The short point which really falls for consideration in the present Writ Petition is whether publication of a Notification issued under Section 4 of the Slums Act in the Official Gazette is adequate compliance with Section 4 of the Slums Act and the Rules framed thereunder. The answer to this question is an emphatic no. {Para 20}
21. Section 4 of the Slums Act provides that the Competent Authority on being satisfied that an area is required to be declared as slum for one or more of the reasons set out in Section 4 of the Slums Act, the Competent Authority may, (i) by Notification in the Official Gazette so declare such area to be a slum area; and (ii) that such declaration shall also be published in such other manner (as will give due publicity to the declaration in the area) as maybe prescribed. The "other manner" of publication prescribed are to be found in Rule 3 of the Slum Rules which provide thus, viz.
"3. Other manner of Publication of Declaration under section 4(1):-
(a) The declaration referred to in sub-section (1) of section 4 shall also be published in one local newspaper as the Competent Authority may, for ensuring due publicity to the declaration in the area in respect of which the declaration is made, decide.
(b) A copy of such declaration shall be pasted on the Notice Board in the office of the Competent Authority and shall also be displayed in a conspicuous place in such area. A substance of the declaration shall also be proclaimed by beat of drum in the area.
(c) The Competent Authority shall as far as practicable serve a notice on every owner or occupier or both of the property in such area stating the effect of the declaration and specifying the time within which any aggrieved person may appeal to the Tribunal under sub-section (3) of section 4 of the Act.
A plain reading of Rule 3 makes clear that each of the above modes of publication are distinct and separate from each other. Rule 3 also makes clear that in due compliance thereof the Competent Authority is required to publish the said Notification by exercising each of the modes set out in Rule 3 and not any one or more of the modes set out. Therefore, the Competent Authority when declaring an area as a slum is mandatorily required to do each of the following, viz.
a. Publish the declaration in one local newspaper having wide circulation in the relevant area.
b. Paste a copy of the declaration on the notice board in the office of the Competent Authority.
c. Display a copy of the said declaration in a conspicuous place in the area declared as a slum.
d. Make a proclamation of the substance of the said declaration in the area declared as a slum by beat of a drum.
e. Serve notice upon every owner and occupier of the property in the area declared as a slum (i) stating the effect of the declaration and (ii) specifying the time within which an aggrieved person may Appeal to the Tribunal under Section 4(3) of the Slums Act.
It is only in cases where, for some compelling reason that it is not practicable to serve individual notice upon every owner and occupier of the said land under Section 3(c) that service of such notice shall be dispensed with. This would however require the Competent Authority to have compelling reasons for not personally serving every owner and occupier of the said area. These reasons must be recorded and available (a) for good order and (b) in the event that want of such notice is called into question by any owner and occupier of the said area. The mandatory modes of publication prescribed in Rule 3 read with Section 4 of the Slums Act is not without good reason as the effect of a declaration of land as a slum has widespread ramifications which would affect the right, title and interest of both the owners and occupiers of such land.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Writ Petition No. 3838 of 2021
Decided On: 09.06.2023
Allan Sebastian D'Souza and Ors. Vs. Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Tribunal and Ors.
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
A.S. Doctor, J.
Citation: MANU/MH/2043/2023.
Print Page