Showing posts with label S 41 of small cause court Act. Show all posts
Showing posts with label S 41 of small cause court Act. Show all posts

Sunday, 28 August 2022

Can the court grant interim relief U/S 9 of the Arbitration Act relating to possession of property given on leave and license?

As held by the Full Bench in Central Warehousing Corporation, Mumbai (supra) in the arbitration agreement in such cases is held to be invalid and inoperative on the principle that it would be against public policy to allow the parties, by a contract to oust the exclusive jurisdiction of the Small Causes Court by virtue of Section 41 of the PSCC Act.

41. Thus, in my opinion, the respondents are correct in their

contention that this Court would not have jurisdiction to entertain the Section 9 petition considering the nature of the reliefs, which in fact pertain to or are incidental to the possession of the licenced premises as asserted by the petitioners, subject matter of the leave and licence agreements. Hence, as held by the Court in the decisions as discussed above, jurisdiction to entertain any such proceedings would lie with the Small Causes Court under the provisions of Section 41 of the PSCC Act.

In view of such conclusion, it may not be possible for the Court to pass any orders on the present petition permitting the respondent to deposit in this Court liquidated damages which Mr. Shah had agreed to deposit even in the present proceedings. In view of the fact that the present proceedings are held as not maintainable and having reached such conclusion, it may not be permissible for the Court to bifurcate causes of action, the principles of law in that regard being well settled. Needless

to observe that it would be open to the petitioner to seek prayers in that regard in appropriate proceedings in the event the claims are pure monetary disputes falling within the realm of arbitrability of such disputes. All contentions of the parties in that regard are expressly kept open.

42. Resultantly, these petitions filed under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,1996, cannot be entertained. The petitions are accordingly dismissed. The petitioners are at liberty to take recourse to other appropriate proceedings as may be available to the petitioners in law including to assert pure monetary claims in arbitral proceedings as discussed in paragraph 37 of this judgment.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION

ARBITRATION PETITION (L.) NO. 22526 OF 2022

BXIN Office Parks India Pvt. Ltd. Vs  Kailasa Urja Pvt. Ltd. 

CORAM : G.S. KULKARNI, J.

Pronounced on : AUGUST 20, 2022.

Print Page

Sunday, 3 July 2022

Whether the Small cause court has jurisdiction to try a claim for recovery of security deposit or damages or is said dispute arbitrable?

As held by this Court in the case of Brainvisa Technologies Pvt. Ltd. (supra) license fee, charges and rent are periodical payments made for use and occupation. A claim for recovery of the same, legitimately falls within the exclusive jurisdiction of the Court of Small Causes. In the case at hand, the respondent professes to withhold the security deposit on the ground that the applicant is liable to pay damages. Such a claim, in my considered view, does not fall within the exclusive jurisdiction of the Court of Small Causes, and is amenable to arbitration. 

{Para 45}

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Arbitration Application No. 340 of 2019

Decided On: 05.05.2022

 Bafna Motors Private Limited  Vs.  Amanulla Khan

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

N.J. Jamadar, J.

Citation: MANU/MH/1583/2022
Print Page

Friday, 19 February 2021

Whether the City civil court can entertain an eviction suit if the plaintiff had given suit premises to the defendant for conducting business?

  Section 41(1) of the Presidency Small Cause Courts Act would apply

only to the suit and proceedings between the licensor and licensee or

landlord and tenant relating to recovery of the possession of any immovable

property situated in Greater Bombay or relating to the recovery of license

fees or charges or rent therefor irrespective of the value of the subject matter

of the suit suits or proceedings. In my view, since the Small Causes Court

has already recorded the finding that the suit business was given by the husband of the plaintiff to the predecessor of the defendants on conducting

and there being no relationship of a landlord and tenant or licensor or

licensee, Section 41(1) of the Presidency Small Cause Courts Act, 1882

would not apply to the facts of this case. Perusal of the prayers in the plaint

and more particularly, prayer clause (a) clearly indicates that the plaintiff

had applied for declaration that the defendants were trespassers and have no

right, title or interest in the suit premises or in her business after the period

prescribed under the Conducting Agreement was over. In prayer clause (b),

the plaintiff had prayed for an order and direction against the defendants to

vacate the suit premises and its business being carried therein.

65] In my view, the reliefs sought in prayer clause (b) is incidental to the

prayer clause (a) and more particularly, would depend upon whether the

plaintiff had given the suit business to the defendants on conducting suit

business. The premises were given to the defendants for conducting the suit

business. In my view, prayer clause (b) thus, even otherwise could not be

considered as a suit for recovery of possession of the licensee premises. The

period of Conducting Agreement was admittedly over much before the date

of filing suit by the plaintiff. The alleged rights and interest claimed by the

defendants in the suit premises were already rejected by the Small Causes

Court by recording detailed findings of fact which findings have admittedly,

attained finality. The defendants thus being trespassers in respect of the suit

business and also the premises, the Suit filed by the plaintiff for various reliefs claimed in the plaint was thus maintainable.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

FIRST APPEAL NO. 1791 OF 2007

Shri Purshottam Shankar Shetye  Vs  Abhay Shridhar Shetye

Print Page

Is finding recorded by small cause court upheld by the high court is binding on the party before city civil court in a parallel proceeding?

 The Trial Court dealt with the orders passed by the Small Causes

Court in the declaratory suit filed by the defendants, order passed by the

Appellate Bench of the Small Causes Court and the order passed by this

Court in Writ Petition No. 3521 of 1999 filed by the original defendant

recording various findings in favour of the plaintiff herein and against the

defendants. The Trial Court, accordingly, rightly held that the original

defendant was judicially held to be just conductor of the business and

nothing more, which finding had attained the finality. In view of the fact that

various issues which were raised by the defendants in this Suit were already

concluded by the Small Causes Court and upheld by the Appellate Bench

and this Court, those submissions made by both parties were rightly not

considered by the Trial Court once again in the impugned judgment and

decree. In my view, the findings rendered by the Small Causes Court,

Appellate Bench of the Small Causes Court and this Court in respect of the

suit premises were binding on the parties in the parallel proceedings raising

similar issues.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

FIRST APPEAL NO. 1791 OF 2007

Shri Purshottam Shankar Shetye  Vs  Abhay Shridhar Shetye


CORAM : R.D. DHANUKA, J.


PRONOUNCED ON : 19th MAY 2020

Citation: 2020(6) MHLJ 86

Print Page

Sunday, 7 February 2021

Whether court can direct the licensee to pay maintenance charges to the licensor in application U/O 15A of CPC in eviction suit?

The only question to be considered is whether the maintenance charges could have been directed to be paid under Over XV-A of the Code as prayed for by the defendants.

From the aforesaid averments it is clear that the plaintiff has admitted that it is liable to pay maintenance charges of Rs.25,000/- per month during the period of Leave and Licence agreement. As stated above the said agreement specifically refers to various amenities provided by the licensor and with a view to enable the licensee to enjoy the same the plaintiff is required to pay Rs.25,000/- per month.

10. The provisions of Section 7(14) of the said Act define the term "standard rent". The standard rent in the present case has not been determined under Section 8 of the said Act. However reading of both the agreements on the basis of which the plaintiff has been inducted as a licensee indicates that besides the amount of licence fees, it is also liable to pay maintenance charges and failure to pay maintenance charges gives a cause of action to the licensor to terminate the licence.

 In Puspa Sen Gupta vs. Susma Ghose (1990) 2 SCC 651 while considering the provisions of West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1956 and the question whether the tenant was liable to pay amount of Rs.8/- per month towards electricity besides Rs.32/- as rent, it was observed that the expression "rent" was not defined under relevant Act. However on reading the entire Act, the word "rent" would also include payment in respect of amenities or services provided by the landlord under the term of tenancy. It was observed that considering various provisions a tenancy would carry with it amenities to be provided or services to be maintained by the landlord and hence the amount of rent would include the amount of electricity charges. Drawing support from the aforesaid observations it can be said in the facts of the present case that the plaintiff was liable to pay maintenance charges besides license fees. This has infact been admitted by the plaintiff in its written statement to the counter-claim. In that view of the matter the trial Court was not justified in refusing to direct the plaintiff to pay Rs.25,000/- per month towards maintenance charges. The impugned order therefore is liable to be modified accordingly.

 Bombay High Court

Daksha  Jyotindra Patel And Vs Big V. Telecom Pvt. Ltd. Nagpur ... on 8 November, 2019
Bench: A.S. Chandurkar
  WRIT PETITION NO.3553 OF 2019



CORAM : A. S. CHANDURKAR, J.

 Judgment pronounced on : November 08, 2019 

Citation: 2020(6) MHLJ 313

Print Page