Showing posts with label sketch map. Show all posts
Showing posts with label sketch map. Show all posts

Tuesday, 19 February 2019

Whether court can make sketch map as a part of decree after passing of decree?

It is clear that the Plaintiff had also produced two other maps on 20.2.2001 and 12.6.2001. The Plaintiff had sought partition of the suit property in terms of the plan produced on 6.2.2001 which is evident from the application referred to above. As such, the Plaintiff cannot be permitted to say that the map produced with the application dated 6.2.2001 was not the map filed by him. It is not possible to give effect to the partition decree without a sketch map of the suit Schedule property. At the time of passing the judgment and decree, the trial court should have made the said map as a part of the decree so that the partition could have been effected as per the said sketch. No party should be allowed to suffer for the error of the court. In the circumstances, the trial court has rightly made the plan a part of the decree for effecting partition. We are of the view that the High Court was not justified in setting aside the said order.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 3120 of 2009

Decided On: 19.04.2018

Subhash Chandra Sen Vs.  Nabin Sain (D) thr. L.Rs.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
N.V. Ramana and S. Abdul Nazeer, JJ.

Citation: 2019(1) MHLJ 596
Print Page

Sunday, 30 September 2018

Whether court can make sketch map part of partition decree after passing of decree?

 Learned Counsel for the Appellants submits that the Appellants/defendants filed an application on 06.02.2001 praying that the suit may be partitioned in terms of the plan annexed to the application. However, by oversight the said plan was not exhibited. The plan demarcates the common area. The court had passed a decree by consent. Since the plan was not exhibited, difficulties arose for execution of the partition decree. Therefore, the court below has rightly allowed the application. The High Court on certain assumptions has set aside the said order. Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the Respondents submits that three sketch maps have been produced at different stages in the suit. Therefore, the High Court has rightly directed the parties to file a joint petition indicating their intention regarding allotment of their property as per their shares by producing a sketch duly drawn by competent person. This order of the High Court does not call for interference.

5. We have carefully considered the submissions of the learned Counsel appearing for the parties. There is no dispute as to the share allotted by the trial court in favour of the parties. The Plaintiff was allotted 3/5th share and the Defendant was allotted 2/5th share in the suit Schedule property. It is clear that the sketch map relied on by the trial court was produced by the Plaintiff showing the frontal 'A' lot property containing his 3/5th share delineated with yellow border and 'B' lot property showing Defendants' 2/5th share delineated with red border. The application filed by the Plaintiff producing the aforesaid map reads as under:

Most Respectfully Sheweth:

1. That the Plaintiff, as per direction of the Court is submitting a settlement Plan alongwith copy in Court this day marking annexure 'A' to the petition and 2/5th share with red border with a statement.

In the circumstances, it is prayed that on the basis of the said settlement plan, partition of the suit property may be made by the learned Court for ends of justice.

And for this, your Petitioner as in duty bound shall ever pray.

Dated: 06.02.2001

Sd/-
Plaintiff

6. It is clear that the Plaintiff had also produced two other maps on 20.2.2001 and 12.6.2001. The Plaintiff had sought partition of the suit property in terms of the plan produced on 6.2.2001 which is evident from the application referred to above. As such, the Plaintiff cannot be permitted to say that the map produced with the application dated 6.2.2001 was not the map filed by him. It is not possible to give effect to the partition decree without a sketch map of the suit Schedule property. At the time of passing the judgment and decree, the trial court should have made the said map as a part of the decree so that the partition could have been effected as per the said sketch. No party should be allowed to suffer for the error of the court. In the circumstances, the trial court has rightly made the plan a part of the decree for effecting partition. We are of the view that the High Court was not justified in setting aside the said order.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 3120 of 2009

Decided On: 19.04.2018

 Subhash Chandra Sen  Vs. Nabin Sain (D) thr. L.Rs.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
N.V. Ramana and S. Abdul Nazeer, JJ.

Citation:(2018) 6 SCC 443
Print Page

Saturday, 18 August 2018

Whether court can execute decree for possession even if there is no plaint map or detailed description of suit property?

The main contention of the applicant is that in the absence of a plaint map or detailed description of the suit property and lane in question, the decree passed by the trial Court is rendered inexecutable. A perusal of the impugned order and even the report of the Commissioner shows that there is no substance in the aforesaid contention raised on behalf of the applicant. Even if, further steps are to be taken while actually executing the decree in question, there are enough powers with the executing Court to take appropriate steps so that the decree is properly satisfied. 
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

Civil Revision Application No. 131 of 2017

Decided On: 23.03.2018

 Shankarlal Chhanulal Nagpure Vs. Pramodkumar Prahladrai Agrawal and Ors.
Print Page

Friday, 17 August 2018

Guidelines of Bombay High court about proper scrutiny of suit by civil judge

 I
deem it appropriate to direct the learned Registrar (Judicial) of
this Court to place a copy of this order before each learned
Principal District Judge in this State so as to bring to the notice
of each Judicial Officer under the respective Judicial district that
a proper scrutiny of the suit shall be performed by the concerned
office of the Courts and in the event of a sketch map being
required to be annexed to the plaints, depending upon the cause
of action in due deference to Order VII Rule 3 of the CPC, the
trial Court shall place such suits in objection category and shall
not proceed with the said suits, until there is a proper

compliance of Order VII Rule 3 of the CPC to avoid further
complications as are visible in the judgments cited in this
proceeding.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE OF BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
WRIT PETITION NO. 1849 OF 2018

DATTATRAYA KASHINATH MANDEKAR Vs CHANGDEO DAGDU KHULE AND OTHERS

CORAM : RAVINDRA V. GHUGE, J.
Dated: February 15 2018
Citation: 2018(4) MHLJ 584
Print Page

Thursday, 1 December 2016

Whether unregistered sketch map acknowledging partition can be exhibited?

In the case of Digambar Adhar Patil v. Devram Girdhar Patil
(died) and another reported in AIR 1995 Supreme Court 1728
wherein it has been held that entries in records of rights maintained in
official course of business is relevant piece of evidence.
On the contrary, Mr. Ganesh Panda, learned Counsel for the
opposite parties has submitted a decision in case of Tek Bahadur
Bhujil v. Debi Singh Bhujil & Ors. reported in AIR 1966 Supreme
Court 292 wherein it is observed in Paragraph 12 thus—
“12. Family arrangement as such can be arrived at orally. Its
terms may be recorded in writing as a memorandum of what
had been agreed upon between the parties. The memorandum
need not be prepared for the purpose of being used as a
document on which future title of the parties be founded. It is
usually prepared as a record of what had been agreed upon so
that there be no hazy notions about it in future. It is only whenthe parties reduce the family arrangement in writing with the
purpose of using that writing as proof of what they had
arranged and, where the arrangement is brought about by the
document as such, that the document would require
registration as it is then that it would be a document of title
declaring for future what rights in what properties the parties
possess.”
Mr. Panda referred to a decision in case of Tarjen Mondal Vs.
Prithiraj Mondal reported in 2011(5) CHN (Cal.) 102, contending that
an unregistered document which is compulsorily registrable cannot be
admitted in evidence adverting to paragraph 14 which reads as under—
“14. Although the deed of family settlement/partition does not
require any registration but once the same is reproduced in
writing then such document requires registration [see. Rajangam
Ier vs. Rajangam Ier, 1923 (69) Indian Cases : Nami Bai vs. Gita
Bai, AIR 1958 SC 706: Roshan vs. Zila AIR 1988 SC 881]”
I have respectfully gone through the above cited decisions by the
rival parties and this Court is of the view that marking of the document
is not a conclusive proof of the contents of the same and is required to
be proved during the trial.
Mr. Das has emphatically submitted that the sketch map
prepared on 28.11.1988 is an acknowledgment of the amicable partition
held long before C.S. operation. If this submission is taken into
consideration in terms of the amended plaint then the said fact can be
enquired into with the help of successive record of right in respect of the
suit properties to find as to whether in terms of amicable partition theproperties amongst the co-sharers were recorded in the C.S. Record of
Right, R.S. Record of Right and L.R. Record of Right and thus, it can be
decided as to whether the sketch map prepared by Amin duly signed by
the persons were by and between the parties to the suit or not.
Having considered the sketch map being produced before the
learned Trial Court pursuant to the amendment of the plaint on that
score, sketch map in my considered opinion is an acknowledgement
alleged to be in respect of amicable partition which is not document
required to be compulsorily registered under Section 17 of the
Registration Act. Dwelling on the principles in case of Kale & Ors. vs.
Deputy Director of Consolidation & Ors. and Bipin Shantilal
Panchal (Supra), this Court is pleased to direct the learned Trial Court
to mark the sketch map as collateral document in question and to
enquire into the factum of amicable partition long before C.S. operation
in the context of the record-of-rights in respect of the suit properties,
ergo, the order impugned is set aside.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CIVIL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present :
The Hon’ble Justice Shivakant Prasad
C.O. 142 of 2013
Harapada Mondal & Ors.
Vs.
Nishikanta Mondal & Ors.

Judgment On : 17.06.2016
Citation:AIR 2016 Cal 340
Print Page