Showing posts with label chain of custody. Show all posts
Showing posts with label chain of custody. Show all posts

Tuesday, 21 July 2026

From Crime Scene to Courtroom: Six Judicial Tests for Trustworthy Forensic Evidence

 

Overview

Forensic reports often arrive in court clothed with an aura of science, certainty and neutrality, particularly in cases involving DNA, fingerprints, ballistics, toxicology and digital forensics. Yet appellate courts have repeatedly reminded that such reports are only as reliable as the process by which samples are collected, preserved, transmitted, tested and interpreted. If any link in this process is weak, the probative value of the entire forensic edifice may collapse.

This article sets out a practical framework for trial judges, public prosecutors and defence counsel to scrutinise forensic evidence across six critical stages:

(1) chain of custody,

(2) contamination and preservation,

(3) scientific methodology,

(4) expert’s qualifications and neutrality,

(5) documentation and procedural trail and

(6) gaps, alternative sources and innocent explanations. 
Print Page

Friday, 29 May 2026

Supreme Court: Under which circumstances DNA/ FSL Report becomes unreliable?

II. RECOVERY OF BLOOD-STAINED SHIRT


34. The second incriminating article recovered at the instance of the Appellant-Pooranmal was the blood-stained shirt which upon being analysed at the FSL purportedly gave a positive test for the presence of the same blood group (O) as that of the deceased-Aruna. From the evidence of the Investigating Officer (PW.22), it transpires that the recovery of the shirt was effected in furtherance of the disclosure statement of the Appellant-Pooranmal (Ex. P-43). The recovery memo of the shirt was proved as (Ex. P-9).


35. We may observe that the Appellant-Pooranmal herein was a free bird since the day of incident i.e. from intervening night of 2nd and 3rd March, 2010 until 4th March, 2010, when he came to be formally arrested in connection with the present case, after being implicated by the co-convict Ladu Lal. The recovery memo (Ex. P-9) indicates that the Appellant-Pooranmal had meticulously concealed the shirt in an iron box and when the same was recovered, it was bearing blood stains. To our mind, it is highly improbable and unnatural that the Appellant-Pooranmal, who was a free bird, would have taken such great pains to conceal the shirt so meticulously rather than simply destroying it by burning. Furthermore, even if the Appellant-Pooranmal was desirous of preserving the shirt, all that was required to obliterate the blood stains was to wash the same. Hence, we are of the firm view that the recovery of the shirt is totally unreliable.


36. The recovery of the shirt was held to be incriminating based on the FSL report (Ex. P-49) as per which the blood stains on the shirt tested positive for the presence of O blood group being the same as that of the deceased-Aruna. For treating the FSL report (Ex. P-49) to be admissible, the prosecution would have to prove the complete chain of custody establishing the sanctity of the sealed articles right from the time of the seizure till the time they reached the FSL. In this regard, we would like to refer to the evidence of the following witnesses:


a. Mathura Singh (P.W.19)


37. Mathura Singh (PW.19), the Head Constable in-charge of the malkhana at Police Station Bijolia, stated that on 6th March, 2010 the Investigating Officer (PW.22) deposited blood-stained tissues and shirt in a sealed cloth bag. An entry to this effect was made in the malkhana register at Serial No. 227. On 7th March, 2010, the Investigating Officer (PW.22) deposited a sealed bag containing 46 notes of Rs. 1,000/- each, totalling Rs. 46,000/-. The witness (PW.19) stated that these articles, which also included the articles/samples recovered from the crime scene and the t-shirt recovered at the instance of the co-convict Ladu Lal, bearing marks A, B, C, L, M (totalling five), were forwarded with constable Surender Singh (PW.16) to SP office Bhilwara on 15th March, 2010 for being deposited at the FSL accompanied by requisite documents. However, because the FSL forwarding letter was not yet prepared, the said articles were returned and handed back to said witness (PW.19) who redeposited the same in the malkhana with an endorsement made in the malkhana register (Ex. P-37).


38. These very articles were again taken out from the malkhana on 18th March, 2010 and handed over to Surender Singh (PW.16) for delivery to FSL. Surender Singh (PW.16) proceeded to Udaipur and deposited the samples at the FSL on 19th March, 2010. He thereafter returned on 20th March, 2010 along with the receipt evidencing such deposit.


39. The witness (PW.19) was confronted with the malkhana entry in his cross-examination and stated as below:


It is wrong to say that I had given the material to Surendra Singh on 12.3.10 for taking to F.S.L. and that due to some shortage in it, the material were returned on 15.3.l0. Ex.D.3 The copy of the Malkhana which was attached with the challan in the file, in the C-D part of which it is written that the material were sent on 12.3.10 is wrong.


b. Surendra Singh (P.W.16)


40. The Carrier Constable, Surender Singh (PW.16), emphatically stated that he carried the malkhana articles to the FSL on 18th March, 2010, deposited them at the FSL, Udaipur on 19th March, 2010 and brought back the receipt. In his cross-examination, the witness (PW.16) stated that he did not recollect taking the same articles to the S.P. office on 12th March, 2010. He was confronted with the malkhana register (Ex. D-3), which records that he had been handed the samples on 12th March, 2010 and had attempted to deposit them at the S.P. Office on 15th March, 2010. However, he feigned ignorance as to the said entry recorded in the official document (Ex.D-3).


41. On a holistic appreciation of the evidence of these two witnesses, it becomes clear that there is a grave discrepancy regarding the safe-keeping/chain of custody of the muddamal articles. It is clearly discernible from the evidence of Mathura Singh (PW.19) that the muddamal articles were sent out of the police station prior to 18th March, 2010, to be precise on 15th March, 2010, but the same were returned from the FSL because of some defects. The precise reason for return of the muddamal articles is not forthcoming in the evidence of the prosecution witnesses. The Carrier Constable (PW.16) categorically denied having carried the samples on any date prior to 18th March, 2010.


42. The entry made in the malkhana register (Ex. D-3) with which both the witnesses were confronted, completely demolishes the versions of PW.19 and PW.16. In this entry, it is clearly recorded that the muddamal articles were forwarded to the FSL on 12th March, 2010. Utter failure of the prosecution to disclose as to the reasons for which the samples were returned from the FSL breaches the unbroken chain of custody mandatorily required to prove the safe keeping of the muddamal articles.


43. In Karandeep Sharma alias Razia alias Raju v. State of Uttarakhand   MANU/SC/0446/2025, this Court emphasised that for a DNA/FSL report to be acceptable and reliable, the prosecution must establish an unbroken chain of custody and demonstrate that the samples remained duly sealed and untampered throughout, and held as follows:


54. In order to make the DNA report acceptable, reliable and admissible, the prosecution would first be required to prove the sanctity and chain of custody of the samples/articles right from the time of their preparation/collection till the time they reached the FSL. For this purpose, the link evidence would have to be established by examining the concerned witness.


55. Evidently, there is not even a semblance of evidence on record to satisfy the Court that the samples/articles collected from the dead body of the child-victim and those collected from the Appellant which were later forwarded to the FSL were properly sealed or that the same remained in a self-same condition right from the time of the seizure till they reached the FSL. No witness from the FSL was examined by the prosecution to prove that the samples/articles were received in a sealed condition. Hence, there is every possibility of the samples being tampered/manipulated by the police officers so as to achieve a favourable result from the FSL, thereby, inculpating the Appellant in the crime.


44. In view of the analysis of evidence made above, we are of the firm view that the requisite link evidence essential to prove the safe-keeping and sanctity of the muddamal articles is lacking and the chain of custody has been breached beyond reprieve, thereby, making the FSL report (Ex. P-49) redundant and a worthless piece of paper.


45. Moreover, this Court in Allarakha Habib Memon v. State of Gujarat   MANU/SC/0856/2024 : 2024:INSC:590 : (2024) 9 SCC 546, expounded that even if the FSL report establishes that the blood group detected on the article recovered at the instance of the Accused matches that of the deceased, such circumstance by itself is not sufficient to link the said Accused with the crime. This Court observed as follows:


42. The trial court as well as the High Court heavily relied upon the FSL reports (Exts. 111-115) for finding corroboration to the evidence of the eyewitnesses and in drawing a conclusion regarding culpability of the Appellants for the crime. We may reiterate that the testimony of the so-called eyewitnesses has already been discarded above by holding the same to be doubtful. Thus, even presuming that the FSL reports (Exts. 111-115) conclude that the blood group found on the weapons recovered at the instance of the Accused matched with the blood group of the deceased, this circumstance in isolation, cannot be considered sufficient so as to link the Accused with the crime.


43. In this regard, reliance can be placed on the judgment of Mustkeem v. State of Rajasthan [Mustkeem v. State of Rajasthan,   MANU/SC/0795/2011 : 2011:INSC:487 : (2011) 11 SCC 724 : (2011) 3 SCC (Cri) 473], wherein this Court held that sole circumstance of recovery of bloodstained weapon cannot form the basis of conviction unless the same was connected with the murder of the deceased by the Accused. The relevant portion is extracted hereinbelow: (SCC p. 730, para 19)


19. The AB blood group which was found on the clothes of the deceased does not by itself establish the guilt of the Appellant unless the same was connected with the murder of the deceased by the Appellants. None of the witnesses examined by the prosecution could establish that fact. The blood found on the sword recovered at the instance of Mustkeem was not sufficient for test as the same had already disintegrated. At any rate, due to the reasons elaborated in the following paragraphs, the fact that the traces of blood found on the deceased matched those found on the recovered weapons cannot ipso facto enable us to arrive at the conclusion that the latter were used for the murder.


(Emphasis supplied)

46. Thus, even if the FSL report (Ex. P-49) shows that the blood found on the shirt allegedly recovered at the instance of the Appellant-Pooranmal matches that of the deceased-Aruna, such finding would by itself not be incriminating in the absence of other cogent and corroborative evidence completing the chain of circumstances.

Ratio: Forensic Science Laboratory (FSL) Report – Chain of Custody – Sanctity of Samples. For an FSL report to be reliable, the prosecution must prove an unbroken chain of custody from seizure to laboratory - In this case, contradictions between the Malkhana In-charge and Carrier Constable regarding the dates the samples were sent and returned from the FSL (due to unspecified "defects") breached the chain of custody – Noted that even if blood groups match, this circumstance in isolation cannot link the accused to the crime without other cogent evidence.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 1266 of 2026 

Decided On: 10.03.2026

Pooranmal Vs. The State of Rajasthan and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Vikram Nath, Sandeep Mehta and N.V. Anjaria, JJ.

Author: Sandeep Mehta, J.

Citation: 2026 INSC 217,MANU/SC/0213/2026

Print Page

Wednesday, 27 May 2026

Supreme court explains the law relating to appreciation of evidence of finger prints

7. As noticed earlier the only incriminating circumstance on the basis of which the High Court upheld the conviction of Mohd. Aman is that his finger prints were found on a brass jug in the house of the deceased. From the evidence adduced in proof of the above circumstance it appears that the brass jug, together with other articles, was seized, packed and sealed on April 14, 1983 and forwarded to the Finger Print Bureau five days after - on April 19, 1983 to be precise - through Const. Mohd. Sadique (P.W. 4) along with a letter written by the Investigating Officer (copy of which was marked as Ext. P.59). On the following day, that is, April 20, 1983 the Bureau sent the articles back after taking photographs of the chance prints found on the jug and three other articles (out of the sixteen sent) with a corresponding letter (Ext. P.60). After Mohd. Aman was arrested on April 20, 1983 his specimen finger prints were taken by H.C. Ramji Ram (P.W. 24) and forwarded to the Bureau on May 24, 1983. As the prints were not clear, the same were returned by the Bureau asking for better prints. Specimen finger prints were thereafter again taken on June 20, 1983 and sent to the Bureau. These prints were also sent back and for the third time prints of Mohd. Aman were taken and sent to the Bureau on June 30, 1983. Thereafter the Bureau gave its report (Ext. 115) with the opinion that the chance finger prints found on the brass jug were similar to and identical with his specimen finger prints.


8. After careful perusal of the evidence adduced in proof of the above circumstance we notice a glaring missing link, in that, the prosecution has failed to establish that the seized articles were not - or could not be - tampered with before it reached the Bureau for examination. Though evidence was led to prove that after seizure the articles were packaged and then sealed, no evidence was led to indicate what was the mark given in the seals and whether the Bureau received the packages with the marked seals intact. Indeed, even the contemporaneous letters exchanged between them (Ext. P.59 and P.60) do not throw any light on this aspect of the matter. Rather, other circumstances appearing on record make the prosecution case doubtful in this regard : first, the articles were kept in the police station for five days without any justifiable reason, secondly the Investigating Officer (P.W. 20) admitted that the seal, mark of which was put on the articles, was with him since the time of seizure and lastly his letter (Ext. P.39) forwarding the seized articles to the Bureau contains admittedly, an overwriting as regards the date of its writing/dispatch and no satisfactory explanation is forthcoming for the same.


Apart from the above missing link and the suspicious circumstances surrounding the same, there is another circumstance which also cast a serious mistrust as to genuineness of the evidence.

Even though the specimen finger prints of Mohd. Aman had to be taken on a number of occasions at the behest of the Bureau, they were never taken before or under the order of a Magistrate in accordance with Section 5 of the Identification of Prisoners Act. It is true that under Section 4 thereof police is competent to take finger prints of the accused but to dispel any suspicion as to its bonafides or to eliminate the possibility of fabrication of evidence it was eminently desirable that they were taken before or under the order of a Magistrate.

The other related infirmity from which the prosecution case suffers is that the brass jug, production of which would have been the best evidence in proof of the claim of its seizure and subsequent examination by the Bureau, was not produced and exhibited during trial - for reasons best known to the prosecution and unknown to the Court. For the foregoing discussion we are unable to sustain the convictions of Mohd. Aman.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 1749 with 1833 of 1996

Decided On: 08.05.1997

Mohd. Aman, Babu Khan and Ors. Vs. State of Rajasthan

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

M.K. Mukherjee and K. Venkataswami, JJ.

Author: M.K. Mukherjee, J.

Citation: 1997 AIR SC 2960, MANU/SC/0771/1997.

Print Page

Sunday, 19 April 2026

What are recent developments in DNA test from perspective of Criminal trial?

 Recent judicial developments show that courts now accept DNA evidence as highly probative, but they insist much more strongly on chain of custody, proper sampling, laboratory integrity, and corroboration before acting on it. From a judge’s point of view, the shift is from treating DNA as merely “scientific and powerful” to asking whether the collection, preservation, documentation, and interpretation are legally reliable and fair.

Main developments

Print Page

Saturday, 18 April 2026

Supreme Court Guidelines Regarding procedure to be followed regarding DNA evidence from the point of collection to the logical end, i.e., conviction or acquittal of the Accused,

 This lack of a common procedure to be followed, is concerning. As such, we issue the following directions which shall be followed henceforth, in all cases where DNA Evidence is involved:


1. The collection of DNA samples once made after due care and compliance of all necessary procedure including swift and appropriate packaging including a) FIR number and date; b) Section and the statute involved therein; c) details of I.O., Police station; and d) requisite serial number shall be duly documented. The document recording the collection shall have the signatures and designations of the medical professional present, the investigating officer and independent witnesses. Here only we may clarify that the absence of independent witnesses shall not be taken to be compromising to the collection of such evidence, but the efforts made to join such witnesses and the eventual inability to do so shall be duly put down in record.


2. The Investigating Officer shall be responsible for the transportation of the DNA evidence to the concerned police station or the hospital concerned, as the case may be. He shall also be responsible for ensuring that the samples so taken reach the concerned forensic science laboratory with dispatch and in any case not later than 48- hours from the time of collection. Should any extraneous circumstance present itself and the 48-hours timeline cannot be complied with, the reason for the delay shall be duly recorded in the case diary. Throughout, the requisite efforts be made to preserve the samples as per the requirement corresponding to the nature of the sample taken.


3. In the time that the DNA samples are stored pending trial appeal etc., no package shall be opened, altered or resealed without express authorisation of the Trial Court acting upon a statement of a duly qualified and experienced medical professional to the effect that the same shall not have a negative impact on the sanctity of the evidence and with the Court being assured that such a step is necessary for proper and just outcome of the Investigation/Trial.


4. Right from the point of collection to the logical end, i.e., conviction or acquittal of the Accused, a Chain of Custody Register shall be maintained wherein each and every movement of the evidence shall be recorded with counter sign at each end thereof stating also the reason therefor. This Chain of Custody Register shall necessarily be appended as part of the Trial Court record. Failure to maintain the same shall render the I.O. responsible for explaining such lapse.


The Directors General of Police of all the States shall prepare sample forms of the Chain of Custody Register and all other documentation directed above and ensure its dispatch to all districts with necessary instruction as may be required. {Para 44}

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 1672 of 2019 

Decided On: 15.07.2025

Kattavellai Vs. State of Tamilnadu

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Vikram Nath, Sanjay Karol and Sandeep Mehta, JJ.

Author: Sanjay Karol, J.

Citation: 2025 INSC 845, MANU/SC/0917/2025.

Print Page

Sunday, 28 December 2025

ELECTRONIC EVIDENCE & CHAIN OF CUSTODY : Why Your Court’s Computer Room Must Never Touch Electronic Evidence?

 


A Judicial Guide to Protecting Digital Evidence in the Age of Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam 2023

OPENING: THE OPERATIONAL TRAP MOST COURTS FALL INTO

Your muddemal room receives a pen drive containing critical CCTV footage. The prosecutor and defence counsel walk into your chambers and ask the same simple question: “Your Honour, can your court’s computer room just copy this for us?”

Your administrative officer is standing by, computer room staff are available, and it seems like a five-minute fix.

Print Page

Thursday, 25 September 2025

Rajasthan HC: Section 65B Certificate Valid Only from Original Recording Device Owner

The Rajasthan High Court recently delivered an important ruling regarding the issuance of certificates under Section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act, which is crucial for the admissibility of electronic records as evidence in court. The Court emphasized that a Section 65B certificate must be issued by the person who owned or operated the original device on which the electronic record was first created. It cannot be validly issued by someone whose device merely contains a transferred copy of that record.

Background of the Case

The case arose from a challenge to a Rent Tribunal order where the respondents submitted electronic evidence stored in a pen drive and compact disc. The petitioner argued that the original recording was made on a third party’s device — specifically, Rajat Sancheti’s device — but the Section 65B certificate was issued by respondent no. 2, whose device only held a later transferred copy of the recording. The petitioner submitted that under the law, only the original device owner could issue the certificate to authenticate the evidence.

Legal Precedents Cited

Justice Anoop Kumar Dhand, presiding over the matter, relied on authoritative Supreme Court rulings in Anvar P.V. v. P.K. Basheer and Arjun Panditrao Khotkar v. Kailash Kushanrao Gorantyal. These rulings firmly establish that the certificate under Section 65B must originate from the person in control of the device on which the electronic record was originally created, which ensures the authenticity and reliability of digital evidence.

Court’s Holding and Impact

The Court held that the certificate issued by respondent no. 2 concerning the transferred copy was invalid and could not render the electronic evidence admissible. However, the Court left a procedural opportunity for the respondents to file a proper and valid certificate issued by the actual owner of the original recording device, thereby allowing the evidence to potentially remain admissible if corrected.

This judgment underscores the critical importance of complying strictly with Section 65B requirements as laid down by the Supreme Court, especially regarding the chain of custody and certification of electronic evidence. Practitioners must ensure that certificates authenticating electronic records emanate from the original device’s controlling person to withstand scrutiny in judicial proceedings.

Conclusion

In the digital era where electronic evidence is increasingly common, the Rajasthan High Court’s clarification provides much-needed guidance and robustness to the procedural requirements under Section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act. This decision serves as a reminder that the integrity of electronic evidence hinges on proper certification from the original source, maintaining the evidentiary standards crucial for justice.

HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN

BENCH AT JAIPUR

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 12210/2025

Shwetabh Singhal,  Vs M/s J.k And Sons, 

JUSTICE ANOOP KUMAR DHAND

Order: 09/09/2025.

Citation: [2025:RJ-JP:36375]

Print Page

Friday, 12 September 2025

District Judge Interview Prep: Understanding WhatsApp Forensics & CDR/SDR Evidence

 Here are the interview questions with detailed model answers:

1.       What are Call Detail Records (CDR) and Subscriber Detail Records (SDR), and what kind of information do they typically contain?

Answer:
CDRs are telecom operator-generated logs of voice and SMS communications. They typically record caller and receiver numbers, call duration, timestamps, cell tower location (cell ID), and SMS metadata. They help establish who communicated, when, and from where. SDRs contain static subscriber identity data like name, address, KYC information maintained by telecom companies. However, SDRs do not contain communication timing or session details.

2.       Can CDR and SDR provide timing information related to PDFs, audio, or video files shared through WhatsApp? Why or why not?
Print Page

Monday, 12 August 2024

Supreme court: Statement Of Accused is Inadmissible U/S 27 of Evidence Act If No New Fact Is Discovered Pursuant To Disclosure

 On a threadbare analysis of the entire record, we do not find that the prosecution examined any witness who had deposed about the link evidence/safe custody of the mudammal articles right from the time they were received at the police station and seized till the time the same reached the FSL. Hence, otherwise also, the FSL report(Exhibits 111-115) pales into insignificance. Investigating Officer(PW-18) deposed that he arrested the Accused persons. A detailed enquiry was made from all three Accused-Appellants, and they were examined for the injuries found on their bodies. Thereafter, all the Accused-Appellants conveyed their willingness to show the place of the offence and thereafter, panchnama as per Section 27 of the Evidence Act was prepared. Since the place of incident was also known to police, this disclosure is irrelevant. {Para 45}

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal Nos. 2828-2829 of 2023 and 112 of 2024

Decided On: 08.08.2024

Allarakha Habib Memon and Ors. Vs. State of Gujarat

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

B.R. Gavai and Sandeep Mehta, JJ.

Author: Sandeep Mehta, J.

Citation:  MANU/SC/0856/2024.

Read full judgment here: Click here.

Print Page

Supreme Court: The court should not rely on FSL report if prosecution has failed to prove chain of custody

 The trial Court as well as the High Court heavily relied upon the FSL reports(Exhibits 111-115) to hold that blood group found on the weapons of offence incriminated the Accused for the crime as the same matched with the blood group of the deceased. In this regard, it is suffice to say that the two weapons which were picked up by Demistalkumar(PW-12) from the place of occurrence were formally seized at the Anand Town Police Station around 2:30 am on 5th May, 2011. Only one of the panchas Mohammad Hussain(PW-5) was examined at the trial. The seizure panchnama(Exhibit -38) records that the three Accused who had inflicted deadly blows to the deceased with dagger, gupti and knife, threw away their weapons near the garden and fled away from the crime scene and that police personnel brought all the weapons to the police station. However, the panchnama(Exhibit P-38) does not bear the signatures of the police constable, Demistalkumar(PW-12) who admittedly collected the weapons from the crime scene and presented them to the police station. Thus, no credence can be given to seizure panchnama(Exhibit P-38) because it suffers from the lacuna of not being attested by the witness who had actually presented the weapons at the police station. In addition, thereto, we may further note that Demistalkumar(PW-12), the police constable who deposited the weapons at the police station, did not state in his evidence as to whom he had given the knife and the gupti which he picked up from the crime scene. These weapons were seized vide seizure panchnama(Exhibit-38) which was admittedly prepared at 2:30 am. However, the Police Constable, Demistalkumar(PW-12) stated that he reached the police station at about 9:15 pm and stayed there for only 20 minutes. These infirmities create a doubt on the very process of seizure of the weapons. {Para 42}


43. The trial Court as well as the High Court heavily relied upon the FSL reports(Exhibits 111-115) for finding corroboration to the evidence of the eyewitnesses and in drawing a conclusion regarding culpability of the Appellants for the crime. We may reiterate that the testimony of the so-called eyewitnesses has already been discarded above by holding the same to be doubtful. Thus, even presuming that the FSL reports(Exhibits 111-115) conclude that the blood group found on the weapons recovered at the instance of the Accused matched with the blood group of the deceased, this circumstance in isolation, cannot be considered sufficient so as to link the Accused with the crime. In this regard, reliance can be placed on the judgment of Mustkeem alias Sirajudeen v. State of Rajasthan   MANU/SC/0795/2011 : 2011:INSC:487 : (2011) 11 SCC 724, wherein this Court held that sole circumstance of recovery of bloodstained weapon cannot form the basis of conviction unless the same was connected with the murder of the deceased by the Accused. The relevant portion is extracted hereinbelow:


19. The AB blood group which was found on the clothes of the deceased does not by itself establish the guilt of the Appellant unless the same was connected with the murder of the deceased by the Appellants. None of the witnesses examined by the prosecution could establish that fact. The blood found on the sword recovered at the instance of Mustkeem was not sufficient for test as the same had already disintegrated. At any rate, due to the reasons elaborated in the following paragraphs, the fact that the traces of blood found on the deceased matched those found on the recovered weapons cannot ipso facto enable us to arrive at the conclusion that the latter were used for the murder.


(emphasis supplied)


44. On a perusal of the deposition of the Investigating Officer(PW- 18), we find his evidence on the aspect of disclosure statements made by the Accused-Appellant leading to the recoveries to be totally perfunctory and unacceptable. The witness did not elaborate upon the words spoken by the Accused-Appellant at the time of making the disclosure statements.


45. On a threadbare analysis of the entire record, we do not find that the prosecution examined any witness who had deposed about the link evidence/safe custody of the mudammal articles right from the time they were received at the police station and seized till the time the same reached the FSL. Hence, otherwise also, the FSL report(Exhibits 111-115) pales into insignificance. Investigating Officer(PW-18) deposed that he arrested the Accused persons. A detailed enquiry was made from all three Accused-Appellants, and they were examined for the injuries found on their bodies. Thereafter, all the Accused-Appellants conveyed their willingness to show the place of the offence and thereafter, panchnama as per Section 27 of the Evidence Act was prepared. Since the place of incident was also known to police, this disclosure is irrelevant. Search of the houses of the Accused-Appellant was undertaken in presence of the panch witnesses and a big knife was seized from the house of the Accused Mohmedfaruk @ Palak, vide panchnama(Exhibit-52).


46. Hence, we are of the firm view that neither the disclosure statements made by the Accused were proved as per law nor the same resulted into any discovery which could be accepted as incriminating inasmuch as the requisite link evidence was never presented by the prosecution so as to establish that the recovered articles remained in the self-safe condition from the date of the seizure till the same reached the FSL.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal Nos. 2828-2829 of 2023 and 112 of 2024

Decided On: 08.08.2024

Allarakha Habib Memon and Ors. Vs. State of Gujarat

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

B.R. Gavai and Sandeep Mehta, JJ.

Author: Sandeep Mehta, J.

Citation:  MANU/SC/0856/2024.

Read full judgment here: Click here.

Print Page