Showing posts with label commercial contract. Show all posts
Showing posts with label commercial contract. Show all posts

Sunday, 19 September 2021

Supreme Court Guidelines for imposition of costs in commercial litigation

Costs:

51. The costs following cause is a principle which is followed in most countries. There seems to be often a hesitancy in our judicial system to impose costs, presuming as if it is a reflection on the counsel. This is not the correct approach. In a tussle for enforcement of rights against a State different principle apply but in commercial matters costs must follow the cause.


53. We may note that the common thread running through all these three cases is the reiteration of salutary principles: (i) costs should ordinarily follow the event; (ii) realistic costs ought to be awarded keeping in view the ever increasing litigation expenses; and (iii) the cost should serve the purpose of curbing frivolous and vexatious litigation.

54. There has to be a proportionality to the costs and if they are unreasonable, the doubt would be resolved in favour of the

paying party. As per Halsbury’s Laws of England, the discretion to award costs must be exercised judicially and in accordance with reason and justice. The following principles have been set out therein:

“In deciding what order (if any) to make about costs, the court

must have regard to all the circumstances, including:

(i) The conduct of all the parties;

(ii) Whether a party has succeeded on part of his case, even if he

has not been wholly successful; and

(iii) Any payment into court or admissible offer to settle made by

a party which is drawn to the court’s attention.

The conduct of the parties includes:

a. Conduct before, as well as during, the proceedings and in

particular the extent to which the parties followed any relevant

pre-action protocol;

b. Whether it was reasonable for a party to raise, pursue or contest

a particular allegation or issue;

c. The manner in which a party has pursued or defended his case

or a particular allegation or issue; and

d. Whether a claimant who has succeeded in his claim, in whole

or in part, exaggerated his claim.”

55. We may add that similar principles are followed in Australia, Hong Kong and Canada largely based on the Common Law principle. In fact in Canada, the Manitoba Law Commission Report analysed the ‘Costs Awards in Civil Litigation’ and referred to six broad goals as under:

a. indemnification – successful litigants ought to at least be

partially indemnified against their legal costs;

b. deterrence – potential litigants should carefully assess the merits

of the claim and should refrain from taking any unnecessary legal

actions;

c. rules should be made decipherable and simple to understand;

d. early settlement of disputes should be encouraged;

e. the costs regime should facilitate access to justice; and

f. there should be flexibility in rules to ensure that justice can be

done.

56. We have set forth the aforesaid so that there is appreciation of the

principles that in carrying on commercial litigation, parties must weigh the commercial interests, which would include the consequences of the matter not receiving favourable consideration by the courts. Mindless appeals should not be the rule. 

57. The best reflection of what costs have been incurred is what the parties have paid towards the counsel fee and out of pocket expenses. 

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NOs.4862-4863 OF 2021

UFLEX LTD. Vs  GOVERNMENT OF TAMIL NADU & ORS.

Author: SANJAY KISHAN KAUL, J.

Dated: September 17, 2021.

Print Page

Wednesday, 23 June 2021

Whether Foreign State can claim sovereign immunity against enforcement of arbitral award arising out of the commercial transaction?

  The prior consent of Central Government is not necessary under Section 86(3) of the Code of Civil Procedure to enforce an arbitral award against a Foreign State. {Para 44}

45. A Foreign State cannot claim a Sovereign Immunity against enforcement of an arbitral award arising out of a commercial transaction.

46. Section 36 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act treats an arbitral award as a „decree‟ of a Court for the limited purpose of enforcement of an award under the Code of Civil Procedure which cannot be read in a manner which would defeat the very underlying rationale of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act namely, speedy, binding and legally enforceable resolution of disputes between the parties.

47. Section 86 of the Code of Civil Procedure is of limited applicability and the protection thereunder would not apply to cases of implied waiver. An arbitration agreement in a commercial contract between a party and a Foreign State is an implied waiver by the Foreign State so as to preclude it from raising a defense against an enforcement action premised upon the principle of Sovereign Immunity.

48. In a contract arising out of a commercial transaction, such as the transactions which are subject matter of the present petitions, a

Foreign State cannot seek Sovereign Immunity for the purpose of stalling execution of an arbitral award rendered against it. Once a Foreign State opts to wear the hat of a commercial entity, it would be bound by the rules of the commercial legal ecosystem and cannot be permitted to seek any immunity, which is otherwise available to it only when it is acting in its sovereign capacity. It is the purpose and nature of the transaction of the Foreign State which would determine whether the transaction, and the contract governing the same, represents a purely commercial activity or whether the same is a manifestation of an exercise of sovereign authority.


IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

Date of Decision: 18th June, 2021

OMP (ENF) (COMM) 82/2019 & I.A. No. 7023/2019

KLA CONST TECHNOLOGIES PVT. LTD. Vs THE EMBASSY OF ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF AFGHANISTAN

 CORAM:  MR. JUSTICE J.R. MIDHA

 Dated: JUNE 18, 2021 

Print Page

Friday, 2 October 2020

Basic concept of cross-liability or cross-collateralisation in Commercial contract


The very concept of cross-liability or cross-collateralisation, as applicable to commercial contracts, predicates reciprocity of security and commonality of the parties to the contract. This is, even etymologically, apparent, as "cross-collateralisation" necessarily requires the same collateral being available, as security against more than one loan. "Cross-collateralisation", as a concept known to commercial contracts, necessarily predicates the usage of the collateral, available as security against one loan, as collateral against a second loan. If, however, the two loans are governed by independent loan agreements, the inclusion of a cross collateralisation clause, in one of them, cannot, proprio vigore, justify proceeding against the collateral, provided in the said loan agreement, for satisfaction of the loan in the other agreements, unless the said security is also collateral under such other agreements. It is open, to contractual parties, to provide for such a dispensation in the loan agreements. Absent such dispensation, however, the mere existence of a cross collateralisation, or cross liability, clause in one of the agreements, would be insufficient.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

O.M.P. (I) (COMM.) 142/2020, I.A. 4600/2020, I.A. 4942/2020 and I.A. 4943/2020

Decided On: 31.08.2020

Sunil Goel  Vs.   Indiabulls Housing Finance Limited

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

C. Hari Shankar, J.

Citation: MANU/DE/1654/2020

Print Page

Wednesday, 19 June 2019

Whether interpretation of contract terms regarding taxes will be in arbitrator's domain?

 From the legal position as noted it is evident whether the service
tax liability has been agreed not to be passed on to the recipient of the
service would depend on the interpretation of clauses entered into
between the parties.
 In the instant case, the clause in question does not fix liability on
the contractor to pay service tax that apart from, the clause required
interpretation and in view of the aforenoted Judgments regarding the

interpretation of the contract, view taken by the learned Arbitrator
cannot be faulted.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION

APPEAL NO. 284 OF 2019
IN
ARBITRATION PETITION NO. 214 OF 2014

Central Warehousing Corporation Vs. Aqdas Maritime Agency Pvt. Ltd

CORAM : PRADEEP NANDRAJOG, C.J. &
N. M. JAMDAR, J.
DATE : 14 th JUNE, 2019.
 (Per Chief Justice)
Print Page

Friday, 2 March 2018

Whether principles of contra proferentem are applicable to commercial contract?

The arbitral tribunal has also considered the submission of the respondent about the alleged ambiguity in the contract and has applied the principles of "contra proferentem." The arbitral tribunal has held that there were ambiguities in the contract and thus the principle of "contra proferentem" stood attracted. It was not the case of the respondent that there were ambiguities in the contract nor there was any such averment in any of the pleadings of the respondent that the principle of "contra proferentem" were attracted to the facts of this case. The case of the respondent, on the other hand, was that it was not the responsibility of the respondent to bear the costs of repairs. Be that as it may, the principle of "contra proferentem" does not apply to a commercial contract which is executed by and between the parties with open eyes. The respondent never alleged any ambiguity in the contract at any point of time at the time of execution of the contract documents nor at any point of time later during the execution of the work. The respondent also did not seek any clarification about any provisions of the contract from the petitioner before execution of the contract nor sought any addendum to the contract on that ground or otherwise.
81. It has been held by the Supreme Court in the case of Rashtriya Ispat Nigam Ltd. v. Dewan Chand Ram Saran, reported in MANU/SC/0327/2012 : (2012) 5 SCC 306 that the principle of "contra proferentem" does not apply to the commercial contract. The findings of the arbitral tribunal is thus ex facie perverse and the impugned award thereby applying the principle of "contra proferentem" to a commercial contract shows patent illegality and is in violation of the principles of law laid down by the Supreme Court in the case of Rashtriya Ispat Nigam Ltd. v. Dewan Chand Ram Saran (supra).


IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Arbitration Petition No. 549 of 2013

Decided On: 09.06.2017

 Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd. Vs. Interocean Shipping (India) Pvt. Ltd.

Print Page

Whether arbitrator can allow claim on ground of equity and contrary to terms of contract?

It is thus clear that the arbitral tribunal has awarded the said claim based on equity and contrary to the terms of the contract. The arbitral tribunal could not have decided the matter based on equity in a commercial contract. The respondent had been awarded several contracts of similar nature and was fully aware that the petitioner had not guaranteed any profit to the respondent in respect of these contracts. Merely because the respondent found the contract less profitable or non-profitable after execution of the contract, that could not be a ground for awarding any claim by the arbitral tribunal. The respondent was bound to comply with its obligation under the contract.{PARA 77

78. In paragraph 27 of the impugned award, the arbitral tribunal has held that at the relevant time, the petitioner herein was in a superior bargaining position since they were, to all intents and purposes, monopoly purchasers of the services being offered and therefore, the contractor had little choice available with him. To secure employment in the field of operation of vessels with another party was virtually impossible. It is held that in the instant case, the employment was being offered by an agency of the state from whom the operator had a right to except fair treatment. It is clear that the arbitral tribunal has erroneously applied the principles of law laid down by the Supreme Court in the case of Central Inland Water Transport case which does not apply to a commercial contract. The respondent had submitted its bid with open eyes and being a contractor in the field for last several decades could not even raise such plea that the contract was one sided or that the respondent had no bargaining power while entering into a contract with the petitioner. The award shows total perversity on this issue.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Arbitration Petition No. 549 of 2013

Decided On: 09.06.2017

 Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd. Vs. Interocean Shipping (India) Pvt. Ltd.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
R.D. Dhanuka, J.
Citation: 2017(5) Bom CR 8
Print Page

Monday, 18 April 2016

What is scope of Judicial review in case of tender and commercial contracts?

 As far as law relating to tenders is concerned, the narrow scope for judicial review of tender conditions is well settled. In essence, the court can only interfere in policy decision if they are arbitrary, discriminatory or malafide and not otherwise. On analysing the aforesaid decisions it is evident that unless administrative action of State is against public interest, is arbitrary and malafide, the courts ought not to interfere in matters of commercial contracts. In many cases, the court would not have expertise to review administrative decisions and the court cannot risk to substitute its own decision. The court should also bear in mind that interfering with the decisions in the matter of award of contracts by the State would also impose heavy administrative burden, and therefore, the court should be cautious and reluctant to 6 (2005) 1 SCC 679 17 w226.14-J.sxw interfere with such decisions. The court should also note that a person who willing participated in tender process had no right to challenge the tender conditions especially after undertaking in writing to comply with the tender terms.
Bombay High Court
M/S. Vascular Concepts Ltd vs The State Of Maharashtra on 21 April, 2014
ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION (L) NO.226 OF 2014
CORAM : V. M. KANADE & A. K. MENON, JJ.
Citation;2015 (7) ALLMR  111
Print Page

Sunday, 13 March 2016

Golden Rule for interpretation of commercial contract

  
 
The Apex Court also in the case of Union of India vs.

D.N. Revri and Co., AIR 1976 SC 2257, held that a

commercial     document      between      the   parties    must   be

interpreted in such a manner as to give efficacy to the

contract rather than to invalidate it. The learned Judges

clarified it by saying: -


            "7. It must be remembered that a contract is a
           commercial document between the parties and it
           must be interpreted in such a manner as to give
           efficacy to the contract rather than to invalidate
           it. It would not be right while interpreting a
            contract, entered into between two lay parties, to
           apply strict rules of construction which are
           ordinarily applicable to a conveyance and other
           formal documents. The meaning of such a
           contract must be gathered by adopting a
           common sense approach and it must not be
           allowed to be thwarted by a narrow, pedantic
           and legalistic interpretation."


                          REPORTABLE

                                      IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
                                       CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION


                                      CIVIL APPEAL NO.11438 OF 2014
                                    (Arising out of SLP(C)No. 20990 of 2013 )


                         M/s. Govind Rubber Ltd.                          ...Appellant (s)

                                                     versus

                         M/s. Louids Dreyfus Commodities
                         Asia Pvt. Ltd.                                   ...Respondent(s)


                                     Citation; (2015) 13 SCC 477.

                         M.Y. Eqbal, J.:
Print Page

Monday, 9 November 2015

Rule for construction of commercial contract in arbitration

It was at the stage of enforceability of the said award that the plaintiff has filed this application under Section 48 of the 1996 Act. I have carefully considered the fixture note and the two apparently conflicting clauses. There cannot be dispute that the parties have intended to resolve their dispute through arbitration. The only dispute appears to be the mechanism that is required to be followed for appointment of arbitrator. The petitioner disputes that the fixture note only contains commercial terms. Both the documents contain signatures of the petitioner. In fact, the signature in the fixture note is all that important to find out if any contract has been executed by and between the parties. The petitioner cannot resile from the terms agreed upon and contained in the fixture note. In the event there are two conflicting clauses in two documents it would be the endeavour of the Court to harmonize the two apparently conflicting clauses and to ascertain the intention of the parties. The fixture note as well as the proforma charter party must be read as a whole and every attempt shall be made to harmonize the terms thereof, keeping in mind that the rule of contra preferentem does not apply in case of commercial contract for the reason that a clause in commercial contract is bilateral and has mutually been agreed upon. The jurisdiction of the Tribunal was not questioned on the ground that the said agreement was entered into by coercion or duress. The plaintiff is not disputing their signature on the fixture note or the existence of the fixture note. Even if a plea is taken that the agreement was a product of fraud, the tribunal has jurisdiction to decide this issue. 
Calcutta High Court
Cliff Navigation S. A vs Lmj International Limited on 23 July, 2015

Author: Soumen Sen
Citation;AIR 2015(NOC)1089 Cal
Read full judgment here; click here
Print Page

Monday, 2 November 2015

Landmark judgment on interpretation of commercial contract

In Cargill International S.A. v. Bangladesh Sugar
& Food Industries Corp.22, Potter L.J. balanced the two
approaches and said:
“In this connection [counsel] has rightly made the
point that, when construing the effect of particular
words in a commercial contract, it is wrong to put
a label on the contract in advance and this to
approach the question of construction on the basis
of a pre-conception as to the contact’s intended
effect, with the result that a strained construction
is placed on words, clear in themselves, in order to
fit them within such pre-conception...
On the other hand, modern principles of
construction require the court to have regard to
the commercial background, the context of the
contract and the circumstances of the parties, and
to consider whether, against that background and
 that context, to give the words a particular or
restricted meaning would lead to an apparently
unreasonable and unfair result.”
Reportable
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
 CIVIL APPEAL NO. 610 2015

Harmony Innovation Shipping Ltd. 
 Versus
Gupta Coal India Ltd. & Anr.
Citation;(2015) 9 SCC172
Print Page