Showing posts with label honourable acquittal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label honourable acquittal. Show all posts

Saturday, 24 June 2023

Does the Mention of the Expression 'Benefit of Doubt' in a Judgment of Acquittal Indicate that the Acquittal Was Not Honourable?


 However, the fact remains that mere use of the expression ‘benefit of doubt’ in the judgment of criminal court, by itself, would not deprive the employee from claiming that the acquittal was ‘honourable’ or ‘clean’. If in the totality of the circumstances, the court comes to the conclusion that the acquittal of an employee is after consideration of the entire material and recording categorical finding that the guilt is not proved, the fact that the criminal court had also used an expression ‘benefit of doubt’ in the judgment would not constitute an impediment in inferring ‘honourable acquittal’.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

WRIT PETITION NO.12326 OF 2017

Eknath Shankar Kamble Vs  Chief Executive Officer,

CORAM: N.J.JAMADAR, J.

PRONOUNCED ON : 8 JUNE 2023

Print Page

Wednesday, 1 February 2017

Whether person acquitted in criminal case can be appointed as Judge?

In the facts of the
present case, it is not in dispute that the Petitioner had applied to
join judicial service to the post of Civil Judge, Junior Division and
Judicial Magistrate, First Class. It can hardly be disputed that a
member of the judicial service is a very important person who
dispenses justice to the citizens even in the most remote areas in
the State. The ordinary citizen is not always in a position to
approach the superior Courts for justice and very often his fate is
decided by the Judges of the lower judiciary. This, therefore,
clearly indicates that a Judge of the lower judiciary clearly plays a
very important and pivotal role in the administration of justice and
which is one of the great pillars of our vibrant democracy.
 Coming to the facts of the present case, it is admitted
that a criminal case was filed against the Petitioner. The charges
leveled against him were under sections 324, 504 r/w section 34 of
the IPC. Once can hardly dispute that the charges leveled against
the Petitioner were extremely serious and not of a petty nature
such as shouting slogans, stealing bread or such which did not
involve moral turpitude, such as cheating, misappropriation etc.
In fact, one of the serious charges leveled against the Petitioner was
for voluntarily causing hurt by dangerous weapons or means
(section 324 of the IPC). True it is, that he was finally acquitted of
all the aforesaid charges but on perusing the judgment of acquittal,
it can be seen that it was not a clean acquittal but on the ground of
reasonable doubt. On perusing the judgment of acquittal what we
find is that there was only one independent witness examined by

the prosecution who turned hostile during the trial and did not
support the case of the prosecution. Other than this witness, no
other independent witness was examined to prove the guilt of the
accused. In fact, the prosecution did not even examine the
Investigating Officer. It is in these circumstances that the Trial
Court came to the conclusion that all this creates a doubt about the
guilt of the Petitioner. It therefore held that the prosecution had
failed to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt which itself created
a doubt about the guilt of the Petitioner. Hence the benefit of doubt
was given to the Petitioner.
13. Looking at all this, can it be said that the opinion / order
of the Hon'ble Administrative Judges' Committee dated 25th June,
2012 was perverse and/or so unreasonable that it would shock the
conscience of the Court? Our answer would be an emphatic NO. In
fact, far from this, we are of the opinion that the decision of the
Hon'ble Administrative Judges' Committee was fully justified.
Looking to all these factors, the said Committee felt that the
Petitioner would not be a suitable candidate to be appointed in
judicial service. His character was certainly not one that could be
characterized as unblemished. To an average citizen in a remote
area, a Court of Law is a temple of justice and the persons

dispensing it are looked upon with the highest regard and respect.
Therefore, when being selected for judicial service, a candidate like
the Petitioner, would have to live up to and meet even higher
standards than any other candidate applying for a job with the
Government or other civil services. We, therefore, are unable to
agree with the submissions of Mr Salunke that there is any
infirmity in the order / opinion dated 25th June, 2012 that would
require our interference under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
 CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO.1277 OF 2015

Shri Vithal Waman Shelke Vs The High Court of Bombay,

CORAM: S.C. DHARMADHIKARI &
 B.P. COLABAWALLA JJ.
DATE : 14TH OCTOBER 2016.
Citation: 2016(6) ALLMR 895
Print Page

Thursday, 25 February 2016

When acquittal of govt servant shall not be treated as honourable acquittal on merits?

 What is relevant in the present case which distinguishes the case of the Appellant from the above mentioned cases is Rule 16.3 of Punjab Police Rules, which reads as under:
16.3 Action following on a judicial acquittal:
(1) When a Police Officer has been tried and acquitted by a criminal court he shall not be punished departmentally on the same charge or on a different charge upon the evidence cited in the criminal case, whether actually led or not, unless:
(a) the criminal charge has failed on technical grounds; or
(b) in the opinion of the court or of the Superintendent of Police, the prosecution witnesses have been won over; or
(c) the Court has held in its judgment that an offence was actually committed and that suspicion rests upon the police officer concerned; or
(d) the evidence cited in the criminal case discloses facts unconnected with the charge before the court which justify departmental proceedings on a different charge; or
(e) additional evidence admissible Under Rule 16.25(1) in departmental proceedings is available.
(2)...
 Rule quoted above provides that when a police officer has been tried and acquitted by a criminal court, he shall not be punished departmentally on the same charge subject to certain conditions. In the present case, as is evident from Rule 16.3, requirement of not punishing the officer departmentally is not absolute, and it hinges on either of the five conditions mentioned above [(a) to (e)]. From the copy of the order of acquittal passed by the Judge, Special Court, Ludhiana (Annexure P-6), it is evident that the prosecution witnesses have turned hostile, and they appear to have been won over.
Equivalent Citation: 2015(9)SCALE645, (2016)1SCC671, 
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Civil Appeal No. 5142 of 2009
Decided On: 08.09.2015

 Baljinder Pal Kaur Vs.  State of Punjab and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:Dipak Misra and Prafulla C. Pant, JJ.

Print Page

Sunday, 19 May 2013

Basic concept of honourable acquittal in departmental enquiry


The meaning of the expression ‘honourable acquittal’ came up for consideration before this Court in Management of Reserve Bank of India, New Delhi v. Bhopal Singh Panchal (1994) 1 SCC 541. In that case, this Court has considered the impact of Regulation 46(4) dealing with honourable acquittal by a criminal court on the disciplinary proceedings. In that context, this Court held that the mere acquittal does not entitle an employee to reinstatement in service, the acquittal, it was held, has to be honourable. The expressions ‘honourable acquittal’, ‘acquitted of blame’, ‘fully exonerated’ are unknown to the Code of Criminal Procedure or the Penal Code, which are coined by judicial pronouncements. It is difficult to define precisely what is meant by the expression ‘honourably acquitted’. When the accused is acquitted after full consideration of prosecution evidence and that the prosecution had miserably failed to prove the charges levelled against the accused, it can possibly be said that the accused was honourably acquitted.
22. In R.P. Kapoor v. Union of India, AIR 1964 SC 787, it was held even in the case of acquittal, departmental proceedings may follow where the acquittal is other than honourable. In State of Assam and another v. Raghava Rajgopalachari reported in 1972 SLR 45, this Court quoted with approval the views expressed by Lord Williams, J. in (1934) 61 ILR Cal. 168 which is as follows:
“The expression “honourably acquitted” is one which is unknown to court of justice. Apparently it is a form of order used in courts martial and other extra judicial tribunals. 

Supreme Court of India
Dy.Inspector Gen.Of Police & Anr. vs S.Samuthiram on 30 November, 2012
Print Page