Showing posts with label commercial litigation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label commercial litigation. Show all posts

Sunday, 19 September 2021

Supreme Court Guidelines for imposition of costs in commercial litigation

Costs:

51. The costs following cause is a principle which is followed in most countries. There seems to be often a hesitancy in our judicial system to impose costs, presuming as if it is a reflection on the counsel. This is not the correct approach. In a tussle for enforcement of rights against a State different principle apply but in commercial matters costs must follow the cause.


53. We may note that the common thread running through all these three cases is the reiteration of salutary principles: (i) costs should ordinarily follow the event; (ii) realistic costs ought to be awarded keeping in view the ever increasing litigation expenses; and (iii) the cost should serve the purpose of curbing frivolous and vexatious litigation.

54. There has to be a proportionality to the costs and if they are unreasonable, the doubt would be resolved in favour of the

paying party. As per Halsbury’s Laws of England, the discretion to award costs must be exercised judicially and in accordance with reason and justice. The following principles have been set out therein:

“In deciding what order (if any) to make about costs, the court

must have regard to all the circumstances, including:

(i) The conduct of all the parties;

(ii) Whether a party has succeeded on part of his case, even if he

has not been wholly successful; and

(iii) Any payment into court or admissible offer to settle made by

a party which is drawn to the court’s attention.

The conduct of the parties includes:

a. Conduct before, as well as during, the proceedings and in

particular the extent to which the parties followed any relevant

pre-action protocol;

b. Whether it was reasonable for a party to raise, pursue or contest

a particular allegation or issue;

c. The manner in which a party has pursued or defended his case

or a particular allegation or issue; and

d. Whether a claimant who has succeeded in his claim, in whole

or in part, exaggerated his claim.”

55. We may add that similar principles are followed in Australia, Hong Kong and Canada largely based on the Common Law principle. In fact in Canada, the Manitoba Law Commission Report analysed the ‘Costs Awards in Civil Litigation’ and referred to six broad goals as under:

a. indemnification – successful litigants ought to at least be

partially indemnified against their legal costs;

b. deterrence – potential litigants should carefully assess the merits

of the claim and should refrain from taking any unnecessary legal

actions;

c. rules should be made decipherable and simple to understand;

d. early settlement of disputes should be encouraged;

e. the costs regime should facilitate access to justice; and

f. there should be flexibility in rules to ensure that justice can be

done.

56. We have set forth the aforesaid so that there is appreciation of the

principles that in carrying on commercial litigation, parties must weigh the commercial interests, which would include the consequences of the matter not receiving favourable consideration by the courts. Mindless appeals should not be the rule. 

57. The best reflection of what costs have been incurred is what the parties have paid towards the counsel fee and out of pocket expenses. 

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NOs.4862-4863 OF 2021

UFLEX LTD. Vs  GOVERNMENT OF TAMIL NADU & ORS.

Author: SANJAY KISHAN KAUL, J.

Dated: September 17, 2021.

Print Page