
State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
V
Uttarakhand State Information Commission and others.

Dated : 26th May, 2015
Coram : Hon’ble K.M. Joseph, C.J.
 Hon’ble V.K. Bist, J.

Citation;AIR 2015Uttarakhand 106
Print Page