Showing posts with label amendment of decree. Show all posts
Showing posts with label amendment of decree. Show all posts

Tuesday, 6 November 2018

Whether delay in filing of appeal can be condoned on ground that decree was not prepared?

 In the case of Udayan Chinubhai v. R.C. Bali (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held as follows :-

"35. The time requisite for obtaining a copy under Section 12 (2) must be that time which is "properly required" for getting a copy of the decree (see Lala Bal Mukand (MANU/SC/0376/1975 : AIR 1975 SC 1089) (supra)). It is not possible to conceive how a person may obtain a copy of a decree if that decree, in view of the recitals in the judgment pronounced, cannot be prepared without some further action by a party. A judgment which is unconditioned by the requirement of any action by a party, stands on a different footing and in that event the date of the judgment will necessarily be the date of the decree. In such a case, a party cannot take advantage of any ministerial delay in preparing the decree prior to his application for a copy, that is to say, if there is no impediment in law to prepare a decree immediately after pronouncement of the judgment, no matter if, in fact, the decree is prepared after some time elapses. No party, in that event, can exclude that time taken by the court for preparing the decree as time requisite for obtaining a copy if an application for a copy of the decree has not been made prior to the preparation of the decree. It is only when there is a legal impediment to prepare a decree on account of certain directions in the judgment or for non-compliance with such direction or for other legally permissible reasons, the party who is required to comply with such directions or provisions, cannot rely upon the time required by him, under those circumstances, as running against his opponent."
22. In the judgment of Madhya Pradesh High Court in the case of Ram Singh minor through Kashi Ram and another v. Smt. Ramo Bai minor through Ram Baboo and another (supra), it has been held that if a decree is substantially amended, the right of appeal would be from the date of such substantial amendment and that in any case, such amendment of the decree can be taken be taken into consideration by the Court under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, while considering the question of condonation of delay.

23. The position of law that emerges from the above quoted provision and judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court shows that the appellant/Corporation could not have filed appeal against only the judgment and order dated 11.11.2011 passed by the trial Court because decree was not drawn in terms thereof. The decree could have been drawn upon the respondents making payment of requisite court fee stamps for the decided decretal amount. But respondents admittedly did not make such payment and the decree in terms of judgment and order dated 11.11.2011 was not drawn. Instead, the respondents applied for correction of the said order under Section 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Although it was ostensibly for the typographical error in the operative portion of the said judgment and order dated 11.11.2011, but for ascertaining the quantum of mesne profit to which the respondents were entitled, the correction had a substantial effect.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

Second Appeal (SA) No. 23 of 2018

Decided On: 04.05.2018

 Maharashtra State Warehousing Corporation Vs. Sudhadevi and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Manish Pitale, J.

Citation: 2018(5) MHLJ163
Print Page

How to ascertain limitation for filing of appeal if decree is amended?

Having in view the several decisions it may be justifiable to propound that although the date of the decree under Order 20, Rule 7, Code of Civil Procedure, would be the date of the judgment, yet where a decree is substantially amended either by way of review or by way of the powers of corrections conferred on the Court under Sections 151, 152 or 153 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the party against whom such amendment or correction had been made ought not to be made to suffer merely on the basis of the wording of Order 20, Rule 7, Civil Procedure Code. If I may say so, the ratio decidendi of the above cases would be that if the decree is amended or corrected in respect of unsubstantial matters, a party may not get a right of appeal against such unsubstantial amendments or corrections. But, if it is substantially amended, the right of appeal would be from the date of such substantial amendment. Or, at any rate, if a party files an appeal against the amended decree, he can invoke Section 5 of the Limitation Act; and if his attack is against the amendment itself, there is no reason why the Court should be reluctant to extend time in his favour. At the most, the Court might not allow him to raise those questions which could have been raised if he had filed an appeal against the unamend-ed decree. But different considerations ought to prevail where the amendment is substantial.

In the present case, the amendment is undoubtedly substantial inasmuch as the unamended decree gave the first respondent a mere declaration in spite of a specific prayer about possession made in the plaint. The amended decree gives her possession as well. Therefore, I am of opinion that as laid down by the Division Bench of the Patna High Court in MANU/BH/0312/1929 : AIR 1930 Pat 142 (supra) and by the Division Bench of the Madras High Court in MANU/TN/0358/1944 : AIR 1945 Mad 62 (supra), the appellants' right to file an appeal against the decree for possession would be starting from the date of the amended decree.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH

Second Appeal No. 97 of 1962

Decided On: 13.10.1966

 Ram Singh Minor through Kashi Ram Vs.  Smt. Ramo Bai minor through Ram Baboo and Anr.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
P.K. Tare, J.

Citation: AIR 1968 Madhya Pradesh 220

Print Page

Sunday, 30 September 2018

Whether court can make sketch map part of partition decree after passing of decree?

 Learned Counsel for the Appellants submits that the Appellants/defendants filed an application on 06.02.2001 praying that the suit may be partitioned in terms of the plan annexed to the application. However, by oversight the said plan was not exhibited. The plan demarcates the common area. The court had passed a decree by consent. Since the plan was not exhibited, difficulties arose for execution of the partition decree. Therefore, the court below has rightly allowed the application. The High Court on certain assumptions has set aside the said order. Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the Respondents submits that three sketch maps have been produced at different stages in the suit. Therefore, the High Court has rightly directed the parties to file a joint petition indicating their intention regarding allotment of their property as per their shares by producing a sketch duly drawn by competent person. This order of the High Court does not call for interference.

5. We have carefully considered the submissions of the learned Counsel appearing for the parties. There is no dispute as to the share allotted by the trial court in favour of the parties. The Plaintiff was allotted 3/5th share and the Defendant was allotted 2/5th share in the suit Schedule property. It is clear that the sketch map relied on by the trial court was produced by the Plaintiff showing the frontal 'A' lot property containing his 3/5th share delineated with yellow border and 'B' lot property showing Defendants' 2/5th share delineated with red border. The application filed by the Plaintiff producing the aforesaid map reads as under:

Most Respectfully Sheweth:

1. That the Plaintiff, as per direction of the Court is submitting a settlement Plan alongwith copy in Court this day marking annexure 'A' to the petition and 2/5th share with red border with a statement.

In the circumstances, it is prayed that on the basis of the said settlement plan, partition of the suit property may be made by the learned Court for ends of justice.

And for this, your Petitioner as in duty bound shall ever pray.

Dated: 06.02.2001

Sd/-
Plaintiff

6. It is clear that the Plaintiff had also produced two other maps on 20.2.2001 and 12.6.2001. The Plaintiff had sought partition of the suit property in terms of the plan produced on 6.2.2001 which is evident from the application referred to above. As such, the Plaintiff cannot be permitted to say that the map produced with the application dated 6.2.2001 was not the map filed by him. It is not possible to give effect to the partition decree without a sketch map of the suit Schedule property. At the time of passing the judgment and decree, the trial court should have made the said map as a part of the decree so that the partition could have been effected as per the said sketch. No party should be allowed to suffer for the error of the court. In the circumstances, the trial court has rightly made the plan a part of the decree for effecting partition. We are of the view that the High Court was not justified in setting aside the said order.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 3120 of 2009

Decided On: 19.04.2018

 Subhash Chandra Sen  Vs. Nabin Sain (D) thr. L.Rs.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
N.V. Ramana and S. Abdul Nazeer, JJ.

Citation:(2018) 6 SCC 443
Print Page