Showing posts with label amendment in written statement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label amendment in written statement. Show all posts

Tuesday, 9 August 2022

Golden principles for deciding application for amendment of written statement

  What emerges from the various authorities cited above is that normally, amendment to a written statement is allowed subject to a few exceptions, these exceptions are:


(i) The proposed amendment which the defendant seeks to make, should not cause injustice to the plaintiff and the admissions made in favour of the plaintiff should not be allowed to be withdrawn.

(ii) The proposed amendment should not be allowed, if inconsistent and contradictory allegations in negation to the admitted position of facts or mutually destructive allegations of facts are sought to be incorporated by means of amendment to the pleadings.

(iii) The proposed amendment should not be allowed if it amounts to, or results in, defeating a legal right accruing to the opposite party on account of lapse of time. {Para 23}

24. The law, as regards amendment of written statements, is, thus, almost settled. The principles applicable to the amendments of the plaint are applicable with equal force to the amendments of the written statements. However, the Courts are more generous in allowing amendment of written statement as the question of prejudice is less likely to operate in the case of written statement. The defendant has a right to take alternative pleas in defence, which, however, is subject to an exception that by proposed amendment, the opponent should not be subjected to prejudice. All amendments of the pleadings should be allowed, which are necessary for determination of the real controversies in the suit provided that the proposed amendment does not alter or substitute defence taken. However, inconsistent and contradictory allegations in negation to the admitted position of facts or mutually destructive allegations of facts should not be allowed to be incorporated by means of amendment to the pleadings. Proposed amendment should not cause such prejudice to the other side, which cannot be compensated by costs. No amendment should be allowed, which amounts to, or results in, defeating a legal right accruing to the opposite party on account of lapse of time. The delay, in filing a petition for amendment of the pleadings, should be properly compensated by costs. Error or mistake, which, if not fraudulent, should not be, ordinarily, made a ground for rejecting the application for amendment of a written statement. Above, all, no admission made in favour of a plaintiff, can be allowed to be withdrawn by amendment.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GAUHATI

Decided On: 30.10.2006

Uttam Chand Kothari Vs.  Gauri Shankar Jalan and Ors.
Print Page

Thursday, 15 May 2014

Amendment in written statement incorporating subsequent event is permissible

The learned counsel for the respondent,
however, has objection to the amendment whereby the result of a
case of grant of Succession Certificate is sought to be pleaded at
the end of para no.19 of the written statement. The learned

counsel states that he opposes this amendment since the order on
the application for Succession Certificate was passed in the year
1995 when the suit was very much pending and therefore, that
amendment could have carried out at that time. The learned
counsel for the appellant points out that the appellant did not
hastily carry out this amendment because after the decision of the
Civil Judge (Sr.Dn.) in the application for Succession Certificate,
the plaintiff questioned that decision before the High Court and
the judgment of the High Court came in the year 2008 after the
suit was decided and during the pendency of the appeal.
Therefore, it cannot be said that even this amendment was an
after thought or was sought to be made to protract the
proceedings. 
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE OF BOMBAY
BENCH AT NAGPUR
LETTERS PATENT APPEAL NO.81 OF 2013 IN WRIT PETITION
NO.98 /2013 (D) .
 Digambar  Maroti Amle, Vs  Shantabai Ramkrushna Girhe,

CORAM:
R.C.CHAVAN AND
PRASANNA B.VARALE, JJ.
DATED : 4th APRIL, 2013.
Citation;2014(3) ALLMR176
Print Page