Showing posts with label call details record. Show all posts
Showing posts with label call details record. Show all posts

Saturday, 15 August 2026

Supreme Court: Under which circumstances the court can convict accused based on call detail records and location data of the mobile numbers used by accused?

 The call detail records further amplify the incriminating previous conduct of A1 on the date of incident. The records reveal that A1 was in constant touch with A2, A3 and A5 before the incident. Further, A3, A4 and A5 were in constant touch with each other. The prosecution has relied upon a chart prepared on the basis of the call detail records of the accused persons and it indicates that all the accused persons were in contact with each other. Even without this chart, the call records are quite clear. To add to it, the location data of the mobile numbers used by the accused persons reveals that all the accused persons were present around the restaurant at the time of the incident. Furthermore, the location of A3 to A6 was also traceable at the same spot where the deceased was found in the Honda Accord car at around 12:05 AM after the incident. In such circumstances, the courts have drawn a reasonable inference that the accused persons were acting in a coordinated manner and had an overwhelming nexus with the offence. 

{Para 17}

 In the Supreme Court of India

(Before Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma, JJ.)

Criminal Appeal No(s). 3866 of 2025


Piyush Shyamdasani  Vs State of Uttar Pradesh 

Decided on July 20, 2026


Citation: 2026 SCC OnLine SC 1357.
Read full judgment here: Click here.
Print Page

Supreme Court: Whether the court can convict the accused if Mobile numbers relied upon by the prosecution were not in the name of the accused persons?

 The appellants herein seek to question the findings on the ground that the mobile numbers reflected in the call detail records did not belong to the accused persons. This, in fact, is another incriminating circumstance because the numbers did not belong to the accused persons, but they were found running in the mobile devices recovered from the possession or at the instance of the accused persons. Thus, they were using fake numbers to conceal their identities and to evade surveillance. Notably, A1 was admittedly using two numbers - one registered in his own name and one in the name of his employee (a worker in his factory). Both the numbers were mentioned by him in his original complaint after the incident. The number used by A4 was found running in the mobile phone recovered from him, and the number used by A5 was installed in his phone, which was left by him at his home when he fled away after the incident. When called by the investigators, the call was picked up by the mother of A5 and she disclosed that it was used by A5 only. Again, no rebuttal has been advanced to dispute these facts. {Para 19}

20. The call details reveal that the accused persons were in constant touch with each other using these numbers, irrespective of the persons in whose names the numbers were officially registered. The evidence on record has indicated sufficient nexus between the numbers reflected in the call detail records and the accused persons. If there was any discrepancy in this evidence, the accused persons could have led counter evidence to that effect. However, they failed to rebut this crucial technical evidence. The Court cannot set aside consistent evidentiary findings on bare assertions, without any cogent evidence to support the assertions.

 In the Supreme Court of India

(Before Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma, JJ.)

Criminal Appeal No(s). 3866 of 2025


Piyush Shyamdasani  Vs State of Uttar Pradesh 

Decided on July 20, 2026


Citation: 2026 SCC OnLine SC 1357
Print Page

Sunday, 23 February 2025

What are the implications of not producing and proving CDR records in court?

 In legal proceedings, the burden of proof lies heavily on the party making allegations, particularly in cases involving claims of ill-treatment. The Indian Evidence Act provides a structured approach to how evidence must be presented and substantiated in court. This article explores the implications of communication methods between victims and their parents, particularly focusing on telephonic and written communications, and the necessity of producing documentary evidence to support claims.

When a victim communicates instances of ill-treatment to their parents, the nature and medium of that communication play a crucial role in establishing proof. If such communication occurs via phone calls or written letters, it is essential to produce tangible evidence to substantiate these claims. According to Sections 59 and 60 of the Indian Evidence Act, oral evidence can only support facts that do not pertain to the contents of documents. Therefore, if a victim were to convey their distress through a letter, the letter itself must be presented in court as primary evidence; oral testimony regarding its existence would be inadmissible.

Print Page

Bombay HC: Whether the court should draw Adverse inference against prosecution if prosecution has failed to produce and prove CDR Record if entire communication was through Mobile?

The record very specifically indicates that the prosecution had attached mobile hand set of Ayaz (PW17), Alka (PW2) and Aamir (PW10). The record also indicates that necessary communication was sent to the concerned agencies requiring them to produce call detail records (CDR) however, the prosecution, has failed to produce on record any evidence as regards the CDR either by examining the Nodal Officer or producing the actual call detail records through any other competent witness. The evidence in the form of CDR was most crucial, inasmuch as the same would have made it clear as to whether any calls were indeed made from the mobile hand set of Ayaz (PW17) to PW2 and PW10 at the times indicated by the said two witnesses or even otherwise. Non production of CDR or non examination of any witnesses who would be in a best position to depose to the CDRs clearly warranted the drawal of adverse inference against the prosecution. The learned Sessions Judge has not even adverted, much less, considered this crucial aspect of the matter. In the facts of the present case, we are satisfied that an adverse inference was liable to be drawn against the prosecution for non production of CDRs or non examination of witnesses like Nodal Officer etc., who could have deposed to the call detail records. {Para 28}

29. Although the statement made by Ayaz (PW17) the victim to the police soon after his mysterious rescue will not be substantive evidence, it is nevertheless necessary to note that when this statement makes no reference whatsoever to any demand for ransom though it is the case of the prosecution that such demands were made through the hand set of Ayaz (PW17) and in his presence by the Appellants. Therefore, upon cumulative consideration of the evidence on record, including in particular the circumstance that CDR records were called for but not produced in evidence by the prosecution, an adverse inference was liable to be drawn against the prosecution. We therefore, do not agree with the learned Sessions Judge that the demand for ransom was established beyond reasonable doubt in the present case. Since the demand for ransom is one of the most essential ingredients under Section 364-A of IPC and since the said ingredient has not been established by the prosecution beyond reasonable doubt, we regarded as quite unsafe to convict the Appellants under Section 364A of IPC.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY AT GOA

Criminal Appeal Nos. 39 of 2013, 3 of 2018 and 50 of 2018

Decided On: 08.02.2019

Mohammad Imdar Ali and Ors. Vs. State

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

M.S. Sonak and Prithviraj K. Chavan, JJ.

Author: M.S. Sonak, J.

Citation:  MANU/MH/0186/2019,2019 SCC ONLINE BOM 273.

Print Page

Friday, 1 November 2024

Madras HC: Privacy as a fundamental right includes spousal privacy also and evidence obtained by invading this right is inadmissible

 This is primarily because there has been a clear invasion of theprivacy right of the wife. It is obvious that the husband had stealthily obtained the information pertaining to the call history of his wife. He was not the owner of the mobile device or the registered user of the sim card. He had clandestine custody of the same for probably a brief while. There has been a clear breach of the privacy of the wife. In Justice K.Puttaswamy (Retd) v. UOI (AIR 2017 SC 4161), it was held that privacy is a fundamental right. Can evidence procured in violation of this right be admissible in evidence?. This question does not admit of an easy answer. The learned amicus has tabulated the dichotomy of judicial opinion :

Admissible Inadmissible

Kethana Lokes v. Rahul Bettakotte

2024 Karnataka HC 21752

Asha Latha v. Durgesh

2023 SCC OnLine Chh 3959

Deepti Kapur v. Kunal Julka

AIR 2020 Del 156

Rayala Bhuvanewari v.

Naggaphanender AIR 2008 AP 98

Preeti v. Kunal

AIR 2016 Raj 153

Neha v. Vibhor Garg (2021)

(Punjab & Haryana HC)

Sachin Arora v. Manju

2023 DHC 3197

Sankarram v. Kalaiselvi

CMSA(MD)No.54 of 2021 (Madurai

Bench of the Madras High Court).

Neha v. Vibhor Garg has been challenged before the Hon'ble Supreme Court in SLP (C) No.21195 of 2021. Vide order dated 28.04.2022, the proceedings before the Family Court have been stayed. The order of the High Court had not been stayed. {Para 9}

10.The following observations and ratio laid down by the Court of

Appeal in Imerman v. Technquiz (2010 EWCA Civ 908) are relevant : “it was a breach of confidence for a person intentionally to obtain another person’s information secretly and without authorisation, knowing that he reasonably expected it to be private, and, without that other persons authority, ...... that the husband had an expectation of privacy at common law and in accordance with article 8 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms in respect of the majority of documents stored on the server which had been accessed without his authority at a stage in the divorce proceedings ....

Why should one spouse have no right of confidentiality

enforceable against the other in relation to their separate lives and personalities?...

Each spouse is entitled to a separate life, distinct from the

shared matrimonial life.

Legal protection applies to protect the confidence itself, not merely to prevent the dissemination of information. It does not need to be shown that the information will be misused; merely that it has been obtained in breach of confidence would be sufficient.”

In Katz v. United States (389 U.S 347 (1967), Justice Harlan propounded the reasonable expectation of privacy test to determine whether an action by the government has violated an individual's reasonable expectation of privacy. It was a two part test ; the individual has exhibited an actual (subjective) expectation of privacy and the expectation is one that society is prepared to recognise as reasonable. If both requirements are met and the government has taken an action which violates this 'expectation', then the government's action has violated the individual's right. In a research paper titled “My Diary is Your Diary : The Right to Privacy in a Marriage” by Turkish author Dr.Nadire Ozdemir, it was recommended that the Harlan test laid down in the context of state surveillance should be extended to matrimonial relationships also and that the spouses should be entitled to claim right of privacy against each other.

11.Some of the courts which leaned in favour of admissibility of

evidence obtained in breach of privacy relied on Section 14 of the Family Courts Act, 1984. The said provision is as follows :

“Application of Indian Evidence Act, 1872:—A

Family Court may receive as evidence any report, statement,

documents, information or matter that may, in its opinion, assist it

to deal effectually with a dispute, whether or not the same would

be otherwise relevant or admissible under the Indian Evidence Act,

1872 (1 of 1872).”

I am however not able to agree with such an approach. Though privacy like any other fundamental right is not absolute, it was held in Justice K.Puttaswamy case by Justice D.Y.Chandrachud for himself and three other Hon'ble Judges that any curtailment or deprivation of the privacy right would have to take place under a regime of law and that the procedure must be fair, just and reasonable and subject to constitutional safeguards. The expression

“regime of law” requires some elaboration. Taking inspiration from the title of the book “Legislating Privacy” by Priscilla M Regan, I hold that “regime of law” envisages a special and comprehensive legislation dealing with the subject of privacy. Such a parliamentary legislation would also deal with the question relating to admissibility of evidence procured in breach of one's privacy. Exceptions may be created. National security and supreme public interest could be overriding considerations. In the absence of such a

comprehensive legislation, one has to conclude that there is no “regime of law” dealing with the subject of privacy as of now. The Family Courts Act, 1984 was enacted more than three decades prior to Justice Puttaswamy judgment. The discretionary power conferred on the Family Court under Section 14 of the Family Courts Act cannot be said to fall within the meaningof the aforesaid expression “regime of law”. There is no legislative validation of evidence obtained by violating the fundamental right to privacy. In this background, it would not be proper for the courts to carve out exceptions on their own.

12.The observations made by the High Court of Harare, Zimbabwe

in CRB 57 of 2016 (S. v Nsoro) dated 25.02.2016 are apposite though rendered in a criminal case. The deceased husband refused to let the accused wife read a text message which the husband had received on his phone. Out of anger over the deceased’s refusal to divulge the message, the wife had stabbed the husband causing his death. Justice Chitapi has the following take on the right to privacy between spouses :

“...Section 57 (d) of the Constitution provides that

every person has the right to privacy of their

communications. There is no law which provides that

a husband or wife has a right to infringe on the

privacy of the other’s communications. The accused’s

insistence that the deceased should divulge a

communication made to him on his phone was in

itself an infringement upon the right of the deceased

to privacy of communication. The deceased was

lawfully entitled to refuse to divulge the message he

had received on his phone to the accused albeit the

accused being his wife....

It is the court’s view that society should learn to

respect privacy of communications. Many a time, the

cellphone has been cause of ‘matrimonial quarrels

and domestic disputes because couples do not respect

each others' right to communications made or

received. A cellphone is materially a gadget which is

intended to ease communications between persons. A

lot of cases come before the courts in which a spouse

will have invaded the private communications of

another by going through messages and other

communications on the other spouse’s phone. This

practice should be deprecated. It amounts to

investigating or eavesdropping on one another.

Usually, spouses who do this will be aiming to find

evidence of wrongful conduct by the other.

Eavesdropping on another’s cellphone is evidence of

lack of trust in that other person. Courts are flooded

with cases where couples or spouses seek to prove

wrongful conduct by the other using evidence in the

form of messages retrieved from another spouse’s

phone. Such evidence unless obtained with the

consent of the owner of the phone would have been

illegally obtained in contravention of the rights of

every person to the privacy of communication as

guaranteed by Section 57 of the constitution and

evidential rules relating to admissibility of illegally

obtained evidence should be applied....”

13.I came across an interesting article titled “Rethinking the ‘Fruits

of the poisonous tree’ doctrine: Should the ‘ends’ justify the

‘means’?” (2020 SCC OnLine Blog OpEd 76). The authors Bharat Chugh & Taahaa Khan lament the consequentialist approach that ‘the tree may be poisonous but the fruit is fine’. To them, the concept of ends justifying the means is deeply troubling and calls for judicial intervention. They also invoke the “Unfair Operation Principle” applied by the UK Courts. This principle prohibits admission of evidence if in the given case, its reception runs contrary to the principles of basic fairness. The principle gives courts the discretion to decide, on a case to case basis, as to what would operate fairly or unfairly against the accused, and in appropriate cases, exclude such evidence. Theauthors refer to 94th Report of the Law Commission of India which suggests exclusion of evidence unlawfully obtained in criminal cases.

14.Trust forms the bedrock of matrimonial relationships. The

spouses must have implicit and total faith and confidence in each other. Snooping on the other destroys the fabric of marital life. One cannot pry on the other. Coming specifically to the position of women, it is beyond dispute that they have their own autonomy. They are entitled to expect that their private space is not invaded. The wife may maintain a diary. She may jot down her thoughts and intimate feelings. She has every right to expect that her husband will not read its contents except with her consent. What applies to diary will apply to her mobile phone also. The Hon'ble Supreme Court is now considering the question whether forcible sexual intercourse by the husband against the wife's will would constitute marital rape. Obtaining of information pertaining to the privacy of the wife without her knowledge and consent cannot be viewed benignly. Only if it is authoritatively laid down that evidence procured in breach of the privacy rights is not admissible, spouses will not resort to surveillance of the other. One may wonder if marital misconduct which has to be made out for obtaining relief may become impossible of proving. It is not so. It can very well be established and proved by appropriate means. Interrogatories can be served. Adverse inference can be drawn. The charged spouse can be called upon to file affidavit with the express warning that falsity will lead to prosecution for perjury. In exceptional cases, the court can even take it upon itself to unearth the truth. Law cannot proceed on the premise that marital misconduct is the norm. It cannot permit or encourage snooping by one spouse on the other. Privacy as a fundamental right includes spousal privacy also and evidence obtained by invading this right is inadmissible.

BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT

CRP(MD)No.2362 of 2024

R..... ... Petitioner/Petitioner/Respondent

vs.

1.B..... ...Respondent/Respondent/Petitioner

2.The Secretary to Government,

 Ministry of Electronics and

Information Technology

(MEITY), Government of India,

 New Delhi. ... 2nd respondent

CORAM

 MR.JUSTICE G.R.SWAMINATHAN

Pronounced on : 30.10.2024.

Read full Judgment here: Click here.

Print Page

Sunday, 8 September 2024

Whether accused can seek direction U/S 91 of CRPC for supply of call details and location chart of investigating officer?

 I have heard learned counsel for the parties at length & gone through the available records. After hearing the arguments advanced by counsel for the petitioner and the rival contention and after perusal of the order passed by the Trial Court, it appears that the petitioner is seeking direction from this Court for the supply of the call details of the calls made from the mobile phone of the investigating officer. The grievance of the petitioner is that the calls made from the mobile of the investigating officer would indicate the presence, location and the activities of the investigating officer whereas the case of the State is that in the details of mobile calls of the investigating officer, it is not suggested to be the calls relating to the present case and apart from the present case, the investigating officer being a police officer, had been dealing with the other matters and activities of various other accused and with regard to the duty assigned to him. Further contention made by the prosecution is that the accused could not claim the record of various activities of the investigating officer and he has to restrict to the activity of the investigating officer in the present case only. The prosecution has claimed that accused does not have any right to have the information about the final activities of the investigating officer and that cannot be limited to the activity in the present case. So, the accused could not be said to be entitled for seeking the details of records of all the calls made or calls received from the mobile phone of the investigating officer. {Para 8}


9. The Seamed Magistrate has delivered a reasoned order for the denial of the claim of the petitioner. Similar reasoned order has also been passed by the revisional Court i.e. Court of Sessions. This Court is not of any different view than the one taken by learned Metropolitan Magistrate as well as by the Court of Sessions. So the view of the Trial Court as well as the Court of Sessions is upheld by this Court also. Consequently, the present petition is dismissed.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

Crl. M.C. No. 406/2016

Decided On: 18.07.2016

Attar Singh Vs. State (NCT of Delhi)

Hon'ble Judges/Coram: P.S. Teji, J.

Citation: 2016 SCC OnLine Del 3907,MANU/DE/2928/2016.

Print Page

Sunday, 30 June 2024

How to prove call details record(CDR) in court as per Indian law?

 Proving Call Detail Records (CDRs) in court under Indian law involves several steps to ensure their admissibility and authenticity as evidence. Here’s a step-by-step guide to the process:

1. Obtain the CDRs Legally:

  • Legal Procedure: CDRs must be obtained through a legal procedure, typically by a court order or by a request from a law enforcement agency during an investigation.
  • Authority: The request for CDRs should be made by an authorized officer, usually not below the rank of Superintendent of Police, and should be sanctioned by a competent authority as per the Indian Telegraph Act, 1885, and the Information Technology Act, 2000.

2. Ensure Authenticity:

Print Page

Thursday, 7 July 2022

Whether accused can pray to the court for the preservation of the CDR of the raiding party’s mobile phone to prove his innocence?

 The counsel for the petitioner argued that the petitioner was falsely implicated in the present case by the investigating agency and was not arrested in the manner as alleged in the FIR. The entire prosecution case is planted and concocted. The contents mentioned in the Final Report under section 173 Cr.P.C. regarding the recovery of contraband and manner of arrest are completely false and far away from truth. The investigating agency may destroy the evidence which is required to prove the innocence of the petitioner during the trial of the case. The petitioner along with the co-accused was apprehended/hijacked by the raiding party at toll plaza, National Highway at Pilakhua, Hapur, U.P. in dramatic manner. The petitioner has a right to natural justice and fair investigation and for this it is required to preserve the location chart of the members of the raiding party as mentioned in the FIR along with the location chart and the contact no. of the accused including the petitioner. {Para 4}

7. In the present case, the members of raiding party belong to a specialized investigating agency which carries investigation in the matter of national interest, terrorism, armed dealing, drug paddling and organized criminal activities and for said purpose the members of the raiding party have to remain in touch with the secret informers. It would not be in the interest of the functioning of the investigating agency to preserve CDR of mobile phone of the raiding party as it may cause prejudice to the personal safety/security of the police officials as well as may expose identity of the secret informers. The investigation is already completed.

8. After considering all facts, the relief as prayed for cannot be granted and the petition is dismissed.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

 W.P.(CRL) 1236/2022

 KRISHAN PAWDIA Vs THE STATE, NCT OF DELHI 

 CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUDHIR KUMAR JAIN 

Decided on: June 03, 2022.

Citation: 2022 SCC OnLine Del 1758. 

Print Page