Showing posts with label occupier. Show all posts
Showing posts with label occupier. Show all posts

Tuesday, 13 June 2023

Should the Slum Authority Issue Individual Notices to All Owners and Occupiers of Immovable Property Before Declaring an Area as a Slum Area?

The short point which really falls for consideration in the present Writ Petition is whether publication of a Notification issued under Section 4 of the Slums Act in the Official Gazette is adequate compliance with Section 4 of the Slums Act and the Rules framed thereunder. The answer to this question is an emphatic no. {Para 20}


21. Section 4 of the Slums Act provides that the Competent Authority on being satisfied that an area is required to be declared as slum for one or more of the reasons set out in Section 4 of the Slums Act, the Competent Authority may, (i) by Notification in the Official Gazette so declare such area to be a slum area; and (ii) that such declaration shall also be published in such other manner (as will give due publicity to the declaration in the area) as maybe prescribed. The "other manner" of publication prescribed are to be found in Rule 3 of the Slum Rules which provide thus, viz.


"3. Other manner of Publication of Declaration under section 4(1):-


(a) The declaration referred to in sub-section (1) of section 4 shall also be published in one local newspaper as the Competent Authority may, for ensuring due publicity to the declaration in the area in respect of which the declaration is made, decide.


(b) A copy of such declaration shall be pasted on the Notice Board in the office of the Competent Authority and shall also be displayed in a conspicuous place in such area. A substance of the declaration shall also be proclaimed by beat of drum in the area.


(c) The Competent Authority shall as far as practicable serve a notice on every owner or occupier or both of the property in such area stating the effect of the declaration and specifying the time within which any aggrieved person may appeal to the Tribunal under sub-section (3) of section 4 of the Act.


A plain reading of Rule 3 makes clear that each of the above modes of publication are distinct and separate from each other. Rule 3 also makes clear that in due compliance thereof the Competent Authority is required to publish the said Notification by exercising each of the modes set out in Rule 3 and not any one or more of the modes set out. Therefore, the Competent Authority when declaring an area as a slum is mandatorily required to do each of the following, viz.


a. Publish the declaration in one local newspaper having wide circulation in the relevant area.


b. Paste a copy of the declaration on the notice board in the office of the Competent Authority.


c. Display a copy of the said declaration in a conspicuous place in the area declared as a slum.


d. Make a proclamation of the substance of the said declaration in the area declared as a slum by beat of a drum.


e. Serve notice upon every owner and occupier of the property in the area declared as a slum (i) stating the effect of the declaration and (ii) specifying the time within which an aggrieved person may Appeal to the Tribunal under Section 4(3) of the Slums Act.


It is only in cases where, for some compelling reason that it is not practicable to serve individual notice upon every owner and occupier of the said land under Section 3(c) that service of such notice shall be dispensed with. This would however require the Competent Authority to have compelling reasons for not personally serving every owner and occupier of the said area. These reasons must be recorded and available (a) for good order and (b) in the event that want of such notice is called into question by any owner and occupier of the said area. The mandatory modes of publication prescribed in Rule 3 read with Section 4 of the Slums Act is not without good reason as the effect of a declaration of land as a slum has widespread ramifications which would affect the right, title and interest of both the owners and occupiers of such land.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Writ Petition No. 3838 of 2021

Decided On: 09.06.2023

Allan Sebastian D'Souza and Ors.  Vs. Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Tribunal and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

A.S. Doctor, J.

Citation: MANU/MH/2043/2023.

Print Page

Saturday, 31 December 2022

Whether Occupier Of Flat is Entitled To Transit Rent For Period Of Dispossession During Redevelopment?

The fact remains that as respondent no. 3 is in possession of the tenement in question and would now be handing over possession of such tenement to the petitioner/society. Hence considering the consistent view taken by this Court in Heritage Lifestyles and Developers Pvt. Ltd. vs. Amar-Villa Co-Operative Housing Society and others MANU/MH/0380/2011 : 2011 (3) Mh.L.J. 865 and in Saikripa Co-operative Housing Society Ltd. V/s. Osho Developers & Ors.1, the party who is dispossessed, would be entitled to the transit rent as it is such party who is put to hardship.{Para 9}

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Commercial Arbitration Petition (L.) No. 4301 of 2022

Decided On: 16.03.2022

Maniar Associates LLP  Vs. Vijay Niwas Co-op. Hsg. Soc. Ltd. and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

G.S. Kulkarni, J.

Citation: MANU/MH/1454/2022
Print Page

Monday, 25 October 2021

Whether occupier of property is liable to pay property tax if he files Municipal appeal?

 It is not possible to accept this submission. Section 209 as already clarified above, deals with the case of liability for payment of property taxes as far as occupiers are concerned. The bill is raised on the person primarily liable for payment of property tax. If the person primarily liable is not the occupier of the premises, then, the bill may be raised on the occupier and after it is served on him the recovery can be effected in accordance with section 199 to 209 of the MMC Act. While recovering taxes, the arrears cannot be recovered from such occupiers under section 209, if the same have remained due for more than one year. Thus, the recovery in terms of section 209 cannot be effected if the property tax has remained in arrears for more than one year. It is not possible to extend the provision and particularly sub-section 3 of 209 and read it into section 217(5) of the Act. It will be defeating the Legislative Mandate if such a reading of the provision is permitted. The word "payable" is used in sub-section 5 only to point out that after the appeal is filed the payment of property taxes which are due on the basis of the original and the increased rateable can be secured during the pendency of the appeal provided it is claimed from the appellant by issuing bills from time to time, since filing of the appeal. Therefore, to secure further sum till such time as the appeal is decided that sub-section 5 has been introduced in the Statute Book. In other words to enable and facilitate the corporation to effect recovery of property taxes levied and assessed at the original rate and to secure the claim on the basis of the revised or increased rateable value that this provision is made. Taxes are public dues and their recovery should not be hampered in any manner because challenge to the levy and assessment is pending before a court of law, is the intent in inserting sub-section (5) in the Act. That intent will be defeated if it is held that operation of this provision is controlled and restricted by section 209(3) of the MMC Act. That section serves another purpose. Once, the Legislature does not provide for any restriction and enacts the law in absolute terms full effect must be given to the provision or else the object and purpose of its insertion is defeated and frustrated. Once its introduction is understood in proper perspective, then, it is not difficult to reject the submissions of Mr.Joglekar.{Para 22}

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

S.C. DHARMADHIKARI, J.

Dena Bank & Anr. Vs. Municipal Corporation Of Gr. Mumbai & Anr.

Print Page

Monday, 18 October 2021

Should Municipal Corporation give general particulars like the assessment method in the special notice issued for assessing property tax?

 It was vehemently contended that the special notice, which is issued must mention material particulars, like method of assessment, carpet area, letting rate, as also the reasons for fixing the gross rateable value at a particular figure so that the concerned asses-see can effectively and specifically file his objections and meet with the case of the Tax Department and produce relevant and matching evidence in support of his contentions. {Para 74}

 What are the requirements of a notice which are stipulated in Rule 15(2)? Notice under Section 15(2) is issued after entry in the assesment book has been made. Sub-rule (2) of Rule 15 requires that the special written notice to the owner or the occupier shall specify the nature of such entry. In other words, the special notice must inform the owner about the entries mentioned in Rule 9, Clauses (a), (b), (c) and (d), because the said Rule 15 has to be read with Rules 9 and 13. When a statute specifies as to what should be the contents of a notice, and that is so specified in Rule 15(2), the general principles enunciated by the aforesaid decisions and of other High Courts would not be applicable.

For the purposes of giving an opportunity to an owner or an occupier to file a complaint, all that he has to be informed is what the Commissioner has entered in the assessment book. One of the items, which is entered, is the ratable value. The Commissioner is under no obligation to inform as to how the rateable value, which is entered in the assessment book, has been arrived at. It is for the owner to complain if he finds the rateable value to be high. The principles for fixation of rateable value are well-known. Ordinarily, a rateable value will be arrived at after particulars had been given by the owners or occupiers under Rule 8 of the Rules. On the receipt of the notice, it will be for the complainant to lead evidence and prove as to what should be the correct rateable value. A hearing is contemplated by Rule 18 and if the assessee requires any clarification with regard to the entry made in the assesssment book, we see no reason as to why this clarification would not, ordinarily, be given. Be that as it may, Rule 15(2) docs not require the giving of any particulars in addition to what is stated therein. The aforesaid decisions of various Courts, therefore, can be of no assistance to the respondents. {Para 75}

Gujarat High Court
Municipal Corporation Of The City ... vs Oriental Fire & General Insurance ... on 8 September, 1994
Print Page

Under which circumstances can the court determine the correct rateable value of the property for assessing property tax?

  But, where the principle of waiver does not apply and a notice under Rule 15(2) is not issued and an assessment is made, then after coming to the conclusion that the assessment is a nullity, can the Small Cause Court quash the assessment simpliciter or does it have a duty or jurisdiction to take further action in the matter. {Para 68}

69. The provisions of Rule 20 clearly show that the power of the Commissioner to make changes in the entry can be exercised only during the official year itself. Once this official year is over, the Commissioner will have no jurisdiction to make any alteration. In Anant Mills Co. Ltd. v. Municipal Corporation, Ahmedabad, 1993(2) G. L. H. 897, it was held by a Division Bench of this Court, after examining the scheme of the Act, that the assessment must be completed before the close of the relevant official year and once the official year has expired, the Commissioner cannot assess and levy property tax and, therefore, the Court also cannot issue direction to the Commissioner to do something which was not permissible under the Act. The quashing of the assessment would mean that the Commissioner would not be in a position to reassess and levy property taxes and the taxes for those official years would be totally lost to the Corporation. This being the position, the appellate court cannot and should not set aside the assessment and remand the case for de novo assessment by the Commissioner. Any remand would, obviously, serve no useful purpose.

70. In view of the aforesaid position in law, it was submitted by the learned counsel for the Corporation that in such cases, the Chief Judge or the Judges of the Small Cause Court themselves should determine the rateable value in accordance with law. The counsel for the respondents, however, contended that if the assessment is a nullity, because of non-compliance with the provisions of Rule 15(2), or otherwise, then the Small Cause Court has no option but to quash the assessment, in toto.

71. The principle underlying the judgment in Anant Mill's case clearly answers the aforesaid question in favour of the Corporation. In that case, it had been contended that the Chief Judge has no jurisdiction to entertain the grounds affecting legality of the assessment. It was also submitted in that case, on behalf of the assessee, that if the Chief Judge came to the conclusion that the method of assessment was illogical or irrelevant and the assessment, therefore, invalid, then it would not be competent for the Chief Judge to determine the rateable value afresh by applying the appropriate method in a correct manner. Elaborating further, it was submitted that all that the Chief Judge would be able to do would be to declare the assessment invalid and leave it to the Commissioner to make a fresh assessment according to the correct method and this would, again, result in the Corporation losing the tax altogether. Similar is the contention raised before us, namely, that the assessment is bad as proper procedure is not followed. Rejecting the submission, the Division Bench, in Anant Mills' case, at page 922, observed as follows :--

".....This contention is also, in our opinion, without substance. It ignores the scheme of the provisions in regard to appeals contained in the Act. We have already pointed out that an appeal may be preferred against the rateable value and in this appeal the assessee would challenge the determination of the rateable value made by the Commissioner. He may challenge it on any ground available to him and such ground may well relate to the method of valuation adopted for the purpose of determining the rateable value. It is apparent from the provision in Section 409 Sub-section (1) and particularly the words "before evidence as to value has been adduced" that the appeal against rateable value is in the nature of an original proceeding where evidence as to value may be led by both parties. The Chief Judge may on the application of a party to the appeal appoint a competent person to make the valuation and such person may be called as a witness and if he is so-called, he may be cross-examined by the other side. The evidence as to value which may be adduced before the Chief Judge in the appeal may be based on any method which is regarded by the party or his witness as appropriate. It cannot be restricted to the method of valuation adopted by the Commissioner. So also when a competent person is directed to make a valuation, he may value it according to the method which he regards as proper there is no requirement in the statute that his, valuation must be based on the method adopted by the Commissioner. The entire question as to retable value would be open before the Chief Judge and as contemplated under Section 411 Clause (a), it would be for the Chief Judge to fix the ratable value and the decision of the Chief Judge fixing the ratable value would be final, subject to appeal to the High Court and the Commissioner would be bound to give effect to such decision as provided in Section 413. The whole scheme of the provisions clearly contemplates that in the appeal against the ratable value, the Chief Judge would have to fix the ratable value after considering the evidence as to value which may be adduced before him and it is implicit in this process that he would also have to decide which method of valuation should be adopted. If, therefore, the Chief Judge takes the view that the contractor's test method is inappropriate or inapplicable, he can decide which other method should be adopted and fix the rateable value by applying such method on the basis of the evidence before him."

It was contended by Shri Modi that such a course would be clearly contrary to the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Martin Burn Limited v. Calcutta Municipal Corproation, AIR 1966 SC 529 and that if the order of assessment is not valid, because of non-compliance with Rule 15(2), or any other Rule, then the Court would have no jurisdiction to undertake the exercise of fixing the ratable value itself. Similar contention was also raised in Anant Mills case. The Court examined the relevant provisions of the Calcutta Municipal Act, 1928, and compared the same with the provisions of the Bombay Provisional Municipal Corporation Act, and then observed as follows:--

".... This decision given on the basis of a scheme of taxation contained in the Calcutta Act can hardly be of any relevance when we are considering a question arising under a totally different scheme of taxation contained in the Corporation Act. The power of the Court of Small Cause under the Calcutta Act was to cancel the assessment or to revise or alter the valuation and the Supreme Court held that since the method on the basis of which the valuation was made by the Corporation was illegal, the Court of Small Cause could not do anything except cancel the assessment; it would not make an independent valuation itself by adopting the correct method, for that would not be revision or alteration of the valuation. But here under the Corporations Act the power of the Chief Judge in appeal against rateable value is not restricted merely to revision or alteration of the valuation. On the contrary it is a wide power conferred in general terms without any words of limitation. It says that an appeal against the rateable value shall be heard and determined by the Chief Judge. The Chief Judge is empowered to fix the rateable value after considering the evidence a to value adduced before him and the Commissioner is enjoined to give effect to the decision of the Chief Judge. The principles of the decision in Martin Burn's case can, therefore, have no application under the Corporation Act.

30. The result of this discussion is that if we quash and set aside the assessment made by the Deputy Municipal Commissioner on any of these grounds urged on behalf of the petitioners, the tax for the official years 1967-68 and 1968-69 would be lost to the Corporation whereas no such drastic consequence would ensue if these grounds are left to be decided by the Chief Judge in the appeals preferred by the petitioners. The Chief Judge can entertain these grounds and if he is of the view that the contractors method adopted by the Deputy Municipal Commissioner is not proper or relevant to the determination of the annual rental value, he can determine the annual rental value of the premises by applying the appropriate method and the tax can be levied on the petitioners on the basis of such ratable value. The latter alternative would do full justice to the peitioners without causing grave and undue hardship which would inevitably result to the Corporation if the former alternative were adopted. We, therefore, refuse to entertain these grounds in the exercise of our jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution. They can be decided by the Chief Judge in the appeals preferred by the petitiones...."

We are in respectful agreement with the aforesaid observations in Anant Mill's case. Following the said ratio, it would mean that even if the assessment is held to be not in accordance with law, whether because of the wrong method followed with regard to determining the rateable value or because of any irregularity or illegality in procedure or because of violaton of the principles of natural justice or because notice under Rule 15(2) had not been issued, then the Small Cause Court would itself have the jurisdiction to examine evidence and determine the correct rateable value. It would be wholly inappropriate for the Small Cause Court to merely quash the assessment, which would have the effect that for the official years in question, the entire tax would be lost to the Corporation. In effect, the ratio decidendi of the decision in Anant Mills' case is that the Small Cause Court exercises the same power and will have the same jurisdiction, which is exercised by the Commissioner for the purposes of determining what should be the correct rateable value.


Gujarat High Court
Municipal Corporation Of The City ... vs Oriental Fire & General Insurance ... on 8 September, 1994
Print Page

Does the principle of waiver apply if the property owner files a complaint against an assessment of property tax even though he has not received a special notice?

  It was further submitted that when the property is newly constructed or the rateable value is to be increased, then issuance of a notice under Rule 15(2) is mandatory. Such a notice in writing is to be issued in addition to the public notice given under Rule 13(1). It was also submitted that the use of the word 'shall' in Rule 15(2) makes the issuance of such a notice mandatory and if the same is not given, any assessment made would be null and void.{Para 63}

64. The requirement of giving a notice under Rule 15(2) is clearly in consonance with the principles of natural justice. The Rules contemplate that once entries have been entered in the assessment book, then they can be adopted in subsequent years and that a new assessment book must be made once every four years. The advertisement, contemplated by Rule 13, is only to the effect that the assessment book is ready and that it can be inspected at a place to be notified therein. In case of a property newly constructed or where the rateable value is to be enhanced, such public, notice under Rule 13 would give no indication regarding the entries made. The requirement of Rule 15(2) of giving a special notice if only to make the person concerned aware of the fact that the premises are going to be entered in the assessment book for the first time or the rateable value is liable to be changed.

65. What will be the effect, if a special notice, as contemplated by Rule 15(2), is not issued?

66. Reading of Rule 15(2) shows that giving of special notice is mandatory. The use of the word 'shall' in Rule 15(2) clearly indicates that there is an obligation which is cast on the authorities concerned to issue a notice in writing notwithstanding the fact that a general notice may have been published under Rule 13. A notice under Rule 13, published in the newspaper, would not indicate the properties, which are newly added in the assessment book or the changes with regard to the rateable value, which have been made. The public notice under Rule 13 would merely state that the entries in the assessment book have been completed and the same is open for inspection. In the case of new properties, where rateable value has been increased, special notice must be given under Rule 15(2). As we have already observed, the requirement of giving a special notice under Rule 15(2) incorporates one of the cardinal principles of natural justice. The owner is required to be put to notice as to what action is contemplated by the Corporation with regard to the fixation of rateable value. If no such notice is given, then the result, which must normally, follow is that the said assessment will have to be quashed. The Small Cause Court, once it is satisfied that a special notice, as required under Rule 15(2), has not been given, would, normally, set aside the assessment. We are saying 'normally' because, one situation may arise, in which case, even if notice under Rule 15(2) has not been given, the Small Cause Court ought not to set aside the assessment. Such a situation will arise where notice under Rule 15(2) is waived. The principle of waiver, in such cases, is that if certain requirements or conditions are provided by a statute, in the interest of a particular person, then the requirements, or conditions, even if mandatory, may be waived by that person, if no public interest is involved, and in such a case, the act done will be valid even if the requirement or condition has not been performed.

67. Where, therefore, an assessee chooses to file a complaint against the proposal to fix or increase the reteable value, even without the issuancc of a valid special notice under Rule 15(2), the principle of waiver would apply. The requirement of issuing a notice under Rule 15(2) is to give an opportunity, of filing a complaint, to the assessee. If a complaint is filed then the purpose for which the notice was to be issued, is fulfilled. In such a case, even if no notice is issued or the notice, which is issued, suffers from any defect, the principle of waiver would apply and an assessee, in appeal before the Small Cause Court, or even thereafter, cannot be allowed to contend that non-compliance with the provi-sions of Rule 15(2) must result in the assessment being regarded as a nullity. In those appeals, therefore, where complaints were filed under Rule 16 and the same were disposed of under Rule 18, a contention that no notice under Rule 15(2) was not served cannot be raised.

Gujarat High Court
Municipal Corporation Of The City ... vs Oriental Fire & General Insurance ... on 8 September, 1994
Print Page

Whether Municipal Corporation should give a special notice to both owner and occupier of property for assessment of property tax?

It was then submitted that special notice under Rule 15(2) must be issued to the owner, as well as to the occupier. In support of this submission, it was urged that Sub-rule (2) of Rule 15 stated that the Commissioner shall give a special written notice "to the owner or occupier of the said premises".{Para 57}

58. It is, no doubt, true that Sub-rule (2) of Rule 15 does contemplate a situation, where special notice may be given to the owner or occupier. In other words, Sub-rule (2) of Rule 15 does not contemplate special written notice to be given only to the owner. If that is so, then under what circumstances is a special written notice required to be given to an occupier?

59. The Scheme of the Act and the Rules clearly is that liability for payment of property tax is on the person primarily liable. This is clearly provided by Section 139, read with Rule 8. In order to find out who is the person primarily liable, information may be sought from the owner or occupier. The person primarily liable under S. 139(1)(b) is the lessor or the superior lessor. This liability, however, shifts to the occupier at the stage of assessment, and before the raising of the bill only when the provisions of Rule 12(2) are attracted. If true information with regard to the name of the person, who is primarily liable, is not given by the person in occupation of the premises, then Sub-rule (2) of Rule 12 makes the occupier himself to be liable for all property taxes leviable. Rule 15(2), which follows Rule 12, when it refers to special notice being given to the occupier, can have reference to a case, where Rule 12(2) is applicable and the name of the person primarily liable is not known. Special notice under Section 15(2) will also have to be given to a tenant where he, under Section 139(2) of the BPMC Act, and not the owner, is liable to pay the tax by virtue of his being the tenant of the land on which premises are constructed by him. There is no third situation where a special notice has to be given to tenant.

60. The Rules cannot travel beyond the scope of the Act. The liability to pay property tax, according to Section 139(1) in case of tenanted premises, is on the lessor. It is the name of the person, who is primarily liable, which is to be entered in the assessment book, as provided by Rule 9(c). The Act, in contradistinction to the Rules, contemplates realisation of property tax from the tenant under Section 140(1) in a case only after bill has been submitted to the lessor and the same remains unpaid. The stage of Rule 15(2) is prior in point of time to the raising of the bill. Under the Act, the liability to pay property tax is fastened on the occupier or the tenant only under the provisions of Section 140. The demand for property tax can be made only after the assessment book has been finalised and a bill raised. The assessment book is finalised only when provisions of the Rules, including Rule 15, have been complied with and complaints received and determined under Rule 18. Therefore, interpreting Rule 15(2), in the light of the provisions of the Act, the inference can only be that the Rule's require only one assessment to be made on the person, who is primarily liable and not on any one else. Notice under Rule 15(2) to an occupier, and not to an owner, is, therefore, contemplated only when the occupier does not inform about the name of the owner, thereby attracting the provisions of Rule 12(2), which, by a fiction, makes him the person liable till the requisite information is obtained or where provisions of Section 139(2) are applicable.

61. It was also submitted that special notice under Rule 15(2) must be given both to the owner and occupier. It was contended that even if the liability to pay the tax is of the owner, by virtue of Section 139 of the Act, nevertheless, in the event of the rent having been fixed as being inclusive of taxes, then, if special notice is served on the occupier-

tenant, the landlord, for no fault of his, would be punished and penalised if the tenant does not inform the owner about the service of such a notice or he himself does not take any action in pursuance of such notice. Therefore, it is just and expedient to read the conjunction 'or' of Rule 15(2) as 'and'. We see no substance in this submission. The Act provides that the person primarily liable is the lessor, vide Section 139. Provisions of Rule 15(2) come into play during the course of assessment. The assessment is to be made in respect of the premises and, obviously, the person concerned would be, the owner. In this back ground, when duty is cast to serve a notice under Rule 15(2), on owner or occupier, the implication clearly is that, normally, special notice will be issued to the owner. It is only where the provisions of Rule 12(2) come into play and the occupier becomes liable that a notice under Rule 15(2) would be required to be issued to him.

62. The Act and the Rules do not contemplate two notices in respect of the same premises for a single official year being issued to two different persons. If the contention of Mr. Modi is correct, the effect would be that for a single official year, one notice will have to be issued to the occupier and another notice to the tenant. This may, then, result in conflicting situations arising. Supposing the owner does not file any objections and accepts the proposed assessment, can the tenant file a complaint and oppose the same. The reverse situation would be where the tenant accepts the proposed rateable value, but the owner objects. In each of such cases, a very anomalous situation will result when no objections are filed pursuant to one notice, which is issued under Rule 15(2) and the assessment would become final, but in respect of the same premises, if the other person, viz., either the owner or the tenant, files complaints, then the proposed assessment would not be final. The conjunction 'or' in Rule 15(2) can, under no circumstances, in our opinion, be regarded as 'and'.

Gujarat High Court
Municipal Corporation Of The City ... vs Oriental Fire & General Insurance ... on 8 September, 1994
Print Page

Sunday, 24 November 2019

Whether it is mandatory to obtain written permission from competent authority under slum Act to evict trespasser?

 Insofar as the definition of 'occupier' in Section 2(e) of the 1971 Act is concerned, it must be immediately stated that the said definition is not exhaustive but inclusive. Clauses (i) to (iv) of Section 2(e) definitely do not embrace within itself a trespasser but Clause (v) that reads, 'occupier' includes 'any person who is liable to pay to the owner damages for the use and occupation of any land or building' would surely take within its fold and sweep a trespasser since such person is not only liable for damages for an act of trespass but also liable to pay to the owner damages for the use and occupation of any land or building trespassed by him. It is immaterial whether damages for the use and occupation are in fact claimed or not by the owner in an action against the trespasser. By no stretch of imagination, a trespasser could be taken out of the definition of 'occupier' in Section 2(e)(v) of the 1971 Act. Clause (v), in our opinion, includes a person who enters the land or building in possession of another with permission or consent but remains upon such land or building after such permission or consent has been revoked since after revocation of permission or consent, he is liable to pay damages for unauthorised use of land or building. The Division Bench of the Bombay High Court in Taj Mohamed Yakub v. Abdul Gani Bhikan MANU/MH/0976/1990 : (1991) Mh L J 263 has taken the view that a trespasser is included in the definition of 'occupier' under Section 2(e)(v) of the 1971 Act which, we hold, is the correct view. 

16. Once it is held that a trespasser is included in the definition of 'occupier' in Section 2(e)(v) of the 1971 Act, what necessarily follows is that before initiation of any suit or proceeding for eviction of such trespasser, the previous written permission of the Competent Authority is required as mandated by Section 22(1). Section 22(1) starts with non obstante clause and it is clear from the provision contained in Clause (a) thereof that no person shall institute any suit or proceeding for obtaining any decree or order for eviction of the occupier from any building or land in a slum area or for recovery of any arrears of rent or compensation from any such occupier or for both without the previous written permission of the Competent Authority. The use of words 'no' and 'shall' in Sub-section (1) of Section 22 makes it abundantly clear that prior written permission of the Competent Authority for an action under Clause (a) thereof is a must. The role of the Competent Authority under the 1971 Act is extremely important as the legislature has conferred power on him to carry out execution of works in improvement of the slum. Sub-section (2) of Section 22 requires the person desiring to obtain the permission to make an application in writing to the Competent Authority. As per Sub-section (3) on receipt of such application, the Competent Authority by an order in writing may either grant or refuse to grant such permission after giving an opportunity to the parties of being heard and after making such summary enquiries into the circumstances of the case as it thinks fit. Sub-section (4) of Section 22 requires the Competent Authority to take into account the factors set out therein for granting or refusing the permission. These provisions contained in Section 22 are salutary in light of the scheme of 1971 Act and have to be followed. It has to be held, therefore, that for eviction of a trespasser who is 'occupier' within the meaning of Section 2(e)(v) of 1971 Act from the land or building or any part thereof in a declared slum area, the written permission of the Competent Authority under Section 22(1)(a) is mandatorily required.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 2789 of 2005

Decided On: 01.12.2010

Laxmi Ram Pawar  Vs. Sitabai Balu Dhotre and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Aftab Alam and R.M. Lodha, JJ.
Print Page