Showing posts with label S 65B of Evidence Act. Show all posts
Showing posts with label S 65B of Evidence Act. Show all posts

Saturday, 23 May 2026

Supreme Court: Oral evidence of officials of the telecom company cannot substitute Section 65B certificate

 


Understanding Call Detail Records and the Statutory Requirements of Section 65B Certification

In the contemporary legal landscape, telecommunications data serves as a silent, ubiquitous witness. For the legal practitioner, a Call Detail Record (CDR) represents a "digital footprint" capable of establishing presence, association, and timeline. However, the transition of this data from a server log to admissible evidence is governed by rigorous statutory prerequisites. As a senior architect of legal curriculum, it is imperative to understand that in the realm of electronic evidence, the integrity of the process is as vital as the fact of the evidence itself.

1. The "Digital Footprint": Defining the Call Detail Record (CDR)

Print Page

Supreme Court: Call Detail Records are Not Admissible Without S.65B Evidence Act Certificate

 It was further contended that the call detail

records were proved by the nodal officers of the

service providers, i.e. Vibhor Rastogi (PW.23) and

Saurabh Kumar (PW.24) and hence, non-production

of the certificate under Section 65-B of the Evidence

Act [Section 63 of the BSA] pales into insignificance.

Mere non-production of the certificate under Section

65-B of the Evidence Act [Section 63 of the BSA] in

this case cannot be treated to be fatal to the

prosecution’s case, particularly, when the call detail

records have been duly proved by examining the

employees of the service providers i.e., Vodafone and

Bharati Hexacom Ltd./Bharati Heckjakom Ltd.{Para 22}

18. The Evidence Act does not contemplate

or permit the proof of an electronic record by

oral evidence if requirements under Section

65-B of the Evidence Act are not complied

with, as the law now stands in India.”

(Emphasis Supplied)

52. Admittedly, in the present case, the certificate

under Section 65-B of the Evidence Act [Section 63 of

the BSA] was not proved by the prosecution. In the

absence of the certificate, mandatorily required

under Section 65-B of the Evidence Act [Section 63 of

the BSA], the call detail records become inadmissible

in evidence and cannot be relied upon to support the

prosecution’s case.

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO(S). OF 2026

(Arising out of SLP (Crl.) No (s). 1977 of 2026)

POORANMAL Vs  THE STATE OF RAJASTHAN & ANR. 

Author: Mehta, J.

Citation: 2026 INSC 217.

Dated: MARCH 10, 2026.
Print Page

Sunday, 28 December 2025

ELECTRONIC EVIDENCE & CHAIN OF CUSTODY : Why Your Court’s Computer Room Must Never Touch Electronic Evidence?

 


A Judicial Guide to Protecting Digital Evidence in the Age of Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam 2023

OPENING: THE OPERATIONAL TRAP MOST COURTS FALL INTO

Your muddemal room receives a pen drive containing critical CCTV footage. The prosecutor and defence counsel walk into your chambers and ask the same simple question: “Your Honour, can your court’s computer room just copy this for us?”

Your administrative officer is standing by, computer room staff are available, and it seems like a five-minute fix.

Print Page

Friday, 22 August 2025

Bombay HC: Sessions Judge Can consider Electronic Evidence in Criminal Revision Without Section 65-B Certificate

 For considering whether the learned Revisional Court has rightly passed the order and at this stage whether for viewing CD or any other material, whether certificate under section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act is necessary? At this stage the Court is not accepting the said document as a proof in the trial. The Court is also not adjudicating upon any of the issues or the points with the help of such a document. As stated, it is only for the purpose of ascertaining as to whether case is made out to issue direction under section 156(3) of the Cr.P.C. assuming that the Court takes cognizance by rejecting the prayer for directions under section 156(3) of the Cr.P.C. and direct police to make an inquiry under section 202 of the Cr.P.C., still stage of trial is yet to come. The question of admissibility of offence would come only in the Trial and not any time before such document is tendered into evidence and sought to be proved by the prosecution or the parties to the proceedings. Therefore, the question of expecting a certificate under section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act itself does not arise at this stage. {Para 16}


21. This Court finds in view of above discussion that at this stage, what needs to be considered is only that a revision is pending before the Sessions Court against order passed by the learned JMFC refusing to pass order under section 156(3) of the Cr.P.C. The objection is only to viewing of the CD by the Revisional Court. The learned Sessions Judge has rightly held that there is no bar to look into the documents and has rightly rejected the application and permitted the respondent to display the video recording. This order is passed only to enable the Court to look into the material that was produced before the Magistrate and nothing else. This Court finds that no fault can be found with the impugned order. For the above reasons, the order passed by the learned Sessions Judge does not require any interference.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)

Criminal Writ Petition No. 76 of 2023

Decided On: 05.06.2023

Sudhir and Ors. Vs. The State of Maharashtra and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Kishore C. Sant, J.

Citation: MANU/MH/1987/2023

Print Page

Friday, 1 November 2024

Whether the court can allow husband to prove call record of mobile of his wife downloaded from website of JIO by submitting his own S 65B certificate ?


Coming to the case on hand, the certificate enclosed by the 
husband reads that the electronic statement was taken from Jio official website and that the website is in order without any malfunction. One can take judicial notice of the fact that call history can be obtained by reaching out to the website of the concerned telecom service provider from the mobile phone. The user of the device would get OTP. After authentication, the information sought for will be provided which can be downloaded. A cursory perusal of Ex.P4 would show that the mobile phone belonged to the wife and the husband had access to the same. When the mobile phone with the sim card was in the custody of the husband, he had reached out to the telecom service provider (Jio) and obtained the call data. The certificate filed by the husband is no certificate at all. It is not a defective certificate. It is not the case of the husband that he wrote to the service provider and there was no response. The call history was downloaded from Jio website. Therefore, only a person occupying a responsible official position in Jio could have issued the certificate. The husband/respondent herein could not have issued a self serving certificate. Therefore, the case on hand will fall outside the caveat laiddown in Arjun Panditrao Khotkar by the Hon'ble Supreme Court. Ex.P4 ought to have been accompanied by a certificate as contemplated in Section 65B(4) of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. The court below could not have deferred taking a decision in the matter. {Para 8}

BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT

CRP(MD)No.2362 of 2024

R..... ... Petitioner/Petitioner/Respondent

vs.

1.B..... ...Respondent/Respondent/Petitioner

2.The Secretary to Government,

 Ministry of Electronics and

Information Technology

(MEITY), Government of India,

 New Delhi. ... 2nd respondent

CORAM

 MR.JUSTICE G.R.SWAMINATHAN

Pronounced on : 30.10.2024.

Read full Judgement here: Click here.

Print Page

Sunday, 26 May 2024

Delhi HC: There Can't Be Piecemeal Disclosure Of Material On Which Prosecution Seeks To Base Its Case

It is a cardinal principle of criminal jurisprudence that the accused is to be supplied with all documents that the prosecution seeks to rely upon, before the commencement of the trial. There cannot be piecemeal disclosure of material on which the prosecution seeks to base its case. The requirement to disclose the entire incriminating material prior to framing of charge stems from the right of the accused of fair opportunity to meet the case of the prosecution and to effectively put forth the defence. {Para 39}

40. To elaborate, such requirement is imperative to afford a meaningful opportunity to the accused to defend at the following stages - firstly, prior to commencement of trial to enable the accused to contest the framing of charge and seek discharge. Secondly, in case the accused fails to seek discharge, he should have fair opportunity to cross-examine prosecution witnesses and put his defence to them. Thirdly, to enter on his defence and adduce any evidence in support thereof.

41. Thus, requirement of such full disclosure is an extremely valuable right and an essential feature of the right to a fair trial as it enables the accused to prepare for the trial before its commencement. 

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

 CRL.M.C. 4107/2023 & CRL.M.A. 5116/2024

CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGTATION  Vs R. VASUDEVAN & ORS. 

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIKAS MAHAJAN

Dated:  22.05.2024.

Print Page

Friday, 26 January 2024

Whether non production of S 65B certificate of Evidence Act at an earlier stage is a curable defect?

 The courts below had gone on a wrong premise to opine that there was delay of six years in producing the certificate whereas there was none. The matter was still pending when the application to resummon M. Krishna (PW-189) and produce the certificate Under Section 65-B of the Act was filed Under Section 311 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. {Para 12}


13. It was only vide order dated 07.04.2017 that the report prepared on the basis of electronic devices was refused to be taken on record by the Trial Court. The original electronic devices had already been produced in evidence and marked as MOs. It was during the examination in chief of M. Krishna (PW-189) that the report of CFSL dated 29.11.2010 was sought to be exhibited. However, the Trial Court vide order dated 07.04.2017 declined to take the same on record in the absence of a certificate Under Section 65B of the Act. When the aforesaid witness was further examined in chief on 27.04.2017, the report Under Section 65B was produced to which objection was raised by the counsel of the defence and vide order dated 20.06.2017 the Trial Court declined to take the certificate, issued Under Section 65B of the Act, on record. It was thereafter that an application was filed Under Section 311 of the Code of Criminal Procedure for recalling M. Krishna (PW-189) and produce the certificate Under Section 65-B of the Act on record. The same was rejected by the Trial Court vide order dated 18.01.2018.


14. From the aforesaid facts, it cannot be inferred that there was delay of six years in producing the certificate. In fact, report received from CFSL, Hyderabad on the basis of the contents of electronic devices dated 29.11.2010 was already placed before the Trial Court on 16.10.2012. In fact, the stand of the prosecution was that when the original electronic devices were already produced and marked MOs, there was no need to produce the certificate Under Section 65-B of the Act. Still, as a matter of abundant caution, the same was produced that too immediately after objection was raised by the Accused against the production of CFSL report prepared on the basis of the electronic devices seized.


15. Fair trial in a criminal case does not mean that it should be fair to one of the parties. Rather, the object is that no guilty should go scot-free and no innocent should be punished. A certificate Under Section 65-B of the Act, which is sought to be produced by the prosecution is not an evidence which has been created now. It is meeting the requirement of law to prove a report on record. By permitting the prosecution to produce the certificate Under Section 65B of the Act at this stage will not result in any irreversible prejudice to the Accused. The Accused will have full opportunity to rebut the evidence led by the prosecution. This is the purpose for which Section 311 of the Code of Criminal Procedure is there. The object of the Code is to arrive at truth. However, the power Under Section 311 of the Code of Criminal Procedure can be exercised to subserve the cause of justice and public interest. In the case in hand, this exercise of power is required to uphold the truth, as no prejudice as such is going to be caused to the Accused.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 3456 of 2023 (Special Leave Petition (Crl.) No. 6548 of 2022)

Decided On: 06.11.2023

State of Karnataka Vs. T. Naseer and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Vikram Nath and Rajesh Bindal, JJ.

Citation: 2023/INSC/988,MANU/SC/1217/2023.

Author: Rajesh Bindal, J.

Print Page

Thursday, 30 March 2023

Can the court call a witness in a criminal case on an application filed by a third party U/S 311 of the CrPC?


In the facts and circumstances of the present case, the petitioner-Company is neither the complainant nor is a victim but is a telecasting company who had conducted a sting operation and the video was telecasted which bearing has got direct bearing upon the subject matter of the present FIR. This Court is of the view that the subject matter of the telecast goes to the root of the matter. The scope of Section 311 Cr.P.C is very wide as has been so held in a plethora of judgments as discussed above. The journalist namely Abhishek who has been summoned as a prosecution witness is not an authorized person, according to the petitioner-Company, whereas the Deputy General Manager namely Arunesh Kumar is an authorised person to issue a certificate and prove the same under Section 65-B of the Evidence Act vide Annexure P-7 which is an authorization letter. Therefore, this Court is of the view that even if the petitioner is not a victim nor complainant but he could have certainly filed application under Section 311 Cr.P.C on the basis of facts and circumstances. {Para 26}

27. It is therefore held that for the purpose of filing of application under Section 311 Cr.P.C, it is not necessary that the applicant has to be either complainant or prosecution or victim or a listed witness. The provisions of Section 311 Cr.P.C can be invoked by any other person who is able to show that the evidence of witness sought to be examined will be necessary for just decision of the case. Rather, a persual of Section 311 Cr.P.C would show that it is the duty of Court to apply its mind to ascertain as to whether testimony of person sought to be summoned is required for just decision of the case. However in such like cases, power has to be exercised in a very careful, diligent and judicious manner for which cogent and strong reasons should be recorded.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT

CHANDIGARH

CRM-M-52970-2022 (O&M)

Bennett Coleman and Company Limited Vs State of Haryana and others

CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE JASGURPREET SINGH PURI

Neutral Citation No:=2023:PHHC:046881

Date of Decision: 29.03.2023

Print Page

Saturday, 11 September 2021

Whether the court can admit evidence of SDR, CDR and tower location in criminal case if prosecution has failed to support this evidence with S 65B Evidence Act certificate?

  In addition to the evidence of CCTV footage, the

prosecution sought to rely upon SDR, CDR and tower location of the

accused. Mahamuni (PW15) has stated in his evidence that as per his

letter issued to Superintendent of Police, Buldhana, he received four

papers which were marked as Exh. 125. He stated in his evidence

that from CDR and SDR, he came to know about the location of the

accused at the time of incident. He identified the contents of the said

letter which were marked as Exhs. 126 and 127. Learned trial Court refused to place reliance upon SDR, CDR and tower location of the accused as the said electronic evidence were not supported by certificate under Section 65B (4) of the Evidence Act. In our opinion,the learned trial Court has rightly refused to rely upon the electronic evidence placed on record by the prosecution in the form of CCTV footage, CDR, SDR and tower location of the accused for noncompliance of Section 65B (4) of the Evidence Act. {Para 126}

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

: NAGPUR BENCH : NAGPUR.

CRIMINAL CONFIRMATION CASE NO. 01 OF 2020

 State of Maharashtra, Vs  Sagar Vishwanath Borkar,
Print Page

How to appreciate CCTV camera evidence in Rape Case under POCSO Act?

 G] ADMISSIBILITY OF ELECTRONIC EVIDENCE :-

120. Sections 65A and 65B of the Evidence Act, 1872 deal

with the admissibility and contents of evidence of information

contained in electronic records. The Apex Court in the case of

Anwar P. V. vs P. K. Basheer, reported in (2014) 10 SCC 473 has held

that these two sections are a complete Code in themselves on the

admissibility of evidence of information contained in electronic

records.

121. Section 65B(1) differentiates between –

i) the “original document” – the electronic record on

the device in which the original information is first

stored (qualifying it as primary evidence), and

ii) the output from such device which contains

information originating from the original document,

i.e. a copy made therefrom (being secondary

evidence) [Arjun Panditrao Khotkar vs Kailash

Kushanrao Gorantyal, (2020) 7 SCC 1].

122. The Hon’ble Apex Court has in Arjun Panditrao Khotkar

(supra), in para 73.2, expounded the law on admissibility of primary

and secondary evidence in electronic form in the following words–

“ 73.2. The clarification referred to above is that

the required certificate under Section 65B(4) is

unnecessary if the original document itself is

produced. This can be done by the owner of a

laptop computer, computer tablet or even a mobile

phone, by stepping into the witness box and

proving that the concerned device, on which the

original information is first stored, is owned

and/or operated by him. In cases where the

“computer” happens to be a part of a “computer

system” or “computer network” and it becomes

impossible to physically bring such system or

network to the Court, then the only means of

providing information contained in such electronic

record can be in accordance with Section 65B(1),

together with the requisite certificate under

Section 65B(4). The last sentence in Anvar P.V.

(supra) which reads as “…if an electronic record as

such is used as primary evidence under Section 62

of the Evidence Act…” is thus clarified; it is to be

read without the words “under Section 62 of the

Evidence Act…” With this clarification, the law

stated in paragraph 24 of Anvar P.V. (supra) does

not need to be revisited.”

[Emphasis supplied]

123. It is necessary to note that the Hon’ble Apex Court in

Anwar P. V. (supra) has clarified its position on primary evidence

holding that if an electronic record is used as primary evidence under

Section 62 of the Evidence Act, it may be admissible in evidence

without any compliance of conditions under S. 65B. Arjun Panditrao

Khotkar (supra) held this position to be good law when read without

the words, “under Section 62 of the Evidence Act”, while placing its

derivation in S.65B(1). The Hon’ble Apex Court held that the

certificate under S. 65B(4) is unnecessary if the “original document”

itself is produced, since it is being used as primary evidence of the

information contained in the electronic record. This can be done by

the owner of the device (on which the original electronic record is

first stored) by proving that it is owned and/or operated by him.

124. Commonly, the original electronic record of a CCTV

footage is stored on a memory chip/CD/DVD/hard drive or any

similar device on a computer, DVR or NVR wherein the footage is

recorded. The original electronic record stored on a memory

chip/CD/DVD/hard drive, being the place where the electronic

record is first stored, is said to be the original document, qualifying it

as primary evidence. Such information can be led as evidence by

producing the hard drive, wherein the original document is first

stored, before the Court. In order to prove the information contained

in such electronic record, the memory chip/CD/DVD/hard drive on

which the electronic record was first stored can be produced before

the Court. Similarly, in cases where the device happens to be a part

of a “computer system” or “computer network”, such system or

network or server can be produced before the Court, if it is possible.

In case where the device happens to be a part of a “computer system”

or “computer network” and it becomes impossible to physically bring

such system or network to the Court, then the only means of proving

information contained therein can be, as specified above is, “in

accordance with Section 65B(1), together with the requisite

certificate under Section 65B(4).”

125. The prosecution has relied upon the CCTV footage from

camera no. 2 covering the area of the main gate of the office of

APMC Market, Chikhli. The prosecution has examined PI Gulabrao

Wagh (PW14) and Dy.S.P. Baburao Mahamuni (PW15) in order to

prove the said CCTV footage. From the evidence of Dy.S.P. Mahamuni

(PW15), it appears that the prosecution has brought on record the

CCTV footage copied in pendrive (Article-M). It is stated by Dy.S.P.

Mahamuni (PW15), that its Hash value was taken by NPC Sharad

Giri and accordingly certificate under Section 65B of the Evidence

Act (Exhibit 112) was taken. Though evidence of PI Wagh (PW14)

and Dy.S.P. Mahamuni (PW15) has been corroborated by panch

witness Subhash Bhalerao (PW2) regarding CCTV footage, it appears

that the prosecution has failed to adduce evidence of a person

occupying responsible official position in relation to the operation or

the management of the activities in relation to CCTV in the APMC

Market, Chikhli. Since the prosecution has failed to bring on record

the primary evidence in relation to CCTV footage in the form of hard

disc of the said CCTV footage wherein the footage was stored, it was

necessary for the prosecution to satisfy the ingredients of Sub-Section

(4) of Section 65B of the Evidence Act. Merely because the CCTV

footage has been exhibited by the trial Court and no objection was

raised on behalf of the accused, the CCTV footage cannot be read in

evidence. The said issue is no longer res-integra in view of the

judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Arjun Panditrao Khotkar

(supra). We are, therefore, of the considered opinion that in absence

of compliance of Sub-Section (4) of Section 65B of the Evidence Act,

the CCTV footage from camera no.2 covering the area of main gate

of the office of APMC Market, Chikhli cannot be relied upon as

admissible evidence of the prosecution.


IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

: NAGPUR BENCH : NAGPUR.

CRIMINAL CONFIRMATION CASE NO. 01 OF 2020

 State of Maharashtra, Vs  Sagar Vishwanath Borkar,
Print Page

Sunday, 2 May 2021

Whether litigant must file certificate U/S 65B of Evidence Act along with electronic evidence in proceeding before an arbitrator?

 The contention that that the Arbitral Tribunal had grossly erred

in accepting the said evidence without an affidavit under Section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 is difficult to accept. This is because of two reasons. First, in terms of Section 1 of the Indian Evidence Act 1872, the said Act is not applicable to proceedings before the arbitrator. Second, no such objection was taken on behalf of the petitioners at the appropriate stage, that is, before the Learned Arbitrator. {Para 27}

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

 Judgment delivered on: 15.04.2021

 O.M.P. (COMM) 79/2021

MEGHA ENTERPRISES AND ORS Vs M/S HALDIRAM SNACKS PVT. LTD. 


CORAM

HON’BLE MR JUSTICE VIBHU BAKHRU

Print Page

Tuesday, 14 July 2020

Landmark Supreme Court Judgment : Certificate required under Section 65B(4) is a condition precedent to the admissibility of Electronic evidence

The reference is thus answered by stating that:
(a) Anvar P.V. (supra), as clarified by us hereinabove, is the law
declared by this Court on Section 65B of the Evidence Act. The
judgment in Tomaso Bruno (supra), being per incuriam, does not lay down the law correctly. Also, the judgment in SLP (Crl.) No. 9431 of 2011 reported as Shafhi Mohammad (supra) and the judgment dated
03.04.2018 reported as (2018) 5 SCC 311, do not lay down the law
correctly and are therefore overruled.
(b) The clarification referred to above is that the required
certificate under Section 65B(4) is unnecessary if the original document
itself is produced. This can be done by the owner of a laptop computer,
computer tablet or even a mobile phone, by stepping into the witness
box and proving that the concerned device, on which the original
information is first stored, is owned and/or operated by him. In cases
where the “computer” happens to be a part of a “computer system” or
“computer network” and it becomes impossible to physically bring such
system or network to the Court, then the only means of providing
information contained in such electronic record can be in accordance
with Section 65B(1), together with the requisite certificate under Section
65B(4). The last sentence in Anvar P.V. (supra) which reads as “…if an
electronic record as such is used as primary evidence under Section 62
of the Evidence Act…” is thus clarified; it is to be read without the words
“under Section 62 of the Evidence Act,…” With this clarification, the law stated in paragraph 24 of Anvar P.V. (supra) does not need to be
revisited.
(c) The general directions issued in paragraph 62 (supra) shall
hereafter be followed by courts that deal with electronic evidence, to
ensure their preservation, and production of certificate at the
appropriate stage. These directions shall apply in all proceedings, till
rules and directions under Section 67C of the Information Technology
Act and data retention conditions are formulated for compliance by
telecom and internet service providers.
(d) Appropriate rules and directions should be framed in exercise
of the Information Technology Act, by exercising powers such as in
Section 67C, and also framing suitable rules for the retention of data
involved in trial of offences, their segregation, rules of chain of custody,
stamping and record maintenance, for the entire duration of trials and
appeals, and also in regard to preservation of the meta data to avoid
corruption. Likewise, appropriate rules for preservation, retrieval and
production of electronic record, should be framed as indicated earlier,
after considering the report of the Committee constituted by the Chief
Justice’s Conference in April, 2016.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NOS. 20825-20826 OF 2017

ARJUN PANDITRAO KHOTKAR Vs  KAILASH KUSHANRAO GORANTYAL 
Print Page

Saturday, 30 May 2020

Bombay HC: Electronic evidence cannot be used for cross-examination without a certificate as per S 65B of Evidence Act

 Emphasizing this facet of sub-section (4) the decision in Anvar holds that the requirement of producing a certificate arises when the electronic record is sought to be used as evidence. Reliance was placed on the earlier decision in Union of India v. CDR Ravindra V Desai [(2018) 16 SCC 273] wherein it was emphasised that non-production of a certificate under Section 65-B of Evidence Act on an earlier occasion is a curable defect. Reliance was also placed on the judgment of the Supreme Court in Sonu @ Amar v. State of Haryana [(2017) 8 SCC 570], wherein it was held that the crucial test was whether the defect could have been cured at the stage of marking the document. Applying the said test it was held that if an objection was taken to the CDRs being marked without a certificate, the Court could have given the prosecution an opportunity to rectify the deficiency. Thus, though it may be considered that the production of certificate is a curable defect; yet, accused in present case should explain from whose custody he has procured the said CCTV Footage. Unless the basic authenticity of the said document/electronic record is shown, it can not be even used in cross-examination.
20. The procedure adopted by learned Magistrate was wrong. When the accused had not explained any reason in his application Ex.38, which was for production of document; there was no question of allowing the informant to re-call for cross. Further the learned Magistrate has failed to see that he had not allowed the production of document first, but then went on to re-call the witness in advance. Neither in application Ex.38 nor in Ex.37, the accused has disclosed the source from where he has secured the CCTV footage. There was no attempt on his part earlier to call the owner of the said shop, where the CCTV cameras are installed. He also says that he has downloaded the said footage on the CD and has produced it. That means the manner in which the copy of the original record was made has not been explained. It appears that the CD has been got produced without its transcription. When the authenticity of the document was raised, then at least certain prima facie compliance ought to have been got done, before re-calling the witness by the learned Magistrate. When all these facts and circumstances were not observed by the learned Magistrate, though in normal course it ought not to have been observed, it will have to be observed that the impugned orders below Ex.37 and 38 are sheer example of non-application of mind and non-adherence of basic provisions of law. They are patently illegal, hence, deserve to be set aside by invoking the constitutional powers under Article 226 and 227 of Constitution of India and inherent powers of this Court under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.

In the High Court of Bombay,Aurangabad Bench
(Before Vibha Kankanwadi, J.)

X   Vs  State of Maharashtra 

Criminal Writ Petition No. 1579 of 2019
With
Criminal Application No. 3214/2019
Decided on January 13, 2020

Citation: 2020 SCC OnLine Bom 143
Print Page

Friday, 29 May 2020

When court can rely on Electronic evidence tendered in the form of hard disk,CD and DVD without certificate under S 65B of Evidence Act?

Ourselves witnessing CCTV footages from the Hard Disk, CD and DVD:

114. The Hard Disk at Exhibit 1 contained in the DVR is available on the record of the Sessions Court. The witnesses PW 1 Raghuveer, PW 2, Raju, PW 3 Sitaram, PW 4 Pramod, PW 5 Kailash, PW 14 Shubham, PW 16 Rupali and PW 18 Vitthal were confronted with the relevant portion in CD-'X' and Annexure DVD CY-66/13 (Article 18A) during the course of their examination-in-chief. We asked the learned counsels appearing for the parties as to whether there is legal impediment for this Court to view the footages from the Hard Disk, DVD and CD, and their response is that there cannot be. In fact, all of them expressed that the Sessions Court should have got the entire system produced on record assembled and the witnesses should have been confronted with the footages recorded in the Hard Disk at Exhibit 1. We, therefore, called upon the Technicians from the establishment in the High Court in our Chamber. We opened the seals of the articles sealed and produced. We got it assembled and have ourselves viewed the footages contained in the Hard Disk at Exhibit 1, which was connected to the DVR, CD-marked as 'X' and DVD at Article 18A.

115. After witnessing the footages in the Hard Disk, CD and DVD, we neither find any difference nor any discontinuity or insertions in the Hard Disk at Exhibit 1. On the contrary, we find that the recordings in the Hard Disk and the DVD and CD are in the same continuity and corresponds with each other. We find that the DVD at Article 18A and CD-'X' are the true and genuine copies of the footages in camera Nos. 1, 2 and 7 in CCTV recorded in the Hard Disk at Exhibit 1. We also find that the entire electronic evidence produced on record is not only consistent with each other, but also consistent with the oral evidence of the witnesses. Probably for this reason, there was no insistence from the defence for showing the footages from the Hard Disk, which is a primary electronic evidence.

116. We do not find it necessary to consider the question as to the admissibility of secondary evidence produced by a person not in power and possession of the CCTV system. We find that the primary as well as secondary evidence of electronic record is produced, and that the secondary evidence is a true and genuine copy of relevant primary evidence available on record. In the absence of any objection or cross-examination of the witnesses, PW 1 Raghuveer, PW 2 Raju, PW 3 Sitaram, PW 4 Pramod, PW 5 Kailash, PW 14 Shubham, PW 16 Rupali and PW 18 Vitthal, on the aspect of CD-marked as 'X' and DVD at Article 18A not being the true and genuine copies of the footages contained in the Hard Disk at Exhibit 1, in our view, the provision of Section 65-B of the Evidence Act is not at all attracted so as to make the electronic evidence in the form of CD and DVD inadmissible to establish the incident and the identity of the assailants. We, therefore, hold that the electronic evidence tendered in the form of Hard Disk at Exhibit 1, CD-'X' and DVD-Article 18A is admissible in the facts and circumstances of the case without a certificate under Section 65-B of the Evidence Act. We, therefore, accept such a view taken by the Sessions Court to be legal, correct and proper.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

Criminal Appeal Nos. 254, 255, 393 of 2015, 121, 180 and 181 of 2016

Decided On: 05.06.2018

 Bhupesh Tichkule Vs. The State of Maharashtra
Print Page

Saturday, 16 May 2020

Delhi HC: The court may raise a presumption about the reliability of Electronic Evidence as per S 114 of Evidence Act if conditions mentioned in Section 65B of Evidence Act are satisfied

Section 65A states that contents of electronic record may be proved in accordance with the provisions of Section 65B. We have already interpreted and referred to Section 65B. The importance of the said Section is that it does away with the requirement to produce the original computer or the original media on which data or information was stored and allows the secondary evidence in the form of computer output to be produced and admitted in evidence, subject to the condition that when evidence of computer output is produced and tendered, certificate of a person occupying a responsible official position in relation to operation of the relevant device or management of the relevant activities as prescribed by Section 65B of the Evidence Act is produced. In this manner, Section 65B authorises production and admission, in evidence, all computer output without production of the original, i.e., it permits leading of secondary evidence without the original being produced. ( Para 46)

53. In view of the aforesaid discussion, information memorised as business record or records maintained in common course of events are not treated as hearsay even if the maker lacks personal knowledge of the facts or events. The document should be prepared in normal course of business must have been at or near the time of events it records and should have been made in normal course of business activities or events. Sub-section (4) to Section 65B postulates that the certificate should be given by a person occupying a responsible official position in relation to operation of the relevant device or management of the relevant activities. If the said conditions are satisfied, it promotes and establishes the trustworthiness. In such cases, presumption of fact regarding genuineness and authenticity of the content can be invoked at the discretion of the court under Section 114 of the Evidence Act.

54. In Anwar P.V. (supra) in paragraph 1 itself the Supreme Court noticed the difference between relevancy and admissibility, which is examined at the initial stage; and genuineness, veracity and reliability of the evidence, which is seen by the court subsequently. Thus, the ratio and dictum in Anwar P.V. (supra) is based and predicated on the difference between admissibility and veracity or evidentiary value. The Supreme Court dealt with the aspect of admissibility in strict legal sense, not to be confused with evidentiary value or correctness of contents. Of course, when the conditions mentioned in Section 65B are satisfied, in terms of Section 114 of the Evidence Act, the court may presume existence of certain facts for the computer output would have data and information collected or derived in common course of human conduct and in public and private business.

55. In terms of sub-section (1) to Section 65B, original evidence need not be produced when conditions of Section 65B are satisfied. The computer output in relation to the information and computer in question are admissible as secondary evidence, when certificate under Section 65B is produced. However, Section 65B nowhere states that the contents of the computer output shall be treated as the truth of the statement. Section 65B deals with admissibility of secondary evidence in the case of "electronic records" and not with the truthfulness or veracity of the contents. However, when a certificate under Section 65B is produced the Court may presume or form a prima facie opinion, which is rebuttable and may not be accepted.

56. Electronically generated record is entirely a product of functioning of a computer system or computer process, like call record details or a report generated on a fax, which shows the number from and to which the fax were sent, time, etc. is generated electronically. It does not contain any assertion. Therefore, as noticed above it is not hearsay. These are not writings made by a person (see United States versus Khorozian, 333 F. 3d 498, 506). Normally non-assertive conduct is more reliable, provided there has been no fraud and interpolation in the preparation of the record. Computer generated telephone records are not similar to a statement by a human declarant and, therefore, cannot be treated as hearsay and the credibility and evidentiary value is determined on the reliability and accuracy of the process involved. Ergo, in these cases when conditions of Section 65B are satisfied, the probative value or weight can be substantial of course, subject to verification as to the credibility and integrity of the contents.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

Crl. A. 711/2014

Decided On: 24.11.2015

 Kundan Singh  Vs. The State
Print Page

Whether court can permit production of certificate U/S 65B of Evidence Act at subsequent stage?

Anwar P.V. (supra) partly overruled the earlier decision of the Supreme Court on the procedure to prove electronic record(s) in Navjot Sandhu (supra), holding that Section 65B is a specific provision relating to the admissibility of electronic record(s) and, therefore, production of a certificate under Section 65B(4) is mandatory. Anwar P.V. (supra) does not state or hold that the said certificate cannot be produced in exercise of powers of the trial court under Section 311 Cr.P.C. or, at the appellate stage under Section 391 Cr.P.C. Evidence Act is a procedural law and in view of the pronouncement in Anwar P.V. (supra) partly overruling Navjot Sandhu (supra), the prosecution may be entitled to invoke the aforementioned provisions, when justified and required. Of course, it is open to the court/presiding officer at that time to ascertain and verify whether the responsible officer could issue the said certificate and meet the requirements of Section 65B.

Emails are downloaded and computer output, in the form of paper prints, are taken every day. These emails may become relevant and important electronic evidence, subsequently. It is difficult to conceive and accept that the emails would be inadmissible, if the official i.e. the person who downloaded them and had taken printouts had failed to, on that occasion or simultaneously record a certificate under Section 65B.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

Crl. A. 711/2014

Decided On: 24.11.2015

 Kundan Singh  Vs. The State
Print Page

How is the doctrine of hearsay applicable for proof of Electronic evidence?

In Balram Prasad Agrawal versus State of Bihar and Others; MANU/SC/0427/1997 : (1997) 9 SCC 338, the Supreme Court referred to the concept of hearsay evidence and observed that even if some information is ruled out as hearsay, it may still remain admissible as evidence of the conduct of the witness. Relying on Section 8 of the Evidence Act, it was observed as under:-

"11. ...This part of the evidence of PW 6 would not be hit by the rule of exclusion of hearsay evidence. A decision of this Court deserves to be noted on this aspect. In the case of J.D. Jain v. State Bank MANU/SC/0427/1981 : AIR 1982 SC 673 of India a Bench of three learned Judges speaking through Baharul Islam, J. in the Report has made the following pertinent observations: (AIR p. 676, para 10 : SCC p. 148, paras 21 and 22)

"The word "hearsay" is used in various senses. Sometimes it means whatever a person is heard to say; sometimes it means whatever a person declares on information given by someone else. (See Stephen on Law of Evidence)

The Privy Council in the case of Subramaniam v. Public Prosecutor 1956 WLR 965, observed:

"Evidence of a statement made to a witness who is not himself called as a witness may or may not be hearsay. It is hearsay and inadmissible when the object of the evidence is to establish the truth of what is contained in the statement. It is not hearsay and is admissible when it is proposed to establish by the evidence, not the truth of the statement but the fact that it was made. The fact that it was made quite apart from its truth, is frequently relevant in considering the mental state and conduct thereafter of the witness or some other persons in whose presence these statements are made."
The term "hearsay" applies to both spoken or oral evidence and also has reference to what is written. Hearsay evidence is rejected on the principle that the best evidence obtainable should be produced as it is relatively trustworthy, whereas hearsay evidence poses difficulties for it derives value not from the witness himself, but on the veracity and competence of some other person whose version is not tested in the cross-examination.

50. For principle of hearsay to apply and reject an evidence, it must be shown that it was made by some other declarant other than the one testifying at the trial of hearing and the statement is being offered in evidence to prove the truth of the matter asserted. Therefore, even if the evidence is an assertion made by the declarant, it will not be hearsay until it is offered to prove the truth of what is asserted.

51. A statement which is not assertion, i.e., to state the truth declared and maintained, but only a statement of fact is not hearsay. A hearsay declarants non-verbal conduct may qualify as a "statement" for purpose of exclusion under the hearsay rule, if the conduct of the person intended by him as a substitute for oral or written verbal expression.(see, Matter of Cherl H., 2 Dist. 153 CA 3d 1098). Pertinently, in case of self-generated data or information there is no declarant as such who is asserting a fact.

52. Evidence may be offered for different purposes. The same evidence can be treated as hearsay and non-hearsay depending upon its relevance, i.e., whether it is relevant for a substantive truth or for some other purpose. For example, when person A meets person B and speaks to him about an occurrence, testimony of person B to the said effect would not be hearsay, but may become hearsay if a party seeks to rely upon facts stated by person A implicating a third person. Thus, we must notice and record the difference between a "factum of statement" and "truth of a statement". The said distinction has been recognised and accepted in several pronouncements in J.D. Jain versus State Bank of India, MANU/SC/0427/1981 : AIR 1982 SC 673, Manilal Navavati versus Sushila Mahendra Nanavati, MANU/SC/0192/1964 : AIR 1965 SC 364 and S.R. Ramaraj versus Special Court, Bombay, MANU/SC/0600/2003 : (2003) 7 SCC 175. Thus, electronic record produced as a statement as a tangible in form of a CD, print out on paper, etc. as a fact in itself, must be distinguished from electronic record, which is produced to prove truth of the matter it asserts or correctness of contents for the latter postulates adjudication of veracity and credibility of the information by the person who has made a statement offering or producing the document for its truth.

53. In view of the aforesaid discussion, information memorised as business record or records maintained in common course of events are not treated as hearsay even if the maker lacks personal knowledge of the facts or events. The document should be prepared in normal course of business must have been at or near the time of events it records and should have been made in normal course of business activities or events. Sub-section (4) to Section 65B postulates that the certificate should be given by a person occupying a responsible official position in relation to operation of the relevant device or management of the relevant activities. If the said conditions are satisfied, it promotes and establishes the trustworthiness. In such cases, presumption of fact regarding genuineness and authenticity of the content can be invoked at the discretion of the court under Section 114 of the Evidence Act.

54. In Anwar P.V. (supra) in paragraph 1 itself the Supreme Court noticed the difference between relevancy and admissibility, which is examined at the initial stage; and genuineness, veracity and reliability of the evidence, which is seen by the court subsequently. Thus, the ratio and dictum in Anwar P.V. (supra) is based and predicated on the difference between admissibility and veracity or evidentiary value. The Supreme Court dealt with the aspect of admissibility in strict legal sense, not to be confused with evidentiary value or correctness of contents. Of course, when the conditions mentioned in Section 65B are satisfied, in terms of Section 114 of the Evidence Act, the court may presume existence of certain facts for the computer output would have data and information collected or derived in common course of human conduct and in public and private business.

55. In terms of sub-section (1) to Section 65B, original evidence need not be produced when conditions of Section 65B are satisfied. The computer output in relation to the information and computer in question are admissible as secondary evidence, when certificate under Section 65B is produced. However, Section 65B nowhere states that the contents of the computer output shall be treated as the truth of the statement. Section 65B deals with admissibility of secondary evidence in the case of "electronic records" and not with the truthfulness or veracity of the contents. However, when a certificate under Section 65B is produced the Court may presume or form a prima facie opinion, which is rebuttable and may not be accepted.

56. Electronically generated record is entirely a product of functioning of a computer system or computer process, like call record details or a report generated on a fax, which shows the number from and to which the fax were sent, time, etc. is generated electronically. It does not contain any assertion. Therefore, as noticed above it is not hearsay. These are not writings made by a person (see United States versus Khorozian, 333 F. 3d 498, 506). Normally non-assertive conduct is more reliable, provided there has been no fraud and interpolation in the preparation of the record. Computer generated telephone records are not similar to a statement by a human declarant and, therefore, cannot be treated as hearsay and the credibility and evidentiary value is determined on the reliability and accuracy of the process involved. Ergo, in these cases when conditions of Section 65B are satisfied, the probative value or weight can be substantial of course, subject to verification as to the credibility and integrity of the contents.



57. We have already referred to the distinction between factum of a statement and truth of a statement and the concept of presumption of memorandum or records maintained in normal course of business and the credibility or trustworthiness of electronic records. However, it must be understood that mere admission or admissibility of the electronic record would not mean that the contents of the electronic record have been proved beyond doubt and debate and are automatically proved when the document is marked exhibit. Mere marking of a document as exhibit does not dispense with the proof of its contents (see Sait Tarajee Khimchand versus Yelamarti Satyam, MANU/SC/0022/1971 : AIR 1971 SC 1865, Narbada Devi Gupta versus Birendra Kumar Jaiswal, MANU/SC/0862/2003 : (2003) 8 SCC 745 and Mohd. Yusuf versus D. and Another, MANU/MH/0106/1968 : AIR 1968 Bombay 112). Provisions of Section 65 of Evidence Act are apposite on the said legal principle and reference can also be made to Sections 91 and 92 of the Evidence Act. The latter sections deal with exclusion of oral evidence by documentary evidence in certain cases and in which cases oral evidence can be led even when there are documents recording terms of contract, grant or any other disposition of property or when a matter is required by law to be reduced to a form of a document. The effect of the aforesaid provisions is that when a certificate under Section 65B authenticates the computer output, it will only show and establish that the computer output is the paper print out or media copy, etc. of the computer from which the output is obtained. The court has still to rule out when challenged or otherwise, the possibility of tampering, interpolation or changes from the date the record was first stored or created in the computer till the computer output is obtained. The focus over here is not so much on the creation of the out-put as stipulated under sub-section (2) to Section 65B, but rather on the preservation and sanctity of the record after it was originally created. It extends beyond identification of the particular computer equipment and the process or equipment used for computer output, etc. It would relate to the policies, procedures for use of the equipment that stored the said information since creation and data base and integrity of the same. Questions which would arise and have to be answered is whether data base was protected and had no or limited access, which permits modification/alteration; whether the data base could be wrongly lodged or created or could be transferred or changed when the data base was transferred and stored in the backup systems. These are questions which are pertinent and have to be examined to ascertain whether or not there was possibility of change, alteration or manipulation in the initial or original data after it was created. The courts must rule out that the records have not been tampered and read the data or information as it originally existed. These are aspects which are not codified as such, for probative value is examined on the case to case basis keeping in mind the relevant facts.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

Crl. A. 711/2014

Decided On: 24.11.2015

 Kundan Singh  Vs.  The State

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Sanjiv Khanna and R.K. Gauba, JJ.

Citation: MANU/DE/3674/2015
Print Page

Friday, 15 May 2020

What are material prerequisites for proof of email evidence?

What falls for adjudication in the present case is whether on the basis of the aforesaid emails, the defendant No. 1 can be said to be having the written consent of the defendants No. 3 & 4 to transfer or agree to transfer the aforesaid second floor flat.

18. However before discussing the contents of the emails it may be stated that as per Section 65B of The Indian Evidence Act, 1872, for such emails to be proved, it has to be proved/established that the computer during the relevant period was in the lawful control of the person proving the email; that information was regularly fed into the computer in the ordinary course of the activities; that the computer was operating properly and the contents printed on paper are derived from the information fed into the computer in the ordinary course of activities and a certificate identifying the electronic record has to be proved. Most of the emails aforesaid are stated to be exchanged by the defendants No. 3&4 with the son of the defendant No. 1 who has however not been produced in evidence. The plaintiff No. 1 in his affidavit by way of examination-in-chief has also not satisfied the aforesaid conditions of Section 65B of the Act. The emails on which reliance is placed to plead written consent of the defendants No. 3&4 cannot thus be said to be proved.

19. However even if the said emails were to be held to be proved, in my view the same do not constitute written consent of the defendants No. 3&4 to the defendant No. 1 agreeing to transfer the share of the defendants No. 3 & 4 in the second floor flat, within the meaning of the Memorandum of Family Settlement/Agreement dated 17th March, 1998 supra for the following reasons;

(a). There is no email of prior to the date of Agreement to Sell.

(b). There is no statement that the email address with which the said emails had been exchanged are that of the defendants No. 3 & 4.

(c). The defendant No. 1 or his son with whom the emails are stated to have been exchanged by the defendants No. 3 & 4 have not been examined as witnesses.

(d). What is conveyed by the son of the defendant No. 1 to the defendant No. 3 in the email Exhibit PW-1/8 dated 12th December, 2006 is that he was going ahead with the sale when as aforesaid the Agreement to Sell had already been executed prior thereto.

(e). There is no evidence as to who is Raje Chacha, referred to in the emails.

(f). There is nothing to show that the e-mails purported to have been sent by the defendant No. 1 or his son were delivered to the defendants No. 3 & 4.

(g). Even in the email dated 1st October, 2007, what is purported to be conveyed to the defendant No. 3 is that the Aggarwal Chemist from the Hauz Khas Market (plaintiff No. 1) was interested to buy and option was given to the defendant No. 3 to keep the front terrace. The language thereof is indicative of nothing having been finally decided tilt then, when as aforesaid the Agreement of which specific performance is claimed is of a date prior thereto.

(h). The email Exhibit PW-1/10 dated 17th January, 2007 purportedly from the defendant No. 3 is only of forwarding the certain documents and does not confirm consent to sell. 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

CS (OS) 86/2009

Decided On: 24.01.2013

Babu Ram Aggarwal Vs.  Krishan Kumar Bhatnagar and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Rajiv Sahai Endlaw, J.

Print Page